Insensibility during slaughter of pigs in comparison to other domestic stock

The onset of insensibility during slaughter was studied in five, 31-day-old pigs. The state of sensibility was determined from the study of electroencephalograms (EEC) which were of a bipolar transhemispheric derivation. In 3 pigs slaughtered by bilateral severance of both common carotid arteries and jugular veins, it was judged that insensibility occurred within 25 s and there was no resurgence of cerebrocortical activity following subsequent respiratory gasps. The EEGs became isoelectric within 115 s. These results are compared with previous findings by the authors that adult sheep and lambs slaughtered by similar techniques became insensible within 7 s whereas, in calves, the onset of insensibility was delayed for up to 85 s and there were resurgences of cerebrocortical activity, following a respiratory gasp, for more than 300 s. These differences in the apparent onset of insensibility in the 3 species of animal are discussed in relation to the anatomical features and possible dynamics of the blood supply to the brain during slaughter. It is concluded that for humane reasons, head-to-back electrical stunning of pigs is preferable to a head-only method.     

Insensibility during slaughter of pigs in comparison to other domestic stock

The onset of insensibility during slaughter was studied in five, 31-day-old pigs. The state of sensibility was determined from the study of electroencephalograms (EEC) which were of a bipolar transhemispheric derivation. In 3 pigs slaughtered by bilateral severance of both common carotid arteries and jugular veins, it was judged that insensibility occurred within 25s and there was no resurgence of cerebrocortical activity following subsequent respiratory gasps. The EEGs became isoelectric within 115s. These results are compared with previous findings by the authors that adult sheep and lambs slaughtered by similar techniques became insensible within 7s whereas, in calves, the onset of insensibility was delayed for up to 85s and there were resurgences of cerebrocortical activity, following a respiratory gasp, for more than 300s.

These differences in the apparent onset of insensibility in the 3 species of animal are discussed in relation to the anatomical features and possible dynamics of the blood supply to the brain during slaughter.

It is concluded that for humane reasons, “head-to-back” electrical stunning of pigs is preferable to a “head-only” method.     

Differences in blood supply to the cerebral cortex between sheep and calves during slaughter

Using methylene blue boli, injected via an intracardiac catheter, the blood supply to the brain in two one- to 10-day-old calves and three adult sheep was studied during and after severance of the common carotid arteries and jugular veins. Passage of dye through cerebral vessels could not be observed in the exposed cerebrum of sheep after bilateral severance of major blood vessels. When vessels were severed on one side only, the passage of dye was noted for at least 53 seconds. In calves, after bilateral severance, sequential boli of dye could be detected passing through the cerebral vessels for more than 100 seconds. These results provide an explanation and support for the belief that there are major differences in the onset of insensibility between sheep and calves subsequent to severance of the common carotid arteries and jugular veins. The differences in blood supply to the brain which were demonstrated could be accounted for by differences in the blood supply to the brain by the vertebral artery in sheep and cattle. The effects of slaughter on the blood supply to the eye are discussed as a possible explanation of the disparity between results of studies in this general field which have used retinal responses in their investigations and those which have not.     

Cortical function in cattle during slaughter: conventional captive bolt stunning followed by exsanguination compared with shechita slaughter

Brain function was examined in adult cattle after conventional captive bolt stunning or shechita slaughter, using eight animals in each treatment. The times to loss of evoked responses (visual and somatosensory) and spontaneous activity in the electro-corticogram were used to determine the onset of brain failure. Captive bolt stunning followed by sticking one minute later resulted in immediate and irreversible loss of evoked responses after the stun. Spontaneous cortical activity was lost before sticking in three animals, and in an average of 10 seconds after sticking in the remaining five animals. The duration of brain function after shechita was very variable, and particularly contrasted with captive bolt stunning with respect to the effects on evoked responses. These were lost between 20 and 126 seconds (means of 77 seconds for somatosensory and 55 seconds for visual evoked responses) and spontaneous activity was lost between 19 and 113 seconds (mean 75 seconds) after slaughter.     

