Faecal Contamination Indicators in Irrigation Water: Evaluation of a Standard Method and Comparison with an Alternative System

This study compares the detection of faecal contamination indicators in irrigation water (25 samples) by two analytical techniques: multiple tube fermentation method (MPN) and Colilert/Enterolert Quanti-Tray system. Our aim was to investigate variations in the test results and determine whether variations could be related to 1) the interval of time between the sample collection and analysis and 2) the manual labour of the operator. Each water sample was analysed at specific intervals of time from the sample collection within 24 h and by three different operators. Statistical analysis was employed to evaluate the results. We have proved that the indices obtained with the multiple tube fermentation method show greater variation than the values obtained with the Colilert and Enterolert systems. Furthermore, some samples, analysed by the MPN method, showed different values, but not statistically significant, in relation to the intervals of time between the sample collection and analysis and in relation to the data obtained by the manual labour of the operators. Values for the same sample varied in respect to legislative limits. The Colilert and Enterolert systems for the detection of indicator bacteria could be a substitute for the standard methods. This procedure could be used for monitoring the quality of irrigation water.