Plant limiting nutrients in Andean-Patagonian woody species: Effects of interannual rainfall variation,soil fertility and mycorrhizal infection

Andean-Patagonian forests are especially interesting for the study of N and P limitation because they receive minimal atmospheric pollution, have little influence of vascular N-fixing species, and grow on volcanic soils that retain P. In a previous study of 10 woody species (four broad-leaved deciduous species, three broad-leaved evergreens and three conifers) conducted during an exceptionally dry year in NW Patagonia, and on the basis of nutrient resorption efficiency and proficiency, we suggested that N was the most limiting nutrient except for the broad-leaved evergreen Lomatia hirsuta. In the present work, we compared patterns of nutrient limitation during a dry and a wet year, quantified the percentage of mycorrhizal infection, and related mycorrhizal behavior and nutrient limitation to soil fertility. We used N and P concentrations in green leaves as indicators of nutrient requirements, and N and P concentrations in senescent leaves (resorption proficiency) and the N/P ratio in green leaves as indicators of nutrient limitation. We also determined leaf mass area (LMA) and lignin concentration as indicators of structural and chemical defences. From previous works, the following soil fertility indicators were included: pH, organic C, total N, exchangeable cations, Olsen-P, potential N mineralization (pNmin) and N retained in microbial biomass (N-MB). Nitrogen, P and lignin concentrations in green and senescent leaves did not differ significantly between the dry and the wet year either by species or by functional groups. Most species behaved as N-proficient and P-non-proficient; this together with values of foliar N/P ratios lower than 14–16 confirmed N limitation in these forests. The only species limited by P but not by N was L. hirsuta (1.0–1.1% N in senescent leaves, N/P ratio = 21–23), a non-mycorrhizal species with cluster roots. The lack of P limitation in the other species was probably related to the high percentages of infection with arbuscular mycorrhizae (80–90% in Maytenus boaria and the conifers Araucaria araucana, Austrocedrus chilensis and Fitzroya cupressoides), and ectomycorrhizae (73–79% in five Nothofagus species). Nitrogen and P requirements were positively correlated among themselves and negatively with lignin and LMA. Soil fertility was positively correlated with nutrient requirements and negatively with lignin and LMA. Conifers had lower N and P requirements, higher LMA, lower foliar N/P ratio and grew on soils of lower soil N dynamics (lower pNmin and N-MB) than ectomycorrhizae-associated species.