Comparison of serological tests for the measurement of the primary immune response to avian infectious bronchitis virus vaccines

The immune response of individual chickens exposed in an aerosol apparatus to live commercial avian infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) vaccines was measured by serum neutralization (SN), haemagglutination inhibition (HI), complement fixation (CF) and agar gel precipitin (AGP) tests over a period of 14 weeks.The SN titres showed considerable variation for individual chickens and in a large number of birds were negative until 14 weeks after infection.Positive HI titres were recorded for most birds at one week after infection and persisted throughout the observation period. Some relationship was seen between HI and SN titres particularly in birds showing a high immune response.The results obtained with the AGP were transient, variable and did not compare well with results obtained by the other tests. The highest number of positive AGP reactors were seen two to three weeks after infection.Most birds showed positive titres by the CF test at some time after infection but titres were always low and did not correlate with results obtained by the other tests.Twenty-two weeks after vaccination 23 chickens were challenged by aerosol exposure to the Massachusetts 41 strain of IBV and four days later the trachea, kidneys and oviducts were removed from each bird for attempted virus isolation. Virus was recovered from only one kidney and 11 trachea samples. The mean pre-challenge HI and SN titres of birds from which no virus was recovered were significantly higher than the mash titres of vaccinated birds from which virus was isolated after challenge.