Assessment of spatial variability in nitrate leaching to reduce nitrogen fertilizers impact on water quality

Nitrogen leaching has caused a growing societal concern over N fertilizer impact on water quality. One way to decrease nitrogen loss through leaching is to adjust fertilizer inputs to site-specific conditions. This study was conducted to investigate spatial variability of NO₃ leaching parameters on a 5 ha commercial wheat field (Typic Ustifluent) located 25 km north of Tokat, Turkey, for the purpose of dividing the field into small cells in which application rates can be kept constant. NO₃ leaching parameters were calculated using the monthly analysis version of computer program NLEAP (nitrate leach and economic analysis package) on a regular grid spacing of 25 m, and semi-variogram for each parameter was calculated using the computer program GEAOES. The values for parameter NL (nitrate leached) were between 24.64 (low) and 77.28 kg ha⁻¹ (medium), for NAL (nitrate available for leaching) 42.46 (low) and 274.40 kg ha⁻¹ (high), and for MRI (movement risk index) 0.28 (low) and 0.35 (medium). Values for parameter ALRP (annual leaching risk potential) varied from high (index=4) to moderate (index=3). A moderately significant correlation (r=0.54, P<0.01) was found between measured and model-estimated values for the parameter NAL, indicating that the NLEAP model adequately simulated the NO₃ leaching in the study area. Values for range were 360 m for NAL, 350 m for NL and 180 m for MRI, and nugget effect was 0.72 for MRI, 0.45 for NAL and 0.25 for NL, and mean correlation distances (MCD) were 145 m for NAL and 61 m for NL. Although, the spatial patterns for the parameters NAL and NL were similar, the upper cell limit for parameter NAL was higher than two times that of parameter NL, suggesting that calculation of input for continuous control of nitrogen application rate in a variable rate nitrogen fertilizer application program be based on the spatial pattern of NL but not on that of NAL.     

Estimating potential nitrate leaching in nitrogen fertilized and irrigated tomato using the computer model NLEAP

Groundwater pollution caused by leaching of NO₃-N from agricultural systems has caused public concern for decades. To preserve the groundwater and reduce economic losses for the farmers, a rapid and accurate estimation of NO₃-N moving below the root zone is crucial. In this study, the value of the computer program NLEAP (Nitrate Leaching and Economic Analysis Package) to simulate nitrate leaching was evaluated using data from an experiment conducted with 12 lysimeters (1.25 m i.d. and 2 m deep) in 1996 and 1997. Three tomato (H2274 variety) seedlings were planted in each lysimeter and nitrogen rates of 0, 80, 160, and 240 kg N ha⁻¹, as ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulphate, were applied to the lysimeters under a fixed irrigation program. Effluent was collected from the outlets of the lysimeters and analyzed for NO₃. The model adequately simulated nitrogen leaching for each year (R²=0.93 and P<0.03 for 1996, and R²=0.87 and P<0.06 for 1997). The high coefficients of determination, between observed and simulated values, revealed that the model can be successfully used to estimate the amount of the NO₃ leaching under the experimental conditions. The results also showed that the NO₃ available for leaching (NAL) values were important background information for determining an optimum N rate for groundwater quality and maximum gain, and NO₃ available for leaching (NAL), amount of NO₃ leached (NL), movement risk index (MRI), and annual leaching risk potential (ALRP) parameters should be considered together to estimate the nitrogen pollution risk.     

Water and nitrate movement in drip-irrigated onion under fertigation and irrigation treatments

Frequent fertigation of crops is often advocated in the technical and popular literature, but there is limited evidence of the benefits of high-frequency fertigation. Field experiments were conducted on an Indo-American Hybrid var., Creole Red, of onion crop during three winter seasons of 1999–2000 through 2001–2002 in coarse-textured soil of Delhi under the semi-arid region of India. Three irrigation levels of 60, 80 and 100% of the crop evapotranspiration (ET) and four fertigation frequencies of daily, alternate day, weekly and monthly comprised the fertigation treatment. Analysis of soil samples indicated considerable influence of fertigation frequency on NO₃-N distribution in soil profile. NO₃-N in lower soil profiles (30.0–60.0 cm soil depth) was marginally affected in daily, alternate day and weekly fertigation. However, fluctuations of NO₃-N content in 0.0–15.0, 15.0–30.0, 30.0–45.0 and 45.0–60.0 cm soil depth was more in monthly fertigation frequency. The level of soil NO₃-N after the crop season shows that more NO₃-N leached through the soil profile in monthly fertigation frequency. Amounts of irrigation water applied in three irrigation treatments proved to be too small to cause significant differences in the content of NO₃-N leached beyond rooting depth of onion. Yield of onion was not significantly affected in daily, alternate day and weekly fertigation, though there was a trend of lower yields with monthly fertigation. The highest yield was recorded in daily fertigation (28.74 t ha⁻¹) followed by alternate day fertigation (28.4 t ha⁻¹). Lowest yield was recorded in monthly fertigation frequency (21.4 t ha⁻¹). Application of 56.4 cm irrigation water and 3.4 kg ha⁻¹ urea per fertigation (daily) resulted in highest yield of onion with less leaching of NO₃-N.     

