A study of the effect of variation in the calorie‐protein ratio of a medium energy diet and a high energy diet containing sucrose on the efficiency of egg production in caged layers

Literature pertaining to the variation in the protein content of layers’ diets is discussed and the lack of information on the effect of calorie‐protein ratio on food conversion is mentioned. The experiment described in the present paper was designed to test the effect of variations in calorie‐protein ratio on food conversion on a diet of high energy content (1340 k cal/lb.) based on sucrose supplementation and on a medium energy diet (1160 k cal/lb.). At the same time three types of pullet, Thornber 606, Thornber 404 and Light Sussex x Brown Leghorn pullets were compared on the two types of diet, each being fed at three nominal protein levels of 13, 15 and 17 per cent giving a total of eighteen treatments. The pullets were individually recorded for egg production, egg weight and food consumption. Meta‐bolisable energy crude protein determinations were carried out on each of the six diets employed and the actual calorie‐protein ratios calculated.

There was no significant effect on egg production when the calorie‐protein ratio of the diet was raised from 69 (i.e. k cal M.E./lb. per 1 per cent protein) to 90 but an increase to 103 reduced production and egg weight. It was found that maximum efficiency of food conversion was realised at ratios of 76 to 78.

The efficiency of conversion of dietary energy was unaffected by energy concentration in the diet.

The lightweight hybrid (Thornber 606) produced eggs more efficiently than either the Thornber 404 or the crossbred type.     

The nutritive value of fish meal, meat-and-bone meal and field bean meal as measured by digestibility experiments on the adult colostomised fowl

Digestibility experiments were carried out, using colostomised hens fed semi‐synthetic diets containing fish meal, meat‐and‐bone meal or field bean meal as the sole source of protein. A “nitrogen‐free” diet was fed to one group of three birds.

Metabolic faecal nitrogen (MFN) output of birds consuming about 75 g dry matter/d was 106 mg/d. The amino acid composition of the MFN was determined. Endogenous urinary nitrogen output (one result) was 0.80 mg Wg0–75/d.

The true digestibilities of the crude protein of fish meal, meat‐and‐bone meal and field bean meal were respectively 89, 69 and 83 per cent. Digestibility coefficients of individual amino acids were also determined and it was found that the amino acids were not equally digestible. However, for each protein source most of the coefficients fell within a range of + 5 per cent of the mean.

The metabolisable energy content of the fish meal was 2645 kcal/kg, meat‐and‐bone meal 1988 kcal/kg and field beans 2910 kcal/kg.     

Studies on the effect of lysine and methionine supplementation of a high‐protein maize‐soyabean diet and of a low‐protein barley‐white fish meal diet on the performance of caged layers

Selected literature relating to the amino acid supplementation of layers’ diets is reviewed and the results of two experiments are presented.

In the first experiment a basal soyabean meal diet (14.3 per cent crude protein) was supplemented with L‐lysine and DL‐methionine, singly and together. Supplementation of the basal soyabean diet with the amino acids caused no significant effects on egg production, mean and total egg weight or food conversion efficiency. None of the soyabean diets proved as satisfactory for egg production or food conversion efficiency as a fish meal control diet (16.9 per cent crude protein).

In the second experiment the effect of adding 0.1 per cent each of L‐lysine and DL‐methionine or 0.2 per cent each of l‐lysine and DL‐methionine to a low fish meal diet (2.5 per cent fish meal) was examined. The addition of 0.2 per cent of each amino acid caused an increase in egg production.

Mean egg weight was improved by the addition of amino acids at both levels although this effect was not statistically significant. Comparison of the low fish meal diets with a fishmeal control diet (10 per cent fishmeal) showed that at the 0.2 per cent addition of amino acids, egg production, total egg weight and food conversion efficiency were better than on the 10 per cent fish meal control diet.

Two breeds, light and medium hybrids were used in both experiments.

The results are discussed with reference to their practical significance.     

