Human immunoglobulin E (IgE) binding to heated and glycated ovalbumin and ovomucoid before and after in vitro digestion

This study focuses on the effect of heating and Maillard reaction (MR) on the in vitro digestibility and rabbit IgG- and human IgE-binding properties of ovalbumin (OVA) and ovomucoid (OM) to estimate the impact of processing on their allergenicity. With the human sera studied, heat treatment significantly reduced IgE binding to both OVA and OM, whereas MR reduced the IgE binding to OVA but increased IgE binding to OM. In contrast, heat treatment significantly favored OVA digestibility but glycation impaired it, and these treatments did not affect the digestibility of OM. The changes observed in the digestibility affected the immunogenicity of the digests accordingly, so that the higher the digestibility, the lower the antibody binding. Heat treatment and glycation by MR showed an influence on the potential allergenicity of the main egg white proteins that could be related to their resistance to denaturation and digestive enzymes.     

Allergenicity of Maillard reaction products from peanut proteins

It is known that peanut allergy is caused by peanut proteins. However, little is known about the impact of roasting on the allergenicity of peanuts. During roasting, proteins react with sugars to form Maillard reaction products, which could affect allergenicity. To determine if the Maillard reaction could convert a nonallergenic peanut protein into a potentially allergenic product, nonallergenic lectin was reacted with glucose or fructose at 50 degrees C for 28 days. Browning products from heat-treated peanuts were also examined. The products were analyzed in immunoblot and competitive assays, using a pooled serum (i.e., IgE antibodies) from patients with peanut anaphylaxis. Results showed that the products were recognized by IgE and had an inhibitory effect on IgE binding to a peanut allergen. Thus, the findings suggest that these Maillard reaction products are potentially allergenic and indicate the need to verify whether the Maillard reaction products formed in peanuts during roasting increase their allergenicity.     

Conjugates of bovine serum albumin with chitin oligosaccharides prepared through the Maillard reaction

Chitin neoglycoconjugates (BSA-CO) were obtained by the conjugation of bovine serum albumin (BSA) with chitin oligosaccharides (CO) through the Maillard reaction (nonenzymatic glycation). CO produced by acid hydrolysis of chitin were fractionated using an ultrafiltration membrane system (1-3 kDa cutoff). The Maillard reaction was carried out by heating a freeze-dried mixture containing BSA and CO at 60 °C (under 43% relative humidity for 6 and 12 h). BSA-CO were characterized by available amino groups content, intrinsic tryptophan emission spectra, gel electrophoresis, and mass spectrometry. Biological assays included interaction with wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) and with bacterial adhesins of Escherichia coli K88+ and Salmonella choleraesuis. Glycation of BSA was revealed by reduction of available amino groups and fluorescence intensity and also retarded migration through SDS-PAGE. Conjugation of BSA with chitin oligomers appeared to be time dependent and was confirmed by mass spectrometry, by which molecular mass increase for monomers and dimers was observed. Monomers were estimated to contain either one or two glycation sites (at 6 and 12 h of treatment, respectively), with one or two tetrasaccharide units attached. Consequently, dimers showed two or four glycation sites. BSA-CO presented biological recognition by WGA and E. coli K88+ and S. cholerasuis adhesins. The strategy used in this work represents a simple method to obtain glycoconjugates to study applications involving protein-carbohydrate recognition.     

Influence of the maillard reaction on the allergenicity of rAra h 2, a recombinant major allergen from peanut (Arachis hypogaea), its major epitopes, and peanut agglutinin