Trickle and sprinkler irrigation of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) in the Middle Anatolian Region in Turkey

The potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) is widely planted in the Middle Anatolian Region, especially in the Nigde-Nevsehir district where 25% of the total potato growing area is located and produces 44% of the total yield. In recent years, the farmers in the Nigde-Nevsehir district have been applying high amounts of nitrogen (N) fertilizers (sometimes more than 900 kg N ha⁻¹) and frequent irrigation at high rates in order to get a much higher yield. This situation results in increased irrigation and fertilization costs as well as polluted ground water resources and soil. Thus, it is critical to know the water and nitrogen requirements of the crop, as well as how to improve irrigation efficiency. Field experiments were conducted in the Nigde-Nevsehir (arid) region on a Fluvents (Entisols) soil to determine water and nitrogen requirements of potato crops under sprinkler and trickle irrigation methods. Irrigation treatments were based on Class A pan evaporation and nitrogen levels were formed with different nitrogen concentrations.The highest yield, averaging 47,505 kg ha⁻¹, was measured in sprinkler-irrigated plots at the 60 g m⁻³ nitrogen concentration level in the irrigation treatment with limited irrigation (480 mm). Statistically higher tuber yields were obtained at the 45 and 60 g m⁻³ nitrogen concentration levels in irrigation treatments with full and limited irrigation. Maximum yields were obtained with about 17% less water in the sprinkler method as compared to the trickle method (not statistically significant). On the loam and sandy loam soils, tuber yields were reduced by deficit irrigation corresponding to 70% and 74% of evapotranspiration in sprinkler and trickle irrigations, respectively. Water use of the potato crop ranged from 490 to 760 mm for sprinkler-irrigated plots and 565–830 mm for trickle-irrigated treatments. The highest water use efficiency (WUE) levels of 7.37 and 4.79 kg m⁻³ were obtained in sprinkle and trickle irrigated plots, respectively. There were inverse effects of irrigation and nitrogen levels on the WUE of the potato crops. Significant linear relationships were found between tuber yield and water use for both irrigation methods. Yield response factors were calculated at 1.05 for sprinkler methods and 0.68 for trickle methods. There were statistically significant linear and polynomial relationships between tuber yield and nitrogen amounts used in trickle and sprinkler-irrigated treatments, respectively. In sprinkler-irrigated treatments, the maximum tuber yield was obtained with 199 kg N ha⁻¹. The tuber cumulative nitrogen use efficiency (NUE_cu) and incremental nitrogen use efficiency (NUE_in) were affected quite differently by water, nitrogen levels and years. NUE_cu varied from 16 to 472 g kg⁻¹ and NUE_in varied from 75 to 1035 g kg⁻¹ depending on the irrigation method. In both years, the NH₄-N concentrations were lower than NO₃-N, and thus the removed nitrogen and nitrogen losses were found to be 19–87 kg ha⁻¹ for sprinkler methods and 25–89 kg ha⁻¹ for trickle methods. Nitrogen losses in sprinkler methods reached 76%, which were higher than losses in trickle methods.     

Modelling optimal strategies for decreasing nitrate loss with variation in weather – a farm-level approach