Effects of dietary protein,methionine and lysine on urinary amino acid excretion in turkeys1

1. Two experiments were conducted to determine the influence of dietary protein and amino acids on urinary excretion of amino acids and nitrogen in colostomised turkey hens.

2. Normal and colostomised turkeys 8 weeks of age were fed on control and high protein diets. Body weight gains of both types of birds were similar. Diet did not affect the amino acids in the urine significantly, but urinary nitrogen was higher with the high protein diet.

3. Normal and colostomised turkeys 10 weeks of age were fed a diet with either supplemental DL‐methionine or L‐lysine hydrochloride (each 20 g/kg diet). DL‐methionine depressed gain and resulted in considerable excretion of methionine in urine. Lysine had little effect on weight gain or urinary lysine.     

Role of caeca in the nitrogen nutrition of the chicken fed on a moderate protein diet or a low rotein diet plus urea

1. A study was carried out to investigate whether the back‐flow of urine into the caeca benefits the nitrogen economy of adult cockerels fed on a diet containing 100 g protein/kg and when dietary urea is absorbed, excreted into urine and utilised.

2. No significant effects of colostomy on nitrogen utilisation were observed in chickens fed on 100 g/kg protein diet, whereas colostomy was highly effective in decreasing it in chickens on a diet containing 50 g protein/kg plus urea (P< 0.05).

3. Nitrogen utilisation in conventional birds was significantly less when a diet of moderate protein content was fed than when a low protein diet plus urea was fed, but the opposite effect was seen with colostomised birds (P <0.05).

4. Colostomy increased urea excretion (nitrogen/kg body weight/day) from 4 to 9 mg in chickens fed on the moderate protein diet, but greatly, from 45 to 182 mg, in those fed on the low protein diet plus urea (P<0.05).

5. Blood urea concentration increased by about 20 mg per 100 ml in 3 h, a value which was maintained up to 6 h but which returned to the prefeeding concentration at 24 h; both control and colostomised chickens on the low protein diet plus urea responded similarly.

6. After feeding urea, half the daily excretion of urea was observed to occur within 6 and 9 h, respectively, in control and colostomised chickens. The excretion rate of urea (the peak occurred during 3.6 h in the colostomised and during 1.3 h in the control) was at least twice as high in colostomised as in normal birds 3 h postfeeding.

7. It is concluded that the caeca play a useful role in nitrogen economy of the protein‐depleted chicken, but not in the protein‐adequate chicken and that dietary urea degradation in the caeca occurs from 3 h after feeding.     

Some factors affecting urinary and Faecal nitrogen loss by chickens fed on a protein‐free diet

1. In adult colostomised cockerels, the rates of urinary and faecal nitrogen loss were measured when feeding low‐ and high‐energy, protein‐free diets after a preliminary period during which diets of differing energy and protein contents had been fed.

2. Urinary nitrogen excretion increased with increasing protein and decreasing energy in the preliminary diet.

3. Urinary nitrogen excretion was high during the first 3 d of feeding a high‐energy, protein‐free diet, decreased rapidly during the next 3 d and thereafter become relatively constant. However, in the case of a low‐energy, protein‐free diet, urinary nitrogen excretion gradually declined throughout the trial period of 15 d, resulting in increased urinary nitrogen excretion.

4. After a 3‐d period of adjustment faecal nitrogen loss from birds fed on a protein‐free diet was relatively constant under the conditions examined.     

The effects of early and late maturity on the protein requirements of pullets

Growing pullets were exposed to two light patterns which caused a difference in sexual maturity of 5 weeks. From 28 to 38 weeks of age they were fed diets containing crude protein levels of 7.0, 8.5, 10.0, 11.5, 13.0 and 14.5 per cent. Yellow maize provided 45 per cent and soyabean meal 55 per cent of the protein in all six diets.

