The quest for cryptic creatures: Impacts of species-focused recreational diving on corals

Coral reefs are popular with ecotourists, but the impact of divers on reefs is cause for concern. In this study, we assessed the damage to corals caused by divers seeking cryptic but charismatic fish such as seahorses (family Syngnathidae) and frogfishes (Antennariidae), which are found on reefs around the world. These fish are closely associated with the reef substratum, thus bringing divers into close proximity to coral. We found that when in the vicinity of frogfish and seahorses, divers made unintentional contact with corals significantly more often and for longer periods than when these species were absent. This change in diver behaviour resulted in a greater frequency of coral breakage and scarring at seahorse/frogfish sites than at ecologically equivalent control sites. However, the spatial extent of damage appeared limited. Beyond 1-3 m from the seahorse or frogfish, coral breakage and scarring rate decreased to levels similar to those of control sites. None of the coral species, which suffered the most damage, was particularly rare, suggesting that the habitat conservation concern of these marked shifts in diver behaviour is limited. Nevertheless, the use of pre-dive briefings and smaller dive group sizes could minimise the damage caused by divers approaching cryptic species of interest near the reef.     

“Take only photographs and leave only footprints”?: An experimental study of the impacts of underwater photographers on coral reef dive sites

Impacts caused by recreational scuba diving on coral reefs vary widely among different dive locations and individual divers. Linear modelling was used to explore a range of individual and situational risk factors associated with divers who damaged corals in the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park. Recreational divers were followed for 10–15 min, and all contacts with, and damage to corals were recorded. Information on the dive site, diving experience, gender, and use of an underwater camera were recorded. Thirty-two out of 214 divers (15%) damaged or broke corals, mostly by fin kicks (95%). Impacts were most likely to be caused by male divers, in the first 10 min of the dive, at sites with a large abundance of branching corals. Specialist underwater photographers caused more damage on average (1.6 breaks per 10 min) than divers without cameras (0.3 breaks per 10 min). To explore the effects of gender and use of a camera further, we issued single-use underwater cameras to 31 randomly chosen divers and compared their behaviour to a control group. Use of a camera had no influence on the rate or amount of damage caused by these naïve photographers, but male divers were more likely to break corals and caused significantly more damage, on average, (1.4 breaks per 15 min) than female divers (0.3 breaks per 15 min). Variability in the amount of damage caused by divers in our sample reflected the very different underwater behaviours exhibited by specialist and non-specialist photographers, and male and female divers. Greater understanding of the causes of harmful behaviours by these groups will allow better targeting of on-site interpretative and cautionary information and may prove to be a more palatable management strategy than regulation of site use.     

Effects of fishing pressure and trophic group on abundance and spillover across boundaries of a no-take zone

We investigated factors influencing fish abundance and emigration across the boundaries of a no-take zone (NTZ), and its adjacent fished zones, within the Nabq Managed Resource Protected Area, South Sinai, Egyptian Red Sea. Underwater visual census of eight families of reef fish was undertaken at three depths across the whole NTZ (1.2 km), and for a similar distance into the adjacent fished zones. Because most fishing occurs in shallow water, the effect of the NTZ changed with depth. On reef flat transects (1 m depth), seven families showed significantly higher abundance in the NTZ, whereas at 10 m depth only two herbivorous families, Acanthuridae (surgeonfishes) and Siganidae (rabbitfishes) showed a significant difference, both being more abundant in the fished zones, an effect most likely due to reduced competition or predation. To look for evidence of emigration (spillover) of fish from the NTZ, data were also tested for evidence of gradients in abundance extending from within the NTZ to within the fished zones. In shallow water six families showed significant declines in abundance moving away from the centre of the NTZ, whereas at 10 m, the only significant gradients were for acanthurids and siganids, both becoming more abundant moving further into the fished zones. Comparisons of estimated fish length between areas also showed significant differences. The results indicate that at Nabq, while fishing reduces the abundance of most families, especially predators, abundance of some families and species, especially herbivores, may increase under light fishing pressure. Thus, spillover may occur to an extent and in a direction depending on trophic group and fishing intensity.     