A farm-level framework for assessing the economic impact of measures to reduce nitrate loss by leaching is described. The framework links a database of crop treatments and nitrogen loss generated with the IACR SUNDIAL model for 10 years of weather and an economic model, Farm-adapt, for a root-cropping farm on sandy loam in the East Midlands of England. Weather induced variation in nitrate loss over time was greater than that resulting from differences in management practice. Limits on nitrate loss per hectare resulted in a relatively small annual mean cost to the farm when allowed to choose the optimal management practice (including doing nothing) in each year (e.g. £8 ha⁻¹ for a 30 kg ha⁻¹ limit, resulting in a 6.2 kg ha⁻¹ and 3.2 mg l⁻¹ reduction in mean nitrate-N loss and mean nitrate-N concentration, respectively). In no years was it feasible with the treatments tested to reduce concentration of nitrate-N to the EU limit of 11.3 mg l⁻¹ in every week of the year. A mean annual loss of 11.3 mg l⁻¹ was feasible in four out of 10 years at a mean cost of £10 ha⁻¹. The most cost-effective reductions of loss (in terms of £ kg⁻¹ nitrate-N ha⁻¹) were achieved by targeted reductions in N application followed by a combination of reduced N and growing winter cover before spring crops. Untargeted limits (quotas) on nitrogen, nitrogen taxes and application of single management practices were less cost effective than combinations of practices. Three management strategies, based on these combinations, were imposed for all years. Mean costs were greater than where the farm could choose the optimal management practice in each year; a 4.67 mg l⁻¹ reduction in nitrate-N concentration cost £19 ha⁻¹ and a 5.88 mg l⁻¹ reduction £33 ha⁻¹.     

Soil N and salinity leaching after the autumn irrigation and its impact on groundwater in Hetao Irrigation District,China

Soil water and salinity are crucial factors influencing crop production in arid regions. An autumn irrigation system employing the application of a large volume of water (2200–2600 m³ ha⁻¹) is being developed in the Hetao Irrigation District of China, since the 1980s with the goal to reduce salinity levels in the root zone and increase the water availability for the following spring crops. However, the autumn irrigation can cause significant quantities of NO₃⁻ to leach from the plant root zone into the groundwater. In this study, we investigated the changes in soil water content, NO₃–N and salinity within a 150 cm deep soil profile in four different types of farmlands: spring wheat (F_W), maize (F_M), spring wheat–maize inter-planting (F_W–M) and sunflower (F_S). Our results showed that (1) salt losses mainly occurred in the upper 60 cm of the soil and in the upper 40 cm for NO₃–N; (2) the highest losses of salt and NO₃–N could be observed in F_W, whereas the lowest losses were found in F_W–M.NO₃–N concentration, pH and electrical conductivity (EC) in the groundwater were also monitored before and after the autumn irrigation. We found that the autumn irrigation caused the groundwater concentration of NO₃–N to increase from 1.73 to 21.6 mg L⁻¹, thereby, exceeding the standards of the World Health Organization (WHO). Our results suggest that extensive development of inter-planting tillage might be a viable measure to reduce groundwater pollution, and that the application of optimized minimum amounts of water and nitrogen to meet realistic yield goals, as well as the timely application of N fertilizers and the use of slow release fertilizers can be viable measures to minimize nitrate leaching.     

Water use and lint yield response of drip irrigated cotton to the length of irrigation season

A 2-year experiment was conducted at Tal Amara Research Station in the Bekaa Valley of Lebanon to determine water use and lint yield response to the length of irrigation season of drip irrigated cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.). Crop evapotranspiration (ET_crop) and reference evapotranspiration (ET_rye-grass) were directly measured at weekly basis during the 2001 growing period using crop and rye-grass drainage lysimeters. Crop coefficients (K_c) in the different growth stages were calculated as ET_crop/ET_rye-grass. Then, the calculated K_c values were used in the 2002 growing period to estimate evapotranspiration of cotton using the FAO method by multiplying the calculated K_c values by ET_rye-grass measured in 2002. The length of irrigation season was determined by terminating irrigation permanently at first open boll (S1), at early boll loading (S2), and at mid boll loading (S3). The three treatments were compared to a well-watered control (C) throughout the growing period. Lint yield was defined as a function of components including plant height at harvest, number of bolls per plant, and percentage of opened bolls per plant.Lysimeter-measured crop evapotranspiration (ET_crop) totaled 642 mm in 2001 for a total growing period of 134 days, while when estimated with the FAO method in 2002 it averaged 669 mm for a total growing period of 141 days from sowing to mature bolls. Average K_c values varied from 0.58 at initial growth stages (sowing to squaring), to 1.10 at mid growth stages (first bloom to first open boll), and 0.83 at late growth stages (early boll loading to mature bolls).Results showed that cotton lint yields were reduced as irrigation amounts increased. Average across years, the S1 treatment produced the highest yield of 639 kg ha⁻¹ from total irrigations of 549 mm, compared to the S2 and S3 treatments, which yielded 577 and 547 kg ha⁻¹ from total irrigations of 633 and 692 mm, respectively, while the control resulted in 457 kg ha⁻¹ of lint yield from 738 mm of irrigation water. Water use efficiency (WUE) was found to be higher in S1 treatment and averaged 1.3 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹, followed by S2 (1.1 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹), and S3 (1.0 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹), while in the control WUE was 0.80 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹. Lint yield was negatively correlated with plant height and the number of bolls per plant and positively correlated with the percentage of opened bolls. This study suggests that terminating irrigation at first open boll stage has been found to provide the highest cotton yield with maximum WUE under the semi-arid conditions of the Bekaa Valley of Lebanon.     