Rate of lay, egg weight and body weight were greater in the late maturing flock than in the early flock at the start of the assay and throughout the assay period. The late maturing pullets required more protein to reach and maintain their maximum potential than the early birds, presumably because their potential output was greater. The late birds showed a diminishing but continued response to protein up to the highest level fed (14.5 per cent corresponding to 23 g. protein per bird day). The early maturing pullets showed no response to dietary protein levels beyond 11.5 per cent and their estimated protein requirement was about 16 g. per bird day.

When limiting amounts of protein were fed (7.0–10.0 per cent of the diet) the two flocks achieved similar levels of egg output. In both flocks and throughout the assay, body weight and egg weight fell at the two lowest levels and increased at the three highest levels of protein.

It is concluded that the protein requirements of early maturing and late maturing flocks of pullets may differ, but only in a way which corresponds directly with their different potential outputs. In the late flock, which had the higher protein requirement, excellent production was obtained with a diet containing 14½ per cent crude protein all of which came from vegetable sources.     

Amino acid interactions in chick nutrition. 3. Interdependence in amino acid requirements

The quantitative nature of specific interactions between certain indispensable amino acids has been examined in a series of factorial experiments with young chicks.

It was demonstrated that when the dietary concentration of lysine was 1.10 per cent, the arginine requirement of the chick was 0.80 per cent. When the lysine concentration was raised to 1.35, 1.60 or 1.85 per cent of the diet, the arginine requirement was increased to 0.92, 1.04 and 1.15 per cent of the diet respectively. In another experiment, it was found that when due importance had been attached to the interaction between lysine and arginine, the requirements for these amino acids could be lowered to 0.94 per cent and 0.81 per cent respectively. These concentrations are considerably lower than those normally recommended for young chicks.

The interrelationship between leucine and isoleucine has also been defined in quantitative terms. At concentrations of 1.40, 2.15 or 2.90 per cent leucine, the isoleucine requirement was 0.58, 0.62 and 0.65 per cent of the diet respectively.

In a further study, a similar dependence of valine requirements upon the dietary concentration of leucine was observed: at concentrations of 1.40, 2.40 or 3.40 per cent leucine, the valine requirement was shown to be 0.77, 0.89 and 1.01 per cent respectively. The results of the experiment on the threonine‐tryptophan interaction indicated that at concentrations of 0.80, 1.30, 1.80 or 2.30 per cent threonine, the tryptophan requirement was 0.17, 0.18, 0.19 and 0.20 per cent of the diet respectively.

The results of the present study permit the general conclusion that the requirements of amino acids are interdependent.     

Some effects of changing protein levels during the pullet laying year

Three diets containing 12, 14 and 16 per cent crude protein were fed to laying pullets from 23 to 63 weeks of age. The laying year was divided into three periods of 10, 15 and 15 weeks to examine the effect of feeding these diets at different stages of lay. Eighteen treatments were used, representing all possible combinations of three diets in the first period, three diets in the second period and two diets (16 and 12 per cent) in the third period. Two groups of 75 pullets were allocated to each treatment.

In each period the diet had a significant effect on the rate of lay, egg output (g./day) showed a linear regression on protein intake. There was no indication that the amount of protein needed to maximise egg output was any less in one period than another, although the level of maximum output varied substantially as the year progressed.

Where the feeding of an inadequate level of protein in one period was followed by a higher level in the next, liveweight showed a marked recovery but there was little evidence of compensatory egg production. When the protein of the diet was reduced from 16 to 12 per cent, rate of lay fell sharply to a level below that of birds which had received the 12 per cent protein diet throughout.     

Changes in dietary protein level during the pullet year

A “High” protein diet (14 per cent crude protein, 2490 k cal. ME/kg.) and a “Low” protein diet (10.5 per cent protein, 2420 k cal. ME/kg.) were fed to two types of laying pullet. One type was a small commercial hybrid weighing about 1.6 kg. and the other was a large first cross weighing about 2.4 kg. at 20 weeks. After 12 weeks and 24 weeks of lay, groups were transferred from the High to the Low protein diet and vice versa.

