Bimodal effect of methylenedioxyphenyl compounds on detoxifying enzymes in the housefly

Thirteen methylenedioxyphenyl (MDP) compounds, including commercial insecticide synergists and juvenile hormone analogs, were compared in their effect on detoxifying enzymes in the housefly (Musca domestica). Flies were fed a diet containing 1% of the compounds for 3 days. Enzymes were then assayed in vitro for their activity using aldrin and DDT as substrates. Piperonyl butoxide (PB), sesamex, propyl isome, sulfoxide, safrole, isosafrole, 6,7-epoxy-3,7-diethyl-1-[3-4(methylenedioxy) phenoxy]-2-octene (MDP-JH I) and 6,7-epoxy-3-methyl-7-ethyl-1-[3,4-(methylenedioxy) phenoxy]-2-octene (MDP-JH II) all caused a bimodal effect, inhibiting microsomal epoxidase and inducing DDT-dehydrochlorinase in the resistant Isolan-B strain. Two of these, PB and MDP-JH I, gave similar results with the susceptible strain, stw;w⁵ and two resistant strains, Fc-B and Orlando-DDT. However, o-safrole, piperonylic acid, piperonal, 3,4-methylenedioxybenzyl acetate and methyl-(3,4-methylenedioxy) benzoate had little or no effect on the enzyme systems studied. The standard susceptible strain (WHO-SRS) responded to these compounds very differently. Among those tested, piperonyl butoxide, sesamex, safrole, and isosafrole were inducers of microsomal epoxidase, a 4-fold increase occurring after treatment with sesamex. Only MDP-JH II showed a marked inhibition of the epoxidase. These treatments did not effect DDT-dehydrochlorinase activity in this strain.The enhancement of DDT-dehydrochlorinase activity by the MDP compounds is associated with an increased rate of DDT dehydrochlorination in vivo. The stimulatory effect could be blocked by treatment with actinomycin D or cycloheximide.     

An Example of Cross-resistance to Pyrethroids in DDT-resistant Aedes aegypti

Comparisons of the susceptibility of several strains of adult Aedes aegypti were made. Mosquitoes from Bangkok and Jakarta were found to be highly resistant to DDT and resistant to pyrethroids relative to a laboratory strain. A strain from Singapore, where less DDT has been used, was susceptible to DDT and pyrethroids. Two strains from the Caribbean had LC₅₀ values to DDT 3 times that of the reference strain while the LC₅₀ values against bioresmethrin synergised with piperonyl butoxide were 1 1/2 times raised. Another two strains from central Africa were 2 times tolerant of DDT and 1 1/2 times tolerant of bioresmethrin plus piperonyl butoxide. Agents which block DDT-dehydrochlorinase, esterases and oxidases each caused small increases in the mortality of the Bangkok strain due to DDT and bioresmethrin as well as augmenting toxicity to the susceptible reference strain. It is tentatively suggested that resistance in the Bangkok strain is due to a combination of the actions of these and perhaps other resistance mechanisms.     

Cross-resistance to pyrethroids and other insecticides in Aedes aegypti

Two substrains of Aedes aegypti, already resistant to DDT and pyrethroids, were further selected using either DDT or permethrin by mass exposure of the females only. DDT selection over 14 generations raised the resistance to DDT so far that no accurate LC₅₀ values could be determined. Selection with permethrin raised the tolerance to an irregular plateau 7–10 times the original. DDT selection in the adults raised the DDT resistance of the larvae, but this could be partly overcome using a dehydrochlorinase inhibitor. The resistance to pyrethroids was increased but tolerance of dieldrin, malathion and propoxur compounds was little changed. Permethrin selection of the adults raised resistance to pyrethroids more than DDT selection but also increased DDT resistance. Similar patterns were found for the larval insects. A strain from Demerara in Guyana showed both DDT and pyrethroid resistance, including strong resistance to pyrethrins together with dieldrin and propoxur. It was concluded that two major independent resistance mechanisms existed in the selected strains, a dehydrochlorinase affecting DDT alone, and an unknown mechanism, probably nerve insensitivity (kdr) affecting both DDT and pyrethroids.     