Spatial variability of solutes in a pecan orchard surface-irrigated with untreated effluents in the upper Rio Grande River basin

Untreated effluents are blended with water from the Rio Grande River and used for irrigation in the Juarez Valley of northern Mexico. Effluents are a source of nutrients, but may also be a source of heavy metal contamination. This study was conducted to characterize deposition patterns of selected metals, salts, and total nitrogen in a 6 ha pecan (Carya illinoenisis K.) orchard which had healthy-to-stunted trees with dieback. Orchard soil was collected along multiple transects to depths of 1.2 m, with spacing every 20 m. All solutes showed a magnitude variability in particular ions. Chromium, Ni, Pb, and Cd concentrations averaged <14 mg kg⁻¹. Soil Na, Ca, K, Mg, SO₄, Cl and NO₃–N averaged <100 mg kg⁻¹. Total N was <0.21%. Most solutes accumulated at the soil surface with the exception of Na and SO₄. Linear semi-variograms best described spatial metal deposition and surface clay content with a range of influence >189 m. Spherical semi-variograms best described spatial distribution of salts and total N, but accounted <50% of the variability. The solubility of solutes in moderately alkaline irrigation water and their specific behavior in calcareous soils likely affected deposition patterns. Estimated metal loads from irrigation over a 15-year period were <3 kg ha⁻¹, but about 187 Mg ha⁻¹ for total dissolved solids (salts). Pecan leaf tissue showed no signs of heavy metal accumulation. Suboptimum pecan growth was associated with salt accumulation in a clayey area with low permeability. Salts, in particular Na, rather than metals may be the most important inorganic contaminants for irrigated agriculture in this region. Salt loads in irrigation waters are expected to increase as agriculture increasingly relies on urban effluents too expensive to convert to potable water.     

Fate of gypsum surface — applied to an Appalachian hill pasture watershed

Low pH soils leached with gypsum solutions have been shown to sorb gypsum thereby increasing calcium and improving root growth of some crops. However, in some situations, exchangeable aluminum is leached which could enter waterways and potentially cause adverse off-site impacts. Due to relatively high solubility, gypsum itself has potential to impact stream water chemistry. In this study, 8250 kg ha⁻¹ gypsum was applied to plots in a steep 4.3 ha-pasture watershed in central Appalachia. Changes in the 0–40 cm soil profile and changes in water chemistry at a flume below a seep which drains the watershed were measured in response to this application. After the end of the second growing season, and a total rainfall of 1.7 m, 46% of the applied gypsum calcium was still in the top 40 cm of soil. The rainfall had a 11.4% efficiency rate of transporting gypsum out of the top 40 cm compared to movement of a saturated solution through an inert medium. Of the applied gypsum sulfate, 3.4% exited the watershed through stream flow. Maximum gypsum concentrations in stream flow, which occurred during a storm event, were 34 ppm or <1.5% of saturation levels. No detectable aluminum was measured in stream flow at the flume. These findings indicate that as long as a minor part of watersheds such as this one has gypsum applied at rates less than 10,000 kg ha⁻¹, off-site environment impacts should be minimal.     

Assessment of the effect of tie-ridging on smallholder maize yields in Malawi

Tie-ridging is being promoted in Malawi as an on-field rainwater harvesting technique to ensure a maize (Zea mais L.) crop during a dry or drought year. Resource-poor smallholder farmers are likely to take up tie-ridging if it increases and not decreases maize yield in most years. A numerical study was conducted to calculate the expected maize yield gain due to tie-ridging taking into account the probability of occurrence of drought, dry, normal and wet years (climatic uncertainty). Mean yields due to tie-ridging in drought, dry, normal and wet years at different N levels were derived from observed smallholder maize yield data using a linear nitrogen response model and field-observed retained rainwater amounts in tie-ridged fields. Simulation results indicate that tie-ridging will result in hybrid maize yield gain in a drought year (1050 kg ha⁻¹) and dry year (560 kg ha⁻¹). There will be a hybrid maize yield loss in a normal year (350 kg ha⁻¹) and wet year (700 kg ha⁻¹). For local maize, there will be a yield gain in a drought year (500 kg ha⁻¹), dry year (220 kg ha⁻¹) and normal year (120 kg ha⁻¹). There will be a slight yield loss in a wet year (60 kg ha⁻¹). Considering observed probability of the occurrence of drought, dry, normal and wet years in Malawi, the study reveals that there will be no hybrid maize yield gain in any coming year with tie-ridging. For local maize, the expected yield gain in any coming year was positive (133.3 kg ha⁻¹) but this gain is less than the minimum gain required considering the opportunity cost of labour (142.5 kg ha⁻¹). Thus under the smallholder conditions and climate of Malawi, the expected yield gain in any coming year due to tie-ridging is likely to be minimal and uneconomic.     

