The biochemical nature of malathion resistance in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan

Malathion resistance in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan was synergized by triphenyl phosphate, primarily a carboxylesterase inhibitor. There was a slight degree of antagonism with piperonyl butoxide. The major metabolite of malathion in larvae of both the resistant and susceptible strains was malathion monocarboxylic acid. Resistant larvae produced about twice as much of this product as the susceptible larvae. This suggests that a qualitative or a quantitative change in a carboxylesterase enzyme may be the basis of malathion resistance in this strain. Analysis of general esterase levels to α- and β-naphthyl acetate showed that there was no quantitative change in the amount of carboxylesterase enzyme present in the resistant strain as compared to the susceptible.     

Studies on hydrolases in various house fly strains and their role in malathion resistance

Aliesterase, carboxylesterase, and phosphorotriester hydrolase activities in six house fly strains were studied in relation to malathion resistance. Selection of two susceptible strains with malathion for three generations resulted in an increase in both carboxylesterase activity and LD₅₀ of malathion, indicating that the increased detoxication by the enzyme was the major mechanism selected for malathion resistance. With the highly resistant strains, however, the carboxylesterase activity alone was not sufficient to explain the resistance level, and the involvement of additional mechanisms, including phosphorotriester hydrolase activity, was suggested. The E₁ strain, which had high phosphorotriester hydrolase activity but normal or low carboxylesterase activity, showed a moderate level, i.e., sevenfold resistance. Upon DEAE-cellulose chromatography, two or three esterase peaks were resolved from susceptible, moderately resistant, and highly resistant strains. The substrate specificity, the sensitivity to paraoxon inhibition, and the $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio of malathion hydrolysis were studied for each esterase peak from the different strains. The results suggested the existence of multiple forms of esterases with overlapping substrate specificity in the house fly.     

The biochemical basis of malathion resistance in the sheep blowfly,Lucilia cuprina

The in vivo and in vitro metabolism of [¹⁴C]malathion was studied in susceptible (LS) and malathion resistant (RM) strains of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina (Wiedemann). No difference was found between strains in the penetration, excretion, storage, or inhibitory potency of the insecticide. However, RM degraded malathion to its α- and β-monocarboxylic acid metabolites more rapidly than LS, both in vivo and in vitro. This enhanced degradation of [¹⁴C]malathion occurred in vitro in both mitochondrial and microsomal fractions of resistant flies. Kinetic analysis revealed that these fractions degraded malathion by discrete mechanisms. The enzymes from the mitochondria of both strains had the same K_m, whereas the microsomal enzyme from the RM strain had a fivefold higher K_m than that from the LS strain. Studies of esterase activities and the effect of enzyme inhibitors showed that both the mitochondrial and microsomal resistance mechanisms were the result of enhanced carboxylesterase activity. It was concluded that increased carboxylesterase detoxification of malathion adequately explained the high level of malathion resistance in RM if rate-limiting factors such as cuticular penetration were taken into account.     

Esterase-mediated malathion resistance in the human head louse, Pediculus capitis (Anoplura: Pediculidae)

Resistance in a dual malathion- and permethrin-resistant head louse strain (BR-HL) was studied. BR-HL was 3.6- and 3.7-fold more resistant to malathion and permethrin, respectively, compared to insecticide-susceptible EC-HL. S,S,S-Tributylphosphorotrithioate synergized malathion toxicity by 2.1-fold but not permethrin toxicity in BR-HL. Piperonyl butoxide did not synergize malathion or permethrin toxicity. Malathion carboxylesterase (MCE) activity was 13.3-fold and general esterase activity was 3.9-fold higher in BR-HL versus EC-HL. There were no significant differences in phosphotriesterase, glutathione S-transferase, and acetylcholinesterase activities between strains. There was no differential sensitivity in acetylcholinesterase inhibition by malaoxon. Esterases from BR-HL had higher affinities and hydrolysis efficiencies versus EC-HL using various naphthyl-substituted esters. Protein content of BR-HL females and males was 1.6- and 1.3-fold higher, respectively, versus EC-HL adults. Electrophoresis revealed two esterases with increased intensity and a unique esterase associated with BR-HL. Thus, increased MCE activity and over-expressed esterases appear to be involved in malathion resistance in the head louse.     