In the heavy strain birds the High and Low protein diets both supported good egg production throughout the trial and changing from High to Low protein had no effect on rate of lay. The opposite change from Low to High, made after 12 weeks of lay, stimulated an increase in rate of lay above the level of birds which had received the High protein diet throughout.

In the small hybrid pullets the low protein diet did not support a normal rate of lay. Attempts to reduce dietary protein by switching from High to Low after 12 or 24 weeks caused a fall in rate of lay. Groups transferred from Low to High increased their rate of lay to a level comparable with controls kept on High protein throughout.

Egg weight and body weight were affected by dietary protein level in both strains. Changes in the diet caused corresponding changes in both egg weight and body weight.

It is concluded that there is little scope for reducing the level of protein in the diet during the laying year. If a diet is inadequate in the early stages of production it is likely to remain inadequate for any later stage. On the other hand, some unexpected benefit was obtained in one strain by increasing the dietary protein beyond the level which was adequate for maximum egg production in the first 3 months of lay.     

Efficiency of egg production of three types of caged layers fed diets containing maize, oats or barley as the main cereal ingredient

The results of two similar experiments, each using 204 pullets in cages, are presented. In each experiment, a type of light commercial hybrid, heavier commercial hybrids and Brown Leghorn×Light Sussex cross‐breds were compared, in factorial design, on diets containing either 65 per cent barley, 55 per cent maize or 35 per cent oats and 15 per cent bran. Individual records of egg production, egg weight, food conversion and body weight were kept for eight 28‐day periods, starting when the pullets were in full production.

There were no significant differences in egg production between diets but in both experiments a significantly improved food conversion ratio was obtained on the high maize diets, which also gave the highest level of energy consumption.

Most breed differences were not significant but in Experiment 1 the crossbreds produced significantly fewer eggs than the hybrids and in Experiment 2 the light hybrids gave a significantly better food conversion ratio than the two heavier types. The crossbred pullets consumed the most energy in both experiments and in Experiment 1 had significantly the worst energetic efficiency of egg production.

There were no significant interactions between type of pullet and type of diet in either experiment. Thus there were no indications that, at the energy levels investigated, favourable effects may be expected from the feeding of higher energy diets to the lighter hybrid type pullet.

The practical significance of feeding a high barley diet is discussed.     

The performance of male ducklings given starter diets with different concentrations of energy and protein

1. Male ducklings were fed for 14, 21 or 28 d on diets containing 180, 200, 220 or 240 g of protein and 10.88 or 12.55 MJ of metabolisable energy (ME) per kg, followed by a common finisher diet until 56 d of age.

2. Birds given starter diets with 220 or 240 g of protein per kg were significantly heavier at 14 d than those given diets with 180 or 200 g protein per kg.

3. There was no significant benefit in feeding diets with protein levels greater than 180 g/kg for more than 14 d.

4. Diets with only 10.88 MJ of ME per kg produced significantly lighter birds at 28 and 56 d of age and significantly reduced food conversion efficiency up to 14 d.     

A formal method of determining the dietary amino acid requirements of laying‐type pullets during their growing period

1. The amino acid requirements of laying type pullets during the growing period can be estimated by measuring the growth of different components of the body and making use of nutritional constants that define the amount of each amino acid that is required for the production of the tissues being formed.

2. In this experiment, carcase analyses of each of three breeds of pullets were conducted at weekly intervals throughout the growth of the pullets, to 18 weeks of age. Measurements were made of body weight, gut‐fill and feather weight, and chemical analyses consisted of water, protein, lipid and ash measurements of both the body and the feathers. Each age group comprised 10 birds of each breed.

3. Gompertz functions accurately estimated the growth of both body protein and feather protein, to 18 weeks of age, from which the rate of growth of these two components of the body could be estimated. The mature weight of pullets was overestimated by the Gompertz growth curve, which may indicate that a pullet ceases to increase in body protein content once sexual maturity has been reached.

4. Using allometric relationships between the chemical components of the body and of feathers, all the components of growth could be estimated from the growth of body protein and feather protein. These components were then added together to determine the growth rate of the body as a whole.

