国际学术会议分区PACT规则改进

在2000年之前,由于国内主办和参与的国际学术会议很少,因此国际会议论文一度是国内学术考核与评估的可靠依据之一。随着国内与欧美学术界交流日益频繁,国内低质量甚至盈利性国际学术会议越来越多。国际学术会议分区成为高校科研管理面临的新问题。现有的一些国际学术会议分区规则对数据的量和可靠性要求比较高,会议主办方作假难度不大,管理成本较高。文章提出使用4个指标——会议收录论文数量、论文作者多元化程度、会议主席学术水平、最近20年会议举办次数——评价国际学术会议质量,再进行分区,数据容易获得,会议主办方作假难度较大,管理成本低。

Improvement of PACT Rules for International Academic Conferences Ranking

International conference was once a reliable basis for academic assessment in China before 2000, due to the lack of conferences held or participated by China. However, with the increasingly frequent exchanges between China and western academia, there are more and more low quality and profit oriented international conference in China. The international academic conference ranking has become the new problem for the scientific research management of universities. The current ranking rules have high demands on the quantity and reliability, while it is easy to fake with high management costs. This paper proposed a improved conference ranking rule with four indexes including paper quantity collected by conference, the diversification degree of paper author, the academic level of conference chairman and the number of conference in recent 20 years, to evaluate the quality of international academic conference and make the ranking, which was not easy to fake and had low management costs.