Pseudocercospora griseola,the causal agent of common bean angular leaf spot: Strain characterization and sensitivity to fungicides

Angular leaf spot (ALS), an important disease of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris), is caused by the fungus Pseudocercospora griseola. This pathogen has a wide genetic variability and, therefore, poses a challenge to integrated disease management. The use of resistant cultivars is difficult; hence, the application of fungicides has been a common practice in common bean cultivation. P. griseola strains were morphophysiologically characterized and their sensitivity to common fungicides used to control ALS was studied. The strains were evaluated for sporulation capacity and a representative sample of 34 strains was bioassayed to determine their sensitivity to commercial concentrations of five fungicides, namely pyraclostrobin, mancozeb, pyraclostrobin + metconazole, chlorothalonil and tebuconazole. Another sample of 29 strains was studied for conidial germination and dimensions. Sporulation capacity ranged from 0.88 to 27.67 × 10⁴ conidia/ml and germination percentage ranged from 39% to 72%. The large differences among strains suggest a wide genetic variability among the strains. A wide variability in aggressiveness of P. griseola was observed, which has consequences for breeding programmes aimed at resistance. The behaviour of pathogen strains differed in every fungicide evaluated, even in a population that has not been under selection pressure in the field. These results confirm the need for further studies and may guide future research with this pathogen.     

Microdroplet application for determination of comparative topical and residual efficacy of formulated permethrin to two populations of diamond back moth (plutella xylostella L.)

An on-demand, uniform droplet generator was used to apply 120 μm diameter drops of formulated permethrin either directly onto 3rd-instar Plutella xylostella, of two Ohio populations, or onto the abaxial surface of leaf discs (1-1000 drops cm^?2) to which those larvae were subsequently exposed. Incorporating a fluorescent tracer (Saturn Yellow GT-17N) in the spray mixture confirmed that ?direct hit”? larvae had received a topical dose from a single droplet. There was little difference in the LC₅₀/LD₅₀ for either population of P. xylostella when 24 and 48 h mortality assessments from direct hits were compared, but the LD₅₀ of Celeryville larvae was 6-8 times greater than that of Fremont larvae. Residual deposits of 120 μm drops containing approximately the LC₅₀, based on the topical assays, revealed that a droplet density providing a dose per cm² leaf surface of more than 1000 times the LD₅₀ was required to cause median mortality. The efficiency of utilisation, based on the topical LD₉₅ values, was 0.0006% and 0.072% for Fremont and Celeryville larvae, respectively.     

Variations among field isolates of Botrytis cinerea in their sensitivity to antifungal compounds

Seventeen field isolates of Botrytis cinerea were compared by determining their radial growth on synthetic media containing various amounts of 21 antifungal compounds. Twelve of these compounds were fungicides that are recommended for the control of Botrytis infections. There were marked differences between the isolates in their sensitivity to the compounds. Individual isolates displayed high levels of resistance to some of the fungicides, including benomyl, carbendazim, iprodione, thiabendazole, thiophanate-methyl, vinclozolin and zineb. The most potent growth inhibitors were benomyl and carbendazim (ED₉₅ values for most isolates <0.1 μg fungicide ml^?1 media), dichlofluanid, iprodione, nystatin, thiabendazole, thiophanatemethyl and vinclozolin (ED₉₅ values for most isolates < 1.0 μg ml^?1), and captan, chlorothalonil, dicloran and thiram (ED₉₅ values for most isolates < 6.0 μg ml^?1). Zineb was much less potent than the other recommended anti-Botrytis fungicides; it was no more effective than carboxin, dinocap and mancozeb (ED₉₅ values for most isolates > 25 μg ml^?1).     

