A comparison of finishing systems and duration for spring-born Aberdeen Angus × Holstein-Friesian and Belgian Blue × Holstein-Friesian steers

In Ireland, the majority of dairy cows calve in spring and the male progeny are reared for beef as steers. Over half of all dairy calves are beef crosses with Aberdeen Angus and Belgian Blue representing two extremes in maturity type. The objective of this study was to compare different finishing systems in the autumn/winter of their second year for spring-born steers of contrasting maturity type. A total of 80 spring-born calves, 40 Aberdeen Angus × Holstein-Friesian (AA) and 40 Belgian Blue × Holstein-Friesian (BB) were reared together to 16 months of age. They were then blocked on live weight within breed type and assigned to a pre-experimental slaughter group and to four finishing groups namely: (i) pasture only for 94 days to slaughter, (ii) concentrates ad libitum indoors for 94 days to slaughter, (iii) pasture only for 94 days followed by concentrates ad libitum indoors for 95 days to slaughter, and (iv) concentrates ad libitum indoors for 189 days to slaughter. After slaughter, the 6–10th ribs joint was separated into its component tissues and a sample of m. longissimus was chemically analysed. Mean slaughter weights and carcass weights per day from arrival were 922 and 957 (s.e. 10.6)g, and 476 and 511 (s.e. 6.1) g for AA and BB, respectively. Corresponding carcass weights, kill out proportions, ribs joint fat and muscle proportions, and m. longissimus lipid concentrations were 300 and 322 (s.e. 3.9) kg, 515 and 534 (s.e. 2.4) g/kg, 181 and 121 (s.e. 4.2) g/kg, 605 and 666 (s.e. 4.5) g/kg, and 42 and 25 (s.e. 2.5) g/kg, respectively. Mean daily live weight gains for the finishing treatments as listed were 714, 1539, 999 and 1186 (s.e. 32.0) g, respectively. Corresponding mean daily carcass gains, carcass weights, ribs joint fat proportions and m. longissimus lipid concentrations were 416, 901, 645 and 774 (s.e. 24.6) g, 252, 296, 336 and 359 (s.e. 5.5) kg, 76, 165, 154 and 210 (s.e. 5.9) g/kg, and 13, 34, 32 and 55 (s.e. 3.5) g/kg. It is concluded that BB had heavier carcasses of better conformation with less ribs joint fat and less intramuscular lipid than AA. Neither breed type had acceptably finished carcasses after 94 days on pasture, but both breed types had acceptably finished carcasses following concentrate feeding for 94 days. The carcasses of the BB animals on pasture for 94 days and then finished on concentrates were not acceptably finished and m. longissimus lipid concentration was < 25 g/kg. In contrast, the carcasses of the AA animals finished on concentrates for 189 days were over fat and m. longissimus lipid concentration was > 65 g/kg.     

A comparison of Friesian, Aberdeen Angus × Friesian and Belgian Blue × Friesian steers finished at pasture or indoors

Cross-breeding of dairy cows with beef bulls is common in Ireland with the Aberdeen Angus and Belgian Blue beef breeds both widely used. These breeds differ in maturity and consequently in their suitability for production systems differing in intensity and slaughter age. The objective of this study was to compare spring-born Holstein–Friesian (FR), Aberdeen Angus × Holstein–Friesian (AA) and Belgian Blue  × Holstein–Friesian (BB) steers slaughtered off pasture at the end of their second grazing season or slaughtered at the end of the second winter following indoor finishing. Fifty-four (18 per breed type) steers were managed together to 16 months of age. They were then blocked on weight within breed type and assigned to a 3 (breed types) × 2 (finishing strategies) factorial experiment. The two finishing strategies were (i) concentrate supplementation (mean 3.65 kg/day) at pasture for 105 days to slaughter, and (ii) pasture only for 105 days followed by indoor finishing on grass silage plus concentrates for 141 days to slaughter. Mean slaughter and carcass weights per day of age for FR, AA and BB were 852, 802 and 834 (S.E. 13.1) g, and 427, 412 and 452 (S.E. 7.3) g, respectively. Corresponding kill-out proportions, carcass conformation and carcass fat classes were 501, 514 and 542 (S.E. 2.4) g/kg, 1.90, 2.15 and 2.89 (S.E. 0.073), and 3.09, 3.27 and 2.59 (S.E. 0.122), respectively. The response to concentrates at pasture was 101 g live weight and 83 g carcass weight per kg dry matter. It is concluded that there were few differences between FR and AA in carcass growth and composition but BB had heavier carcasses of better conformation with higher proportions of lean meat and high-value lean joints than both FR and AA. Acceptable live weight and carcass weight gains were obtained on pasture plus concentrates but BB and FR carcasses were not acceptably finished off pasture. Both FR and AA produced acceptable carcasses following indoor finishing and BB carcasses, while below the target fat class, were acceptably finished based on internal fat and dissected carcass fat proportions.