Mechanisms of DDT resistance in larvae of the mosquito Aedes aegypti L

Larvae of eight strains of Aedes aegypti were exposed to DDT and compared for resistance, DDT uptake, in-vivo breakdown of DDT and residual unmetabolised DDT. Resistance varied widely between strains, three being fully susceptible, two almost immune and three of intermediate resistance. Breakdown of DDT by dehydrochlorination to 1,1-dichloro-2,2-bis(4-chlorophenyl)ethylene (pp'-DDE) occurred in all strains and was greater in the five resistant types, but there was no significant correlation between the extent of breakdown in the resistant strains and the level of resistance. Moreover the overall difference between susceptible and resistant strains disappeared when they were compared at a low, almost sublethal, concentration of DDT. Larvae of resistant strains carried a greater absolute quantity of unmetabolised DDT in the body and were able to tolerate levels of DDT that were lethal to susceptible larvae. However the two most resistant strains (T8 and B51) contained significantly less DDT plus pp'-DDE than strains of intermediate resistance (T30 and BSJ) from which they had been derived. Addition of the synergist chlorfenethol to DDT increased its knockdown effect on all resistant strains, suggesting that dehydrochlorination was a factor in resistance. Three strains, two DDT-resistant and one DDT-susceptible, were tested with 1,1-bis(4-ethoxyphenyl)-2,2-dimethylpropane (I), an insecticide that cannot be dehydrochlorinated. All the strains were relatively tolerant to it although the DDT-susceptible strains were less tolerant. Addition of the synergist sesamex decreased the level of tolerance to I in all strains which suggested that microsomal oxidation made some contribution to it. It is concluded that three factors contribute to larval DDT resistance in A. aegypti; (a) increased metabolism to pp'-DDE; (b) increased tolerance to unmetabolised internal DDT; and (c) reduced content of DDT+pp'-DDE (only in the most resistant strains and due either to reduced absorption or increased excretion). These factors are discussed in relation to known larval resistance genes R^DDT1 and y.     

Interstrain comparison of glutathione-dependent reactions in susceptible and resistant houseflies

Glutathione S-alkyl- and S-aryltransferase activities and the glutathione-dependent reactions involved in the metabolism of diazinon, parathion, DDT and γ-BHC were determined in two susceptible and three resistant housefly strains. The relative rate of formation of desethyl diazinon and desethyl parathion and the degradation of γ-BHC paralleled the activities of the alkyl and aryltransferases in the various strains of houseflies suggesting that a single enzyme might be involved. DDT-dehydrochlorinase showed different relative rates among the strains indicating that the dechlorination was catalyzed by a different enzyme. The enzyme responsible for the conjugation of the pyrimidinyl moiety of diazinon appears to be different from the one which catalyzes the conjugation of the p-nitrophenyl moiety of parathion. The dearylation reactions were not mediated by the glutathione S-aryltransferase in the various housefly strains.     

Genetic and biochemical studies of resistance to permethrin in a pyrethroid-resistant strain of the housefly (Musca domestica L.)

One or more weak factors of resistance on autosome 2, and barely detectable resistance on autosome 3, confer moderate resistance to several pyrethroids (5–13-fold) in the field-collected Ipswich strain of houseflies. In these flies, which unlike other pyrethroid-resistant strains lack kdr or super-kdr, pyrethroid resistance probably developed in response to prolonged treatment of buildings for animals with pyrethrins synergised with piperonyl butoxide. Substrains, isolated genetically from Ipswich flies and with resistance only on autosome 2, degraded permethrin more rapidly than susceptible flies and produced larger amounts of very polar metabolites. In this, they differed from flies with kdr or super-kdr which resembled susceptible flies in their metabolism of permethrin. NIA 16388 (propyl prop-2-ynyl phenylphosphonate) was a better synergist and reduced the metabolism of permethrin more than piperonyl butoxide in both the susceptible and resistant insects. The slight increase in synergism and minimal decrease in metabolism when piperonyl butoxide was applied with NIA 16388 indicated that the latter also inhibited detoxication that was sensitive to piperonyl butoxide.     

