Esterase inhibitors as synergists for (+)-trans-chrysanthemate insecticide chemicals

Four synergists are used to evaluate the relative contribution of esterases and oxidases in the metabolism of four pyrethroids, the (+)-trans- and (+)-cis-isomers of resmethrin and tetramethrin, by five insect species and by mice. Three of these compounds are known pyrethroid synergists, S,S,S-tributyl phosphorotrithioate acting as an esterase inhibitor and piperonyl butoxide and O-(2-methylpropyl) O-(2-propynyl) phenylphosphonate acting as oxidase inhibitors. The fourth synergist, 1-naphthyl N-propylcarbamate, is an esterase inhibitor selected by screening 65 candidate esterase and oxidase inhibitors for maximal potency in synergizing the toxicity of trans-resmethrin to milkweed bugs. Naphthyl propylcarbamate synergizes the toxicity of trans-resmethrin and -tetramethrin to milkweed bugs, cockroaches, houseflies, cabbage loopers, and mealworms but not to mice. The persistence of trans-resmethrin in milkweed bugs treated by injection is increased by the esterase inhibitors while that of cis-resmethrin is increased by the oxidase inhibitors. The optimal synergist varies with the species and the pyrethoid, being related to both the nature of the pyrethroid alcohol moiety and the trans- or cis-configuration of the acid moiety. This probably results from species variations in the relative significance of esterases and oxidases in pyrethroid detoxification.