The biochemical basis of resistance to organophosphorus insecticides in the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina

The metabolism in vivo and in vitro of [¹⁴C]parathion and [¹⁴C]paraoxon was studied in a susceptible (LS) and an organophosphorus-resistant (Q) strain of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina. Both strains detoxified the insecticides in vivo via a number of pathways, but the resistant strain produced more of the metabolites diethyl phosphate and diethyl phosphorothionate. No difference was found between strains in the rate of penetration of the compounds used. Also, in vitro studies showed no difference between strains in the sensitivity of head acetylcholinesterase to inhibition by paraoxon. Both the microsomal and the 100,000g supernatant fractions degraded paraoxon, but resistance in Q could be explained by the eightfold greater rate of diethyl phosphate production with or without added NADPH. Parathion was also degraded to diethyl phosphorothionate by an NADPH-requiring enzyme in microsomal preparations from both strains. However, Q produced significantly more diethyl phosphorothionate in vivo than LS. It was concluded that organophosphorus resistance in Q was due mainly to a microsomal phosphatase hydrolyzing phosphate but not phosphorothionate esters, probably enhanced by a microsomal oxidase detoxifying the latter.     

Role of a microsomal carboxylesterase in reducing the action of malathion in eggs of Triatoma infestans

A microsomal malathion carboxylesterase present in Triatoma infestans eggs was active from the first day of embryonic development. This microsomal egg malathionase (MEM) showed a unique band in polyacrilamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) when malathion was used as substrate. In vivo metabolism of [¹⁴C]malathion during all embryonic development showed a 10% degradation due to carboxylesterases. The in vitro evaluation of the same metabolic pathway catalyzed by the microsomal fraction of T. infestans eggs showed partial inhibition by paraoxon. α- and β-malathion monoacids were identified as the main metabolites of the in vivo and in vitro metabolic pathways. The carboxylesterase band that appeared in PAGE (MEM) from the first day of embryonic development could be the main cause of malathion tolerance in T. infestans eggs.     

The in vitro degradation of [14C]malathion by enzymatic extracts from resistant and susceptible strains of Drosophila melanogaster

Enzyme preparations from Drosophila melanogaster flies degraded [¹⁴C]malathion to α- and β-malathion monoacids and, hence, were considered to contain malathion carboxylesterase (ME) activity. Although ME- activity was stable during preincubation in the absence of malathion, it decreased dramatically during the course of the reaction, and could not be completely recovered by Sephadex G-25 chromatography. Furthermore, the protein fraction after chromatography still contained ¹⁴C, suggesting that the enzyme had become inhibited by a bound, ¹⁴C-labeled derivative. Extracts from a resistant (malathion-selected), an intermediate control, and the susceptible Canton S strains of D. melanogaster differed in the lability of ME activity during the reaction. This difference was partly attributed to the production of small amounts of malaoxon (2–8%) by the extracts from the more resistant strains. No consistent strain differences were found when the rate of malathion degradation was measured during the first minute of reaction, either with or without a microsomal oxidase inhibitor (metyrapone) present. These results, together with the cross-resistance of the malathion-selected strain to other insecticides and the lack of a synergistic effect of two carboxylesterase inhibitors (triphenyl phosphate and S,S,S-tributylphosphorotrithioate) suggested that malathion carboxylesterase does not contribute significantly to the observed differences in malathion resistance between strains.     

General esterase,malathion carboxylesterase,and malathion resistance in Culex tarsalis

The role of esterases in malathion resistance in Culex tarsalis has been investigated. When larvae of a resistant and a sensitive strain were placed in water containing [¹⁴C]malathion, malathion penetrated to give initially similar internal levels. With resistant mosquitoes, after 15 min the internal malathion concentration decreased to low levels while the monoacid degradation products accumulated in the larvae and were excreted into the surrounding water, whereas in susceptible larvae the internal malathion level stayed high and was lethal. It is suggested that the decrease in internal malathion and the resulting resistance were caused by an active malathion carboxylesterase in the resistant strain. A specific assay for malathion carboxylesterase with [¹⁴C]malathion showed 55 times more activity in resistant than in susceptible larvae, whereas when general esterase activity was assayed with α-naphthyl acetate only 1.7 times the activity was found. Analyses by starch gel electrophoresis showed a peak of malathion carboxylesterase, 60-fold higher from resistant than from susceptible larvae, in a gel zone which did not stain for general esterase activity. General esterases that did not hydrolyze malathion showed different electrophoretic patterns in the two populations, which are likely due to the nonisogenic character of the strains. These results show that use of a specific assay and the demonstration of degradation of malathion in vivo are essential for assessment of the contribution of esterase activity to the malathion-resistant phenotype in mosquito populations.     

