self-(in)compatibility almond genotypes: A review

To compile self-(in)compatibility almond genotypes, a review of 133 commercial cultivars of wide geographical origin was made. The information gathered from own and mainly published work will be useful for both grower's cultivar choice when planting and for breeder's cross design when planning. The almond S genotypes compiled were identified using five different methods: biological (pollination tests in the field and in the laboratory) and molecular (RNases, PCR and sequencing). In most cases, genotypes were assigned after combining more than one technique. Cultivars were classified into three categories: self-incompatible (99), self-compatible (16) and doubtful self-incompatible (18). The database is divided in 9 fields (name, origin, parentage, obtention year (crossing, selection or release), S genotype, technique used, reference, consensus genotype, and cross incompatibility group). A study of the 27 S alleles already identified and their geographical distribution within the cultivated almond is also presented. The study was divided into cultivars of known and unknown parentage and the distribution of S alleles frequencies was uneven among the 133 cultivars. S allele frequencies are related to geographical origin. Some alleles (S ₁, S ₅, S ₇ and S ₈) are more frequently observed than the others among cultivars of both known and unknown parentage. In the cultivated almond, the S f allele is only found in the Puglia region, Italy. The S _f frequency is three times higher in cultivars released from breeding programmes than in cultivars selected by growers. From the 351 resulting possible genotypes by combination of the 27 S alleles identified only 20 CIG (0-XIX) have been established, which represents a small fraction of the whole genetic diversity of this polymorphic gene in almond.     

Primers amplifying a range of Prunus S-alleles

Although various consensus polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers have been reported for identifying Prunus S‐alleles, they have been developed from and optimized on a limited set of alleles, which may limit their applicability to a broader allele range. To develop a primer set for use across the genus, degenerate consensus primers were designed from conserved regions of 27 S‐RNase sequences available from five Prunus species. The primers were tested in 15 previously genotyped cultivars of cherry, almond and apricot, representing alleles S₁ to S₆ in each crop and also S_c in apricot. Comparisons were made with previously published primers tested in the same 15 cultivars under reported reaction conditions. The new primers generated an amplification product for each of the 19 S‐alleles whereas those previously available amplified no more than 14. The primers will be useful for genotyping and genetic studies in cultivars and wild populations.     

Identification of S-alleles in almond using multiplex PCR

The S-genotypes of eight almond (Prunus dulcis Miller (D.A. Webb)) cultivars from different geographical origins and of nine new selections from the CEBAS-CSIC (Murcia, Spain) breeding program were determined using single and multiplex PCR with different sets of specific oligonucleotide primers. The results of PCR using the AS1II- and AmyC5R-specific primers showed amplification in a single reaction of 10 different self-incompatibility alleles and of the self-compatibility allele S _f. However, the amplified fragments of the S _f allele were of similar sizes to those amplified from the S ₃ self-incompatibility allele. For this reason, a specific PCR primer CEBASf was designed from the intron sequence of S _f. A multiplex-PCR reaction using the AS1II, CEBASf and AmyC5R primers permitted unequivocal identification of the 10 self-incompatibility alleles and of the self-compatibility allele. Multiplex PCR opens the possibility to identify new S-alleles using different sets of primers. The applications of these PCR markers in the almond-breeding programs are discussed.     

Improved discrimination of self-incompatibility S-RNase alleles in cherry and high throughput genotyping by automated sizing of first intron polymerase chain reaction products

A novel polymerase chain reaction (PCR) approach to determine and confirm the self‐incompatibility (S) genotype of cherries is reported. The method involves PCR amplification with a new pair of consensus primers that immediately flank the first intron of cherry S‐RNases, one of which is fluorescently labelled. Fluorescent amplification products range from 234 to c. 460 bp and can be sized accurately on an automated sequencer. Thirteen S alleles reported in sweet cherry can be distinguished, except for S₂ and S₇, which have an amplification product of exactly the same size. S₁₃, which is also amplified, gives a microsatellite‐like trace which shows minor intra‐allelic length variation. This method gives fast and accurate results and should be especially useful for medium/high‐throughput genotyping of wild and cultivated cherries.     