The in vitro degradation of [14C]malathion by enzymatic extracts from resistant and susceptible strains of Drosophila melanogaster

Enzyme preparations from Drosophila melanogaster flies degraded [¹⁴C]malathion to α- and β-malathion monoacids and, hence, were considered to contain malathion carboxylesterase (ME) activity. Although ME- activity was stable during preincubation in the absence of malathion, it decreased dramatically during the course of the reaction, and could not be completely recovered by Sephadex G-25 chromatography. Furthermore, the protein fraction after chromatography still contained ¹⁴C, suggesting that the enzyme had become inhibited by a bound, ¹⁴C-labeled derivative. Extracts from a resistant (malathion-selected), an intermediate control, and the susceptible Canton S strains of D. melanogaster differed in the lability of ME activity during the reaction. This difference was partly attributed to the production of small amounts of malaoxon (2–8%) by the extracts from the more resistant strains. No consistent strain differences were found when the rate of malathion degradation was measured during the first minute of reaction, either with or without a microsomal oxidase inhibitor (metyrapone) present. These results, together with the cross-resistance of the malathion-selected strain to other insecticides and the lack of a synergistic effect of two carboxylesterase inhibitors (triphenyl phosphate and S,S,S-tributylphosphorotrithioate) suggested that malathion carboxylesterase does not contribute significantly to the observed differences in malathion resistance between strains.     

Changes in malathion resistance with age in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan

Resistance to malathion in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan was measured at intervals during the first week of adult life. LT₅₀ values for homozygous resistant females decreased four-fold during the first 7 days of adulthood. A decrease in resistance with age also occurred in heterozygotes; the LT₅₀ values of males and females fell sevenfold during the first 5 days of adulthood. The sensitivity to malathion of a susceptible strain increased with age. A biochemical basis for the declining resistance levels was investigated. Resistant and susceptible adults were homogenized at intervals during the first week of adulthood and soluble extracts were incubated with [¹⁴C]malathion. The rate of malathion metabolism to mono- and dicarboxylic acids was faster in resistant than in susceptible mosquitoes. The rate of malathion metabolism decreased with age in both strains. A decrease in carboxylesterase activity with age in resistant and susceptible mosquitoes is thus responsible for the increasing sensitivity to malathion. Implications for the monitoring of resistance in the field by diagnostic dosages and for the future use of malathion in mosquito control are discussed.     

Selective inhibition of separate esterases in rat and mouse liver microsomes hydrolyzing malathion,trans-permethrin,and cis-permethrin

Separate esterase activities of rat and mouse liver microsomes hydrolyzing malathion, trans-permethrin, and cis-permethrin were differentiated on the basis of their sensitivities to inhibition by paraoxon and α-naphthyl N-propylcarbamate (NPC). In rat liver microsomes, the malathionhydrolyzing activity was more sensitive to both inhibitors and showed a different time course of NPC inhibition than the activities hydrolyzing the permethrin isomers. Paraoxon completely inhibited trans-permethrin hydrolysis, but only partially inhibited that of cis-permethrin. The paraoxonsensitive trans- and cis-permethrin-hydrolyzing activities were not differentially inhibited, but separate inhibition curves were obtained for the inhibition of trans- and cis-permethrin hydrolysis by NPC. The mouse liver esterase activity hydrolyzing trans-permethrin showed a similar paraoxon sensitivity to that of rat liver, but that the paraoxon-sensitive portion of the cis-permethrinhydrolyzing activity was 5.5-fold less sensitive to paraoxon than the corresponding rat liver activity and was clearly differentiated from the mouse liver trans-permethrin-hydrolyzing activity. The mouse liver malathion-hydrolyzing activity was 100-fold less sensitive to paraoxon and 14-fold less sensitive to NPC than the corresponding rat liver activity. Rat and mouse liver esterase activities hydrolyzed trans- and cis-permethrin at similar rates under standard assay conditions, but mouse liver esterases were 10-fold less active in hydrolyzing malathion. The higher specific activity of rat liver malathion-hydrolyzing esterases resulted from the greater apparent affinity and maximum velocity for malathion hydrolysis. These results demonstrate that the hydrolysis of malathion, trans-permethrin, and cis-permethrin by rat and mouse liver microsomal preparations involves several esterases with differing substrate specificities and inhibitor sensitivities.     