Effect of slaughter on the spontaneous and evoked activity of the brain

The principal blood vessels in the neck which are severed at slaughter in commercial poultry processing plants are described. Mechanical slaughtering methods often severed the spinal cord without cutting the carotid arteries. The manual method of slaughter cut one carotid artery plus one jugular vein. The effects of 9 different slaughtering methods on spontaneous and evoked electrical activity in the brain were examined in anaesthetised chickens and ducks. Severing the spinal cord without cutting the carotid arteries was found to result in death from asphyxia, and cutting one carotid artery plus one jugular vein was one of the slowest methods of killing the birds. Inducing a cardiac arrest at electrical stunning was the quickest method of inducing death. Spontaneous activity in the brain was lost before visual evoked activity. The times before loss of spontaneous activity varied between 23 and 233 s according to the method of slaughter and loss of evoked activity ranged between 90 and 349 s after slaughter.     

The role of the vertebral arteries in maintaining spontaneous electrocortical activity after electrical stunning and slaughter in calves

This paper examines the role of the vertebral arteries of calves in determining the time to loss of spontaneous electrocortical activity after slaughter by a throat-cut severing the soft tissues of the neck ventral to the spinal column. Four calves with the vertebral arteries ligated took 43 +/- 1.3 s to lose cortical activity after the throat was cut. Four similar animals with intact vertebral arteries and the rostral end of the common carotid arteries clamped immediately after slaughter, to ensure that vertebral blood passed to the brain, took 51 +/-25 s to lose cortical activity. It was concluded that factors other than blood flow from the vertebral arteries contribute to the prolonged time to loss of electrocortical activity after slaughter that has been observed in some calves.     

Physiologic reactions during the slaughter of cattle and sheep with and without stunning

In a first trial the cortical activity of cattle and sheep was tested using only an electrocorticogram (ECoG). The results showed a shorter phase after sticking or the ritual slaughter cut respectively, until the ECoG disappears in stunned animals. However, considering the time between stunning and the cervical state, the interval until disappearance of the ECoG was prolonged in the stunned animals. The observed time differences, however, are only a tendency and not statistically confirmed. Insofar, concerning animal protection, the different slaughter methods could be regarded equivalent. A second trial was designed in a manner to allow a more exact interpretation of the ECoGs and was completed by measuring visually and somatosensorically evoked potentials. Additionally, in contrast to the first trial, only adult cattle were used here. The results revealed shorter intervals until disappearance of cortical activities when using captive-bolt stunning. Also the variance was much lower in this trial than after ritual slaughter. The mean of the time differences was relatively low (5.5 seconds). It was especially remarkable that after captivebolt stunning absolutely no evoked potentials could be registrated, whereas these potentials lasted for 77 seconds (somatosensorically evoked potentials) and 55 seconds respectively (visually evoked potentials) after the ritual slaughter cut. Thus, after ritual slaughter a nervous conduction was measured up to 126 seconds in the extreme cases. However, from the results obtained it can not be concluded whether or not pain sensitivity occurred in the animals.     

Electroencephalographic studies of calves associated with electrical stunning, throat cutting and carcass electro-immobilisation

Electroencephalographic (EEG) recordings were made on 34 calves (two days to six weeks old, 30-50 kg) during the slaughter process. The calves, supported in a V-shaped box or polypropylene net, were either head-only electrically stunned (50 Hz, 1.0 A) across the head and allowed to recover, head-only stunned followed by throat cutting or head-only stunned followed by throat cutting and electro-immobilisation. All time intervals were measured from the commencement of the stun. The electro-immobilisation (80 V peak, 14.3 Hz, 5 ms square wave) at 15-26 seconds post-stun was applied through electrodes attached to nose and anus, for periods ranging from 5-60 seconds. The head only stun produced an elevated EEG amplitude of the electroplectic fit which lasted approximately 34 seconds followed by a quiescent period before the EEG amplitude again became elevated above normal. A normal pre-stun pattern was not reached until many minutes had elapsed. Following the stun, the forelegs were usually flexed and then extended, gradually becoming part of the paddling movements commencing as early as eight seconds post-stun. Such movements were taking place while the animal was still stunned. With a head-only stun followed by throat cutting, the electroplectic fit was reduced to about 23 seconds and the amplitude of the EEG fell to about 10 microV after 50-73 seconds and breathing was inhibited for at least 20 seconds after stun commencement. If inadvertently only one carotid was severed, the EEG did not fall as rapidly as when both carotids were cut. The increase in amplitude of the EEG tracings was caused by stunning but the reduced duration of this increase in calves in which the throat was cut, suggests that there is an impairment of recovery of brain function from the moment of cutting and recovery of sensibility is unlikely. In reviewing the criteria of sensibility, we believe that insensibility can be presumed to continue from stun initiation, through the throat cut until the EEG falls below 10/microV provided that there is no resurgence of activity and the EEG amplitude continually falls rapidly enough. By this criteria, calves which are electrically stunned and rapidly exsanguinated remain permanently and irreversibly insensible. The addition of at least 15 seconds electro-immobilisation causes an even more rapid fall in the amplitude of the EEG (<10 microV at 50 seconds) making insensibility more certain as well as abolishing animal movement.     