Oxidative cleavage of a carboxyester bond as a mechanism of resistance to malaoxon in houseflies

The synergistic effect of triphenyl phosphate (a carboxyesterase inhibitor), sesamex (inhibitor of microsomal oxidation) and O,O-diethyl O-phenyl phosphorothioate on the toxicity of malathion and malaoxon for one susceptible and two resistant strains of housefly was studies. It was found that in the resistant strain G (characterized by high carboxyesterase activity) both malathion and malaoxon were synergized by triphenyl phosphate, but only malaoxon (and not malathion) by sesamex. The other resistant strain E 1, moderately tolerant for malathion but highly resistant to malaoxon, differed from strain G in that triphenyl phosphate had no effect; its response to sesamex was similar to that of strain G. The third synergist, O,O-diethyl O-phenyl phosphorothioate, combined the properties of triphenyl phosphate and sesamex. It was found to be the best of the three compounds used.Biochemical in vitro studies showed that both resistant strains could degrade malaoxon oxidatively at a rate at least 10 × higher than that of the susceptible strain. This oxidation could be inhibited by very low concentrations of the thiono analogue; a malaoxon to malathion ratio of 10:1 gave an inhibition of about 70% at a malaoxon concentration of 5 × 10^?6M. The product of this oxidation is malaoxon β-monocarboxylic acid. This metabolite was also found 1 hr after application of malaoxon in vivo.The results mentioned in this paper indicate that houseflies may become resistant to malaoxon by an increased rate of oxidative carboxyester bond cleavage.     

Studies on hydrolases in various house fly strains and their role in malathion resistance

Aliesterase, carboxylesterase, and phosphorotriester hydrolase activities in six house fly strains were studied in relation to malathion resistance. Selection of two susceptible strains with malathion for three generations resulted in an increase in both carboxylesterase activity and LD₅₀ of malathion, indicating that the increased detoxication by the enzyme was the major mechanism selected for malathion resistance. With the highly resistant strains, however, the carboxylesterase activity alone was not sufficient to explain the resistance level, and the involvement of additional mechanisms, including phosphorotriester hydrolase activity, was suggested. The E₁ strain, which had high phosphorotriester hydrolase activity but normal or low carboxylesterase activity, showed a moderate level, i.e., sevenfold resistance. Upon DEAE-cellulose chromatography, two or three esterase peaks were resolved from susceptible, moderately resistant, and highly resistant strains. The substrate specificity, the sensitivity to paraoxon inhibition, and the $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio of malathion hydrolysis were studied for each esterase peak from the different strains. The results suggested the existence of multiple forms of esterases with overlapping substrate specificity in the house fly.     

The mechanism of resistance to lindane and hexadeuterated lindane in the Third Yumenoshima strain of house fly

The factors which cause lindane resistance in the Third Yumenoshima strain, a strain of house flies highly resistant to insecticides, were studied using hexadeuterated lindane. Hexadeuterated lindane has the same physicochemical properties as lindane, but the former is much less biodegradable than the latter. The LD₅₀ ratio of lindane to hexadeuterated lindane in this strain, deuterium isotope effect on LD₅₀ values, was larger than that in S_NAIDM, a susceptible (nonresistant) strain. The penetration rates of labeled and nonlabeled lindane through the insect cuticle were about the same for both strains. Thus, penetration rate does not cause resistance. The metabolic degradation of lindane in the resistant strain in vivo occurred much faster than in the susceptible strain. This was also the case for lindane degradation processes in vitro such as microsomal oxidation and glutathione conjugation. In both strains, significant isotope effects were observed in the degradation rates in vitro of labeled and nonlabeled lindane. Therefore, principal biodegradation and detoxication pathways should include reactions which cleave the CH bonds. When the much less biodegradable d₆ counterpart of lindane was applied to both strains, the susceptible strain became much more highly intoxicated than the other within 20 to 30 min. This indicates that a combination of both greater degradability and probably lower sensitivity at the action site are the main factors underlying resistance in the Third Yumenoshima strain.     

