A comparative study of insecticide resistance assays with the German cockroach

Females of a diazinon-resistant strain of German cockroach exhibiting cross resistance to propoxur were evaluated for resistance to diazinon and propoxur by six assays: LD₅₀s for topical application and injection; LC₅₀, KT₅₀ and LT₅₀ for deposits on wood and KT₅₀ for deposits on glass. Also investigated were certain variables in the topical application technique and the experimental conditions for topical synergism studies. Among all assays, diazinon resistance ratios (resistant:susceptible) ranged from 3- to 145-fold; propoxur varied from 1- to 14-fold. Resistance ratios based on KT₅₀ data were consistently low (<4x) for both insecticides. Resistance to diazinon was 13x when applied topically and 6x when injected. Resistance to propoxur was 14x by injection compared to 8x for topical application. The LC₅₀ assay exhibited the greatest difference in resistance to the two insecticides: namely, 145x to diazinon and 1x(no resistance) to propoxur. By LT₅₀ analysis, resistance to propoxur was 10x compared with 100x resistance to diazinon. Thus, the method used had a significant effect on the final value of the resistance ratio. Even though resistance ratios may vary widely among different techniques, the final choice of a method depends upon many factors. The LT₅₀ method may provide a more realistic appraisal of resistance in wild populations of German cockroaches especially when experimental residues are similar to those used in control programmes.