Targeting the Tick/Pathogen Interface for Developing New Anaplasmosis Vaccine Strategies

Bovine anaplasmosis is a tick-borne hemolytic disease of cattle that occurs worldwide caused by the intraerythrocytic rickettsiae Anaplasma marginale. Control measures, including use of acaricides, administration of antibiotics and vaccines, have varied with geographic location. Our research is focused on the tick-pathogen interface for development of new vaccine strategies with the goal of reducing anaplasmosis, tick infestations and the vectorial capacity of ticks. Toward this approach, we have targeted (1) development of an A. marginale cell culture system to provide a non-bovine antigen source, (2) characterization of an A. marginale adhesion protein, and (3) identification of key tick protective antigens for reduction of tick infestations. A cell culture system for propagation of A. marginale was developed and provided a non-bovine source of A. marginale vaccine antigen. The A. marginale adhesion protein, MSP1a, was characterized and use of recombinant MSP1a in vaccine formulations reduced clinical anaplasmosis and infection levels in ticks that acquired infection on immunized cattle. Most recently, we identified a tick-protective antigen, subolesin, that reduced tick infestations, as well as the vectorial capacity of ticks for acquisition and transmission of A marginale. This integrated approach to vaccine development shows promise for developing new strategies for control of bovine anaplasmosis.     

Molecular phylogeny and biogeography of North American isolates of Anaplasma marginale (Rickettsiaceae: Ehrlichieae)

Anaplasma marginale (A. marginale) is a tick-borne ehrlichial pathogen of cattle that causes the disease anaplasmosis. Six major surface proteins (MSPs) have been identified on A. marginale from cattle and ticks of which three, MSP1a, MSP4 and MSP5, are from single genes and do not vary within isolates. The other three, MSP1b, MSP2 and MSP3, are from multigene families and may vary antigenically in persistently infected cattle. Several geographic isolates have been identified in the United States which differ in morphology, protein sequence and antigenic properties. An identifying characteristic of A. marginale isolates is the molecular weight of MSP1a which varies in size among isolates due to different numbers of tandemly repeated 28-29 amino acid peptides. For these studies, genes coding for A. marginale MSP1a and MSP4, msp1alpha and msp4, respectively, from nine North American isolates were sequenced for phylogenetic analysis. The phylogenetic analysis strongly supports the existence of a south-eastern clade of A. marginale comprised of Virginia and Florida isolates. Analysis of 16S rDNA fragment sequences from the A. marginale tick vector, Dermacentor variabilis, from various areas of the United States was used to evaluate possible vector-parasite co-evolution. Our phylogenetic analysis supports identity between the most parsimonious tree from the A. marginale MSP gene data and the tree that reflected the western and eastern clades of D. variabilis. These phylogenetic analyses provide information that may be important to consider when developing control strategies for anaplasmosis in the United States.     

Anaplasmosis in Cattle in Italy

Bovine anaplasmosis caused by Anaplasma marginale is a disease transmitted by ticks belonging to the Ixodidae family. Southern Italy is considered an endemic zone but environmental and social factors are changing the epidemiology of the disease to expand to previously anaplasmosis-free regions. The available data of published reports of anaplasmosis in Italy together with the data obtained by the National Centre of Reference for Anaplasma, Babesia, Rickettsia and Theileria (C.R.A.Ba.R.T.), allowed to report A. marginale infection in different Italian regions (Lazio, Marche, Campania, Puglia, Basilicata, Calabria, Lombardy, Tuscany, Umbria and Sicily). Cattle are also subject to infection with the related Ixodes ricinus-transmitted pathogen, Anaplasma phagocytophilum that results in reduced milk production in cattle. A. phagocytophilum infect also small ruminants, domestic and wild animals and causes the human granulocytic anaplasmosis. Different studies have been conducted on the presence of A. phagocytophilum in Italy both in the tick vectors and in the wild and domestic reservoirs. Contrary to A. marginale, the prevalence of A. phagocytophilum embraces the whole Italian territory from the Alps to the southern and insular regions.     