CNS insensitivity to pyrethroids in the resistant kdr strain of house flies

Solutions of tetramethrin, RU 11679, or cismethrin caused uncoupled convulsions in 30–40 min in exposed thoracic ganglia from S_NAIDM house flies at concentrations down to 10^?10M: whereas these same compounds at 10^?6M concentrations failed to produce poisoning symptoms when perfused onto the exposed ganglia of the kdr strain of house fly. The pyrethroid analogs examined had a negative temperature coefficient of action on the exposed thoracic ganglia from S_NAIDM flies. DDT and GH-74 possessed positive temperature coefficients of action on the exposed thoracic ganglion of susceptible house flies. It is concluded that the central nervous system of the kdr strain of house fly is resistant to pyrethroid action; furthermore, the resistance appears to be widespread throughout the house fly nervous system, involving sensory, motor, and central neural elements.     

Multifactorial resistance to transpermethrin in field-collected strains of the tobacco budworm Heliothis virescens F.

The penetration, degradation and excretion of [³H]transpermethrin were examined in susceptible and field-collected pyrethroid-resistant strains of the tobacco budworm Heliothis virescens. No consistent differences in labelled materials excreted or recovered in cuticle rinses were found between the resistant (R) and susceptible (S) larvae. Considerably lower levels of the parent compound were present internally in R compared with S larvae after 24h (P <0.01), clearly identifying a metabolic resistance mechanism in Meloland and Westmorland larvae. Moderate levels of absorbed permethrin accompanied by an absence of poisoning symptoms were observed in certain individuals of both R strains, suggesting a second resistance mechanism. Neurobioassays of R larvae showed a consistently lower sensitivity of the neuromuscular system to pyrethroids when compared with the S larvae, thus confirming the indication from metabolic studies of the additional (site-insensitive) mechanism. Toxicity values suggest a cross-resistance to other pyrethroids.     

The biochemical basis of resistance to organophosphorus insecticides in the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina

The metabolism in vivo and in vitro of [¹⁴C]parathion and [¹⁴C]paraoxon was studied in a susceptible (LS) and an organophosphorus-resistant (Q) strain of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina. Both strains detoxified the insecticides in vivo via a number of pathways, but the resistant strain produced more of the metabolites diethyl phosphate and diethyl phosphorothionate. No difference was found between strains in the rate of penetration of the compounds used. Also, in vitro studies showed no difference between strains in the sensitivity of head acetylcholinesterase to inhibition by paraoxon. Both the microsomal and the 100,000g supernatant fractions degraded paraoxon, but resistance in Q could be explained by the eightfold greater rate of diethyl phosphate production with or without added NADPH. Parathion was also degraded to diethyl phosphorothionate by an NADPH-requiring enzyme in microsomal preparations from both strains. However, Q produced significantly more diethyl phosphorothionate in vivo than LS. It was concluded that organophosphorus resistance in Q was due mainly to a microsomal phosphatase hydrolyzing phosphate but not phosphorothionate esters, probably enhanced by a microsomal oxidase detoxifying the latter.     

in vitro metabolism of azinphosmethyl in susceptible and resistant houseflies

The in vitro metabolism of [¹⁴C-methoxy] or [³²P]azinphosmethyl by subcellular fractions of abdomens from a resistant and a susceptible strain of houseflies was studied. The degradative activity in both strains was associated with the microsomal and soluble fractions and required NADPH and glutathione, respectively. The resistant strain possessed higher activity for both the mixed-function oxidases and the glutathione transferase than the susceptible strain, and both systems appear to be important in the resistance mechanism. The mixed-function oxidases were involved in the oxidative desulfuration as well as the dearylation of azinphosmethyl. A glutathione transferase located in the soluble fraction catalyzed the formation of desmethyl azinphosmethyl and methyl glutathione. This enzyme also demethylated azinphosmethyl oxygen analog. Although the soluble fraction exhibited both glutathione S-alkyltransferase and S-aryltransferase activity against noninsecticidal substrates, no evidence of the transfer of the benzazimide moiety from azinphosmethyl to glutathione was obtained. Sephadex G-100 chromatography of the soluble enzymes revealed a common eluting fraction responsible for both types of transferase activity.     

