Burrow systems made by Aporrectodea nocturna and Allolobophora chlorotica in artificial cores: morphological differences and effects of interspecific interactions

Burrow systems of earthworms contained in artificial cores were analysed through X-ray computed tomography and 3D skeleton reconstructions. Gas diffusion experiments were carried out on these cores to characterize soil transfer properties associated with the different burrow systems. Three types of cores were studied: cores in which Aporrectodea nocturna, an anecic earthworm was introduced (treatment 1), cores in which Allolobophora chlorotica, an endogeic earthworm was introduced (treatment 2) and cores that contained both species (treatment 3). Comparisons of the characteristics of the burrow systems of treatment 1 and 2 show important differences: the burrow system of A. nocturna comprises fewer burrows, which are longer, less branched, more vertical and have a lower sinuosity. The burrow system of A. chlorotica is characterized by lower continuity, which however did not result in a lower soil diffusivity. To study the burrow systems made by the two species in the same core (treatment 3), a separation that was based on differences in pore diameter between the two species and that takes into account the burrow orientation was designed. This separation was proven to be efficient since it resulted in low percentages of errors (around 10%) when applied to the burrow systems of treatments 1 and 2. Comparison of the burrow systems from treatments 1 and 3 demonstrated that the burrow system of A. nocturna was influenced by the presence of A. chlorotica: in treatment 3, A. nocturna made burrows that were smaller, more vertical and less branched. However, these interactions have to be confirmed under natural conditions.     

Quantitative estimates of burrow construction and destruction,by anecic and endogeic earthworms in repacked soil cores

Although the role of earthworms in soil functioning is often emphasised, many important aspects of earthworm behaviour are still poorly understood. In this study we propose a simple and cost-effective method for estimating burrow system area and continuity, as well as a new and often neglected parameter, the percentage of burrow refilling by the earthworms own casts. This novel parameter is likely to have a huge influence on the transfer properties of the burrow system. The method uses standard repacked soil cores in PVC cylinders and takes advantages of clay shrinkage and the fact that earthworms were previously shown to prefer to burrow at the PVC/soil interface. In this way, after removing the PVC cylinders off dry cores, the external section of the burrow system made by earthworms along the soil walls could be easily described. We applied this method to characterise the burrow systems of four earthworms species: two anecics (Aporrectodea caliginosa nocturna and Aporrectodea caliginosa meridionalis) and two endogeics (Aporrectodea caliginosa icaliginosa and Allolobophora chlorotica). After one month the burrow's area generated by both anecic species were much larger (about 40 cm²) than the endogeic burrow's area (about 15 cm²). A. nocturna burrow system continuity was higher than that of A. meridionalis and both anecic burrow systems were more continuous than those made by the endogeic earthworms. This was partly explained by the far larger proportion of the burrow area that was refilled with casts: approximately 40% and 50% for Al. chlorotica and A. caliginosa, respectively compared with approximately 20% for the anecic burrows. We discuss whether these estimates could be used in future models simulating the dynamics of earthworm burrow systems by taking into account both burrow creation and destruction by earthworms.     

Sublethal effects of imidacloprid on the burrowing behaviour of two earthworm species: Modifications of the 3D burrow systems in artificial cores and consequences on gas diffusion in soil