9种杀菌剂对胡萝卜类腊肠茎点霉菌生物学特性的影响

72%甲基托布津可湿性粉剂、15%三唑酮可湿性粉剂、70%代森锰锌可湿性粉剂、77%氢氧化铜可湿性粉剂、40%多.五氯可湿性粉剂、75%百菌清可湿性粉剂、50%多菌灵超微可湿性粉剂、50%异菌脲可湿性粉剂、70%叶枯唑可湿性粉剂9种杀菌剂抑制胡萝卜类腊肠茎点霉(Allantophomoides carotae)菌丝生长的EC₅₀分别为136.08、33.66、629.77、139.60、6.45、59.57、461.15、258.01、811.66μg/mL;抑制孢子萌发的EC₅₀分别为1.3510、2.8568、1.7424、1.9559、1.2060、0.1333、0.3462、0.7582、0.4984μg/mL;抑制芽管伸长的EC₅₀分别为2.9593、1.5664、1.8296、8.7493、0.4228、0.1837、0.4486、0.5706、0.2128μg/mL。9种杀菌剂对该菌的作用方式不同。75%百菌清可湿性粉剂对菌丝生长、分生孢子形成、孢子萌发及芽管伸长均有抑制作用;50%多菌灵超微可湿性粉剂对产孢和菌丝生长的抑制作用不显著,但能够抑制孢子萌发和芽管伸长;15%三唑酮可湿性粉剂、77%氢氧化铜可湿性粉剂对菌丝生长的抑制作用十分显著,但对产孢、孢子萌发和芽管伸长作用不明显。     

Bioassays using detached tobacco leaves to determine the sensitivity of Peronospora tabacina to fungicides

Two bioassay methods are described which use detached tobacco leaves to measure the sensitivity of Peronospora tabacina to systemic fungicides. Tobacco leaves (13–15 cm²), treated with fungicides before or after detachment from the plant, were inoculated with sporangia in water drops and, after incubation in beakers and Petri plates, the disease severity and/or production of sporangia was determined 4–7 days after treatment with the fungicides. Of 15 systemic fungicides applied to detached leaves, eight N-phenylamides at 0.066?1.0 μg ml^?1 controlled blue mould; metalaxyl was the most effective fungicide. Isolates of P. tabacina, collected in the field from tobacco plants grown in soil treated with metalaxyl, were not resistant to the fungicide applied to detached leaves prior to inoculation. The fungicide, applied to leaves before detachment, was used to measure the efficacy of five systemic N-phenylamide fungicides sprayed on the basal and unsprayed distal portions of the leaves. Blue mould was controlled on the basal portion of the leaf by all the fungicides at 0.66?1.0 μg ml^?1, but it required the application of 3–30 times more chemical on the basal portion to achieve comparable blue mould control on the distal part of the leaf.     

Effects of some fungicides on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Isaria farinosa</Emphasis>, and <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis> growth and infection rate on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Planococcus citri</Emphasis>

The effects of some fungicides used against citrus diseases, on mycelial growth and conidial germination of Isaria farinosa (Holmsk.) Fries [Sordariomycetes: Hypocreales] and also on the pathogenicity of the fungus on citrus mealybug, Planococcus citri (Risso), were determined. Systemic fungicides such as tebuconazole, penconazole and nuarimol were the most effective as regards both conidial germination and mycelial growth. Protective fungicides such as captan, chlorothalonil, mancozeb and propineb inhibited conidial germination at between 1 and 5 μg ml⁻¹ concentration, but captan, chlorothalonil and propineb did not inhibit the mycelial growth at 5,000 μg ml⁻¹. Mancozeb inhibited mycelial growth between 2,500 and 5,000 μg ml⁻¹. Sulphur and copper oxychloride did not inhibit the fungus even at very high concentrations. Sulphur, copper oxychloride, fosetyl-al, chlorothalonil and carbendazim did not decrease the mortality percentage caused by I. farinosa. Tebuconazole, penconazole and mancozeb were the most effective and respectively reduced the mortality from 83% to 33%, 28% and 30% in the ovisacs, from 81% to 29%, 27% and 29% in the 1st instar larvae, and from 84% to 34% in the adult females.     