Pyrethroid insecticide resistance and treated bednets efficacy in malaria control

Most of the studies on insecticide impregnated bednets efficacy in malaria control have been undertaken in areas where mosquitoes are pyrethroid susceptible. The efficacy of pyrethroid-treated bednets was not compromised even when mosquitoes were kdr resistant. Here, we evaluate a case in which mosquitoes have kdr-like pyrethroid resistance coupled with metabolic mechanisms. Metabolic and kdr-resistance mechanisms in Anopheles stephensi were characterised in our previous study and this easily colonised species was used as a model to examine the efficacy of pyrethroid-treated bednets in the laboratory. Bioassays performed on adults of susceptible (Beech) and resistant (DUB-S) strains using WHO 0.75% permethrin-impregnated papers showed a resistance ratio of 9.75. The recovery rate of the mosquitoes of the DUB-S strain was significantly higher than that of the susceptible strain Beech. The overall permethrin metabolism rates by DUB-S, measured by HPLC method, were 1.5-fold more than by Beech strain. Bioassays performed on DUB-S mosquitoes using different pyrethroid-treated bednets showed that only deltamethrin at 25 mg/m² and α-cypermethrin at 40 mg/m² produced adequate mortality rates. Four other pyrethroids, including permethrin, were ineffective. The deterrency test performed on susceptible and resistant An. stephensi showed that there are significant differences between the entry rates of susceptible and resistant mosquitoes into the exposure tube containing permethrin-treated bednet. These data show that when mosquitoes have both kdr-type and metabolic resistance mechanisms, the efficacy of pyrethroid-treated bednets is questionable.     

Analysis of methidathion resistance mechanisms in Phytoseiulus persimilis A.H

A resistant strain of Phytoseiulus persimilis selected by methidathion pressure for several years metabolizes the [¹⁴C]methidathion faster than does the corresponding susceptible strain. The metabolism is for the main part glutathione dependent and gives the methidathion conjugate on glutathione as a first metabolite: S[5-methoxy-2-oxo-1,3,4-thiadiazol-3(2H)-yl]-l-glutathione. In addition, glutathione transferase with chlorodinitrobenzene as a substrate has a threefold lower K_m in R strain than in S strain. Furthermore, this reaction is competitively inhibited by methidathion with a K_i which is threefold lower in R than in S strain. These results indicated that in this strain of P. persimilis resistance is due to an elevated detoxication of methidathion by a glutathione transferase. Other parameters known to be able to induce resistance in arthropods have been compared in resistant and sensitive strains. Esterase and monooxygenase activity measured with chromogenic substrates are the same in the two strains as is the level of acetylcholinesterase and its inhibition by methidathion oxon. No difference between the two strains has been found in the penetration kinetics measured with [¹⁴C]methidathion. These results indicated that glutathione transferase is the only mechanism which has been selected in P. persimilis, although other mechanisms are known to be involved in resistance to other insecticides in phytoseiid mites.     

Laboratory selected resistance to diflubenzuron in larvae of aedes aegypti

The variation in tolerance to diflubenzuron [1-(4-chlorophenyl)-3-(2,6-difluorobenzoyl)urea] was examined in fourth instar larvae of seven strains of Aedes aegypti, some of which were resistant to DDT and permethrin. The difference between the least and the most tolerant to diflubenzuron was approximately two-fold. There was no correlation with resistance to the other insecticides. A DDT-resistant strain (T8) was selected 10 times (during 12 generations) with diflubenzuron. The LC₅₀ to diflubenzuron had increased 3.3 times by the S₈ generation but there was no further increase in later generations despite further selection. Associated with this increase, a marked decrease in resistance to DDT was observed but no change in permethrin tolerance. A genetically enriched strain (Hotchpotch) was synthesised from 35 strains of different geographic origin and crossed to the selected T8 strain before subsequent generations were selected five times with diflubenzuron. This procedure resulted in an 8 to 12-fold increase in the LC₅₀ value over that for unselected T8, accompanied by a decrease in the slope of the log dose against probit mortality line.     