Changes in malathion resistance with age in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan

Resistance to malathion in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan was measured at intervals during the first week of adult life. LT₅₀ values for homozygous resistant females decreased four-fold during the first 7 days of adulthood. A decrease in resistance with age also occurred in heterozygotes; the LT₅₀ values of males and females fell sevenfold during the first 5 days of adulthood. The sensitivity to malathion of a susceptible strain increased with age. A biochemical basis for the declining resistance levels was investigated. Resistant and susceptible adults were homogenized at intervals during the first week of adulthood and soluble extracts were incubated with [¹⁴C]malathion. The rate of malathion metabolism to mono- and dicarboxylic acids was faster in resistant than in susceptible mosquitoes. The rate of malathion metabolism decreased with age in both strains. A decrease in carboxylesterase activity with age in resistant and susceptible mosquitoes is thus responsible for the increasing sensitivity to malathion. Implications for the monitoring of resistance in the field by diagnostic dosages and for the future use of malathion in mosquito control are discussed.     

Reproductive and developmental defects in a malathion-resistant,laboratory-selected population of Drosophila melanogaster

We have examined the chromosomal basis for reproductive and developmental defects that are associated with malathion resistance in a laboratory-selected population of Drosophila melanogaster. Strains homozygous for second or third chromosomes from this population were more resistant to malathion and had greater mixed-function oxidase activity, decreased fertility, and lower egg production when compared with first chromosome or susceptible strains. Some of the strains carrying resistant third chromosomes were developmentally delayed and required a significantly longer time to pupate. Delayed pupation was not associated with increased in vitro degradation of ecdysone by larvae having increased mixed-function oxidase activity, nor could it be reversed by feeding larvae ecdysone. Differences in mixed function oxidase activity among strains homozygous for second or third chromosomes were strongly correlated with malathion resistance but not with fitness. Although both second and third chromosome strains had high mixed-function oxidase activity, only fly extracts from the third chromosome strains oxidatively degraded [³H]juvenile hormone in vitro to a significant extent. A deficit of vitellogenic oocytes and increased egg laying by females in response to topically applied juvenile hormone-I supported the hypothesis that juvenile hormone titer was lower than normal in these strains. The results indicate that different polygenic systems control malathion resistance and associated fitness defects in this selected population of D. melanogaster. Although these systems are partly independent, they overlap due to pleiotropic effects of third chromosomal genes controlling mixed-function oxidase activity on female reproduction.     

Comparative toxicity,absorption, and metabolism of chlorpyrifos and its dimethyl homologue in methyl parathion-resistant and -susceptible tobacco budworms

Chlorpyrifos (Dowco 179) and its dimethyl homologue, chlorpyrifosmethyl (Dowco 214), were used to study the influence of the O,O-dialkyl group of organophosphorus insecticides on toxicity, absorption, and metabolism among larvae of the tobacco budworm [Heliothis virescens (F.)] from strains that were resistant (R) and susceptible (S) to methyl parathion. In toxicity tests, chlorpyrifos and chlorpyrifosmethyl were more toxic than methyl parathion to 3rd-stage R larvae but less toxic to S larvae. Chlorpyrifosmethyl was more toxic (3–4 ×) than chlorpyrifos to both strains of larvae, and the results of absorption studies indicated that the toxicity differential of the homologues may be explained in part by the more rapid absorption of the dimethyl form. Studies of the in vivo metabolism of both Dowco compounds indicated that each was degraded mainly by the cleavage of the pyridylphosphate linkage. In vitro tests demonstrated that the NADPH-dependent microsomal oxidases were of primary importance in detoxification, while glutathione (GSH)-dependent mechanisms (aryl- and alkyltransferases) present in the soluble cell fractions were of lesser importance. O-dealkylation occurred only with chlorpyrifosmethyl. The R larvae demonstrated greater capability in detoxifying both compounds in the comparative in vivo and in vitro studies of metabolism, but the differences were more apparent during the 5th instar than during the 3rd instar.     

