Conifer Plantations on Drained Peatlands in Britain: a Net Gain or Loss of Carbon?

It is estimated that British peatlands, excluding lowland fens,contain about 3000 million tonnes of carbon, 76 per cent ofwhich is in deep peats (> 45 cm deep) and 9 per cent of whichhas been drained and planted with trees. Undisturbed peatlands emit CH₄ but accumulate CO₂-derived carbon.The net greenhouse effect may be near zero. Peatland drainagevirtually stops methane emission and increases CO₂-carbon lossthrough aerobic decomposition, but can also increase CO₂-carbonfixation by the peatland vegetation partly through microbialmineralization of nitrogen, resulting in either a net loss orgain in CO₂-carbon. Planting conifer forests leads to an accumulation of CO₂-derivedcarbon in the trees, wood products, litter and forest soil upto equilibrium values, totalling about 16.7 kg C m^–2 forPicea sitchensis, Yield Class 12. Deep and shallow peats inthe British uplands contain about 0.47 and 0.80 kg C m^–2per centimetre depth, respectively. Thus, the 16.7 kg C m^–2that is stored by P. sitchensis (Yield Class 12) is equivalentto the carbon stored in about 35.5 cm of deep peat or 20.9 cmof shallow peat. If forests are planted on peats substantiallydeeper than this, there could be a net loss of CO₂-carbon inthe long term. Scenarios are presented for the time course of CO₂-carbon gainand loss when peatlands are drained and planted with conifers.If CO₂ loss rates from drained peats are 50–100 g C m^–2a^–1 there is likely to be increased carbon storage inthe whole system for at least three rotations; but if CO₂ lossrates are 200–300 g C m ^–2 a^–1 increased storagemay be restricted to the first rotation, after which there isa net loss of carbon.