Bull Selection across Age Classes and Variable Female Reproductive Rates in an Open Nucleus Breeding Scheme for Dairy Cattle

Different bull selection strategies and female reproductive rates were simulated under various selection intensities and mating strategies in a nucleus with testing capacity of 80 cows. In all schemes, donor cows were selected after first lactation and bulls were progeny tested. In some schemes, non-progeny tested nucleus bulls could be selected. The nucleus was open on the male side but closed on the female side after nucleus born cows were available. Pedigrees of animals born outside the nucleus were sampled from the Finnish Ayrshire population. Female reproduction rate was either constant or variable. Schemes were compared according to genetic response, and risks measured by rate of inbreeding and coefficient of variation in genetic response between simulation years 5 and 20. Inclusion of one- or three-year-old bulls increased genetic response by 9% and rate of inbreeding up to 81%. Variation in female reproductive rate reduced genetic response by at most 8%. Increase in risks was averted by limiting the number of female full-sibs. Schemes with low selection intensity and factorial mating provided the best results.