丙环唑和醚菌酯药液浓度、雾滴密度与其对小麦白粉病防效的关系

采用室内生物测定和田间试验相结合的方法,研究了丙环唑和醚菌酯的药液浓度及雾滴密度与其对小麦白粉病防效的关系,首次提出了杀菌剂雾滴抑制中密度 (即达到50%抑制率时所对应的雾滴密度,EN₅₀) 这一概念。结果表明:1)室内喷施丙环唑及醚菌酯药液,当丙环唑质量浓度从0.01 g/L提高到1.0 g/L时,对应的EN₅₀值从18.7 cm–2下降至5.1 cm–2,EN₉₀值从755.8 cm–2下降至92.8 cm–2,雾滴杀伤半径 (r₅₀) 从0.92 mm增大到1.77 mm;当醚菌酯质量浓度从0.01 g/L提高到1.0 g/L时,对应的EN₅₀值从227.1 cm–2下降至1.0 cm–2,EN₉₀值从596.1 cm–2下降至26.9 cm–2,雾滴杀伤半径从0.27 mm增大到4.00 mm。2)田间使用MG-1S植保无人机和背负式电动喷雾器喷施丙环唑和醚菌酯防治小麦白粉病,无人机施药液量为15.0 L/hm2,药液质量浓度为5.0 g/L时,在小麦旗叶及倒二叶的雾滴密度分别为29.7和9.5 cm–2,喷施丙环唑和醚菌酯3、5、7 d后,对小麦白粉病的防效分别为41.9%、80.7%、90.2%和30.8%、67.9%、84.5%;电动喷雾器施药液量为450.0 L/hm2,药液质量浓度为0.17 g/L时,在小麦旗叶及倒二叶的雾滴密度分别为287.9和204.2 cm–2,喷施丙环唑和醚菌酯3、5、7 d后的防效分别为42.1%、85.3%、94.3%和28.5%、80.1%、90.5%。研究表明,田间施用丙环唑和醚菌酯时,无需把叶片全部喷湿,只需达到一定雾滴密度即可;运用植保无人机进行高浓度、低容量喷雾时,10~30 cm–2雾滴量即可达到理想的防治效果。     

Effect of the new pyrazole carboxamide fungicide penthiopyrad on late leaf spot and stem rot of peanut

BACKGROUND: Management of early leaf spot (Cercospora arachidicola Hori.), late leaf spot [Cercosporidium personatum (Berk. & MA Curtis) Deighton] and stem rot (Sclerotium rolfsii Sacc.) of peanut (Arachis hypogaea L.) in the southeastern USA is heavily dependent upon sterol biosynthesis inhibitor (SBI) and quinone outside inhibitor (QoI) fungicides. Effective new fungicides with different modes of action could improve overall disease control and extend the utility of the current fungicides. Penthiopryad is a pyrazole carboxamide fungicide being evaluated for use on peanut. Field experiments were conducted from 2004 to 2007 to determine the effect of a range of rates (0–0.36 kg AI ha^?1) of penthiopyrad on leaf spot and stem rot and the relative efficacy of penthiopyrad and current fungicide standards chlorothalonil, tebuconazole and azoxystrobin. RESULTS: Leaf spot control in plots treated with penthiopyrad at 0.20 kg AI ha^?1 or higher was similar to or better than that for the chlorothalonil standard. The incidence of stem rot for all penthiopyrad treatments was usually less than that for the tebuconazole or azoxystrobin standard treatments. Pod yields for all penthiopyrad treatments were similar to or higher than those for the respective standards. CONCLUSION: Penthiopyrad has excellent potential for management of late leaf spot and stem rot of peanut, and may complement current SBI and QoI fungicides. Copyright © 2008 Society of Chemical Industry     

Fate of [14C]Mancozeb in Egg Plants (Solanum melongena L.) during Summer under Sub-tropical Conditions

The fungicide mancozeb belongs to ethylenebis(dithiocarbamate) group of fungicides which is used to control brown and black rust, leaf spot, leaf blight, downy mildew etc. on a variety of plants including egg plants, tomato, potato and others. [¹⁴C]mancozeb, when applied to the foliage of egg plants (Solanum melongena L.) during summer months, dissipated very rapidly with a half-life of only 10·6 days. Ethylenethiourea (ETU), ethyleneurea (EU), ethylenethiuram disulfide (ETD), ethylenethiuram monosulfide (ETM) were the metabolites of [¹⁴C]mancozeb detected in all the plant parts at different times after the treatment. The amount of ETU in fruits after fourteen days of treatment was only 206 μg kg^?1 which is below the maximum permissible level and ultimately came down to 4·6 μg kg^?1 after 42 days. EU was found to be the predominant metabolite, suggesting the breakdown of unstable ETU to relatively stable EU under subtropical conditions.     