Earthworms have been termed ‘ecosystem engineers’ (sensu [Jones, C.G., Lawton, J.H., Shachak, M., 1994. Organisms as ecosysem engineers. Oikos 69, 373-386.]) because of the important roles they play in the soil. As a consequence, it is assumed that if earthworms change their behaviour following exposure to pesticides or pollutants this could have a drastic impact on soil functioning. To test this assumption under laboratory conditions, we studied the burrow systems made by two earthworm species (the anecic Aporrectodea nocturna and the endogeic Allolobophora icterica) in artificial soil cores containing imidacloprid, a widely used neonicotinoid insecticide. After 1-month incubation period, the macropores created in the soil core were analyzed by tomography. In order to further characterize transfer properties associated with burrow systems gas diffusion measurements were also carried out. The burrow systems made by the two earthworm species were very different: A. nocturna made more continuous, less branched, more vertical and wider burrows than A. icterica. Some changes to A. nocturna burrow systems were observed after exposure to imidacloprid (they made a smaller burrow system and burrows were more narrow), but only at the highest concentration of imidacloprid used (0.5 mg kg⁻¹). A. icterica worms were more sensitive to imidacloprid and many differences in their burrow systems (length, sinuosity, branching rate and number of burrows) were observed at both concentrations tested (0.1 and 0. 5 mg kg⁻¹). As a consequence, the continuity of the burrow systems made by both species was altered following imidacloprid treatment. Gas diffusion through the A. nocturna soil cores was reduced but no difference in gas diffusion was observed in the A. icterica soil cores.     

Differences in burrowing behaviour and spatial interaction between the two earthworm species Aporrectodea nocturna and Allolobophora chlorotica

 To study intraspecific and interspecific interactions between different ecological types of earthworm, the burrowing behaviour of two earthworm species (the anecic earthworm Aporrectodea nocturna and the endogeic earthworm Allolobophora chlorotica) was observed in a microcosm. Earthworms were either alone in the microcosm, together with a conspecific earthworm, or with an earthworm of the other species. Observations under red light, including those of the position of the animals and the burrow dug, were recorded 4 times a day for 8 days and provided the data needed to reconstruct the probable trajectories of each earthworm. Differences in movement and burrowing behaviour were observed. Comparisons between the two species confirmed the expected behaviour of each ecological type: A. nocturna reused its burrow system regularly, whereas A. chlorotica rarely did. Moreover, it was shown that A. chlorotica burrowed less and explored a smaller surface when in the presence of A. nocturna. Besides, A. nocturna burrowed less and explored a smaller surface when in the presence of another A. nocturna. If these interactions occur under natural conditions, they could affect the structure of the burrow systems of the earthworm species examined. Received: 15 January 1999     

A non-destructive method for the morphological assessment of earthworm burrow systems in three dimensions by X-ray computed tomography

Summary Earthworm burrows of endogeic species (Allolobophora caliginosa, Octolasium cyaneum) in artificially packed soil columns were examined using X-ray computed tomography. By means of digital image processing, it was possible to reconstruct and visualize the burrow system in three dimensions. The reconstruction revealed morphological features of the burrows which were not obvious from two-dimensional section images.     

Characterization of the burrow system of the earthworms Lumbricus terrestris and Aporrectodea giardi using X-ray computed tomography and image analysis

 The burrow systems of two earthworm species (Lumbricus terrestris and Aporrectodea giardi) were studied in artificially packed soil columns placed in controlled conditions in the laboratory. At the end of the incubation, which lasted 246 days, the burrow systems were characterized on the undisturbed columns using X-ray computed tomography. This method provided a set of digitized images corresponding to horizontal 3-mm-thick sections. The following parameters were measured using image analysis on each section: number of biopores, their volume, and their individual orientation calculated using an elliptical model of the earthworm channel. The profiles of these parameters through the columns showed that the burrow systems of L. terrestris and A. giardi, which are both anecic species, were very different in terms of total volume, number of burrows, burrow orientation and extension with soil depth. These results led us to conclude that the burrow system of L. terrestris can be considered as a permanent structure whereas that of A. giardi is closer to the burrow system of endogeic species. Received: 12 June 1998     

Burrow systems of endogeic earthworms: Effects of earthworm abundance and consequences for soil water infiltration