Outbreak of anaplasmosis associated with novel genetic variants of Anaplasma marginale in a dairy cattle

During early lactation, dairy cows may present a transient immunosuppressive state and develop anaplasmosis caused by Anaplasma marginale. In this study, clinical anaplasmosis in dairy cattle in the Thrace region of Turkey was investigated with respect to within-herd prevalence, vertical transmission, and genetic diversity. In March and September 2015, thirty lactating cows showed primary clinical signs of anaplasmosis, including fever, anaemia, decreased milk yield, anorexia, and laboured breathing. Symptoms disappeared in most cows after administration of long-acting oxytetracycline, but nine of them (30%) died. Following diagnosis based on clinical signs, microscopy and molecular findings, blood samples were collected from apparently healthy lactating cows (n = 184), pregnant heifers (n = 39) and newborn calves (n = 24). DNA was extracted from each sample and analyzed for the presence of major surface proteins (MSPs) of A. marginale, followed by sequencing to assess diversity of isolates. Microscopic examination of erythrocytes revealed A. marginale inclusion bodies in symptomatic cows. Examination of thin blood smears showed 3.8% of the lactating, clinically asymptomatic, cows to be infected with A. marginale, while nPCR detected 31.0% positive. A. marginale infection was not detected in pregnant heifers by either method. Congenital infection was found in one calf by nPCR. This is the first report of transplacental transmission of A. marginale in Turkey. The MSP4 sequence analyses showed high genetic diversity among the isolates, presenting 97.6-99.6% homology at the amino acid level. The sequences of MSP1a amplicons revealed genetic diversity providing three new tandem repeats.     

Transmission of Anaplasma marginale from a naturally-infected wild african giant rat (Cricetomys gambianus), waterhouse) to a calf in Nigeria

Blood taken from an African giant rat in Nigeria, transmitted Anaplasma marginale when inoculated into a splenectomised calf. The infection of the calf was sub-clinical and the highest percentage of infected erythrocytes recorded was 6. Anaplasma marginale was first observed in the calf's blood three days after inoculation, but the parasite disappeared suddenly, nine days after inoculation. This is the first experimental demonstration of A. marginale infection in African giant rats in Nigeria, a country where anaplasmosis is endemic in the cattle population. The significance of giant rats being a reservoir host of A. marginale in Nigeria is discussed.     

Genetic diversity of Anaplasma marginale strains from an outbreak of bovine anaplasmosis in an endemic area

Anaplasma marginale is a tick-borne pathogen of cattle that causes the disease bovine anaplasmosis worldwide. Major surface proteins (MSPs) are involved in host-pathogen and tick-pathogen interactions and have been used as markers for the genetic characterization of A. marginale strains. A. marginale genotypes are highly variable in endemic areas worldwide. The genetic composition of A. marginale strains during anaplasmosis outbreaks has been characterized in one study only which reported a single msp1alpha genotype in infected cattle. However, more information is required to characterize whether a single genotype is responsible for an anaplasmosis outbreak or whether multiple genotypes can cause disease in na?ve cattle within a single herd in endemic areas. The aim of this study was to characterize the genetic diversity of A. marginale strains from an outbreak of bovine anaplasmosis in the State of Tamaulipas, Mexico. A. marginale genotypes were characterized at the molecular level using msp4 and msp1alpha gene sequences. The results revealed that several A. marginale genotypes are present in cattle during acute anaplasmosis outbreaks, thus suggesting that mechanical transmission or stochastic biological transmission through equally efficient independent transmission events may explain A. marginale genotype frequency in a cattle herd during acute bovine anaplasmosis outbreaks in endemic areas. The results reported herein corroborated the genetic heterogeneity of A. marginale strains in endemic regions worldwide. The development and implementation of anaplasmosis control measures is dependent upon understanding the epidemiology of A. marginale in endemic regions, including the characterization of the genetic diversity of strains that produce outbreaks of bovine anaplasmosis.     