The effect of different slaughter methods on the post mortem glycolysis of muscle in lambs

Differences in muscular activity and rates of decline in the pH of the M. longissimus dorsi of lambs subjected to different methods of stunning and slaughter were observed. Lambs electrically stunned by a head-to-leg method had significantly lower initial pH values as compared to animals stunned by an electrical head-only method, or by captive bolt, or without any form of stunning prior to slaughter. When electrical stunning by a head-to-leg method was combined with low voltage (24 V) electrical stimulation during slaughter and bleeding, mean pH values declined at the highest rate and fell to approximately 6.0 within two hours of slaughter. This last procedure, therefore, has the potential to greatly reduce times between slaughter and freezing without increasing the risk of cold shortening and the associated toughness of meat.     

Head-only followed by cardiac arrest electrical stunning is an effective alternative to head-only electrical stunning in pigs

Many small slaughter facilities use head-only electrical stunning to render swine unconscious and insensible to pain before slaughter. Head-only electrical stunning is a reversible procedure that is optimally effective for approximately 15 s after stun completion. In many small North American slaughter plants, the authors have observed hoist speeds that are too slow to achieve a short enough stun-to-bleed interval to maintain insensibility through exsanguination. Unlike many European plants, there is no separate high-speed hoist for pigs and exsanguination on the floor is not condoned. As a result, a 2-stage stunning method was proposed where head-only stunning for 3 s was immediately followed by application of the same stunning wand to the cardiac region of the animal for 3 s while lying in lateral recumbancy. A paired-comparison study was conducted on 89 pigs in a small slaughter facility to compare the head-only method applied for 6 s with the head/heart method. The objective was to evaluate signs of return to sensibility, stun-to-bleed time, blood lactate concentration, muscle pH, drip loss, and fresh meat color to validate the head/heart electrical stunning method for small slaughter plants. Incidence of corneal reflex was not different (P > 0.05) between head/heart (93.8%) and head only (85%) stunning. Nose twitching was more common (P < 0.05) in head only (26.5%) than head/heart (5%) stunning. Head/heart stunning eliminated rhythmic breathing, natural blinking, eye tracking to moving objects, and righting reflex, which were all observed in head-only stunned pigs. Eye tracking to moving objects was observed in 40.8% of head-only stunned pigs. Blood lactate was not different (P > 0.05) between stunning methods (head only: 8.8 ± 0.7 mmol/L, head/heart: 7.8 ± 0.7 mmol/L). Stun-to-bleed time did not differ (P > 0.05; head only: 32 ± 1 s, head/heart: 33 ± 1 s). Mean time to loss of heartbeat with the head-only method was 121 ± 5 s. No heartbeat was observed with the head/heart method. Longissimus thoracis pH, color, and drip loss were not different (P > 0.05) between stunning methods. This study determined that the head/heart electrical stunning method reduces the incidence of signs of return to sensibility without significant effects on meat quality, plant operation speed, or blood lactate concentration. In addition, the head/heart method requires no capital investment for plants that are currently using the head-only method.     

The effect of different slaughter methods on the post mortem glycolysis of muscle in lambs

Differences in muscular activity and rates of decline in the pH of the M. longissimus dorsi of lambs subjected to different methods of stunning and slaughter were observed. Lambs electrically stunned by a “head-to-leg” method had significantly lower initial pH values as compared to animals stunned by an electrical “head-only” method, or by captive bolt, or without any form of stunning prior to slaughter. When electrical stunning by a “head-to-leg” method was combined with low voltage (24V) electrical stimulation during slaughter and bleeding, mean pH values declined at the highest rate and fell to approximately 6.0 within two hours of slaughter. This last procedure, therefore, has the potential to greatly reduce times between slaughter and freezing without increasing the risk of cold shortening and the associated toughness of meat.     