Identification of nitrate leaching hot spots in a large area with contrasting soil texture and management

Identification of nitrate (NO₃) leaching hot spots is important in mitigating environmental effect of NO₃. Once identified, the hot spots can be further analyzed in detail for evaluating appropriate alternative management techniques to reduce impact of nitrate on groundwater. This study was conducted to identify NO₃ leaching hot spots in an approximately 36,000 ha area in Serik plain, which is used intensively for agriculture in the Antalya region of Southern Turkey. Geo-referenced water samples were taken from 161 wells and from the representative soils around the wells during the period from late May to early June of 2009. The data were analyzed by classical statistics and geostatistics. Both soil and groundwater NO₃-N concentrations demonstrated a considerably high variation, with a mean of 10.2 mg kg⁻¹ and 2.1 mg L⁻¹ NO₃-N for soil and groundwater, respectively. The NO₃-N concentrations ranged from 0.01 to 102.5 mg L⁻¹ in well waters and from 1.89 to 106.4 mg kg⁻¹ in soils. Nitrate leaching was spatially dependent in the study area. Six hot spots were identified in the plain, and in general, the hot spots coincided with high water table, high sand content, and irrigated wheat and cotton. The adverse effects of NO₃ can be mitigated by switching the surface and furrow irrigation methods to sprinkler irrigation, which results in a more efficient N and water use. Computer models such as NLEAP can be used to analyze alternative management practices together with soil, aquifer, and climate characteristics to determine a set of management alternatives to mitigate NO₃ effect in these hot spot areas.     

The effects of different irrigation regimes on cucumber (Cucumbis sativus L.) yield and yield characteristics under open field conditions

A study was conducted to determine the effects of different drip irrigation regimes on yield and yield components of cucumber (Cucumbis sativus L.) and to determine a threshold value for crop water stress index (CWSI) based on irrigation programming. Four different irrigation treatments as 50 (T-50), 75 (T-75), 100 (T-100) and 125% (T-125) of irrigation water applied/cumulative pan evaporation (IW/CPE) ratio with 3-day-period were studied.Seasonal crop evapotranspiration (ET_c) values were 633, 740, 815 and 903 mm in the 1st year and were 679, 777, 875 and 990 mm in the 2nd year for T-50, T-75, T-100 and T-125, respectively. Seasonal irrigation water amounts were 542, 677, 813 and 949 mm in 2002 and 576, 725, 875 and 1025 mm in 2003, respectively. Maximum marketable fruit yield was from T-100 treatment with 76.65 t ha⁻¹ in 2002 and 68.13 t ha⁻¹ in 2003. Fruit yield was reduced significantly, as irrigation rate was decreased. The water use efficiency (WUE) ranged from 7.37 to 9.40 kg m⁻³ and 6.32 to 7.79 kg m⁻³ in 2002 and 2003, respectively, while irrigation water use efficiencies (IWUE) were between 7.02 and 9.93 kg m⁻³ in 2002 and between 6.11 and 8.82 kg m⁻³ in 2003.When the irrigation rate was decreased, crop transpiration rate decreased as well resulting in increased crop canopy temperatures and CWSI values and resulted in reduced yield. The results indicated that a seasonal mean CWSI value of 0.20 would result in decreased yield. Therefore, a CWSI = 0.20 could be taken as a threshold value to start irrigation for cucumber grown in open field under semi-arid conditions.Results of this study demonstrate that 1.00 IW/CPE water applications by a drip system in a 3-day irrigation frequency would be optimal for growth in semiarid regions.     

