Natural Regeneration in Thinned Douglas-fir Stands in Western Oregon

ABSTRACT

In response to interests by land management agencies to transform even-aged stands to structurally mimic old-growth forests, we evaluated whether thinning in 40- to 80-year-old Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) stands influenced amount and composition of advanced regeneration 5 to 7 years following treatment. We used data from two large-scale management experiments (Density Management Study and Young Stand Thinning and Diversity Study) conducted in western Oregon. Thinning focused on the removal of Douglas-fir, while maintenance of minor species was encouraged. Although both experiments showed higher tree regeneration after thinning, we found that variation in regeneration density was too high (3 orders of magnitude) to find statistical differences among thinning intensities. While seedlings of the major species, Douglas-fir and western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla), were always present and dominated regeneration on nearly all sites, species trends were driven by high spatial and compositional variation throughout all units, treatments, and sites. Thinning increased the number of species within the regeneration layer. Hereby, species diversity was strongly related to overstory composition, suggesting seed source limitations for minor species. Hence, favoring rare species during thinning operations may be an effective method to increase regeneration species richness. Local conditions, as defined by overstory density appeared more influential than regional climate patterns in determining seedling densities. Shrub and grass competition did not prevent seedling establishment as their cover values were generally not as high as typically found in clearcuts in the region. The high variation in seedling density and species richness within the seedling stratum in the thinned stands may set the stage for development of structural complexity in even-aged Douglas-fir plantations.