Thresholds and multiple scale interaction of environment, resource use, and market proximity on reef fishery resources in the Solomon Islands

Reef fish are critical in maintaining the ecological function of coral reefs and providing food security for coastal communities in developing countries. Reef fishery stocks are under increasing threat from factors such as climate-related habitat degradation, land use practices, and resource extraction related to human population growth, direct consumption and increasing connectivity between the in situ fishery and fish markets. This study investigates how reef fish stocks are related to environmental, localised resource use and market proximity indicators across 51 sites in the Solomon Islands. Hard coral cover is the best indicator of total target fishery biomass, with cover of less than around 31% associated with significantly less biomass than sites with higher coral cover. Direct resource use indicators such as fish consumption and fish sale pressure were poor predictors of target fish biomass. Distance of the fishery resource from community, provincial sub-station, provincial capital and national capital are all significantly and positively correlated with biomass for four key fishery families: Acanthuridae (surgeonfish), Scaridae (parrotfish), Lethrinidae (emperor), Lutjanidae (snapper). Multiple spatial scale relationships are evident between market proximity indicators and Lutjanidae and Scaridae families. Thus, while pooled target fishery biomass is constrained by environment, analysis at fishery family resolution reveals the effects of anthropogenic impact through market proximity on constraining fishery biomass distribution in the Solomon Islands. This study highlights the need for reef fishery managers and conservation practitioners to focus attention on proximity of resources to markets to sustain the ecological health of reef dominated ecosystems.     

Impacts of a Hawaiian marine protected area network on the abundance and fishery sustainability of the yellow tang, Zebrasoma flavescens

Marine protected areas can enhance fish stocks within their boundaries, but the circumstances in which they might also supplement stocks or enhance fisheries outside their boundaries are less clear. Using visual survey and fishery data, we assess the impacts of increasing fishing effort, and of the establishment in Hawaii of a network of areas closed to aquarium fishing, on the prime-target species, yellow tang (Zebrasoma flavescens), and draw conclusions about MPA impacts on long-term fishery sustainability. Between 1999, when 27.8% of the coastline was closed to collecting, and 2007, the number of active fishers and total catch of yellow tang doubled. Prior to MPA establishment, yellow tang densities were similar at sites open to fishing and those slated for closure. By 2007, closed areas had five times the density of prime targeted sized fish (5-10 cm), and 48% higher density of adults than open areas. Densities of adults in ‘boundary’ areas (open areas <1 km from nearest MPA boundary) were significantly higher than in open areas far from MPA boundaries, which was indicative of spillover at that scale. Given the long life-span of yellow tang (>40 years) relative to the duration of protection and the increasing intensity of fishing, the likelihood is that protected areas will become increasingly important sources for the adult fishes which will sustain stocks and the fishery over the longer term.     

Impacts of ski-development on ptarmigan (Lagopus mutus) at Cairn Gorm, Scotland

This paper reports adverse impacts on numbers and breeding success of ptarmigan (Lagopus mutus) in 1967-1996 at a ski area in the Cairngorms massif, where ptarmigan normally show 10-year population cycles. An influx of carrion crows (Corvus corone), generalist predators, followed the development. On the most developed area near the main car park, ptarmigan occurred at high density but then lost nests to frequent crows, reared abnormally few broods, died flying into ski-lift wires and declined until none bred for many summers. On a nearby higher area with fewer wires, ptarmigan lost nests to frequent crows and reared abnormally few broods, but seldom died on wires. Adult numbers declined and then became unusually steady for over two decades, with no significant cycle. On a third area further from the car park, ptarmigan lost fewer nests to the less frequent crows but bred more poorly than in the massif’s centre, and showed cycles of lower amplitude than there. On a fourth area yet further away, with few or no crows, ptarmigan bred as well as in the massif’s centre and showed cycles of the same amplitude as there.