Studies on ticks of veterinary importance in Nigeria XI. Observations on the biology of ticks detached from the red-flanked duiker (Cephamophys rufulatus) and parasites encountered in their blood

Some aspects of the biology of Amblyomma variegatum and Boophilus decoloratus detached from red-flanked duikers were studied. Smears were also made from the blood of the duikers and examined for the presence of parasites.Anaplasma marginale was the only blood parasite found in the blood smears. Compared with ticks detached from cattle, duiker ticks produced a greater number of eggs. The lengths and breadths of eggs produced by duiker ticks were greater than those of cattle ticks and unlike A. variegatum detached from cattle, the lengths and breadths of eggs of earlier and later ovipositions of this species detached from duiker were similar. Whereas deformed eggs characterized by circular shape and small size constituted a small percentage of eggs of cattle ticks, none was found among eggs of duiker ticks. The pre-oviposition, oviposition and eclosion periods, microscopic egg structure, embryonic development, hatching patterns and mortality rates of the eggs of ticks from both hosts were similar.     

Transformation of Anaplasma marginale

The tick-borne pathogen, Anaplasma marginale, has a complex life cycle involving ruminants and ixodid ticks. It causes bovine anaplasmosis, a disease with significant economic impact on cattle farming worldwide. The obligate intracellular growth requirement of the bacteria poses a challenging obstacle to their genetic manipulation, a problem shared with other prokaryotes in the genera Anaplasma, Ehrlichia, and Rickettsia. Following our successful transformation of the human anaplasmosis agent, A. phagocytophilum, we produced plasmid constructs (a transposon bearing plasmid, pHimarAm-trTurboGFP-SS, and a transposase expression plasmid, pET28Am-trA7) designed to mediate random insertion of the TurboGFP and spectinomycin/streptomycin resistance genes by the Himar1 allele A7 into the A. marginale chromosome. In these trans constructs, expression of the fluorescent and the selectable markers on the transposon, and expression of the transposase are under control of the A. marginale tr promoter. Constructs were co-electroporated into A. marginale St. Maries purified from tick cell culture, and bacteria incubated for 2 months under selection with a combination of spectinomycin and streptomycin. At that time, ≤1% of tick cells contained colonies of brightly fluorescent Anaplasma, which eventually increased to infect about 80–90% of the cells. Cloning of the insertion site in E. coli and DNA sequence analyses demonstrated insertion of the entire plasmid pHimarAm-trTurboGFP-SS encoding the transposon in frame into the native tr region of A. marginale in an apparent single homologous crossover event not mediated by the transposase. Transformants are fastidious and require longer subculture intervals than wild type A. marginale. This result suggests that A. marginale, as well as possibly other species of Anaplasma and Ehrlichia, can be transformed using a strategy of homologous recombination.     

Targeting the tick/pathogen interface for developing new anaplasmosis vaccine strategies

Bovine anaplasmosis is a tick-borne hemolytic disease of cattle that occurs worldwide caused by the intraerythrocytic rickettsiae Anaplasma marginale. Control measures, including use of acaricides, administration of antibiotics and vaccines, have varied with geographic location. Our research is focused on the tick-pathogen interface for development of new vaccine strategies with the goal of reducing anaplasmosis, tick infestations and the vectorial capacity of ticks. Toward this approach, we have targeted (1) development of an A. marginale cell culture system to provide a non-bovine antigen source, (2) characterization of an A. marginale adhesion protein, and (3) identification of key tick protective antigens for reduction of tick infestations. A cell culture system for propagation of A. marginale was developed and provided a non-bovine source of A. marginale vaccine antigen. The A. marginale adhesion protein, MSP1a, was characterized and use of recombinant MSP1a in vaccine formulations reduced clinical anaplasmosis and infection levels in ticks that acquired infection on immunized cattle. Most recently, we identified a tick-protective antigen, subolesin, that reduced tick infestations, as well as the vectorial capacity of ticks for acquisition and transmission of A marginale. This integrated approach to vaccine development shows promise for developing new strategies for control of bovine anaplasmosis.     

Genetic diversity of Anaplasma marginale strains from cattle farms in the province of Palermo, Sicily

Bovine anaplasmosis, caused by the tick-borne rickettsia Anaplasma marginale, is endemic in Sicily and results in economic loss to the cattle industry. This study was designed to characterize strains of A. marginale at the molecular level from cattle in the Province of Palermo, Sicily. Seropositivity of cattle >or=1 year old for A. marginale in the study area ranged from 62% to 100%. The observed prevalence of A. marginale infections in cattle herds ranged from 25% to 100%. Two predominant A. marginale msp4 genotypes were found. A positive correlation was found between the prevalence of infection and the presence of Rhipicephalus (Boophilus) annulatus. Phylogenetic analysis of msp4 sequences of European strains of A. marginale did not provide phylogeographical information. These results suggest that development of farm husbandry systems and vaccines for genetically heterogeneous populations of A. marginale are needed for control of anaplasmosis in this region of Sicily.     