By creating burrows, earthworms influence the transfer properties of soils. The effects of endogeic species on soil transfer properties, however, are not yet well understood because these earthworms generally create burrows that are refilled by casts and have no preferential vertical orientation. Thirty soil cores were incubated for various periods (1–3 or 4 weeks) at different earthworm densities (70, 210, 345 or 480 individuals m⁻²). The cores were then scanned using X-ray tomography and the burrow systems were characterised by measuring the total burrow volume, bioturbation volume (refilled burrows and lateral compaction around the burrows), the number of branches, tortuosity and continuity (assessed by computing the number of burrows with a vertical extension greater than 15, 20 and 25% of the core). We also computed the mean geodesic distance, i.e. the mean distance from the bottom to the top of the core assuming that distances inside burrows are null. Rainfall simulations were carried out on 17 cores chosen to encompass the variations observed in the burrow systems. The water transfer efficiency of each core was estimated by measuring two parameters: breakthrough volume and the percentage of water transmitted after 1 h of rain. Burrow and bioturbation volume increased significantly and steadily with time and earthworm density. We estimated that on average Allolobophora chlorotica burrowed 22 cm per week. All other burrow system characteristics also increased with time and earthworm density except the mean geodesic distance, which decreased significantly. This suggests that intraspecific interactions had no significant effect on burrow system geometry. Univariate PLS regressions were used to understand which burrow system characteristics had the strongest influence on water transfer. These regressions showed that the mean geodesic distance was the most important parameter. This means that in addition to individual burrow characteristics, the spatial arrangement of the whole burrow system also had a major effect on transfer properties.     

Burrow constructions during the development of Lumbricus badensis individuals

Summary Juveniles of the anecic earthworm species Lumbricus badensis hatch from cocoon chambers, which the adult has excavated at depths between 0.4 and 1.5 m. After hatching the young animals migrate to the soil surface through the burrow of the adult. Juveniles live epigeically in self-constructed horizontal tubes during the first growing season. After hibernating in the soil at depths between 30 and 50 cm, juveniles make U-shaped burrows in the mineral soil. Later a main tube is constructed penetrating into the soil. This tube is split into two branches forming a V near the soil surface, and resembling the burrow of the adult. The burrow of an adult earthworm may reach a depth of 2.5 m and ramifies into 5–7 outlet tubes near the soil surface. The construction of the burrows during an individual's development, together with the transition from the epigeic to the anecic way of life, shows the close relationship of the anecic Lumbricus species to epigeic types. The feeding behaviour of the adult and the construction of the humic wall confirm this close relationship.Dedicated to the late Prof. Dr. M.S. Ghilarov     

Dynamic study of the burrowing behaviour of Aporrectodea nocturna and Allolobophora chlorotica: interactions between earthworms and spatial avoidance of burrows

The behaviour of earthworms belonging to two different species and ecological types (Aporrectodea nocturna and Allolobophora chlorotica) was studied using two-dimensional (2D) terraria. Two experiments were set up to gain insight into the nature of interactions between these earthworms. Firstly, the evolution of the burrow systems was analysed with the density of the earthworms varying from one to five individuals. Secondly, a burrow system was first established by using one earthworm which was then removed before the introduction of a second earthworm. This second earthworm therefore encountered a burrow system created either by a conspecific earthworm or by an earthworm of the other species. These experiments showed that: (1) intra- and interspecific interactions occur between earthworms, (2) these interactions are dependent on the physical presence of the earthworms, and (3) spatial avoidance can occur (A. chlorotica avoiding burrows created by A. nocturna). The results suggest that earthworm burrow systems are "individual structures", rarely used by other earthworms when inhabited. When abandoned, the burrows may be recolonised depending on the ecological type of the earthworm under consideration.     