Electrocardiograms as an aid in assessing the stunning of cattle and pigs

Electrocardiograms (ECG's) were made from cattle and pigs after slaughter using only the left arm and right arm recording electrodes of a portable electrocardiogram with 12 recording electrodes. Functional heart activity was demonstrated in cattle after stunning with a captive bolt, nonpenetrative percussive methods and a head-only electrical technique. Recordings compatible with ventricular fibrillation were made in the majority of cattle and pigs subjected to a head-to-chest form of electrical stunning. In cases where the placement of stunning electrodes was defective, functional cardiac activity could be detected. Movement artefact on the ECG trace associated with epileptiform seizures following head-only electrical stunning was a technical problem. This was reduced by restunning the animal with a captive bolt before taking an ECG. The examination of ECG's made subsequent to slaughter could form an important component of the quality control of Halal slaughter or a slaughter process using the head-to-body electrical stunning techniques. Adoption of this would be facilitated by the development of a more simple and less sensitive electrocardiograph than that used in the present investigation.     

Electroencephalographic studies of adult cattle associated with electrical stunning, throat cutting and carcass electro-immobilization

Twelve adult cattle were electrically stunned head-only (400 V, 2.5 A, 50 Hz) behind the ears for four seconds. Within ten seconds of stun initiation, the carotid arteries, jugular veins, trachea and oesophagus were severed. Twenty seconds after the stun initiation, ten animals received an electro-immobilization current (80 V peak, 14.3 Hz, 5 ms square wave, 300 mA) nose to anus for periods ranging from 30-37 seconds. Electroencephalographic (EEG) traces were recorded before and after the stun up until electroimmobilization and at cessation of electro-immobilization by means of implanted electrodes, and animal movement was recorded on videotape. Before the stun, the EEG trace was within a window of sensibility (10-40 microV amplitude). During the stun, the amplitude increased and sometimes exceeded 500 microV. At the end of electro-immobilization, EEG amplitude was less than 10 microV, indicating insensibility. This amplitude was reached in the two non-immobilized animals 57 seconds and 63 seconds after stun initiation. During stunning, the forelegs and hindlegs usually tucked under the animals. Various degrees of foreleg extension then occurred. From about ten seconds post-stun, paddling movements occurred, at which time the EEG trace showed large-amplitude waves characteristic of a stunned animal. During immobilization, the animals stiffened and breathing stopped. After immobilization weak muscle spasms occurred that did not interfere with dressing operations. Non-immobilized animals moved excessively, inhibiting dressing. It is concluded that adult cattle rendered insensible by stunning do not recover sensibility during the stun/throat-cut/immobilization operation and therefore this procedure is humane.     

The use of electrical stunning followed by electro-immobilization for the humane slaughter of cattle

Sir;- In New Zealand, calves are often electrically stunned before slaughter. However, electrical stunning is not usually used for adult cattle, primarily because the large size of the adult animal makes restraint more difficult, resulting in less reproducible stunning, with potential danger to personnel from animal movement. In addition, the slaughter of cattle may be inhumane if the stunning process does not ensure immediate and permanent insensibility (Newhook and Blackmore 1982b). The use and humaneness of electrical stunning of sheep and cattle have been the subject of our recent research, in which we have addressed and resolved many of these problems. We wish to relate our observations in the context of head-only electrical stunning of cattle followed by electro-immobilization to maintain insensibility and ensure carcass stillness.     

Solving return-to-sensibility problems after electrical stunning in commercial pork slaughter plants

OBJECTIVE: To determine causes and solutions for return-to-sensibility problems after electrical stunning in pigs. DESIGN: Case studies. SAMPLE POPULATION: 6 federally inspected pork slaughter plants. PROCEDURE: 100 to 200 pigs were scored in each plant for stunner positioning, squealing when stunner was applied, and signs of insensibility. All pigs were held in a V-shaped restrainer conveyor and stunned with a manually applied head-to-body electrical stunner. RESULTS: Percentage of pigs that had blinking after stunning ranged from 0.5 to 7. None of the pigs had a righting reflex or kicked in response to stimuli. All signs of possible return to sensibility disappeared before bleeding pigs reached the scalding tub. Spontaneous eye blinking was eliminated by improving bleeding practices to increase blood flow, ergonomically redesigning the stunner operator's work station to make correct placement of the stunner easier, redesigning the head electrode to facilitate correct placement, reducing line speed from 1,200 to 1,080 head/h, correcting problems with poor initial contact of the stunner, and increasing amperage of a stunner that was set too low for sows. In 1 plant, a fatigued operator was the cause of stunner placement mistakes that resulted in signs of returning to sensibility. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Problems with electrical stunning can be easily corrected, but effective stunning requires monitoring of correct electrode placement, amperage, and bleeding procedures. Observation of spontaneous natural eye blinking without touching the eye is recommended for use under field conditions, because it is less prone to misinterpretation than are other methods.     