Cell-mediated immunity in bovine anaplasmosis and correlation with protection induced by vaccination (a review)

Information related to pathogenesis, transmission, mechanism of protection and host-parasite interaction in anaplasmosis has not been completely established. Empirical methods of prevention and control of anaplasmosis include premunition, chemotherapy, and vaccination with inactivated preparations of A. marginale; however, absolute measurement of protection has not been available. The humoral antibody response is well documented but no evidence has been produced for the existence of protective antibodies. The leukocyte migration inhibition test, blast transformation, cytotoxicity measurement, and delayed cutaneous hypersensitivity response of animals exposed to virulent, attenuated and inactivated preparations of A. marginale have indicated that the cell-mediated immune response is probably related to protection in bovine anaplasmosis. Establishment of initial infection with replicating forms of anaplasma seems to be the only means of producing solid immunity against subsequent challenge. The attenuated A. marginale vaccine recently developed in our laboratory should therefore play an important role in prevention of anaplasmosis.     

Genetic diversity of anaplasma species major surface proteins and implications for anaplasmosis serodiagnosis and vaccine development

The genus Anaplasma (Rickettsiales: Anaplasmataceae) includes several pathogens of veterinary and human medical importance. An understanding of the diversity of Anaplasma major surface proteins (MSPs), including those MSPs that modulate infection, development of persistent infections, and transmission of pathogens by ticks, is derived in part, by characterization and phylogenetic analyses of geographic strains. Information concerning the genetic diversity of Anaplasma spp. MSPs will likely influence the development of serodiagnostic assays and vaccine strategies for the control of anaplasmosis.     

The use of tick transmission by Boophilus microplus to isolate pure strains of Babesia bovis,Babesia bigemina and Anaplasma marginale from cattle with mixed infections

Pure strains of Babesia bovi, Babesia bigemina and Anaplasma marginale were isolated from cattle infected with all 3 species as well as a Theileria sp. and Eperythrozoon teganodes, using only transmission by the tick, Boophilus microplus. Unengorged adult ticks transferred to susceptible cattle transmitted A. marginale, but not Babesia. Engorged adults gave rise to progeny that transmitted Babesia, B. bovis by larvae and B. bigemina by male ticks. The Theileria and E. teganodes were not transmitted by the ticks and thus did not appear in calves used for isolating the pure strains of Babesia and A. marginale.     

Characterization of Anaplasma phagocytophilum and A. ovis infection in a naturally infected sheep flock with poor health condition

Anaplasma species are transmitted by ticks and cause diseases in humans and animals. These pathogens infect sheep, an economically important domestic animal worldwide. The current study was designed to characterize in 200 animals the infection with Anaplasma phagocytophilum and Anaplasma ovis and the genetic diversity of A. ovis strains collected from a naturally infected sheep flock with poor health condition. Sheep had 98% seroprevalence to Anaplasma spp. antibodies. PCR results confirmed the presence of A. phagocytophilum and A. ovis DNA in 11.5% and 37% of the sheep, respectively. Concurrent infections were detected in 6.5% of the sheep. Seventy-one adult ticks were collected from 45 sheep with infestations ranging from one to 15 ticks per animal. The analysis of A. ovis msp4 sequences demonstrated a previously unreported polymorphism for this pathogen with 17 different haplotypes in infected sheep. These results demonstrated that, although A. ovis msp4 haplotypes may be less variable when compared with Anaplasma marginale and A. phagocytophilum strains on a global scale, genetic polymorphisms occur in this locus in strains obtained from an infected sheep flock with poor health condition.     