The influence of thermal processing and nonenzymatic browning reactions on the IgE-binding activity of rAra h 2 was studied and compared to findings recently reported for the allergen's natural counterpart. ELISA experiments as well as inhibition assays revealed that thermal treatment of rAra h 2 in the presence of reactive carbohydrates and carbohydrate breakdown products induces a strong increase of the IgE-binding activity, thus collaborating with the data reported for the natural protein isolated from peanuts. To localize the Ara h 2 sequences responsible for the formation of highly IgE-affine glycation sites, model peptides have been synthesized mimicking sequences which contain possible targets for glycation as well as the immunodominant epitopes. Immunological evaluation of these peptides heated in the absence or presence of reducing sugars and carbonyls, respectively, revealed that neither the two lysine residues of Ara h 2 nor its N-terminus are involved in the formation of IgE-affine structures by Maillard reaction. Also, the cysteine-containing major epitope 3 (aa 27-36) was found to lose its IgE-binding capacity upon heating. By contrast, the overlapping major epitopes 6 and 7, which do not contain any lysine or arginine moieties, showed a distinct higher level of IgE binding when subjected to Maillard reaction, thus giving the first evidence that nonbasic amino acids might be accessible for nonenzymatic glycation reactions and that these posttranslational modifications might induce increased IgE binding of the glycated Ara h 2. Analogous experiments were performed with peanut agglutinin, considered in the literature as a minor allergen. ELISA experiments revealed that the majority of tested sera samples from peanut-sensitive patients showed a high level of IgE binding to the lectin even after heat treatment. In contradiction to published data, nonenzymatic browning reactions seem to deteriorate the IgE affinity of the lectin.     

Antioxidant properties and metal chelating activity of glucose-lysine heated mixtures: relationships with mineral absorption across Caco-2 cell monolayers

Model Maillard reaction products were generated by heating glucose-lysine mixtures (GL) at 150 degrees C for different times (15, 30, 60, and 90 min). Samples were characterized by free lysine, browning, and UV-visible spectra and assessed for antioxidant properties, metal chelating ability, and effects on mineral absorption across Caco-2 monolayers. It was found that the capacity to retard lipid peroxidation in a model linoleic acid emulsion system increased with heating time up to 60 min and then leveled off, whereas the scavenging activity toward 1,1-diphenyl-2-picryl-hydrazyl (DPPH) radicals increased in early periods of the reaction (15 and 30 min of heating) and decreased thereafter. The iron binding affinity of the different samples was not correlated with antioxidant properties, and iron transport in Caco-2 cells was unchanged between samples. On the contrary, copper chelating activity showed significant correlation with free radical scavenging activity and with copper absorption across intestinal cells. It can be concluded that severe heat treatment of GL mixtures maintained the ability to reduce lipid peroxidation but decreased the free radical scavenging activity. Moreover, antiradical activity, copper chelation ability, and positive effects on copper absorption were correlated and associated to compounds formed at early stages of the Maillard reaction.     

Reactivities of D-glucose and D-fructose during glycation of bovine serum albumin.

Glycation of bovine serum albumin by D-glucose and D-fructose under dry-heating conditions was studied. The reactivities of D-glucose and D-fructose, with respect to their ability to utilize primary amino groups of proteins, to cross-link proteins, to develop Maillard fluorescence, and to reduce protein solubility in the presence and absence of air (molecular oxygen) were investigated. D-Glucose showed a higher initial rate of utilization of primary amino groups than D-fructose, both in the presence and in the absence of oxygen. Subsequent reactions of the Amadori and Heyns rearrangement products, cross-linking, development of Maillard fluorescence, oxidation, and fragmentation, indicated that the alpha-hydroxy carbonyl group of Amadori products is more reactive than the aldehydo group of Heyns products. D-Fructose showed a greater sensitivity than D-glucose toward the presence of oxygen at the initial stages of the Maillard reaction. The presence or absence of oxygen in the glycation mixture did not seem to have an influence on the nature of products generated in the glycation mixtures during the advanced stages of the Maillard reaction.     

Antioxidant properties of malt model systems

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of kilning and roasting temperatures on antioxidant activity of malt model systems prepared from combinations of glucose, proline, and ferulic acid. Model systems (initial a(w) = 0.09, 6% moisture) were heated at 60 degrees C for up to 24 h, at 90 degrees C for up to 120 min, and at 220 degrees C for up to 15 min. The antioxidant activity of the glucose-proline-ferulic acid model system increased significantly on heating at 60 degrees C for 24 h or at 90 degrees C for 120 min. In contrast, the glucose-proline, ferulic acid-glucose, and ferulic acid-proline systems presented either nonsignificantly increased or unchanged antioxidant activity. The antioxidant activity of both the glucose-proline-ferulic acid and glucose-proline model systems increased significantly after heating at 220 degrees C for 10 min, followed by a significant decrease at 15 min. The data suggest that (1) at 60 degrees C, ferulic acid reacts with Maillard reaction products, resulting in a significant increase in antioxidant activity; (2) at 90 degrees C, the antioxidant activity of the glucose-proline-ferulic system comes from both ferulic acid and Maillard reaction products; and (3) at 220 degrees C, the major contributors to antioxidant activity in glucose-proline-ferulic acid and glucose-proline systems are glucose-proline reaction products.     