Hydrolysis of malathion by rabbit liver oligomeric and monomeric carboxylesterases

The hydrolysis of malation by rabbit liver oligomeric and monomeric carboxylesterases (CE's) (EC 3.1.1.1) results in the formation of a mixture of α- and β-monoacids. A new chromatographic procedure was utilized to investigate the formation of α- and β-monoacids. The oligomeric carboxylesterase (oCE) produced an $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio of monoacids of 4.55, and the monomeric carboxylesterase (mCE) produced an $\text{α}\text{β}$ ratio of monoacids of 2.33. The ratios of α- and β-monoacids were independent of the initial concentration of malathion and remained constant over the time course of the reaction. Kinetic studies demonstrated that the K_m values were the same for the corresponding reactions which produced either α-monoacid or β-monoacid with the same enzyme. Since both carboxylesterases are electrophoretically pure, the kinetic data strongly supports the theory that the reactions which produced α- and β-monoacids are catalyzed by the same active site. Comparison of the k_cat and K_m values governing the hydrolysis of malathion by the two esterases, together with their relative abundance in liver, indicated that the oCE would be responsible for about 80 to 98% of the hydrolytic detoxication of malathion by rabbit liver.     

Effects of an impurity on malathion and its structural analog on rat liver carboxylesterases and erythrocyte esterases

The inhibitory effects on liver microsomal carboxylesterases and erythrocyte membrane esterases produced by an impurity of malathion was investigated. Treatment of rats with an impurity of malathion, O,O,S-trimethyl phosphorothioate (OOS-Me), and its structural analog O,O-dimethyl S-ethyl phosphorothioate (OOS-Et) inhibited liver microsomal malathion and phenthoate carboxylesterases. The inhibition lasted for at least 7 days following a single oral administration of OOS-Me. These treatments inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and (Na⁺ + K⁺)-dependent ATPase of erythrocyte membranes which persisted at least 3 days. OOS-Et was a more potent inhibitor of all the esterases examined than OOS-Me. Pretreatment of rats with a metabolic inducer, phenobarbital, or a metabolic inhibitor, piperonyl butoxide, had no effect on such inhibitory effects on liver microsomal carboxylesterases produced by OOS-Me or OOS-Et.     

Metabolism of cisanilide (Cis-2,5-dimethyl-1-pyrrolidinecarboxanilide) by rat liver microsomes

Metabolism of [phenyl-¹⁴C] and [(2,5) pyrrolidine-¹⁴C] cisanilide was investigated in vitro with microsomal preparations from rat liver. Microsomal activity was associated with a mixed-function oxidase system that required O₂ and NADPH and was inhibited by CO. Two major ether-soluble metabolites were isolated. They were identified as primary oxidation products: 2-hydroxy-2,5-dimethyl-1-pyrrolidinecarboxanilide (A) and 4′-hydroxy-2,5-dimethyl-1-pyrrolidinecarboxanilide (B). Minor ether-soluble metabolites were also isolated. Precursor product studies and qualitative thin layer chromatography analysis of [pyrrolidine-¹⁴C] and methylated [phenyl-¹⁴C] hydrolysis products suggested that these metabolites were secondary oxidation products formed from metabolites A or B. One of these metabolites appeared to be the dihydroxy product 2,4′-dihydroxy-2,5-dimethyl-1-pyrrolidinecarboxanilide. Crude microsomal preparations (postmitochondrial supernatant fractions) also formed small quantities (<10%) of polar metabolites. Enzyme hydrolysis with β-glucuronidase (Escherichia coli) indicated that approximately 50% of these metabolites were glucuronides. Similarities and differences in cisanilide oxidation in vivo in plants and in vitro with rat liver microsomal preparations were discussed.     

