Development of cotton pests exhibiting different feeding strategy on water-stressed and kaolin-treated cotton plants

Consistent data demonstrate the positive response of sap-sucking insects to water-stressed plants, but there is a lack of information about the performance of chewing species, including whether their responses vary according to their feeding specializations. We tested the hypothesis that herbivores with distinct feeding strategies and host specialization will respond differently to two plant conditions, i.e. water deficit and kaolin treatment, where the latter is used to reduce abiotic and biotic plant stressors. We determined the development and reproduction of four major cotton pest species with different feeding strategies (chewing and sap sucking) and with specializations ranging from monophagous to polyphagous using well-watered or water-stressed cotton plants, which were treated or not treated with kaolin. Three chewing (lepidopteran) species, Alabama argillacea (Hüb.), Heliothis virescens (Fabr.) and Chrysodeixis includens (Walk), as well as one sap-sucking species, Bemisia tabaci (Gen.), were used as models. The neonate larvae of all three chewing species exhibited lower survival when fed the leaves of water-stressed plants. In addition, the neonate larvae fed leaves from water-stressed and kaolin-treated plants did not complete their development or they exhibited low survival. Older larvae also exhibited significantly lower survival on kaolin-treated plants. The effects on life history traits were more obvious in monophagous chewing species compared with polyphagous species when fed leaves from water-stressed plants. The performance of B. tabaci was superior on water-stressed and untreated kaolin plants. Thus, water-stressed and kaolin-treated plants negatively affected all chewing species, whereas water-stressed plants only positively affected the sap-sucking species.