Dry-period irrigation and fertilizer application affect water use and yield of spring wheat in semi-arid regions

Based on a field study on the semi-arid Loess Plateau of China, the strategies of limited irrigation in farmland in dry-period of normal-precipitation years are studied, and the effects on water use and grain yield of spring wheat of dry-period irrigation and fertilizer application when sowing are examined. The study includes four treatments: (1) with 90 mm dry-period irrigation but without fertilizer application (W); (2) with fertilizer application but without dry-period irrigation (F); (3) with 90 mm dry-period irrigation plus fertilizer application (WF); (4) without dry-period irrigation and fertilizer application (CK). The results indicate that dry-period irrigation resulted in larger and deeper root systems and larger leaf area index (LAI) compared with the non-irrigated treatments. The root/shoot ratio (R/S) in the irrigated treatments was significantly higher than in the non-irrigated treatments. The grain yields in F, W and WF are 1509, 2712 and 3291 kg ha⁻¹, respectively, which are 13.7, 104.3 and 147.9% higher than that (1328 kg ha⁻¹) of CK, and at the same time the grain yields in W and WF are also significantly higher than in F. Water use efficiencies (WUE) in terms of grain yield are 5.70 and 6.91 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹ in W and WF, respectively, being 65.7 and 101.1% higher than that (3.44 kg ha⁻¹ mm⁻¹) of CK. The highest WUE and grain yield consistently occurred in WF, suggesting that the combination of dry-period irrigation and fertilizer application has a beneficial effect on improving WUE and grain yield of spring wheat.     

Farm-scale stormwater losses of sediment and nutrients from a market garden near Sydney,Australia

Agricultural runoff contributes to water quality problems in the Hawkesbury–Nepean River near Sydney, Australia. This paper presents a case study of sediment, nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) losses from a market garden in the Hawkesbury–Nepean catchment. Event-based runoff sampling and flow and rainfall monitoring were carried out at the boundary of an 8-ha commercial market garden near Richmond, NSW, over two years (1995–1997). A record of fertiliser use and soil management was compiled during the runoff monitoring period. Soil management practices were similar to other market gardens on duplex soils in the area. Farm practices were consistent with ‘traditional’ industry practices.Over the 2-year period, stormwater runoff losses from the farm were equivalent to 19 t ha⁻¹ per year of suspended sediment, 11 kg of P ha⁻¹ per year, and 127 kg of N ha⁻¹ per year. Sixty percent of soil loss occurred in summer (December, January and February), reflecting both seasonal climatic changes and soil management practices. Soil erosion was the major mechanism for P mobilisation and transport; however, a significant increase in the event mean concentration (EMC) of soluble P was observed over the 2 years. During this period, we measured an increase in extractable soil P (Bray) in surface soil from 174 to 304 mg kg⁻¹ and a concomitant decrease in P sorption. The highest concentrations of N in runoff occurred after applications of poultry manure and during an extensive fallow period (late spring through to the end of summer). The results show that, in the Sydney region, market gardening on duplex soils using traditional practices is environmentally unsustainable, and may provide economic incentive to bring about change.     

Grain yield and water use in a long-term fertilization trial in Northwest China

The wheat- (Triticum aestivum L.) and corn- (Zea mays L.) rotation system is important for food security in Northwest China. Grain yield and water-use efficiency [WUE: grain yield/estimated evapotranspiration (ET)] were recorded during a 24-year fertilization trial in Pingliang (Gansu, China). Mean yields of wheat for the 16 years, starting in 1981, ranged from 1.29 Mg ha⁻¹ for unfertilized plots (CK) to 4.71 Mg ha⁻¹ for plots that received manure (M) annually with nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) fertilizers (MNP). Corn yields for the 6 years, starting in 1979, averaged 2.29 and 5.61 Mg ha⁻¹ for the same respective treatments. Whether the years were dry, normal or wet, average grain yields and WUEs for both crops were consistently highest in the MNP and lowest in the CK treatment, and were always lower in the N than in the M treatment and in all others treatments that received N along with P fertilizers. More importantly, WUEs for MNP and for straw along with N annually and P every second year (SNP) were always higher than the other fertilized treatments in dry years. Compared to yield data, coefficients of variance (CV) for WUEs were consistently low for all treatments, suggesting that WUEs were relatively stable from year to year. Yields and WUEs declined over time, except in the CK and MNP treatments for wheat. Declined yields of wheat for the N and M treatments were comparable, and the decline for the NP treatment was similar to that for the SNP treatment. Likewise, corn yields and WUEs declined for all treatments. Grain yields were significantly correlated with ET, with slopes ranging from 0.5 to 1.27 kg m⁻³ for wheat and from 1.15 to 2.03 kg m⁻³ for corn. Balanced fertilization and long-term addition of organic material to soil should be encouraged in this region to maximize the use of stored soil water, arrest grain yields decline, and ensure sustainable productivity using this intensive cereal cropping system.     