Identification and characterization of new S‐alleles associated with self‐incompatibility in almond

Almond is a highly heterozygous species with a high number of S‐alleles controlling its gametophytic self‐incompatibility system (GSI). In this work, we have analysed 14 Spanish local almond cultivars for S‐RNase allele diversity. Five new S‐RNase alleles were identified by cloning and sequencing, S₃₁ (804 bp) in ‘Pou de Felanitx’ and ‘Totsol’, S₃₂ (855 bp) in ‘Taiatona’, S₃₃ (1165 bp) in ‘Pou d’Establiments’ and ‘Muel’, S₃₄ (1663 bp) in ‘Pané‐Barquets’ and S₃₅ (1658 bp) in ‘Planeta de les Garrigues’. Additionally, seven already known almond alleles could be recognized in the local cultivars studied. The high number of new alleles identified reveals the wide diversity of almond germplasm still existing and requiring characterization, and points to the possibility of new findings by a wider study focusing on other provenances. The almond S‐RNases have been compared to those of other Prunus species, showing a high identity and confirming that the S‐RNase gene in this genus presents a probable common ancestor.     

S-allele identification by PCR analysis in sweet cherry cultivars

Gametophytic self‐incompatibility, governed by the S‐locus, operates in sweet cherry. The knowledge of the S‐genotype of sweet cherry cultivars is therefore essential to establish productive orchards by defining compatible combinations. The isolation of sweet cherry S‐R Nases has allowed the use of different molecular techniques to characterize the S‐genotypes of sweet cherry cultivars. Previously, incompatibility group assignment could only be carried out on mature trees through pollination tests. In this work, PCR analysis with primers designed on the conserved sequences of sweet cherry S‐R Nases has been used to characterize the S‐genotype of 71 sweet cherry cultivars, including 26 cultivars whose S‐allele constitution had not been previously described. This approach has allowed the detection of alleles that had not been amplified by PCR before, to identify six putative new S‐alleles, to define three new self‐incompatibility groups and to compile the standards for a PCR‐based S‐allele typing method in sweet cherry.     

Analysis of S‐allele genetic diversity in Sicilian almond germplasm comparing different molecular methods

Italian almond germplasm is characterized by a wide diversity in several growing areas among which Sicily is one of the most important. Analysis with consensus and specific primers and DNA sequencing was performed to investigate S‐RNase genetic diversity and to elucidate the homology rate within a genetic pool of 27 Italian accessions. Interestingly, some of the self‐compatible cultivars did not show the presence of S_f allele. Amplicons from consensus and allele‐specific PCR primers revealed a high level of variability. Sequencing of all the S‐RNase amplicons derived from consensus primers allowed the identification of two new S‐RNase alleles (S₅₁ and S₅₂). Surprisingly, despite the AA replacement mutation, S₅₁ did not exhibit any change of its S‐RNase function. Additionally, several mutations, with no effect on amino acid composition, were detected in the intron and/or in the ORF of four known alleles (S_g, S₁₀, S₃₁ and S₃₅). Genetic variation, regarding point mutations and only detected by sequencing, was revealed among 11 of 27 tested cultivars. The new sources of variability might have an interest for product traceability.     

Stylar ribonucleases in almond: correlation with and prediction of incompatibility genotypes

To clarify incompatibility relationships among almond cultivars, 35 were analysed for stylar ribonucleases, which have previously been shown to correlate with incompatibility S alleles. Stylar proteins were extracted and separated electrophoretically and the zymograms compared with ladders of ribonucleases corresponding to the 12 S alleles previously reported. Sixteen cultivars showed a band corresponding to two of the known ribonucleases, 17 showed one known ribonuclease and one ‘new’ band, and two showed two new bands. Twelve new ribonucleases were detected; 11 were attributed to new S alleles (S₁₃ to S23) and a mutant form of S₇ was attributed to S_7A. Genotypes were proposed for nine cultivars of five incompatibility groups that had not been genotyped previously, VII, X, XI, XII and XIII. Twenty‐four cultivars of unknown incompatibility relationships were provisionally genotyped: six of these could be assigned to existing groups and two new groups were established, XIV and XV, along with group O of cultivars with unique genotypes. Test crosses confirmed that eight pairs of cultivars showing similar zymograms were indeed cross‐incompatible, including the two representatives of each of the two new groups. Virtually all self‐incompatible cultivars of known genotype are listed in a table. The data should be useful for planning cultivar combinations for orchards and for designing crosses for breeding programmes.     