Effect of a mixture of iprobenfos and malathion on the development of malathion resistance in the mosquito Culex pipiens pallens Coq

A malathion-resistant (RM) strain of Culex pipiens pallens Coq was obtained by successively selecting a field population with malathion in the laboratory. The synergistic effect of iprobenfos on malathion toxicity and alpha-naphthyl acetate (alpha-NA) esterase assay revealed that malathion resistance in the RM strain was associated with increased alpha-NA esterase activity and the synergism was mainly due to the inhibition by iprobenfos of this activity. There was no difference in alpha-NA esterase activity between the larvae and female adults in the susceptible (S) strain, but the activity in the adults was 13-fold higher than in the larvae of the RM strain. To understand the effect of the application of a mixture of iprobenfos and malathion on the evolution of malathion resistance, an artificial strain (Syn) was generated by mixing the RM and S strains with 0.1 frequency of the malathion-resistant individuals. The offspring of the Syn strain were divided into two sub-strains, Rm and Rm+ibp, which were successively treated with, respectively, malathion alone and malathion + iprobenfos (1:2) at LC70. In the mixture, the fungicide iprobenfos acted as a synergist of malathion. After treatment for 10 generations, the resistance level to malathion was 317.4-fold for the Rm sub-strain, whereas for the Rm+ibp sub-strain it was only 38.9-fold, compared with the Syn strain. Similar results were obtained by measurement of alpha-NA esterase activity from both larvae and female adults. The alpha-NA esterase activities in larvae and female adults at F10 generation were 2.6- and 10.9-fold from the Rm+ibp sub-strain and 5.7- and 98.5-fold from the Rm sub-strain, respectively, compared with the Syn strain. The above results suggested that iprobenfos, although it cannot completely stop or prevent the onset of malathion resistance, could dramatically delay its evolution.     

Role of a microsomal carboxylesterase in reducing the action of malathion in eggs of Triatoma infestans

A microsomal malathion carboxylesterase present in Triatoma infestans eggs was active from the first day of embryonic development. This microsomal egg malathionase (MEM) showed a unique band in polyacrilamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) when malathion was used as substrate. In vivo metabolism of [¹⁴C]malathion during all embryonic development showed a 10% degradation due to carboxylesterases. The in vitro evaluation of the same metabolic pathway catalyzed by the microsomal fraction of T. infestans eggs showed partial inhibition by paraoxon. α- and β-malathion monoacids were identified as the main metabolites of the in vivo and in vitro metabolic pathways. The carboxylesterase band that appeared in PAGE (MEM) from the first day of embryonic development could be the main cause of malathion tolerance in T. infestans eggs.     

The purification and characterization of esterases from insecticide-resistant and susceptible house flies

