Evaluation of L-asparaginase: Polyethylene Glycol Conjugate Versus Native L-asparaginase Combined with Chemotherapy: A Randomized Double-blind Study in Canine Lymphoma

L-asparaginase is an enzyme that inhibits protein synthesis by the depletion of sources of L-asparagine, which is necessary for transformed lymphoid cells to proliferate. L-asparaginase is used in the treatment of childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia. A problem with L-asparaginase therapy is the immunogenicity of the enzyme and the development of anaphylactic reactions. Canine lymphoma is a predominantly B-cell tumor with widespread disease; without treatment, dogs with lymphoma usually survive 1-2 months. Canine lymphoma will respond to L-asparaginase therapy. A randomized double-blind study evaluated a polyethylene glycol (PEG) conjugate L-asparaginase combined with chemotherapy (vincristine, cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and prednisone). Thirty-five dogs were randomized to the PEG L-asparaginase group, and 34 dogs were randomized to the native L-asparaginase group. Thirty dogs (85.7%) achieved a complete remission (CR) with a median time to relapse of 217 days, and 32 (94.1%) dogs in the native L-asparaginase group achieved a CR with a median time to relapse of 214 days (P greater than 0.05). The asparaginase was well tolerated in both groups. Two dogs in the native L-asparaginase group had severe allergic reactions, and one dog in the PEG asparaginase group had a generalized urticarial reaction after repeated injections. This study indicates that PEG L-asparaginase has equal therapeutic efficacy to native L-asparaginase.