PCR-based detection of blood parasites in cattle and adult Rhipicephalus appendiculatus ticks

To ascertain the infection rate for tick-borne pathogens in Zambia, an epidemiological survey of Theileria parva, Babesia bigemina and Anaplasma marginale in traditionally managed Sanga cattle was conducted using PCR. Of the 71 native Zambian cattle, 28 (39.4%) were positive for T. parva, 16 (22.5%) for B. bigemina and 34 (47.9%) for A. marginale. The mixed infection rate in cattle was 8.5% (6/71), 16.9% (12/71), 7.0% (5/71) and 2.8% (2/71) for T. parva/B. bigemina, T. parva/A. marginale, B. bigemina/A. marginale and T. parva/B. bigemina/A. marginale, respectively.To predict the risk for transmission of tick-borne pathogens from ticks to cattle, a total of 74 Rhipicephalus appendiculatus ticks were collected from a location where cattle had been found positive for T. parva. Of the ticks collected, 10 (13.5%) were found to be PCR-positive for T. parva. The results suggest that the infection rate for tick-borne pathogens was relatively high in Sanga cattle and that adult R. appendiculatus ticks were highly infected with T. parva.     

Phylogenetic analysis of Anaplasma marginale strains from Paraná State, Brazil, using the msp1alpha and msp4 genes

Anaplasma marginale is an obligate intraerythrocytic rickettsial pathogen (order, Rickettsiales: family, Anaplasmataceae) that causes bovine anaplasmosis. This disease is widely distributed in tropical and sub-tropical regions of the world and causes important economic losses to cattle production. Major surface protein (MSP)1a (msp1alpha gene) is one of the six MSPs identified on A. marginale from cattle, whose sequence and size vary according to the number of tandem 28- to 29-amino acid repeats. This study characterized the msp1alpha and msp4 genes obtained from three distinct Brazilian herds from the State of Paraná. Three strains of the msp1alpha and one strain of the msp4 gene were sequenced. The strains evaluated revealed PCR products of different size, representing three, five and six internal repeats. Sequence analyses confirmed the number of tandem sequence copies and revealed a high degree of sequence identity with strains from other Brazilian States, as well as strains from the USA, Europe and Israel. The msp1alpha DNA and amino acid sequences from A. marginale and DNA sequences of msp4 strains did not reveal distinct phylogeographical segregation. However, the amino acid sequences of msp4 demonstrated definite phylogeographical relationship. These results suggest that the amino acid sequences of msp4 should be used for phylogenetic identification of A. marginale strains and may be an important tool for the epidemiology and control of anaplasmosis. Additionally, the close similarity of the Paraná strains of A. marginale with strains from USA, Europe and Asia may reflect the introduction of these genes during the development of the Brazilian bovine herd.     

Phylogenetic Analysis of Anaplasma marginale Strains from Paraná State,Brazil, Using the msp1α and msp4 genes

Anaplasma marginale is an obligate intraerythrocytic rickettsial pathogen (order, Rickettsiales: family, Anaplasmataceae) that causes bovine anaplasmosis. This disease is widely distributed in tropical and sub‐tropical regions of the world and causes important economic losses to cattle production. Major surface protein (MSP)1a (msp1α gene) is one of the six MSPs identified on A. marginale from cattle, whose sequence and size vary according to the number of tandem 28‐ to 29‐amino acid repeats. This study characterized the msp1α and msp4 genes obtained from three distinct Brazilian herds from the State of Paraná. Three strains of the msp1α and one strain of the msp4 gene were sequenced. The strains evaluated revealed PCR products of different size, representing three, five and six internal repeats. Sequence analyses confirmed the number of tandem sequence copies and revealed a high degree of sequence identity with strains from other Brazilian States, as well as strains from the USA, Europe and Israel. The msp1α DNA and amino acid sequences from A. marginale and DNA sequences of msp4 strains did not reveal distinct phylogeographical segregation. However, the amino acid sequences of msp4 demonstrated definite phylogeographical relationship. These results suggest that the amino acid sequences of msp4 should be used for phylogenetic identification of A. marginale strains and may be an important tool for the epidemiology and control of anaplasmosis. Additionally, the close similarity of the Paraná strains of A. marginale with strains from USA, Europe and Asia may reflect the introduction of these genes during the development of the Brazilian bovine herd.     