'Francolí', a late flowering almond cultivar re-classified as self-compatible

To verify the compatibility behaviour of the almond cultivar ‘Francolí’ and to clarify its S genotype a combination of pollination tests, stylar ribonuclease and allele specific PCR analysis was used. ‘Francolí’ was released from IRTA's breeding programme in 1994, having been putatively raised from the cross ‘Cristomorto’ (S₁S₂) × ‘Gabaix’ (S₁₀S₂₅). This cultivar was also reported to be self‐incompatible but revealing only one S band in the zymograms after S‐RNases analysis. ‘Francolí’ sets nuts after test crossing with two S₁S₂₅ cultivars, having a different genotype from that earlier reported. ‘Francolí’ was also observed to be self‐compatible after selfing flowers in the field and in the laboratory. ‘Francolí’ was re‐assigned the S₁S_f genotype after test crossing, stylar ribonuclease and PCR data analysis. After microsatellite analysis, the self‐compatible ‘Tuono’ (S₁S_f) cultivar is suggested as the male parent of ‘Francolí’ instead of the earlier reported ‘Gabaix’.     

The myrobalan (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus cerasifera</Emphasis> L.): a useful diploid model for studying the molecular genetics of self-incompatibility in plums

A series of PCR methods were used to detect S-RNase alleles and SFB alleles and to determine S-genotypes in 25 accessions of myrobalan (Prunus cerasifera L.). Firstly, primers flanking the polymorphic second intron were used to identify S-RNases in agarose gels. These primers amplified one or two bands per accession in 25 accessions. Then consensus primers were designed for amplifying the polymorphic first intron, unique to Prunus S-RNases, for automated fluorescent detection. Each accession produced one or two peaks. New primers were then developed to amplify the intron in the SFB gene, for detection by fluorescence. Cross-referencing PCR bands and peaks indicated 15 S-alleles were present in the 25 accessions. Cloning, sequencing and comparison with published data indicated that the amplified products were S-RNase alleles. Sequence information was used to design primers specific for each S-RNase. Full and consistent S-genotypes were obtained by cross-comparing PCR data for 23 of the 25 accessions, and two accessions appeared to have a single allele. Pollen-tube microscopy indicated function of some but not all of the S-alleles sequenced.     

Development of a molecular CAPS marker for the self-incompatibility locus in Brassica napus and identification of different S alleles

Using primers annealing to S locus sequences the cleaved amplified polymorphic sequences (CAPS) method was applied to develop a marker and to characterize different alleles at the self‐incompatibility locus in Brassica napus. A segregating F₂ population from a cross of a self‐incompatible (SI) and a self‐compatible parent, as well as seven SI lines representing four different S alleles were used. Several primers specific to the S locus in B. oleracea and B. campestris, chosen from the literature, allow polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of genomic DNA. However, only one primer pair amplified a single specific and reproducible PCR fragment of the expected length in B. napus. Digestion with restriction endonucleases revealed polymorphisms for two CAPS markers absolutely linked to the S locus. Using the codominant marker efMboI it was possible to discriminate all three F₂ genotypes. With this marker and an additional marker using another primer pair it was possible to distinguish between three of the four different S alleles and five of the seven SI lines, respectively.     

Identification of incompatibility genotypes in almond (Prunus dulcis Mill.) using specific primers based on the introns of the S-alleles

Identification of the incompatibility genotypes of almond cultivars is important in breeding programmes for designing crosses and for selecting progeny. This paper describes a novel molecular technique for the identification of S‐alleles in almond based on the use of PCR primers designed from the sequences of the introns without the need for restriction enzyme digestion. Nine specific pairs of primers have been designed for the S1, S2, S5, S7, S8, S9, S10 (putative), S23 and Sf alleles, and these confirmed the S‐allele specificities for 22 of the 23 accessions for which published information is available. This technique provides a precise method for identifying S‐alleles from the genomic DNAs of almond cultivars, and will be useful for confirming the segregation of alleles in breeding progeny.     