Earthworm burrowing activity of two non-Lumbricidae earthworm species incubated in soils with contrasting organic carbon content (Vertisol vs. Ultisol)

The aim of this study was to investigate the burrowing activity of two earthworm species: the endogeic Drawida sinica and one undescribed Amynthas species incubated in Vertisol and Ultisol presenting different soil organic C content. Because of their contrasting feeding behaviours, we hypothesised that soil type would have a bigger influence on the burrowing activity of the endogeic than the anecic species. Repacked soil columns inoculated with earthworms for 30 days were scanned using X-ray tomography and the compiled images used to characterise the burrow systems. After scanning, the saturated hydraulic conductivity (K _sat) was also measured. The Amynthas species burrows were less numerous (30 vs. 180), more vertically oriented (57 vs. 37°), more connected from the surface to the bottom of the columns (73 vs. 5 cm³) and had a higher global connectivity index (83 vs. 28%) than those of D. sinica. The K _sat was threefold faster in columns incubated with Amynthas and was linked to the volume of percolating burrows (R ² = 0.81). The soil type did not influence Amynthas burrow characteristics. In contrast, there were 30% more D. sinica burrows in the Vertisol than in the Ultisol while other burrow characteristics were not affected. This result suggests that these burrows were more refilled with casts leading to shorter and discontinuous burrows. The K _sat was negatively related to the number of burrows (R ² = 0.44) but was not statistically different between the Vertisol and the Ultisol, suggesting a constant impact of this species on the K _sat. We found that a decrease in the amount of soil organic C by 50% had only a small influence on earthworm burrowing activity and no effect on the K _sat.     

Assessment of earthworm contribution to soil hydrology: a laboratory method to measure water diffusion through burrow walls

The capacity for water diffusion in burrow walls (i.e. the coefficient of sorptivity) either burrowed by Lumbricus terrestris (T-Worm) or artificially created (T-Artificial) was studied through an experimental design in a 2D terrarium. In addition, the soil density of earthworm casts, burrow walls (0–3 mm around the burrow) and the surrounding soil (>3 mm) were measured using the method of petroleum immersion. This study demonstrated that the quantity of water which transits through burrows of L. terrestris in the soil matrix was lower than that transited through soil fractures, due to a reduction of soil porosity in burrow walls (compaction: cast > worms burrow walls > surrounding soil > artificial burrow walls). Earthworm behaviour, in particular burrow reuse with associated cast pressing on walls, could explain the larger burrow wall compaction in earthworm burrows. If water diffusion was lower through the compacted burrows, burrow reuse by the worms makes them more stable (worms would maintain the structure over years) than unused burrows. The present experimental design could be used to test and measure the specific differences between earthworm species in their contributions to water diffusion. Probably, these contributions depend on the presumed related-species behaviours which would determine the degree of burrow wall compaction.     

Microcosm investigations into the influence of sheep manure on the behaviour of the geophagous earthworms Aporrectodea trapezoides and Microscolex dubuis

A series of experiments was conducted over 96 h in 240-mm-deep soil microcosms, to assess the effect of the presence and distribution of sheep manure over the soil surface on the vertical and horizontal distribution of burrows and numbers of the earthworms Aporrectodea trapezoides and Microscolex dubius. Within some microcosms the dung was placed on half of the soil surface and this caused aggregation, with over two-thirds of the earthworms being found in the soil directly under the manure. The presence of surface-applied sheep manure caused both species to aggregate in the surface soil. In contrast, without manure, A. trapezoides was evenly distributed throughout the soil profile while M. dubius aggregated in the deeper soil. The pattern of burrow construction was also influenced by the presence of surface manure. In the absence of manure, burrows of both species were evenly distributed through the soil, but in the presence of surface manure M. dubius constructed proportionally more burrows close to the surface. Both species constructed approximately twice the burrow area in the absence than in the presence of surface manure. For both species the daily rate of burrow construction decreased over the experimental period. From these data we inferred that there was more widespread and active foraging behaviour in both species when organic food material was scarce. M. dubius differed from A. trapezoides in that it more strongly concentrated foraging activity in the vicinity of the manure food source.     

