A Chronic Plant Test for the Assessment of Contaminated Soils. Part 1: Method development (9 pp)

-

PREAMBLE According to the German Federal Soil Protection Act (BBodSchG 1998), the habitat function of soils must be protected. Despite the fact that in the Federal Soil Protection Ordinance (BBodSchV 1999) it has not been established how this goal can be reached reliably, it is clear that such a biological function can only adequately be assessed using biological test methods. This is especially true when a soil is contaminated by a mixture of often unknown chemicals. In such a case the use of chemical analysis aiming at a small range of known substances is not sufficient and must therefore be supplemented by biological methods. For this reason, several standardised test methods are available (e.g. using earthworms, collembolans or plants; Römbke and Knacker 2003; ISO 2003). Since acute tests are usually not sensitive enough for the assessment of potentially contaminated soils (e.g. Hund-Rinke et al. 2002), chronic tests like the earthworm reproduction tests (ISO 1998) are recommended for this purpose.

-

A chronic plant test for the determination of phytotoxicity was missing until quite recently. The term phytotoxicity is understood here as the capacity of a compound or a contaminated soil to cause temporary or long-lasting damage to plants (EPPO 1997). Therefore, the German Ministry for Education and Research sponsored a project (1997 – 1999) in which – based on existing standardised methods – such a chronic plant laboratory test was developed and partly validated (Kalsch and Römbke 2000). The new test can be used for the evaluation of single chemicals (see Part 1 of this mini-series) as well as for the assessment of contaminated or remediated soils (see Part 2 of this mini-series).

-

ABSTRACT Background and Scope. As part of the efforts to improve the biological testing of contaminated soils, the German government sponsored the standardisation of a chronic plant bioassay. This new test is based on experiences with various acute plant tests (e.g. published by OECD or ISO) and existing North American Plant-Life-Cycle Bioassays. In this contribution the characteristic properties of the test are described.

Methods

The test can be performed either with Brassica rapa (turnip) or Avena sativa (oat). Its duration is 35 to 64 days with OECD artificial soil and a German standard field soil acting as controls. Water and nutrients are provided by an automatic wick irrigation system. Besides measuring biomass and shoot length, the number of pods, seeds and flowers are applied as chronic measurement endpoints. During the development of the test, TNT (2,4,6-trinitrotoluene) and Pyrene were used as model test substances.

Results

Pyrene did not affect B. rapa (turnip) in concentrations of up to 10.000 mg/kg soil (due to the often low sensitivity of A. sativa (oat) no further test with this substance was performed). Depending on the endpoint the results varied in the tests with TNT. With few exceptions, the NOEC (No Observed Effect Concentration) values were determined as 55.5 mg TNT/kg soil for B. rapa (turnip) and as 75 (unfertilised) and 150 (fertilised) mg TNT/kg soil for A. sativa (oat). The EC50-values varied between 96.3 and 207.2 mg TNT/kg soil for B. rapa (turnip) and 183.1 – 505.6 mg TNT/kg soil for A. sativa (oat), depending on the endpoint.

Outlook

The results of this work have been used to prepare a draft test guideline, which has recently been standardised by the International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO). Practical experiences with this test system are described in Part II of this mini series.