Expression and inheritance of nerve insensitivity resistance in larvae of Helicoverpa armigera (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) from China

Nerve insensitivity resistance to synthetic pyrethroids was detected in a resistant field strain (JSFX-R) of the cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner), using a neurophysiological assay in which extracellular spontaneous neuronal activity was measured in response to cis-cypermethrin. The nerve insensitivity mechanism was selected using a combination of toxicological and neurophysiological methods. The third-instar larvae in selected strains of Family-37 and CTR strain expressed a very high resistance to fenvalerate (RF = 2060-fold and 805-fold, respectively) and high cross-resistance to DDT (RF = 1927-fold and 2384-fold, respectively) which was not affected by two metabolic synergists, PBO and DMC. The frequency of nerve-insensitive individuals detected in neurophysiological assays (54, 81 and 100% for JSFX-R strain, and the selected strains Family-43 and Family-37, respectively) was not only positively correlated (R² = 0.968) with the frequency of non-PBO-synergisable resistant individuals detected in toxicological tests (37.5, 62.5 and 90% for JSFX-R strain, Family-43 and Family-37, respectively), but also positively correlated (R² = 0.978) with the frequency of DDT-resistant individuals detected in toxicological tests (40, 67.5 and 93.3% for JSFX-R strain, Family-43 and Family-37, respectively). Analysis of dose–mortality lines to DDT and fenvalerate from F₁ hybrids (R♀ × S♂) indicated that nerve insensitivity resistance to DDT and fenvalerate in the CTR strain was inherited in an incompletely recessive pattern. Degree of dominance (D) was estimated to be −0.66 (± 0.06) (DDT) and −0.26 (± 0.04) (fenvalerate). The dose–mortality curves to DDT in back-cross progeny were strongly suggested, by chi-square analysis, to be fitted with those expected of a one-gene model. Evidence for the co-existence of nerve insensitivity and oxidative metabolic resistance mechanisms within individual H armigera and the effects of their interaction on the expression of resistance to fenvalerate are discussed. © 1999 Society of Chemical Industry     

Various mechanisms responsible for permethrin metabolic resistance in seven field-collected strains of the German cockroach from Iran, Blattella germanica (L.) (Dictyoptera: Blattellidae)

Insecticide resistance in the German cockroach can be mediated by a number of mechanisms, the most common being enhanced enzymatic metabolism. Seven field-collected strains of German cockroach, Blattella germanica (L.) with various levels of resistance to pyrethroids, five out of which were also cross-resistant to DDT were used in this study. The investigation of possible mechanisms responsible for permethrin resistance was carried out using the synergists PBO, DEF and DMC and biochemical assays, including general esterases, glutathione S-transeferases and monooxygenases assays, using an automated microtitre plate reader. PBO and DEF, the inhibitors of cytochrome p450 monooxygenases and general esterases, respectively, affected permethrin resistance to varying degrees depending on the strain. DDT resistance in five strains were not completely eliminated by the synergist DMC, an inhibitor of glutathione S-transferase enzymes, suggesting that a further non-metabolic resistance mechanism such as kdr-type may be present. This suggestion was further supported by GST assay data, where a little elevation in GST activity was detected in only two strains. The synergist data supported by biochemical assays implicated that cytochrome p450 monooxygenases or hydrolases are involved in permethrin resistance in some strains. However, these results implicated both enhanced oxidative and hydrolytic metabolism of permethrin as resistance mechanism in the other strains. The results of synergist and biochemical studies implicated that all the field-collected permethrin resistant strains have developed diverse mechanisms of resistance, although these strains have been collected from the same geographic area. The change in resistance ratios of some strains by using PBO or DEF is discussed. It is of interest to note that because resistance to permethrin was not completely eliminated by DEF and PBO, it is likely that one or more additional mechanisms are involved in permethrin resistance in every strain studied.     