Electrical stunning of red deer (Cervus elaphus)

Eighteen of 23 red deer (Cervus elaphus) at a deer slaughtering premises were successfully stunned with an apparatus modified from that normally used to stun sheep. The five unsuccessful electrical stuns were associated with poor head restraint and poor head contact by the electrodes. The median stunning current was 0.9 A, and in the majority of cases the duration of stunning was less than 1 second. The signs of the electrically induced epileptiform seizures in the deer were dissimilar to those seen in sheep, cattle and pigs, in that the initial tonic phase was less marked, and of shorter duration. A similar shorter and less obvious tonic phase was noted in four deer shot with a captive bolt pistol. Two animals which were electrically stunned, and bled within 10 seconds, showed no signs of recovery while bleeding. The electroencephalograms of four deer stunned with currents of 1.3 A for a duration of either 0.5 or 1.0 seconds were recorded under more controlled conditions. All four animals developed electroencephalograms typical of an epileptiform seizure. The animals exhibited behavioural reactions similar to the other 18 animals in the trial at the deer slaughtering premises and were rendered unconscious for between 54 and 122 seconds. The electroencephalogram activity amplitude was greater than that recorded immediately before stunning and took between 6 and 9 seconds to build up to maximum value. It is concluded that, providing the heads of deer are adequately restrained, head-only electrical stunning can be incorporated into a humane method of slaughter for deer.     

Electrical stunning of cattle--experiences in New Zealand

Ever since the middle of the nineteen-eighties electrical stunning of cattle is used in industrial slaughter plants in New Zealand. Today electrical stun boxes operate in export slaughter plants throughout New Zealand. The reversible stun is utilised on the vast majority of slaughtered cattle. The electrical stunning (head only) immediately followed by bleeding is an alternative to ritual slaughter without prior stunning. Throughout the world's islamic community this alternative is widely accepted as Halal.     

Use of 'thoracic stick' in halal slaughter of bobby calves

Throat cutting associated with halal slaughter of bobby calves fails to sever the vertebral arteries supplying the brain. Such slaughter may be inhumane due to calves recovering from the stun before permanent insensibility, due to blood loss, occurs. Interruption of the vertebral arteries may be achieved by severance of the brachiocephalic trunk or penetration of the heart by the use of a 'thoracic stick', an incision with a knife through the thoracic inlet.     

Slaughter methods: electroencephalographic (EEG) studies on spinal cord section, decapitation and gross trauma of the brain in lambs

By means of electroencephalograms (EEG), attempts were made to determine when insensibility could be presumed in five lambs, two subjected to immobilisation by the punctilla method, two decapitated and one shot by a captive bolt in the poll region. Section of approximately 80% of the spinal cord by the punctilla method had no apparent effect on sensibility and the technique was considered to be inhumane. The EEG obtained from a decapitated bead showed no obvious change in pattern for eight seconds and subsequent changes were similar to those associated with exsanguination only. Thus no evidence was obtained to indicate that decapitation causes immediate insensibility, neither was the belief substantiated that severance of the spinal cord, during the slaughter of sheep, hastens the onset of insensibility. These results also provide additional evidence on the inhumane nature of punctilla slaughter of cattle. The animal shot with a captive bolt in the poll region, as opposed to the frontal region, showed EEG activity for 78 seconds.     

Use of ‘thoracic stick’ in halal slaughter of bobby calves

Throat cutting associated with halal slaughter of bobby calves fails to sever the vertebral arteries supplying the brain. Such slaughter may be inhumane due to calves recovering from the stun before permanent insensibility, due to blood loss, occurs. Interruption of the vertebral arteries may be achieved by severance of the brachiocephalic trunk or penetration of the heart by the use of a ‘thoracic stick’, an incision with a knife through the thoracic inlet.