The biochemical nature of malathion resistance in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan

Malathion resistance in Anopheles stephensi from Pakistan was synergized by triphenyl phosphate, primarily a carboxylesterase inhibitor. There was a slight degree of antagonism with piperonyl butoxide. The major metabolite of malathion in larvae of both the resistant and susceptible strains was malathion monocarboxylic acid. Resistant larvae produced about twice as much of this product as the susceptible larvae. This suggests that a qualitative or a quantitative change in a carboxylesterase enzyme may be the basis of malathion resistance in this strain. Analysis of general esterase levels to α- and β-naphthyl acetate showed that there was no quantitative change in the amount of carboxylesterase enzyme present in the resistant strain as compared to the susceptible.     

In-vitro Metabolism of a Novel Monocrotophos Derivative by Rat and Japanese Quail

NADPH-dependent inhibition of hepatic microsomal carboxylesterase by a derivative of monocrotophos (coded as RPR-5) was studied in rat and Japanese quail as a measure of monooxygenase-catalysed activation of RPR-5. There was NADPH-dependent inhibition of hepatic microsomal α-naphthyl acetate esterase (carboxylesterase) both in rat and quail, indicating monooxygenase-catalysed formation of an oxon that subsequently phosphorylated α-NaE. The pattern of in-vitro metabolism of ¹⁴C-labelled RPR-5 by 11000g supernatant (11-S), microsomes and 105000g supernatant (105-S) fractions of rat and quail livers suggested the involvement of microsomal monooxygenases and carboxylesterases. A radiolabelled metabolite (M2) was tentatively identified as an acid produced by carboxyl esterase attack. In rat, metabolism by microsomal and cytosolic (105-S) carboxylesterases appeared to predominate with relatively little oxidative metabolism. In quail, putative microsomal carboxylesterase hydrolysis of RPR-5 was much lower than in the rat with almost neglible hydrolysis by cytosolic fractions. Also, production of M₂ by quail microsomes was substantially reduced after addition of NADPH, suggesting inhibition of a carboxyl esterase by the oxon of RPR-5. Differences in this detoxification of RPR-5 between rat and quail may be an important factor in determining selective toxicity and the results underline the importance of relating metabolism to toxicity when selecting animal models for toxicity testing.     

农药混剂的选择毒性研究

稻瘟净或异稻瘟净与乐果或马拉松混用,对抗性黑尾叶蝉有明显的增效作用,对小白鼠急性口服毒性也有所增加。小白鼠口服稻瘟净或异稻瘟净后,鼠肝中水解乐果和N—甲基正己酰胺的羧酰胺酶活力明显下降;水解醋酸α-萘酯的羧酸酯酶活力也被抑制。羊肝微粒体的羧酰胺酶在体外分别被稻瘟净、异稻瘟净、磷酸三苯酯、磷酸三甲苯酯、苯硫磷、氧乐果和西维因强烈抑制,它们的I_(50)值为1.3×10~(-8)—4.0×10~(-5)克分子浓度。稻瘟净、异稻瘟净、磷酸三苯酯和西维因分别是羊肝羧酰胺酶和羧酸酯酶的竞争性抑制剂,它们的K_i值在4.8×10~(-8)—1.0×10~(-7)克分子浓度之间。这些结果表明稻瘟净、异稻瘟净等增加乐果和马拉松对哺乳动物的毒性的机制,可能主要是由于它们抑制了哺乳动物体内正常解毒乐果和马拉松的水解酶。文中讨论了这些农药混剂的选择毒性问题。     

Hydrolysis of paraoxon and malaoxon in three strains of Myzus persicae with different degrees of parathion resistance