Four major esterases in one susceptible (CSMA) and two resistant (Hirokawa, E₁) house fly strains were separated by chromatofocusing. Of the four esterases, those with pI's of 5.1 and 5.3 accounted for 90% of the p-nitrophenyl butyrate hydrolyzing activity in the three house fly strains. They also accounted for 70% (Hirokawa, E₁) and 40% (CSMA) of the paraoxon-hydrolyzing activity as well as 87% (Hirokawa), 39% (E₁) and 66% (CSMA) of the malathion-hydrolyzing activity in microsomes as measured by esterase-antibody interaction. In the Hirokawa strain, the pI 5.1 esterase was the predominant esterase and was more active than that of the the CSMA strain. Different substrate specificities and a different K_m toward acetylthiocholine, as well as different rates of malathion and paraoxon hydrolysis between the Hirokawa and CSMA strains, suggest a qualitative difference in the pI 5.1 esterase. For the pI 5.1 esterase from the E₁ strain, a different substrate specificity, a different K_m for p-nitrophenyl butyrate, a different sensitivity to inhibitors, and a different rate of paraoxon hydrolysis suggest that it is a modified esterase. This esterase is not a phosphorotriester hydrolase, nor does it lack nonspecific esterase activity. It is a modified esterase which has a different substrate specificity when compared to the esterases from the other strains. The molecular weight of the esterases studied was approximately 220,000, with pH optima of about 7.0.The ratio of malathion α-monoacid to β-monoacid formation was about 9.0 for the pI 5.1 and 5.3 esterases and 1.5 for the pI 4.8 and 5.6 esterases. The existence of a higher $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio for the pI 5.1 and 5.3 esterases and their significant rate of malathion hydrolysis in the Hirokawa strain indicate that an increase in the $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio in house flies reported was due to the increase in the pI 5.1 esterase in the resistant strain.     

Pyrethroid resistance and esterase activity in three strains of the cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner)

Microplate assay technique for estimation of esterase activity in a single insect was used in combination with dose mortality bioassays to detect pyrethroid resistance in three strains of Helicoverpa armigera and to study the frequency of pyrethroid resistant individuals within the population of the same strain at two larval stages, third and fifth instar. The third and fifth instar larvae of the field strains i.e., Nagpur strain and Delhi strain that displayed high degree of resistance towards deltamethrin, had higher esterase activity compared to a susceptible laboratory strain. The frequency distribution of individuals with elevated esterase activity above 1.00 absorbance unit was correlated with the resistance level of the strains. The frequency of resistant individuals in the third instar larvae of Nagpur strain and Delhi strain were 29% and 23%, respectively compared to 4% in the susceptible strain. The resistant individuals in the resistant strains have markedly increased in the fifth instar larvae with a frequency distribution of 63% and 90% in Delhi strain and Nagpur strain, respectively, while only 14% of individuals was found to have elevated esterase activity in the susceptible strain. The results demonstrated the role of esterase in pyrethroid resistance in H. armigera. Microplate assay proved to be a rapid and reliable biochemical technique for monitoring of pyrethroid resistance in H. armigera.     

Biochemical studies on sheep body louse Bovicola ovis (Schrank) (Phthiraptera: Trichodectidae): comparison of pyrethroid and organophosphate resistant and susceptible strains

Strains of sheep louse Bovicola ovis (Schrank) with various levels of resistance to pyrethroid and one strain with high degree of resistance to organophosphate (OP) insecticides were used to investigate the biochemical mechanisms of insecticide resistance, i.e., enhanced levels of general esterases, specific acetylcholinesterases (AChE), glutathione S-transferase (GST), and mixed function oxidases. Native gel electrophoresis combined with quantitative enzyme assays showed analogous expression profiles of several esterase isozymes in all the strains tested. The determination of the sensitivity of each esterase isozyme to five inhibitors (acetylthiocholine iodide, butyrylthiocholine iodide, paraoxon eserine sulfate, and pCMB) led to the identification of nine esterases in the B. ovis strain. Gel electrophoresis results are supported by enzyme assay studies where, except for the OP resistant strain, no differences in esterase activities were detected in all the pyrethroid resistant and susceptible strains assayed. Statistical analyses demonstrated that some strains have elevated GST activities compared to the susceptible reference strain.     

Biochemical Characterization of Carboxylesterase in the Small Brown Planthopper Laodelphax striatellus (Fallén)

Several forms of carboxylesterase were observed in a malathion-resistant small brown planthopper, Laodelphax striatellus Fallén, by isoelectrofocusing. To study the mechanisms of increased esterase activity, esterases were purified and their biochemical characteristics were investigated in five active esterase isozymes of two resistant strains. These esterases have polymorphic characteristics and their molecular weights ranged from 66 to 70 kDa, due to variations in glycosylation. The pI values of these esterases ranged from 5.3 to 4.7. These esterases were immunologically related and NH₂-terminal amino acids were identical in all isozymes regardless of pI or molecular weight. No differences have been found in kinetic parameters (K_m and V_max) to α-naphthylacetate and specific activity toward α-naphthylacetate and malathion as a substrate in all isozymes. Resistant individuals showed high ali- and malathion carboxylesterase activities and these enhancements were caused by quantitative differences of carboxylesterases with several different pI.     