5. The daily amino acid requirements for 4 functions were calculated, namely, those for the maintenance of body protein and feather protein, and for the gain in body protein and feather protein. These requirements were then summed to determine the requirement of pullets on each day of the growing period.

6. Using the ‘effective energy’ system, the amount of energy required by these pullets was calculated for each day of the growing period, from which the desired daily food intake of the pullets could be predicted. By dividing the amino acid requirement by this daily food intake it was possible to determine the concentration of amino acids that would be needed in the diet in order to meet the requirements of a pullet.

7. The results indicate that the ratio between the requirement for lysine and for methionine and cysteine changes dramatically during the growing period, negating the concept of a fixed ratio between all the amino acids during growth.

8. The above process is the first step in determining the optimal feeding programme for a population of pullets of a given genotype. The constraining effects, of the diet being offered and of the environment in which the pullets are housed, on the food intake and growth rate of each pullet have to be estimated, and such a theory can then be expanded to include all the individuals in the population. Only by the use: of simulation models can all these constraining effects be considered simultaneously.     

Comparison of laying rations with and without animal protein at the Canadian Random Sample Egg Production Test

For a number of years, the laying ration fed to the hens at the Canadian Random Sample Egg Production Test has contained foodstuffs of animal origin to the extent of 3 per cent meat meal, 2 per cent fish meal, 1 per cent dried whey and 2 per cent tallow. Recently, over a period of 2 years, this ration was compared with a modification in which all of the animal products except tallow were removed. The proportions of the remaining ingredients in the modified diet were adjusted to keep protein, energy, calcium and phosphorus levels comparable in the two rations.

In the first test year, the modified diet was slightly superior to the control diet in terms of egg numbers, egg weight and egg quality. In the second year, there were no significant differences in these traits between diets. Although 17 strains were tested in the first year, and 14 in the second, no significant strain × ration interactions occurred in any performance trait.

These trials provided no evidence that the laying hen responds to unknown factors contained in animal products. There was also no evidence that the removal of animal products adversely affected protein quality, although dietary protein levels may not have been low enough to reveal such a change.     

Magnesium tolerance of the growing and laying chicken

The effects of various levels of magnesium in growing and laying rations on growth and laying performance were studied. Levels of magnesium in the growing and laying rations were 0.36, 0.59, 1.06 and 1.83 per cent and 0.48, 0.70, 1.20 and 1.96 per cent respectively.

Only the growing ration containing 1.83 per cent magnesium significantly reduced growth, percentage bone ash and food utilisation during the growing phase (9–20 weeks). In the laying phase (20–40 weeks) significantly greater gains in body weight and percentage bone ash were produced by the birds which had received the growing ration containing 1.83 per cent magnesium.

The magnesium content of the growing rations had no effect on rate of lay, egg weight or egg shell thickness.

Hens fed the laying ration containing 1.96 per cent magnesium gained less body weight, laid fewer and lighter eggs and utilised their food less efficiently than those fed other levels of magnesium.

Egg production and food required per dozen eggs were poorer with the ration containing 1.20 per cent magnesium, but were not statistically different from the rations containing 0.48 or 0.70 per cent magnesium.

Eggs with thinner shells were produced by hens fed the 1.96 per cent magnesium ration at 34 weeks of age than were produced by those fed the 0.48 or 0.70 per cent magnesium rations.     

Compensatory growth in turkeys: effect of undernutrition on subsequent protein requirements

An adequate and a low protein starter diet (29 and 20 per cent crude protein respectively) were fed from o to 6 weeks of age. The poults receiving only 20 per cent protein were 17 per cent lighter at 6 weeks than the fully fed group. Turkeys from each treatment were then fed one of five levels of protein from 6 to 10 weeks of age. After 10 weeks all groups were fed adequate levels of protein to allow undernourished poults to exhibit compensatory growth.