Correlation of ribonuclease zymograms and incompatibility genotypes in almond

Proteins were extracted from styles of 29 self-incompatible cultivars of almond and separated using non-equilibrium pH gradient electro-focusing, and the gels were stained for ribonuclease activity. Mutually incompatible cultivars had similar banding patterns and, for the 24 cultivars already genotyped in France or California, the bands correlated well with the reported alleles. The band corresponding to S₁ of the French labelling system was indistinguishable from that corresponding to S_b of the Californian labelling system, and a controlled cross confirmed that these alleles are identical. The band corresponding to the Californian S_a was distinct from the bands corresponding to French alleles and, to harmonise the allele labels, it was redesignated S₅. The genotypes of five uncharacterised self-incompatible cultivars were inferred from zymograms as follows: ‘Desmayo Largueta’ and ‘Glorieta’, S₁S₅, ‘Masbovera’, S₁S₉, ‘Tarragones’, S₂S₉, and ‘Tokyo’, S₆S₇. The alleles designated S₆ and S₉ have not previously been reported. Nine self-compatible cultivars or selections were analysed, and each showed a band corresponding to an incompatibility allele as well as a common band; however, the correspondence of this common band to S_f, the allele for self-compatibility, is unproven. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Identification and characterization of genomic DNA sequences of the S-ribonuclease gene associated with self-incompatibility alleles S1 to S5 in European pear

The stylar products of the S‐locus for the gametophytic self‐incompatibility (GSI) system in the Rosaceae are ribonucleases (S‐RNases). Recently, sequences for 13 pear S‐RNase alleles have been published and named following a letter–symbol nomenclature (S_a to S_d and S_h to S_p). To establish the correspondence between these sequences and the self‐incompatibility alleles we have described previously (S₁ to S₅), we have amplified genomic DNA with consensus primers from the cultivars, ‘Williams’ (S₁S₂), ‘Coscia’ (S₃S₄), ‘Butirra Precoce Morettini’ (S₁S₃), ‘Santa Maria Morettini’ (S₂S₃) and ‘Doyenne du Comice’ (S₄S₅) and identified PCR products specifically associated with each S allele. Cloning and sequencing of the amplification products has revealed that they correspond to European pear sequences already deposited in the database. This allowed us to link S‐RNase sequences with S allele phenotypes and to determine a correspondence between the symbol–letter nomenclature used to name S‐RNase sequences and the number‐based nomenclature used to name S alleles. Based on this result the prediction of new cross‐incompatibilities among pear cultivars is discussed. Finally, we propose a unified number‐based nomenclature to avoid future confusion denominating S alleles in pear.     

Genotyping apricot cultivars for self-(in)compatibility by means of RNases associated with S alleles

In previous work the existence of proteins with RNase activity associated with S alleles in apricot was demonstrated. These proteins were inherited as described previously for the inheritance of self‐compatibility in this species. In this study, new cultivars have been genotyped for self‐compatibility using this method and it has been demonstrated that in all self‐compatible cultivars examined, the self‐compatibility allele is the same and is associated with an RNase with high activity. Homozygous self‐compatible individuals have been detected among established cultivars as well as among seedlings following breeding activity. This germplasm is of great value within the breeding programme because only self‐compatible seedlings will be produced. The number of S alleles in apricot appears to be low and only eight different alleles have been found in the large number of different cultivars screened. Furthermore, there are alleles present in the Spanish population that are also found in the genetic pool of North American cultivars. The screening of a progeny from the cross between the American cultivar ‘Goldrich’ and the Spanish cultivar ‘Pepito’ demonstrated the existence of the common allele S₂ (detected previously by examining RNases), which was confirmed by the segregation of self‐compatibility in the progeny.     