Malathion carboxylesterase enzymes in Anopheles arabiensis from Sudan

Malathion resistance in Anopheles arabiensis from Sudan is monofactorially inherited and is expressed in the adults but not in the larvae. The resistance is suppressed by the esterase synergist, triphenylphosphate. Semipurification of the soluble esterase enzymes by Sephadex G-25 and Sephacryl S-200 gel filtration revealed no difference between the enzymes of the resistant and susceptible strains with α- or β-naphthylacetate (NA) with a fixed substrate concentration in either the adults or larvae. However, with the malathion-specific assay a second peak of activity was observed in the adult resistant strain which was not present in either the larvae of this strain or the larvae and adults of the susceptible strain. A corresponding threefold difference in the K_m value for α-NA was also observed in the resistant adults over the range of this second peak, but there was no change in the K_m with β-NA.     

Characterization of malathion resistance in a Mexican population of Rhizopertha dominica

Malathion resistance of a field-collected population of Rhizopertha dominica (Coleoptera: Bostrichidae) from Mexico was evaluated and the resistance mechanisms were characterized both in vivo and in vitro. The Mexican population showed a resistance level of 50-fold at LC₅₀ as compared with that of a susceptible laboratory population. Malathion bioassays with the synergists triphenyl phosphate, piperonyl butoxide and diethyl maleate suggested that esterases were likely to contribute to the resistance whereas cytochrome P450 monooxygenases and glutathione S-transferases were not. In-vitro assays of esterases indicated that the general esterase activity was 1·3-fold higher in the Mexican population than in the susceptible population. However, the phosphotriesterase activity in the resistant population was 3·7-fold higher than in the susceptible population. Significantly higher phosphotriesterase activity in the resistant population was further indicated by 3·4-fold increase of V_max in enzyme kinetics and higher frequency of individuals with high phosphotriesterase activity in this population. All these findings suggested that phosphotriesterases play a role in malathion resistance in the Mexican population of lesser grain borer. © 1998 SCI     

Synergism of insecticidal action and effects on detoxifying enzymes in vivo of lambda-cyhalothrin and malathion by some nitrogen heterocycles in resistant and susceptible strains of Tribolium castaneum

The interactions of the synthetic pyrethroid, lambda-cyhalothrin and malathion were studied with purines, pyrimidines, caffeine and some other related nitrogenous compounds in resistant and susceptible strains of Triboliurn castaneum (Herbst.) The results were compared with those obtained with a known synergist, piperonyl butoxide (PBO) and precocene I. Adenine, cytosine, guanine, thymine and uracil synergised lambda-cyhalothrin, especially in the susceptible strain, with maximum effect at a 1:1 mass ratio, with the effect decreasing with increasing proportion of the heterocycle. The order of synergism of lambda-cyhalothrin was; precocene I > PBO > the nitrogenous compounds, in both resistant and susceptible strains. On the other hand, caffeine (lethal effect increased about twice), barbital (about twice), isobarbituric acid (less than twice) and bromacil (up to eight times) synergised malathion in malathion-resistant strains and antagonised in the susceptible strains. Total in-vivo esterases, carbox-ylesterases and cytochrome P₄₅₀ of susceptible and resistant strains showed significantly increased activity or content when treated with either insecticide plus a heterocyclic compound. Exceptions were with bromacil and malathion and for the malathion-specific strain, Kano-C with malathion and the N-heterocycles.     