Biology and control of Polystigma ochraceum, the cause of almond red leaf blotch

Polystigma ochraceum is a major leaf pathogen of almond in Fars Province of Iran. Over a 4-year study period it was found that ascospore discharge began at flowering and continued for 4–5 weeks. The maximum discharge occurred at petal fall. The incubation period was estimated to be 4–5 weeks under experimental conditions. Although the mature ascospores could produce short germ tubes in distilled water or water agar, the fungus could not be cultured or grown on conventional media from either ascospores, pycnidiospores or stromatic tissues under laboratory conditions.
Of several systemic and non-systemic fungicides evaluated under field conditions, triforine at 100–400 μ/ml was most effective. Other fungicides which significantly reduced leaf infection were, in order of efficacy, copper oxychloride (2000 μg/ml), copper hydroxide (2000 mUg/ml), Bordeaux mixture (10 000 μg/ ml) and mancozeb (2000 μg/ml). Carbendazim and thiophanate methyl (500 μg/ml) increased the level of infection. One application of the fungicide at petal fall and then two at 14-day intervals were found to be effective in reducing the disease.     

10th British Weed Control Conference

The performance of different spray droplet spectra of cypermethrin from cone nozzles applied to brassica leaves was evaluated by bioassay using Plutella xylostella larvae. A spray droplet spectrum containing small droplets (VMD = 119 μm) caused a significantly higher knockdown and mortality compared to a coarser spray (VMD = 210 μm). No significant difference in the responses was observed when cypermethrin was sprayed over the top of the plants compared to plants sprayed from both sides using either nozzle; but the fine spray consistently gave better knockdown and mortality regardless of spray direction. The results indicated that spray effectiveness of cypermethrin could be improved by using a fine spray nozzle.     

黄瓜褐斑病防治药剂的离体活性筛选

离体条件下针对黄瓜褐斑病菌对19种杀菌剂进行了活性筛选。结果表明,不同杀菌剂对褐斑病菌菌丝生长和孢子萌发抑制作用不同。对褐斑病菌菌丝生长具有强烈抑制作用的杀菌剂为苯醚甲环唑、咪鲜胺、代森锰锌及嘧霉胺,其EC50分别4.21、4.67、5.59 μg/mL及4.11 μg/mL。甲氧基丙烯酸酯类杀菌剂及防治卵菌病害的药剂对褐斑病菌菌丝生长几乎没有影响。烯肟菌酯、福美双、代森锰锌、烯酰吗啉、百菌清和多菌灵对褐斑病菌孢子萌发具有强烈抑制作用,其EC50分别为3.34、6.62、0.28、3.54、0.53 μg/mL及0.26 μg/mL。50 μg/mL的嘧霉胺虽对孢子萌发抑制作用较小,但10 μg/mL时即可导致萌发的芽管出现明显卷曲、畸形。     

Germination of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Gibberella zeae</Emphasis> ascospores as affected by age of spores after discharge and environmental factors

The effects of age of ascospores (0–18 days after discharge), photon flux density (0–494 mol m^–2 s^–1 PAR), temperature (4–30 °C), frost (–15 °C for 30 min), relative humidity (RH; 0–100%), pH (2.5–6.5) and dryness (0 and 53% RH for up to 40 min) on the germination of the ascospores of the mycotoxin-producing fungus Gibberella zeae (anamorph Fusarium graminearum) were studied. Freshly discharged ascospores germinated within 4 h at 20 °C and 100% RH. The rate of germination and the percentage of viable ascospores decreased over time after the spores were discharged from perithecia. The time course of ascospore germination was not significantly affected by photon flux density. The period of time required to obtain 50% germinated ascospores at 100% RH was 26.90 h at 4 °C, 10.40 h at 14 °C, 3.44 h at 20 °C and 3.31 h at 30 °C. There was no significant effect of frost on the percentage of viable ascospores. A small percentage (6.6 ± 3.8%) of the ascospores germinated at 53% RH. At RH 84% and 20 °C almost 100% of the freshly discharged ascospores germinated. The time course of ascospore germination was affected by pH. The maximum rate of ascospore germination was estimated to be at pH 3.76. Ascospores lost their ability to germinate following exposure to 0% RH almost instantaneously. No germinating spores were detected after an incubation period of 1 min at 0% RH. Incubating the ascospores at 53% RH decreased the percentage of viable spores from 93 to 6% within 10 min. The data demonstrate that age of spores, relative humidity, temperature and pH, but not photon flux density, are key factors in germination of G. zeae ascospores.     