Cotton yield and applied water relationships under drip irrigation

Different irrigation scheduling methods and amounts of water ranging from deficit to excessive amounts were used in cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) irrigation studies from 1988 to 1999, at Lubbock, TX. Irrigation scheduling treatments based on canopy temperature (T_c) were emphasized in each year. Surface drip irrigation and recommended production practices for the area were used. The objective was to use the 12-year database to estimate the effect of irrigation and growing season temperature on cotton yield. Yields in the irrigation studies were then compared with those for the northwest Texas production region. An irrigation input of 58 cm or total water application of 74 cm was estimated to produce maximum lint yield. Sources of the total water supply for the maximum yielding treatments for each year averaged 74% from irrigation and 26% from rain. Lint yield response to irrigation up to the point of maximum yield was approximated as 11.4 kg ha⁻¹ cm⁻¹ of irrigation between the limits of 5 and 54 cm with lint yields ranging from 855 to 1630 kg ha⁻¹. The intra-year maximum lint yield treatments were not limited by water input, and their inter-year range of 300 kg ha⁻¹ was not correlated with the quantity of irrigation. The maximum lint yields were linearly related to monthly and seasonal heat units (HU) with significant regressions for July (P=0.15), August (P=0.07), and from May to September (P=0.01). The fluctuation of maximum yearly lint yields and the response to HU in the irrigation studies were similar to the average yields in the surrounding production region. The rate of lint yield increase with HU was slightly higher in the irrigation studies than in the surrounding production area and was attributed to minimal water stress. Managing irrigation based on real-time measurements of T_c produced maximum cotton yields without applying excessive irrigation.     

Effect of water-saving irrigation on rice yield and water use in typical lowland conditions in Asia

With decreasing water availability for agriculture and increasing demand for rice, water use in rice production systems has to be reduced and water productivity increased. Alternately submerged–nonsubmerged (ASNS) systems save water compared with continuous submergence (CS). However, the reported effect on yield varies widely and detailed characterizations of the hydrological conditions of ASNS experiments are often lacking so that generalizations are difficult to make. We compared the effects of ASNS and CS on crop performance and water use, at different levels of N input, in field experiments in China and the Philippines, while recording in detail the hydrological dynamics during the experiment. The experiments were conducted in irrigated lowlands and followed ASNS practices as recommended to farmers in China. The sites had silty clay loam soils, shallow groundwater tables and percolation rates of 1–4.5 mm per day.Grain yields were 4.1–5.0 t ha⁻¹ with 0 kg N ha⁻¹ and 6.8–9.2 t ha⁻¹ with 180 kg N ha⁻¹. Biomass and yield did not significantly differ between ASNS and CS, but water productivity was significantly higher under ASNS than under CS in two out of three experiments. There was no significant water×N interaction on yield, biomass, and water productivity. Combined rainfall plus irrigation water inputs were 600–960 mm under CS, and 6–14% lower under ASNS. Irrigation water input was 15–18% lower under ASNS than under CS, but only significantly so in one experiment. Under ASNS, the soils had no ponded water for 40–60% of the total time of crop growth. During the nonsubmerged periods, ponded water depths or shallow groundwater tables never went deeper than −35 cm and remained most of the time within the rooted depth of the soil. Soil water potentials did not drop below −10 kPa. We argue that our results are typical for poorly-drained irrigated lowlands in Asia, and that ASNS can reduce water use up to 15% without affecting yield when the shallow groundwater stays within about 0–30 cm. A hydrological characterization and mapping of Asia’s rice area is needed to assess the extent and magnitude of potential water savings.     

Review of measured crop water productivity values for irrigated wheat,rice, cotton and maize

The great challenge of the agricultural sector is to produce more food from less water, which can be achieved by increasing Crop Water Productivity (CWP). Based on a review of 84 literature sources with results of experiments not older than 25 years, it was found that the ranges of CWP of wheat, rice, cotton and maize exceed in all cases those reported by FAO earlier. Globally measured average CWP values per unit water depletion are 1.09, 1.09, 0.65, 0.23 and 1.80 kg m⁻³ for wheat, rice, cotton_seed, cotton_lint and maize, respectively. The range of CWP is very large (wheat, 0.6–1.7 kg m⁻³; rice, 0.6–1.6 kg m⁻³; cotton_seed, 0.41–0.95 kg m⁻³; cotton_lint, 0.14–0.33 kg m⁻³ and maize, 1.1–2.7 kg m⁻³) and thus offers tremendous opportunities for maintaining or increasing agricultural production with 20–40% less water resources. The variability of CWP can be ascribed to: (i) climate; (ii) irrigation water management and (iii) soil (nutrient) management, among others. The vapour pressure deficit is inversely related to CWP. Vapour pressure deficit decreases with latitude, and thus favourable areas for water wise irrigated agriculture are located at the higher latitudes. The most outstanding conclusion is that CWP can be increased significantly if irrigation is reduced and crop water deficit is intendently induced.     