Linking peanut allergenicity to the processes of maturation,curing, and roasting

The processes of peanut maturation, curing, and roasting are known to have an important role in peanut flavors. One of these processes (i.e., roasting) has been found to have an effect on allergenicity. To determine if the other processes (i.e., maturation and curing) affect allergenicity, mature and immature roasted peanuts and peanuts cured at different temperatures (35-77 degrees C) were, respectively, tested for IgE binding and advanced glycation end adducts (AGEs). Peanuts with and without stress proteins, which are associated with peanut maturation and curing, were also tested. Results showed that mature roasted peanuts exhibited a higher IgE binding and AGEs level than immature roasted peanuts. Curing temperatures between 35 and 60 degrees C gave no difference in the profiles. However, a higher curing temperature (i.e., 77 degrees C) exhibited a profile of higher levels of AGEs and IgE binding. These levels were higher in peanuts with stress proteins than without stress proteins. Roasting increased stress protein level and IgE binding. From these results, the processes of maturation and curing, in conjunction with roasting, may be associated with allergenicity, suggesting that these processes may lead to changes in the allergenic properties of peanuts.     

Structural characterization of bovine beta-lactoglobulin-galactose/tagatose Maillard complexes by electrophoretic, chromatographic, and spectroscopic methods

To investigate the influence of the type of carbonyl group of the sugar on the structural changes of proteins during glycation, an exhaustive structural characterization of glycated beta-lactoglobulin with galactose (aldose) and tagatose (ketose) has been carried out. Conjugates were prepared via Maillard reaction at 40 and 50 degrees C, pH 7, and a w = 0.44. The progress of the Maillard reaction was followed by indirect formation of Amadori and Heyns compounds, advanced glycation end products, and brown polymers. The structural characterization of glycoconjugates was conducted by using a number of analytical techniques such as RP-HPLC, isoelectric focusing, MALDI-ToF, SDS-PAGE, size exclusion chromatography, and spectrofluorimetry (tryptophan fluorescence). In addition, the surface hydrophobicity of the beta-lactoglobulin glycoconjugates was also assessed. The results showed a higher reactivity of galactose than tagatose to form the glycoconjugates, probably due to the higher electrophilicity of the aldehyde group. At 40 degrees C, more aggregation was produced when beta-lactoglobulin was conjugated with tagatose as compared to galactose. However, at 50 degrees C hardly any difference was observed in the aggregation produced by galactose and tagatose. These results afford more insight into the importance of the functional group of the carbohydrate moiety during the formation of protein-carbohydrate conjugates via Maillard reaction.     

Chemical and antioxidant properties of casein peptide and its glucose Maillard reaction products in fish oil-in-water emulsions

Maillard reaction products (MRPs) were prepared by reacting casein peptides with different concentrations of glucose at 80 °C for up to 12 h. The chemical properties of MRPs and their effects on lipid oxidation in fish oil-in-water emulsions were investigated. Increasing browning development and absorbance in 294 nm in the MRPs caused an increase in DPPH radical scavenging, but a decrease in iron chelation, which could be related to the loss of free amino groups in the peptides. The MRPs produced with longer reaction time or higher glucose concentrations were less effective in inhibiting lipid oxidation in emulsions at pH 7.0 compared to casein peptides alone. However, the antioxidant activity of MRPs in emulsions at pH 3.0 was not decreased by prolonged heating. The bitterness of MRPs was less than that of the original casein peptides, and bitterness decreased with increasing heating time and glucose concentrations. Therefore, the Maillard reaction was a potential method to reduce the bitterness of casein peptides while not strongly decreasing their antioxidant activity.     

