The influence of compost addition on heavy metal distribution between operationally defined geochemical fractions and on metal accumulation in plant

Purpose

Metal distribution patterns among geochemical fractions are informative for metal phytoavailability. Compost added to polluted soils may adsorb metals on the less phytoavailable fractions. A bioassay experiment was conducted to establish possible correlations between metal concentrations in different soil fractions and metal contents in edible plant parts and to investigate the influence of different compost loads on heavy metal availability to plants.

Materials and methods

Chinese cabbage plants were grown in pots with sandy and clayey soils and soils mixed with different doses of biosolid compost spiked with soluble heavy metal salts (Cd, Cu, and Pb). The metals’ distribution pattern in the soil and mixed samples was determined by sequential extraction procedure (modified BCR protocol). The studied fractions, from most to least bioavailable, were water-extractable (WE), exchangeable-adsorbed (EXC), associated with carbonates and acetic acid-soluble forms (CARB), occluded by reducible (hydro)oxides of Fe and Mn (RO), and associated with organic matter (OM) and a residual fraction (RES). Metal concentrations in soil extracts and in the digested plant tissue were measured by ICP-AES.

Results and discussion

The highest compost doses (72 and 115 Mg ha^?1) enhanced cabbage yield significantly. No excessive phytoaccumulation of metals was observed in plants grown in the clayey soil or its mixtures with compost. The compost dose of 72 Mg ha^?1 was optimal in decreasing Cu accumulation by plants grown in sandy soil, and 28.8 Mg ha^?1 was found to be effective in reducing Cd and Pb uptake. Metals were accumulated in plants primarily from the WE, EXC, and CARB fractions, whereas other fractions decreased phytoaccumulation. Compost addition suppressed heavy metal mobility, but different fractions were active in pollutant sorption, depending on soil type and metal.

Conclusions

Compost addition increased metal proportions in the RO and OM fractions, reducing metal phytoavailability. This is especially important for sandy soils with low adsorption ability and higher vulnerability to metal pollution than clayey soils. A compost dose of 20% v/v (or 28.8 Mg ha^?1) effectively reduced plant accumulation of Cd and Pb. We propose using the first three steps of the modified BCR protocol as a three-step sequential-extraction procedure for the most phytoavailable fractions of heavy metal: WE, EXC, and CARB.