Cloning, expression, and characterization of the MSP1a and MSP1b recombinant proteins from PR1 Anaplasma marginale strain, Brazil

The Anaplasma marginale is a bacterium that has obligate intraerythrocytic multiplication in cattle causing important economic loss. The A. marginale major surface protein 1 (MSP1) complex, heterodimer composed of MSP1a and MSP1b, has been identified as adhesins for bovine erythrocytes. The objectives of this study were to sequences the msp1β gene and produce and characterize recombinant MSP1a and MSP1b from a Brazilian strain of A. marginale, PR1. The msp1α and msp1β genes from the PR1 strain were cloned and expressed in E. coli BL21 Star using the vectors pET102 and pET101/D-TOPO. Antibodies were produced against the recombinant proteins and were shown to react with rMSP1a and rMSP1b demonstrating a molecular mass of 70 kDa to 105 kDa and 100 kDa, respectively for these proteins. Bovine erythrocytes were agglutinated by BL21/rMSP1a and BL21/rMSP1b and, this agglutination was inhibited by the presence of the IgY anti-rMSP1a, confirming the adhesion function of these proteins. Additionally, using the IgY anti-rMSP1a and rMSP1b in a IFI, the presence of rMSP1a and rMSP1b was confirmed on the outer membrane of the recombinant E. coli BL21. Our results show that the msp1β gene from the PR1 strain has both the conserved region and contain the defined polymorphism regions previously described for other strains of A. marginale. The results from this study confirm adhesive functions for rMSP1a and rMSP1b from PR1 strain in bovine erythrocytes invasion.     

Research into the relative importance of tabanidae (Diptera) in mechanical disease transmission

Summary In a dairy farm with 300 cattle, where the possibility of cyclical transmission ofAnaplasma marginale by ticks was precluded, 55 cases of anaplasmosis were observed in 1·5 years. The frequent occurrence of the disease was caused by needle transmission during regular intramuscular trypanocidal treatments, providing suitable reservoirs for additional mechanical transmission by Tabanidae at a calculated proportion of44 per cent of the total number of cases recorded in one year. From the correlation of seasonal fluctuations of Tabanidae species with the anaplasmosis incidence it could be concluded thatTabanus taeniola was the principal mechanical insect vector ofA. marginale.

---

Resumen En una lechería de 300 bovinos en donde se cortó la transmisión cíclica por medio de garrapatas deAnaplasma marginale, se observaron 55 casos en 18 meses. La causa principal de la ocurrencia de anaplasmosis en esta oportunidad, fue la transmisión mecánica por medio de agujas contaminadas, durante tratamientos regulares contra tripanosomiasis. La correlación de fluctuaciones estacionales de especies de tábanos, con la incidencia de anaplasmosis indica que elTabanus taeniola fue el principal vector mecánico deA. marginale.

---

Résumé Dans une ferme laitière de trois cents têtes où la transmission cyclique par les tiques deA. marginale n'était pratiquement pas possible cinquanté cas d'anaplasmose ont été observés en dix huit mois. L'apparition fréquente de la maladie a été causée par l'aiguille utilisée à l'occasion de traitements périodiques contre la trypanosomose, constituant ainsi des réservoirs à partir desquels s'est effectuée la transmission mécanique par les Tabanidés, dans une proportion qui a pu être chiffrée à 44 p. 100 du nombre total de cas observés en une année. L'étude corrélative des fluctuations saisonnières des divers espèces de Tabanidés et de l'incidence de l'anaplasmose a permis de conclure queTabanus taeniola constituait le principal insecte vecteur deA. marginale.

     

Evolution and function of tandem repeats in the major surface protein 1a of the ehrlichial pathogen Anaplasma marginale

The major surface protein (MSP) 1a of the ehrlichial cattle pathogen Anaplasma marginale, encoded by the single-copy gene msp1alpha, has been shown to have a neutralization-sensitive epitope and to be an adhesin for bovine erythrocytes and tick cells. msp1alpha has been found to be a stable genetic marker for the identification of geographic isolates of A. marginale throughout development in acutely and persistently infected cattle and in ticks. The molecular weight of MSP1a varies among geographic isolates of A. marginale because of a varying number of tandemly repeated peptides of 28-29 amino acids. Variation in the sequence of the tandem repeats occurs within and among isolates, and may have resulted from evolutionary pressures exerted by ligand-receptor and host-parasite interactions. These repeated sequences include markers for tick transmissibility that may be important in the identification of ehrlichial pathogens because they may influence control strategies and the design of subunit vaccines.