Functional improvements in dried egg white through the Maillard reaction.

The effects of the Maillard reaction on the functional properties of dried egg white (DEW) were investigated. Maillard-reacted DEW (M-DEW) was prepared by storing sugar-preserved DEW (SP-DEW) at 55 degrees C and 35% relative humidity for 0-12 days. The M-DEW developed an excellent gelling property, and hydrogen sulfide production from heat-induced M-DEW gels decreased. Surface sulfhydryl (SH) group content of M-DEW increased while total SH group and alpha-helix contents decreased with increasing heating time in the dry state. Breaking strength, breaking strain, water-holding capacity, and hydrogen sulfide of heat-induced M-DEW gels significantly correlated with surface and total SH group contents in M-DEW. SDS-PAGE revealed that M-DEW proteins were polymerized in which covalent bonds were involved. The present study demonstrated that the Maillard reaction partially unfolds and polymerizes proteins of SP-DEW and, consequently, improved gelling property of SP-DEW under certain controlled conditions.     

Identification and site-specific relative quantification of beta-lactoglobulin modifications in heated milk and dairy products

During milk processing, proteins can be severely modified by oxidation, condensation, and Maillard reaction, leading to changes in their nutritional and technological properties. In this study, major modifications of beta-lactoglobulin, formed during the heating and processing of milk, were screened by mass spectrometry. For this purpose, beta-lactoglobulin was isolated from the milk samples by gel electrophoresis and analyzed by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry after in-gel digestion with endoproteinase AspN. In heated milk, lactulosyllysine was detected at lysine 47 and 138 or 141 as well as methionine sulfoxide at methionine 7, 24, and 145. All these modifications increased gradually when raw milk was heated for 20, 40, and 60 min at 120 degrees C. The major modifications were also relatively quantified in dairy products, such as raw, high-temperature, ultra-high-temperature, sterilized, and condensed milk as well as infant formulas. The highest contents of lactulosyllysine at Lys47 were detected in powdered infant formulas, whereas lactulosyllysine at Lys138/141 was predominant in condensed milk samples. Methionine sulfoxide at Met7 and Met24 showed a trend toward higher modification rates in more severely processed products.     

Stability of barley and malt lipid transfer protein 1 (LTP1) toward heating and reducing agents: relationships with the brewing process

Barley lipid transfer protein (LTP1) is a heat-stable and protease-resistant albumin that concentrates in beer, where it participates in the formation and stability of beer foam. Whereas the barley LTP1 does not display any foaming properties, the corresponding beer protein is surface-active. Such an improvement is related to glycation by Maillard reactions on malting, acylation on mashing, and structural unfolding on brewing. The structural stability of purified barley and glycated malt LTP1 toward heating has been analyzed. Whatever the modification, lipid adduction or glycation, barley LTP1s are highly stable proteins that resisted temperatures up to 100 degrees C. Unfolding of LTP1 occurred only when heating was conducted in the presence of a reducing agent. In the presence of sodium sulfite, the lipid-adducted barley and malt LTP1 displayed higher heat stability than the nonadducted protein. Glycation had no or weak effect on heat-induced unfolding. Finally, it was shown that unfolding occurred on wort boiling before fermentation and that the reducing conditions are provided by malt extract.     

Improvement of gel properties of dried egg white by modification with galactomannan through the Maillard reaction

The effects of Maillard reaction on gel properties of dried egg white (DEW) with galactomannan (GM) were investigated. Maillard-reacted DEW (MDEW) was prepared by dry-heating a mixture with a weight ratio of 1:4 of GM to DEW at 60 degrees C and 65% relative humidity. The modification of amino groups and polymerization of DEW proteins dry-heated with GM proceeded with increasing the dry-heating time. The covalent attachment of GM to DEW was confirmed from SDS-PAGE analysis. Gel strength and water-holding capacity of MDEW gels were higher than those of DEW dry-heated without GM (control DEW) and reached maximum after 3 days of dry-heating. The appearance of MDEW gels became transparent with increasing the dry-heating time, but control DEW gels were still turbid. MDEW dry-heated for 3 days was almost soluble even after heating of its solution at 90 degrees C, whereas control DEW proteins precipitated. The modification of DEW with GM through the Maillard reaction was an effective method to make a firm and transparent gel from DEW at broader range of pH and NaCl concentration of the medium.     