Effects of metal pollution on soil macroinvertebrate burrow systems

A reduction in the numbers of macroinvertebrates present in soil may have a negative effect on soil structure, infiltration rates, and gas exchanges. Soil pollution by metal is known to have a detrimental effect on soil macrofauna. The aim of the present study was to evaluate (1) direct and indirect effects of soil pollution on soil macroinvertebrate bioturbation and (2) effects of the two macroinvertebrate communities found in a polluted and a nonpolluted area (one supposed sensitive, the other tolerant to metals) on burrow systems parameters. Macroinvertebrate porosity was studied using X-ray tomography. Three-dimensional reconstructions and characterisation of the burrow system were obtained using image analysis. Results showed that metal pollution principally affected the spatial distribution of macropores (more macropores were found near the soil surface) and the shape of the burrow system (branching rate was higher in the polluted soil), whereas soil macroinvertebrate composition principally affects burrow density parameters (the number of burrows was higher for the sensitive macroinvertebrate community).     

Impact of soil compaction on earthworm burrow systems using X-ray computed tomography: preliminary study

This study is a first approach of the impact of soil compaction due to trafficking by machinery on earthworm burrow systems. To this end, two experiments were established. In the first one, microcosms were incubated in the laboratory for 70 d with Lumbricus terrestris or Aporrectodea giardi. In the second experiment, soil cores were excavated from a sugar beet field mainly colonised by L. terrestris and Aporrectodea caliginosa. The cores were then artificially compacted at 0.12 MPa or 0.25 MPa (which corresponds to the compaction due to trafficking by machinery in the field) or remained non-compacted. The whole cores were submitted to an X-ray computed tomography scan. This method allowed to compare the characteristics of the entire burrow system (total and mean burrowed length, mean length and number of burrows) and of the burrows themselves (number, area and roundness of pores constituting the burrows) in the compacted and non-compacted cores. The results showed that soil compaction contributes to close numerous pores, reduce mean length of burrows and increase the number of fragmented burrows. We concluded that soil compaction affects to a large extent the functionality of burrow systems by fragmenting them and affecting their continuity. This impact increases with the intensity of compaction. The applied soil compaction mainly affected the burrows located in the upper part of the soil. From a general point of view and especially for the upper part of the cores, horizontal burrows seemed to be more affected by compaction than vertical or oblique ones. Globally, the effects of soil compaction were especially observed at the greatest applied pressure (0.25 MPa). At 0.12 MPa, the damage to the burrows was less obvious.     

Worms from the cold: Lumbricid life stages in boreal clay during frost

The vertical distribution and activity of earthworm life stages were studied in an arable field during 0.5 m deep frost. The anecic Lumbricus terrestris L. were below the frost at the bottom of their home burrows (max. depth 1.0 m) and remained there apparently active. Their burrows were open, free of ice and water. The endogeic Aporrectodea caliginosa Sav., mainly small juveniles, were aestivating in the frost layer, which confirms freeze-tolerance in this species. Large A. caliginosa individuals were actively burrowing below the frost down to 1 m depth at soil temperatures close to +1 °C, frost evidently triggering much deeper burrowing than summer droughts. Demonstrating cold-hardiness, viable cocoons of both A. caliginosa and L. terrestris were obtained within a 0-0.25 m layer, frozen for ca. one month prior to sampling. These two common earthworms of boreal soils seem to over-winter in all life stages and remain active below the frost, potentially contributing to the maintenance of subsoil processes during the winter months.     