Hydrolysis of permethrin by pyrethroid esterases from resistant and susceptible strains of Amblyseius fallacis (Acari: Phytoseiidae)

Pyrethroid-hydrolyzing activity in whole body homogenates of three insecticide-resistant and one susceptible strain of the predator mite, Amblyseius fallacis Garman has been examined in vitro. The highest esterase activity was found in the synthetic pyrethroid-resistant GH-1 strain body homogenate. All three pyrethroid-resistant strains had esterases that hydrolyzed trans-permethrin two times faster than cis-permethrin but isomer specificity was not observed in the susceptible strain. The pyrethroid esterases of the GH-1 strain were very sensitive to inhibition by dichlorovos, S,S,S-tributhylphosphorotrithioate, and 3-octylthio-1,1,1-trifluoro-2-propanone. Carbaryl and tetraethylpyrophosphate exhibited moderate inhibition in the GH-1 strain. Eserine sulfate and piperonyl butoxide only inhibited permethrin hydrolysis at higher concentrations. Fifteen esterase bands were resolved from body homogenates by gradient gel electrophoresis in the GH-1 strain, and were identified as carboxylesterases. The major pyrethroid-hydrolyzing activity was located in E5–E12 bands from GH-1 and composite susceptible strain esterases. Six esterase bands exhibiting low pyrethroid-hydroloyzing activity were also obtained from the two spotted spider mite, Tetranychus urticae (Koch).     

Dual role of esterases in insecticide resistance in the green rice leafhopper

The role of esterases as related to insecticide resistance was studied in an organophosphorus (OP)-resistant strain of the green rice leafhopper. As judged by p-nitrophenyl acetate hydrolysis, 21, 5, and 74% of the esterase activity was located in nuclei/mitochondria, microsomes, and the soluble fraction, respectively. All the fractions were active in hydrolyzing malathion, paraoxon, and fenvalerate. Hydrolysis of malathion and fenvalerate increased with time while that of paraoxon reached a plateau within 15 min. Since a considerable amount of p-nitrophenol was detected in the paraoxon reaction at 0°C and at zero time, the formation of p-nitrophenol may be due to phosphorylation of the esterases rather than phosphorotriesterase action. The results suggest a dual role for esterases in resistance mechanisms; a catalyst for hydrolysis of malathion and fenvalerate, and a binding protein for the oxygen analogs of other OP insecticides, both of which would protect the intrinsic target, acetylcholinesterase, from inhibition. Chromatofocusing of the soluble fraction resolved five esterase peaks, I–V. These esterases were active toward the three general substrates as well as for the three insecticides tested, except for Peak I in which the overall activity was too low. Thin-layer agar gel electrophoresis showed that the chromatofocusing peaks I–V corresponded to the electrophoretic bands E₁–E₅, some of which were previously shown to be associated with OP resistance. The dual role of these esterases may explain the cross-resistance between malathion and other OP insecticides as well as synergism between OP and carbamate insecticides.     

Characterizations of general esterases in relation to malathion susceptibility in two field populations of the oriental migratory locust, Locusta migratoria manilensis (Meyen)

General esterases were characterized and compared from two populations of the oriental migratory locust, Locusta migratoria manilensis, collected from Huanghua and Pingshan Counties, Hebei Province, China. General esterases were most concentrated in the thorax and abdomen, which contained 46.1 and 36.1% of total esterase activity in females, and 42.7 and 36.0% in males, respectively, when α-naphthyl acetate was used as a substrate. There was no distinct difference in esterase banding patterns in different body regions for the substrates α-naphthyl acetate and β-naphthyl acetate on non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). However, the general esterase activities in the Huanghua population were 1.8-fold higher than those in the Pingshan population in both females and males. Increased esterase activity in the Huanghua population appeared to be mainly due to several additional esterase bands detected on non-denaturing PAGE. Inhibition studies of general esterases using four inhibitors, including paraoxon, malaoxon, eserine, and carbaryl, indicated that most general esterases in the two populations were B-type. The increased esterase activity in the Huanghua population appeared to be associated with a 1.8-fold decreased susceptibility to malathion. Such differences may attribute to the difference in control practices for the locust between Huanghua and Pingshan Counties.