Comparative studies on antigenicity and allergenicity of native and denatured egg white proteins

The binding activities of IgG and IgE antibodies from egg-allergic patients to physically or chemically treated egg white proteins were examined and compared with those of rabbit anti-egg white IgG antibodies. The sera from eight patients and four rabbit antibodies were used in this study. The binding activities of human IgG antibody to partially denatured ovotransferrin (Tf), ovalbumin (OA), and lysozyme (Lys) forms were increased, whereas carboxymethylation (RCM) and heat treatment caused a dramatic decrease in the antigenicity of Tf and ovomucoid (OVM). Tf and OVM were major immunogenic antigens for the rabbit IgG response. Urea also caused Tf to exhibit greater rabbit IgG binding activity. In contrast, human and rabbit antibodies did not react with ovomucin. Partially denatured Tf and Lys also induced strong IgE binding activities. The allergenicity of Tf, OVM, and Lys was decreased by RCM, whereas OA retained its binding capacity. These results suggested that anti-OA IgE recognizes more sequential epitopes and that anti-OVM and Lys antibodies recognize both conformational and sequential epitopes. Tf and OVM were dominant allergens for the IgE antibodies of anaphylaxis patients, whereas IgE from atopic patients bound more strongly with OA and OVM.     

Relative quantification of N(epsilon)-(Carboxymethyl)lysine,imidazolone A,and the Amadori product in glycated lysozyme by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry

The nonenzymatic glycation of proteins by reducing sugars, also known as the Maillard reaction, has received increasing recognition from nutritional science and medical research. In this study, we applied matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) to perform relative and simultaneous quantification of the Amadori product, which is an early glycation product, and of N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine and imidazolone A, two important advanced glycation end products. Therefore, native lysozyme was incubated with d-glucose for increasing periods of time (1, 4, 8, and 16 weeks) in phosphate-buffered saline pH 7.8 at 50 degrees C. After enzymatic digestion with endoproteinase Glu-C, the N-terminal peptide fragment (m/z 838; amino acid sequence KVFGRCE) and the C-terminal peptide fragment (m/z 1202; amino acid sequence VQAWIRGCRL) were used for relative quantification of the three Maillard products. Amadori product, N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine, and imidazolone A were the main glycation products formed under these conditions. Their formation was dependent on glucose concentration and reaction time. The kinetics were similar to those obtained by competitive ELISA, an established method for quantification of N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine and imidazolone A. Inhibition experiments showed that coincubation with N(alpha)-acetylargine suppressed formation of imidazolone A but not of the Amadori product or N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine. The presence of N(alpha)-acetyllysine resulted in the inhibition of lysine modifications but in higher concentrations of imidazolone A. o-Phenylenediamine decreased the yield of the Amadori product and completely inhibited the formation of N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine and imidazolone A. MALDI-TOF-MS proved to be a new analytical tool for the simultaneous, relative quantification of specific products of the Maillard reaction. For the first time, kinetic data of defined products on specific sites of glycated protein could be measured. This characterizes MALDI-TOF-MS as a valuable method for monitoring the Maillard reaction in the course of food processing.     

Qualitative determination of specific protein glycation products by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry Peptide mapping

The nonenzymatic reaction between reducing sugars and proteins, known as the Maillard reaction, has received increased recognition from nutritional science and medical research. The development of new analytical techniques for the detection of protein-bound Maillard products is therefore crucial. In this study, we applied peptide mapping by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry to investigate the formation of structurally specific Maillard products on glycated lysozyme (AGE-lysozyme), produced upon incubation with D-glucose. In parallel, we synthesized N(epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine-modified lysozyme (CML-lysozyme) and N(epsilon)-(carboxyethyl)lysine-modified lysozyme, two well-described glycation products, as model substances. 3-Deoxyglucosone-modified lysozyme and methylglyoxal-modified lysozyme were prepared as examples of glycation products incubated with dicarbonyl compounds. We were able to detect specific modifications on AGE-lysozyme, which were assigned to CML, imidazolone A, and the Amadori product.     