Environmental impact and economic benefits of site-specific nutrient management (SSNM) in irrigated rice systems

Site-specific nutrient management (SSNM) provides a field-specific approach for dynamically applying nutrients to rice as and when needed. This approach advocates optimal use of indigenous nutrients originating from soil, plant residues, manures, and irrigation water. Fertilizers are then applied in a timely fashion to overcome the deficit in nutrients between the total demand by rice to achieve a yield target and the supply from indigenous sources. We estimated environmental impact of SSNM and evaluated economic benefits in farmers’ fields in southern India, the Philippines, and southern Vietnam for two cropping seasons in 2002–2003. On-farm research comparing SSNM and the farmers’ fertilizer practice showed increased yield with SSNM for the three locations, even with reduced fertilizer N rates in some cases. SSNM increased partial factor productivity (kg grain kg⁻¹ fertilizer N) when fertilizer N use efficiency with the farmers’ fertilizer practice was relatively low such as at locations in Vietnam and the Philippines. Use of on-farm data with the DNDC model revealed lower percentage of total N losses from applied fertilizers with SSNM during an annual cycle of cropping and fallows. At the location in India, SSNM showed the potential of obtaining higher yields with increased fertilizer N use while maintaining low N₂O emissions. SSNM in the Philippines and Vietnam showed greater yields with less fertilizer N through improved fertilizer use efficiency, which could reduce N₂O emissions and global warming. Use of SSNM never resulted in increased emissions of N₂O per unit of grain yield, and in environments where higher yield could be obtained with less fertilizer N, the use of SSNM could result in reduced N₂O emissions per unit of grain yield. For the economic analysis, data were generated through focus group discussions (FGD) with farmers practicing SSNM and with other farmers not practicing SSNM. Based on FGD, the seasonal increase in yield of farmers solely due to use of SSNM averaged 0.2 Mg ha⁻¹ in southern Vietnam, 0.3 Mg ha⁻¹ in the Philippines, and 0.8 Mg ha⁻¹ in southern India. Farmers practicing SSNM at the study site in India used less pesticide. The added net annual benefit due to use of SSNM was 34 US$ ha⁻¹ year⁻¹ in Vietnam, 106 US$ ha⁻¹ year⁻¹ in the Philippines, and 168 US$ ha⁻¹ year⁻¹ in India. The increased benefit with SSNM was attributed to increased yield rather than reduced costs of inputs.     

Performance of temperate aerobic rice under different water regimes in North China

Since the late 1990s, aerobic rice varieties have been released to farmers in the North China Plain to grow rice as a supplementary-irrigated upland crop to cope with water scarcity. Little is known about their yield potential, water use, water productivity (WP), and flood tolerance. In 2001–2002, experiments with aerobic rice varieties HD502 and HD297 and lowland rice variety JD305 were conducted under aerobic and flooded conditions. Under aerobic conditions, five irrigation treatments were implemented. Under flooded conditions, JD305 yielded up to 8.8 t ha⁻¹, HD502 up to 6.8 t ha⁻¹, and HD297 up to 5.4 t ha⁻¹. Under aerobic conditions, the aerobic varieties yielded higher than the lowland variety. HD502 produced 3–3.5 t ha⁻¹ with 450–500 mm total water input and 5.3–5.7 t ha⁻¹ with 650 mm water input and more. HD297 produced 3–3.5 t ha⁻¹ with 450–500 mm total water input and 4.7–5.3 t ha⁻¹ with 650 mm water input and more. The water productivity of aerobic rice under aerobic conditions was higher or on a par with that of the lowland variety under flooded conditions, reaching values of 0.6–0.8 g grain kg⁻¹ water. The relatively high yields of the aerobic varieties under aerobic soil conditions were obtained under “harsh” conditions for growing rice. The soil contained more than 80% sand, was permeable, and held water above field capacity for a few hours after irrigation only. The groundwater table was deeper than 20 m, the soil moisture content in the rootzone was mostly between 50 and 80% of saturation, and soil moisture tension went up to 90 kPa. We conclude that the aerobic rice varieties HD502 and HD297 are suitable for water-scarce environments, and can stand being periodically flooded.