Distribution and activity of spray deposits in an oak canopy following aerial application of diluted and undiluted formulations of Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner against the gypsy moth,Lymantria dispar L. (Lepidoptera: Lymantriidae)

The distribution and biological activity of spray deposits resulting from aerial applications of diluted and undiluted Bacillus thuringiensis, ‘Dipel 64AF’ against the gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar L., were examined in oak stands in south-eastern Ontario, Canada. The sprays were applied by fixed-wing aircraft equipped with four ‘Micronair AU4000’ atomizers. Application of diluted formulation at 30 BIU ha^?1 in 6.0–6.4 litre generally resulted in a higher droplet density (10–28 cm ^?2 leaf) than application of undiluted product at the same dosage rate in 1.8 litre ha^?1 (4–10 cm ^?2). However, spray deposits of undiluted product with a volume median diameter (D_v.5) of 90–130 μm caused as much mortality of gypsy moth larvae in bioassays of sprayed foliage as deposits of diluted product with a D_v.5 of 150–350 μm despite a two- to three-fold reduction in droplet density. Our data suggest that by using fine spray atomization, undiluted application of these formulations can offer the same efficacy against gypsy moth as coarsely atomized sprays of diluted product.     

机动弥雾法施用70%吡虫啉水分散粒剂防治小麦蚜虫的雾滴沉积密度与防效的关系

田间采用背负式机动弥雾机对70%吡虫啉水分散粒剂进行喷雾试验,证明若吡虫啉喷雾雾滴在小麦穗部形成一定的沉积密度即可有效防治麦蚜。当70%吡虫啉水分散粒剂用水稀释2 333倍(有效成分300 mg/L),雾滴密度在54,133和280个/cm2条件下,施药7 d后对麦蚜的防治效果分别为83.3% ,88.7%和93.7%;当药剂稀释1 167倍(有效成分600 mg/L),雾滴密度在75,142和291个/cm2条件下,7 d后对麦蚜的防治效果分别为88.1%,94.5%和96.5%。采用背负式机动弥雾机,采用常量150 L/hm2、低浓度(300 mg/L)喷雾时,小麦穗部、旗叶上的雾滴沉积密度分别为177±12,113±8个/cm2,沉积量分别为27.4±6.8,6.6±1.6 ng/cm2,地面流失率为12.8%,7 d后的防治效果为94.0%; 当采用低容量75 L/hm2、高浓度(600 mg/L)喷雾时,小麦穗部、旗叶上的雾滴沉积密度分别为127±13,91±7个/cm2,沉积量分别为29.8±1.2, 6.7±0.6 ng/cm2,地面流失率为10.6%,7 d后的防治效果为93.8%。生产中建议采用吡虫啉低容量75 L/hm2、高浓度600 mg/L喷雾,省工、省水、省时。     

烟草麻孢根腐病菌生理学特性及药剂毒力测定

为明确烟草麻孢根腐病菌Gelasinospora reticulata的生理学特性及对杀菌剂的敏感性,采用十字交叉法和血球计数法研究了不同培养条件对该病菌菌丝生长的影响,并测定了11种不同杀菌剂对病菌的抑制作用。结果表明,该菌菌丝生长和产生子囊孢子的最适宜温度为26~32℃,最适生长pH为4;光照对菌丝和子囊孢子生长有明显的抑制作用;相对湿度高有利于该菌子囊孢子的萌发,当相对湿度高于98%时,萌发率达100%;温、湿度交互作用中,温度和相对湿度分别是影响菌丝生长和子囊孢子萌发的主要因素;不同碳源和氮源对菌丝生长及干重的影响差异显著,其中葡萄糖与酵母膏分别为最适宜碳源和氮源;病菌菌丝体和子囊的致死温度分别为51℃和55℃。咪鲜胺对该菌的抑制效果最好,EC_(50)为1.26μg/mL,其次是吡唑·醚菌酯,EC_(50)为2.78μg/mL,而代森锰锌、丙森锌、三唑酮和代森联抑制作用较差,不适合用于防治烟草麻孢根腐病。     

Efficacy of some fungicides against leaf scald disease of rice

Abstract

In field evaluation trials nine test fungicides significantly reduced the incidence and severity of leaf scald disease of rice caused by Monographella albescens (Thüm)(Rhynchosporium oryzae Hashioka & Yokogi) and increased the yield. Of these fungicides Difolatan (captafol) and Dithane M‐45 (mancozeb) were more effective than the other fungicides. Relatively longer persistence of fungicidal residues was detected in three test chemicals, i.e., Blitox‐50 (copper oxychloride), Difolatan and Dithane M‐45. Amount of rainfall appeared to be a main weather factor in influencing persistence of a fungicide.     