Conjugation of bovine serum albumin and glucose under combined high pressure and heat

The effect of combined heat and pressure on the Maillard reaction between bovine serum albumin (BSA) and glucose was investigated. The effects in the range of 60-132 °C and at 0.1-600 MPa on the lysine availability of BSA were investigated at isothermal/isobaric conditions. The kinetic results showed that the protein-sugar conjugation rate increased with increasing temperature, whereas it decreased with increasing pressure. The reaction followed 1.4th order kinetics at most conditions investigated. A mathematical model describing BSA-glucose conjugation kinetics as a function of pressure and temperature is proposed. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry were used to verify BSA-glucose conjugation and to identify the glucosylated sites. These indicated that the application of combined high pressure and high temperature resulted in significant differences in the progression of the Maillard reaction as compared to heat treatments at atmospheric pressure.     

Redox-related cytotoxic responses to different casein glycation products in Caco-2 and int-407 cells

Sugar-casein glycation products (GPs) were generated by Maillard reaction (MR) with different monosaccharide sources [e.g., glucose (Glc), fructose (Fru), and ribose (Rib)] and prolonged heating (e.g., 27 days at 55 degrees C) to produce Maillard reaction products (MRPs) that varied in opponent (L, a, b) color measurement and changes in pH, available lysine, and amino-sugar ratio. Theses results signified different rates of three sugar and casein glycation. Sugar-casein GPs from aldohexose, ketohexose, and aldopentose sugar sources were recovered on day 18 of heating and compared for bioactive properties using human embryonic intestinal cell (Int-407) and adenocarcinoma cell (Caco-2) lines. Glu- and Fru-casein GPs produced significant (p < 0.05) decreases in antioxidant superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase, and glutathione reductase enzyme activities in the Int-407 cell line, whereas no effect on antioxidant enzymes was obtained from Rib-casein GP. Moreover, the Caco-2 cell antioxidant enzyme status was not affected by the presence of sugar-casein GPs, regardless of sugar source. The reduction in antioxidant enzyme activity of Int-407 cells by Glu and Fru- casein GPs corresponded to a significant (p < 0.05) reduction in Int-407 cell viability. In contrast, no change in Caco-2 cell viability was observed with sugar-casein GP. This finding demonstrates that the noted variable cytotoxic, sugar specific effects of casein GP were related to reductions in critical antioxidant enzyme activities. Moreover, the source of intestinal cell line was an important factor to show the effect of sugar-casein GPs on redox-related cytotoxicity.     

Analysis of glycated and ascorbylated proteins by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry

Proteins or poly-L-lysine which were incubated in the presence of ascorbic acid, dehydroascorbic acid (ascorbylation), or various sugars (glycation) were analyzed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). To also detect more labile reaction products, the Maillard modified proteins or poly-L-lysine were enzymatically hydrolyzed and reacted with N-methyl-N-(tert-butyldimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide to form the N(O)-tert-butyldimethylsilyl (tBDMS) derivatives prior to GC analysis. Under these conditions, the known Maillard products N (epsilon)-(carboxymethyl)lysine (1), oxalic acid mono-N (epsilon)-lysinylamide (2), and N (epsilon)-(carboxyethyl)lysine (3) could be simultaneously detected and quantified in glycated and ascorbylated proteins. Additionally, N (epsilon)-(1-carboxy-3-hydroxypropyl)-L-lysine (4) was identified for the first time as a Maillard product of proteins. Under the conditions applied here, 4 was found only in ascorbylated proteins or poly-L-lysine, but not in glycated proteins. Maillard-modified poly-L-lysine was further subjected to high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis after enzymatic hydrolysis and formation of the phenyl isothiocyanate derivatized amino acids. Using this method, N (epsilon)-formyl-L-lysine (5), which cannot be distinguished from 2 by GC-MS analysis, was identified for the first time as a glycation product. Compound 5 is mainly formed from ribose, lactose, and fructose. The indicated Maillard products were quantified in beta-lactoglobulin (GC-MS) or poly-L-lysine (HPLC) which were glycated or ascorbylated using different precursors.