Single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping of the barley waxy gene by polymerase chain reaction with confronting two-pair primers

A high‐throughput single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping procedure was developed to select amylose‐free barley mutants whose waxy genes had a C‐ to T‐base substitution in exon 5, which converted Gln‐89 of the wild‐type gene into a termination codon. An F₂ population carrying an amylose‐free waxy gene was checked for segregation. Polymerase chain reaction with confronting two‐pair primers (PCR‐CTPP) produced allele‐specific PCR products that have different sizes and are inherited in a co‐dominant manner. Two alleles of the barley waxy gene with SNP were correctly identified in parental strains using the PCR‐CTPP procedure. Segregation of the SNP as detected by PCR‐CTPP in an F₂ population fitted the expected 1:2:1 ratio. The PCR‐CTPP procedure can provide a time saving and cost‐effective alternative to derived cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence in marker‐assisted selection.     

Self-incompatibility genotype identification and stability as influenced by inbreeding in red clover (Trifolium pratense L.)

Summary S allele genotypes of I₁ progenies from eight I₀ red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) clones were determined under isolated field conditions. Each I₁ progeny was vegetatively increased and isolated under a cage for pollination by honey bees. Clones within each I₁ progeny producing relatively large and small amounts of seed were classified homozygous and heterozygous, respectively, for S allele genotype. S allele genotypes were verified by extensive sib crosses in the greenhouse, and almost complete agreement was found with the field classification. I₂ progenies were reciprocally test-crossed with their parental I₀ clones to detect any changes in S specificity and also to confirm the previous S genotype classifications in the I₁ generation. It was concluded that the reliability of field and greenhouse sib classification of S genotypes is based on the strength of the incompatibility reaction in each particular clone. Most I₁'s showed a strong incompatibility reaction as evidenced by low seed set for heterozygous S genotypes, but one progeny showed a weak incompatibility reaction which resulted in S genotype misclassifications. An S specificity was changed in one I₂ progeny.Contribution from the Kentucky Agricultural Experiment Station. This paper (72-3-151) is published with the approval of the Director, Kentucky Agricultural Experiment Station, Lexington, Kentucky 40506, USA.     

Detection and genotyping of SNPs tightly linked to two disease resistance loci, Rsv1 and Rsv3, of soybean

Allele‐specific polymerase chain reaction (AS‐PCR) for assaying single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) would be more widely used with increased availability of AS primers sufficient to distinguish between SNP alleles. AS‐PCR could be a means unambiguously to detect the presence or absence of PCR products. Examples are given here of the detection and genotyping of SNPs in the genomic DNA fragments tightly linked to two soybean mosaic virus resistance genes, Rsv1 and Rsv3, with a modified AS‐PCR procedure in soybean. The modified AS‐PCR that introduces an additional base mismatch closest to the 3′‐end of the AS primers and uses publicly available microsatellite markers as positive controls directly determined SNP alleles from primary PCR of genomic DNAs. It was demonstrated that a set of AS primers designed from two adjacent SNP loci could simultaneously detect the two SNP loci. Using the modified procedure, many SNP loci in eight soybean parental lines and F₂ individuals of three mapping populations could be genotyped. The modified AS‐PCR procedure could greatly facilitate small‐to‐medium scale marker‐assisted selection programmes for agronomically important genes.     

Alleles at a quantitative trait locus for stem solidness in wheat affect temporal patterns of pith expression and level of resistance to the wheat stem sawfly

The stem solidness trait in wheat has been the most effective mechanism for management of the wheat stem sawfly (WSS) for six decades. However, recent results have shown that in certain genotypes, the degree of stem solidness is not a useful indicator of WSS resistance. A morphological characterization of solidness expression indicated that in the genotype ‘Conan’, very solid pith undergoes rapid retraction during stem maturation, resulting in significantly less solidness at maturity. In other solid‐stemmed genotypes, including the standard WSS‐resistant cultivar ‘Choteau’, dense pith in the stem remains nearly unchanged throughout plant development. In cage trials, ‘Conan’ plants were less preferred for oviposition by the WSS when paired with ‘Choteau’ plants. Field bioassays using near‐isogenic lines differing for alleles at Qss.msub‐3BL showed that the Conan allele provides higher levels of early stem solidness and rapid pith retraction during stem maturation. These results suggest that the traditional approach for increasing WSS resistance by selecting for increasing stem solidness needs to be modified to consider temporal variations in pith expression associated with alleles at Qss.msub‐3BL.