Preliminary studies of<Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis> stimulation of sexual mating among isolates of<Emphasis Type="Italic">Mycosphaerella fijiensis</Emphasis>, causal agent of black sigatoka disease in bananas and plantains

Single-ascospore-derived isolates ofMycosphaerella fijiensis Morelet from false horn ‘Agbagba’ plantain leaves obtained from five different villages in southern Nigeria were stimulated to mate under artificial conditions. Pairs of isolates were incubated under blacklight on potato dextrose agar (PDA) with surface-sterilized plantain leaves or on PDA with autoclaved plantain leaves. Some isolates were observed to be sexually compatible by their ability to produce spherical to bulb-shaped fruiting body structures (FBS) and ascospores on pairing. FBS were observed to measure between 39–65 μm (smallest diameter) and 39–104 μm (largest diameter; mean 55.3×71.1 μm) in diameter, whereas ascospore lengths measured between 13.0 and 14.9 μm. Length of incubation time required for FBS production was dependent on the pair of isolates involved, the average being 40.1 days. With some pairs, ascospores were observed after 35 days of incubation. http://www.phytoparasitica.org posting Dec. 16, 2002.     

Effects of fungicide on growth of Leptosphaeria maculans and L. biglobosa in relation to development of phoma stem canker on oilseed rape (Brassica napus)

Controlled‐environment and field experiments were done to investigate effects of the fungicide Punch C (flusilazole plus carbendazim) on growth of Leptosphaeria maculans and L. biglobosa in oilseed rape. In controlled‐environment experiments, for plants inoculated with L. maculans, fungicide treatment decreased lesion size and amount of L. maculans DNA in leaves; for plants inoculated with L. biglobosa, fungicide did not affect lesion size or amount of pathogen DNA. When release of ascospores was monitored using a Burkard spore sampler, the timing and pattern of ascospore release differed between the four seasons. In 2006/2007, the majority of ascospores released were L. maculans, whilst in 2007/2008 the majority were L. biglobosa; in both seasons L. maculans ascospores were released before L. biglobosa ascospores. In field experiments in 2002/2003 and 2003/2004, fungicide treatment decreased severity of stem canker on cv. Apex, but gave no significant yield response. In 2006/2007 and 2007/2008, fungicide treatment decreased phoma leaf spot incidence in autumn and stem canker severity at harvest, and increased yield. Fungicide treatment decreased stem canker severity more on cv. Courage, with a good yield response, than on cv. Canberra. In 2002/2003 and 2003/2004, fungicide treatment decreased the frequency of spread of L. maculans into stem pith tissues and in 2006/2007 fungicide decreased the amount of L. maculans DNA in stem tissues (measured by quantitative PCR). These results are used to suggest how effects of fungicides on interactions between L. maculans and L. biglobosa might affect severity of phoma stem canker and yield response.     

防治牡丹根腐病的有效药剂筛选

采用菌丝生长速率法和孢子萌发法,分别测定了咪鲜胺、醚菌酯、苯醚甲环唑、百菌清、多菌灵、代森锰锌等6种杀菌剂对牡丹根腐病菌的室内毒力。结果表明,6种药剂对病菌菌丝生长的EC50大小顺序为：咪鲜胺<多菌灵<代森锰锌<苯醚甲环唑<百菌清<醚菌酯,其中以咪鲜胺对牡丹根腐病病菌的菌丝生长抑制作用最强, EC50为0.200 mg/L;多菌灵、代森锰锌、苯醚甲环唑、百菌清依次减弱,醚菌酯的抑制菌丝生长的作用最小,EC50为33.98 mg/L。6种药剂对病菌孢子萌发的EC50大小顺序为：百菌清<咪鲜胺<苯醚甲环唑<多菌灵<代森锰锌<醚菌酯;其中以百菌清对牡丹根腐病菌的孢子萌发抑制作用最强,EC50为0.343 mg/L;咪鲜胺、苯醚甲环唑、多菌灵、代森锰锌依次减弱,醚菌酯抑制孢子萌发的作用最小,EC50为38.4 mg/L。