Assessment of the burrow system of Lumbricus terrestris, Aporrectodea giardi, and Aporrectodea caliginosa using X-ray computed tomography

Artificially packed soil columns were inoculated with individuals of different earthworm species (Lumbricus terrestris, Aporrectodea giardi or Aporrectodea caliginosa) and placed under controlled conditions in the laboratory. At the end of the incubation period, which lasted 8 months, three-dimensional reconstructions of the burrow system of each species were obtained using X-ray computed tomography. The particular features of the three burrow systems and the differences between them are discussed in terms of density, orientation and distribution of the burrows and the complexity of the network in relation to variations in soil depth and soil density. Received: 5 February 1997     

Evolution of burrow systems after the accidental introduction of a new earthworm species into a Swiss pre-alpine meadow

 The unintentional introduction of a new earthworm species (Aporrectodea nocturna) into a Swiss pre-alpine meadow resulted in a great increase in earthworm density in the newly colonized area (386 m^–2) compared with the density observed in the natural area (273 m^–2) where an earthworm community was already present. To investigate the impact of this introduction on the burrow systems, eight soil cores (length 25 cm, diameter 16 cm) were taken (four in the colonized area and four in the natural area) and analysed with computer-assisted X-ray tomography. The resulting images were processed to obtain the 3D-skeleton reconstructions of the earthworm burrow systems. Due to high variability in these burrow systems, only slight differences were observed between the two areas. The total burrow length and the mean burrow lengths tended to be greater in the colonized area. Moreover, the distribution of pore numbers with depth showed different patterns with a maximum for depths between 10 cm and 15 cm in the colonized area and a maximum for depths between 20 cm and 25 cm in the natural area. These differences may have been related to: (1) the particular behaviour of A. nocturna, which was observed to cast at the surface in this site, and (2) the predominance of juvenile earthworms around the colonization front. These differences were sufficient to create significant effects on the continuity of the burrow systems (assessed by the number of different pathways between virtual horizontal planes) for the two areas. The colonized area was characterized by a greater pore continuity, which could have resulted in enhanced transfer properties. Received: 2 July 1999     

Associations between soil texture,soil water characteristics and earthworm populations in grassland

Abstract

The aim of the present study was to investigate the relationships between soil physical characteristics and earthworms in a regional-scale field study in Denmark. The earthworm populations along within-field gradients in soil texture were quantified at five field sites, representing dominant soil types of Denmark. Eleven earthworm species were found, but populations were mainly dominated by Aporrectodea tuberculata and A. longa. Despite considerable variation in soil parameters across the five study sites the results suggest that the biomass of anecic worms (or A. longa as a species) was not causally associated with the soil parameters studied. This indicates that there must be other causal factors associated with the abundance (and composition) of anecic worms that are not among the soil texture and structure parameters studied. On the other hand, soil texture (Coarse sand) was associated with the abundance of the dominant endogeic species, A. tuberculata, but not endogeic worms in general. It was hypothesized that anecic and endogeic earthworms might respond to local soil water characteristics rather than soil texture, but this hypothesis could not be confirmed with the present data.     

Axial and radial pressure exerted by earthworms of different ecological groups

 The aim of this study was to measure the pressures exerted by earthworms during burrowing. For this purpose we developed two methods with which to quantify the axial and radial pressure. The data were recorded with an electronic balance that was connected to a PC. Artificial earthworm burrows were used to standardize the measurements. Plexiglas tubes with diameters ranging from 2 to 6.3 mm which corresponded to the diameter of the earthworms were used. A pin was placed inside the tubes, on which the earthworms exerted a pressure by peristaltic locomotion. Only the maximum values of the pressure measurement were taken into account for evaluation, and the arithmetic mean was calculated. The measurements were conducted with Aporrectodea longa, Lumbricus terrestris, Aporrectodea caliginosa, Octolasion cyaneum, Allolobophora chlorotica, Aporrectodea rosea, Lumbricus rubellus and Dendrobaena octaedra. The species examined were classified into ecological groups. The mean axial pressures exerted by each group were in the order: epigeic (14–25 kPa), endogeic (27–39 kPa) and anecic (46–65 kPa). For the mean radial pressure the order was: epigeic (39–63 kPa), anecic (72–93 kPa) and endogeic (59–195 kPa). It was apparent from the results that radial pressure is the most important pressure with respect to the burrowing activity of earthworms. Received: 28 April 1998