Soil and detrital carbon dynamics following forest cutting in the Southern Appalachians

Summary Soil-system CO₂ efflux and detrital C pools were measured in three hardwood watersheds in the Southern Appalachians, USA. On two of the watersheds (hereafter referred to as clearcuts), forests were cut via clearcut logging methods and allowed to naturally regenerate; logging residue was removed on one clearcut and was left in place on the other. The third watershed was an uncut reference watershed. There was no statistically significant difference in CO₂ efflux between the two types of residue treatments on the clearcuts; however, CO₂ effluxes from the clearcuts were 33% less than effluxes from the uncut watershed. Lower CO₂ effluxes on the two clearcuts were associated with higher soil temperatures, smaller live-root masses, and larger forest-floor masses. No long-term (5–8 years) changes in soil C pools were apparent following forest cutting. Therefore, reductions in CO₂ efflux on the clearcuts appear to be due both to fewer live roots and to slower rates of forest-floor decomposition. Cutting of these forests followed by regeneration does not appear to result in large net C transfers to the atmosphere, as has been generally assumed.