Homogenates of three strains of Myzus persicae, A, R, and E, with an LD₅₀ for topically applied parathion of 9, 93, and 263 ng per aphid, showed an in vitro hydrolytic degradation of paraoxon of 2.3, 4.7, and 8.6 pmol/mg aphid/h, respectively. These values represent V_max; K_m was <10^?7M. The three strains showed a malaoxon degradation of 2.4, 11.9, and 18.8 pmol/mg/h at 10^?6M substrate concentration. V_max for R and E was 21 and 27 pmol, respectively and K_m 7 and 4 × 10^?7M. Activity in strain A was too low to estimate these entities. The breakdown product of paraoxon was mainly diethyl phosphoric acid, that of malaoxon mainly dimethyl phosphoric acid. No hydrolysis of the carboxylester groups of malaoxon was found. Hydrolysis of paraoxon and malaoxon was inhibited by isopropyl and n-propyl paraoxon and by the salioxon-analog K₂. The two latter compounds were shown to act as synergists with parathion when added in amounts that caused little mortality when given alone. The hydrolytic enzyme is soluble and retains its activity during incubations of several hours. It is likely that it is responsible for at least part of the resistance. Resistance was maintained without selection over a period of three years. There was no correlation between degree of resistance and carboxylesterase activity of the strains.     

Biochemical Characterization of Carboxylesterase in the Small Brown Planthopper Laodelphax striatellus (Fallén)

Several forms of carboxylesterase were observed in a malathion-resistant small brown planthopper, Laodelphax striatellus Fallén, by isoelectrofocusing. To study the mechanisms of increased esterase activity, esterases were purified and their biochemical characteristics were investigated in five active esterase isozymes of two resistant strains. These esterases have polymorphic characteristics and their molecular weights ranged from 66 to 70 kDa, due to variations in glycosylation. The pI values of these esterases ranged from 5.3 to 4.7. These esterases were immunologically related and NH₂-terminal amino acids were identical in all isozymes regardless of pI or molecular weight. No differences have been found in kinetic parameters (K_m and V_max) to α-naphthylacetate and specific activity toward α-naphthylacetate and malathion as a substrate in all isozymes. Resistant individuals showed high ali- and malathion carboxylesterase activities and these enhancements were caused by quantitative differences of carboxylesterases with several different pI.     

Effect of liver enzyme induction on paraoxon metabolism in the rat

Orally administered [1-¹⁴C]ethyl paraoxon, O,O-diethyl-O-p-nitrophenyl phosphate, is readily absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract of male albino rats. Radioactivity is essentially eliminated in 72 hr by excretion into urine and feces and by expiration as ¹⁴CO₂. Compounds with radioactivity in the urine are tentatively identified as diethyl phosphoric acid, desethyl paraoxon, ethanol, metabolites conjugated with amino acids, and paraoxon; the first compound is the predominant radioactive metabolite. Intraperitoneally injected phenobarbital, DDT, dieldrin, and endrin are inducers of microsomal enzymes that degrade paraoxon. The aryl phosphate-cleaving activity in vitro is not dependent on the addition of NADPH. O-Dealkylation of paraoxon is catalyzed by microsomal enzymes that require NADPH and oxygen and are inhibited by carbon monoxide. Microsomal enzymes from rats pretreated with enzyme inducers give an increased rate of O-dealkylation of paraoxon. Reduced glutathione has little or no effect on paraoxon degradation by either microsomal or soluble enzymes. Actinomycin D inhibits O-dealkylation of paraoxon in vivo, as indicated by reduction of ¹⁴CO₂ formation, and in vitro, as indicated by decreased activity of microsomal O-dealkylase. The role of microsomal mixed-function oxidases and NADPH-dependent O-dealkylase in the metabolism of organophosphorus insecticides is discussed.     

Detoxication capacity in the honey bee,Apis mellifera L

Various detoxifying enzymes, including microsomal oxidases, glutathione S-transferases, esterases, epoxide hydrolase, and DDT-dehydrochlorinase, were assayed in adult worker bees (Apis mellifera L.) using midguts as the enzyme source. A cell-free system was used for all enzyme assays, except that microsomal oxidases required intact midgut because of the inhibitor encountered. Midgut microsomal preparations contained mainly cytochrome P-420, the inactive form of cytochrome P-450, which may explain the low microsomal oxidase activity in microsomes. All enzymes studied were active, suggesting that the high susceptibility of honey bees to insecticides is not due to low detoxication capacity. Sublethal exposure of honey bees to various insecticides had no effect on these enzyme activities, with the exception of permethrin which significantly stimulated the glutathione S-transferase, and malathion, which significantly inhibited the α-naphthylacetate esterase and carboxylesterase.