Cuticular lipids of two resistant and a susceptible strain of houseflies

A study was made of the composition of the cuticular lipids of two resistant strains of houseflies (Rutgers and Fc), both of which show a reduced rate of absorption of insecticides as a partial mechanism of resistance and a susceptible strain (CSMA). Total lipids, monoglycerides, diglycerides and sterol esters (except in the Fc strain), sterols, fatty acids and phospholipid phosphorus were higher in resistant strains than in the susceptible strain. Phosphatidyl-ethanolamine and phosphatidyl-choline were major constituents of the phospholipid fractions and were appreciably higher in the resistant strains. Cuticular wax contents did not differ among strains. Incorporation of lipid precursors, [U-¹⁴]acetate and [³²P]orthophosphate, was greater in the cuticle of one or both resistant strains, depending on the lipid component examined.     

Mechanism of resistance to fenarimol in Aspergillus nidulans

Mycelial uptake of [¹⁴C]fenarimol (10 μg/ml) by 20 fenarimol-resistant mutants of Aspergillus nidulans was compared with uptake by wild-type strain 003. Uptake of the fungicide during the initial 10 min of incubation was significantly lower in all mutant strains than in the wild-type strain indicating that resistance is related with reduced uptake. Upon prolonged incubation a gradual decrease of accumulated radioactivity in the wild-type strain was observed. A few mutants displayed resistance to unrelated chemicals such as p-fluorophenylalanine or d-serine; this phenomenon appeared not to be due to a decreased uptake of the corresponding natural amino acids. Incorporation of [³H]adenine and [¹⁴C]leucine by mycelium of mutant M193 was hardly inhibited after 5 hr of incubation with the fungicide, whereas a distinct effect was found with the wild-type strain. At this time also fungitoxicity to the wild-type strain became apparent. Probably, this effect is indirectly caused by inhibition of ergosterol biosynthesis. Mycelium of mutant M193 incorporated [¹⁴C]acetate slightly less effectively than the wild-type strain. After 2 hr of incubation with this radiochemical leakage of [¹⁴C]acetate metabolites from mycelium of the mutant strain was observed. This indicates that resistance might be correlated with increased excretion of fungal metabolites, which in turn may be related with reduced fitness of fenarimol-resistant mutants.     

Binding of [14C]DDT and [14C]dicyclohexylcarbodi-imide to a lipoprotein of the membrane sector of mitochondrial ATpase

Intact mitochondria, isolated from red coxal muscle of the American cockroach (Periplaneta americana L.), were incubated in the presence of 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2-bis(4-chloro[¹⁴C]phenyl)ethane ([¹⁴C]DDT) to isolate a suspected binding site for DDT in the membrane sector of the mitochondrial ATPase. The requirements for the binding of DDT were compared with those for the binding of dicyclohexyl[¹⁴C]carbodi-imide([¹⁴C]DCCD), a potent inhibitory probe of mitochondrial ATPase activity. [¹⁴C]DDT appeared to bind to a proteolipid of the membrane sector, which also binds [¹⁴C]DCCD. Exchange experiments, with [¹⁴C]DCCD, [¹⁴C]DDT and unlabelled DDT at different concentrations, indicated that DDT and DCCD may be acting on a similar protein. This protein may act as the energy transducing protonophore required for the synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP in coupled mitochondria. Inhibition of mitochondrial ATPase activity may be a consequence of DDT and DCCD binding to this proteolipid protonophore, resulting in the disruption of energy transduction in muscle and nerve.     

Difference in the picrotoxinin receptor between the cyclodiene-resistant and susceptible strains of the german cockroach

As a result of toxicity tests, it was established that all cyclodiene-resistant strains of the German cockroach are also resistant to picrotoxinin, a plant-origin neurotoxicant. Two of the cockroach strains which exhibit a distinct cross-resistance pattern to picrotoxinin (i.e., LPP and FRP) are the ones that have been purified genetically by backcrossing against the susceptible (CSMA) strain. This cross-resistance pattern appears to be specific to picrotoxinin and does not extend to other neuroexcitants such as bicuculline, beta-bungarotoxin, and DDT. The nervous system of the resistant cockroach was found to be less sensitive to picrotoxinin. Furthermore, it was determined that nerve components from the resistant cockroaches have significantly lower binding capacity to [³H]α-dihydropicrotoxinin. The most likely explanation for the above phenomenon is that these cockroaches have developed the cyclodiene resistance by altering the nerve receptor for picrotoxinin.