The percentage protein required for maximum growth in the 6 to 10‐week stage was similar whether turkeys had been fully fed or undernourished from 0 to 6 weeks. But the “ effective “ percentage of protein required in the 6 to 10‐week stage, defined as the level which subsequently allowed maximum body weight at 20 weeks of age, was less for initially fully fed birds. This was because they had smaller growth deficits at 10 weeks and consequently made faster recovery in the limited time allowed.

Turkeys fed 29 and 17 per cent protein or 20 and 22 per cent protein in starter and grower diets respectively reached the same live‐weight at 20 weeks as fully fed turkeys which received 29 per cent protein from o to 6 weeks and 24 per cent protein from 6 to 10 weeks. The compensating turkeys ate about the same total weight of food as fully fed groups, but had a 10 per cent lower total protein intake.     

Protein synthesis in the liver and breast muscle of chicks fed on a high protein diet

1. The influence of feeding a high protein diet containing 400 g crude protein (CP)/kg on liver and breast muscle protein synthesis in chicks was investigated using a large dose injection of l‐[4 ‐³H]phenylalanine.

2. Liver weight of chicks fed on the high protein diet was significantly heavier than that of chicks fed on a control diet with 200 g CP/kg, and breast muscle weight was not affected by the treatment.

3. Fractional and absolute protein synthesis rates, RNA and protein contents, and RNA:protein ratio of breast muscle were not influenced by feeding the high protein diet.

4. Feeding the high protein diet decreased fractional synthesis rate of liver protein, an observation explained by reduced RNA:protein ratio. Liver protein content was elevated by feeding the high protein diet and this resulted in no change in the absolute synthesis rate of liver protein.     

Relationship of decreased caecal urease activity by dietary penicillin to nitrogen utilisation in chickens fed on a low protein diet plus urea

1. The relationship of the decreased caecal urease activity by dietary penicillin to nitrogen utilisation was assessed in chickens fed a low protein diet plus urea.

2. Dietary penicillin at 20 and 100 mg/kg decreased anaerobic bacteria counts, urease activity and ammonia concentration in caecal contents (P< 0.05, except for ammonia in the case of the 100 mg/kg penicillin diet).

3. The 20 mg/kg penicillin diets significantly increased the excretion of urea and total nitrogen (P < 0.05) and decreased ammonia excretion, and significantly reduced nitrogen retention (P < 0.05). The 100 mg/kg penicillin diet also resulted in similar but not significant changes, which tended to be less than those by the 20 mg/kg penicillin diet.

4. Ammonia, urea, glutamine and uric acid concentrations in blood, liver and kidney were unchanged by dietary penicillin.

5. It is concluded that caecal ammonia production from urea was closely correlated with nitrogen utilisation in chickens fed a low protein diet plus urea.     

Water balance of Colostomised and non‐Colostomised hens at different ambient temperatures

1. The quantities of water gained and lost, and hence the total water balance, were determined in normal and colostomised White Leghorn laying hens at ambient temperatures of 5, 20 and 35 °G.

2. In both groups the water intake and water loss at all temperatures were well balanced.

3. Water to food ratios and water content of excreta of normal hens increased with increasing temperature.

4. The wetter excreta at 35 °C are caused by an increased urine production and not by an increased water passage through the alimentary tract.     

Phosphorus requirements of poultry. IV. The effects on growing pullets of feeding diets containing no animal protein or supplementary phosphorus

Pullets reared to 18 weeks of age on diets containing no animal protein supplements and to which no source of inorganic phosphorus was added showed no clinical symptoms of rickets and no significant differences in average body weight, feed consumption, efficiency of feed conversion or livability compared with pullets reared on comparable diets supplemented with inorganic phosphorus.

The results indicate that growing pullets are able to use effectively organic sources of dietary phosphorus for growth and bone formation and can be reared satisfactorily on starter diets containing lower levels of total phosphorus than currently recommended.

Replacing protein of animal origin in pullet starter and growers' diets by soyabean meal and DL‐methionine or by extracted soyabean meal and extracted sunflower seed meal did not result in any adverse effects.