Water and element fluxes during the regeneration of Norway spruce with European beech: Effects of shelterwood-cut and clear-cut

The regeneration of mature Norway spruce with European beech using the shelterwood silvicultural system is a good example of continuous cover forestry. In contrast, the regeneration may also start with clear-cut plots, which often occur after calamities like wind-throw or bark beetle attack. During regeneration the forest ecosystem becomes a highly dynamic system. Nutrient losses from the soil may occur as the element turnover is affected by the reduced nutrient uptake of forest trees as well as the enhanced mineralisation and nitrification due to higher soil temperature and soil moisture. Continuous cover forestry may help to reduce these nutrient losses. In order to test this, we investigated water and element fluxes of two chronosequences. The first investigated regeneration in the shelterwood system, while the second concerned itself with regeneration on clear-cut plots. In a shelterwood-cut about 30% of the mature spruce trees are removed and young beech trees are planted. Some 10 years later a secondary felling is carried out and at age 20 of the beech regeneration the final harvest of the mature trees occurs. Thus, the studied time steps were (a) the first 5 years after the initial cut and planting, (b) 10-year-old beech regeneration after the second shelterwood cut and (c) 20-year-old beech regeneration after the final harvest.Our results indicate that nutrient losses with seepage water – especially nitrogen, calcium and magnesium – occur during the first years after the clear cut and, to a lesser extent, after secondary felling on the selective-cut plot. This may temporarily affect seepage water quality due to elevated nitrate concentrations, which reached values of more than 100 mg l⁻¹. In the time span between planting and an age 20 of the beech regeneration, total losses of nitrogen from the main rooting zone reach 230 kg ha⁻¹ after clear cut. Preliminary estimates of the total nitrogen loss in the shelterwood system range between 150 and 230 kg ha⁻¹ indicating either significantly lower or equal losses of nutrients. In the second case, however, element output is distributed more equally over the 20-year-period than after clear felling where 85% of the nitrate leaching occurs during the first 3 years.