Foliar resistance to late blight in potato clones evaluated in national trials in 1997

Changes in the oomycetePhytophthora infestans in the United States and other parts of the world pose a significant threat to potato production. A continual evaluation of potato clones for resistance to late blight is necessary to identify clones with resistance and to monitor the stability of resistance in light of the emergence of new and more aggressive strains of this pathogen. Twentytwo potato clones (10 cultivars and 12 selections) were evaluated in 1997 for late blight resistance at seven U.S. locations. Seven late blight differentials (R₁R₂R₃R₄, R₁R₂R₄, R₁R₃R₄ R₃, R₈ R₁₀, and R_multi) were also included in the test at five of these locations. The US-8 strain of P.infestans was present at all locations. Percent infected foliage was recorded at approximately weekly intervals following the onset of disease. Area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) was calculated. The nonparametric stability statistics mean absolute rank differences (S _i ⁽¹⁾ ) and variances of the ranks (S _i ⁽²⁾ ) were used to analyze phenotypic stability. Although neither of these statistics was significant for individual clones, both of these statistics were significant when summed over clones, indicating the importance of genotype × environment interactions on the rankings of these clones across locations. The most late blight-resistant and susceptible clones were the most stable; clones in the intermediate ranges were most subject to rank changes due to genotype × environment interactions. The most late blight-resistant clones were AWN86514-2, B0692-4, B0718-3, and B0767-2. The most susceptible clones were B0811-13, B1004-8, Nor-Donna, and Krantz. AUDPC was very low for the late blight differentials R₈ and R_multi, moderately low for R₁₀ and very high for the remaining differentials. This study is important in characterizing the reaction of potato clones to new strains of P.infestans.     

Stability of late blight resistance in population B potato clones

Summary Increased virulence associated with fungicide resistance and variablePhytophthora infestans populations has been recorded in many potato growing regions with enormous economic effects. The current emphasis on disease management in East Africa includes the use of potato varieties with durable resistance to late blight. Seven promising clones from Population B with quantitative resistance (no R-genes), two advanced clones from Population A (with Rgenes) and three control varieties were grown for three cropping seasons in order to determine their reaction and stability of late blight resistance. Late blight occurrence was detected in all cropping seasons. The analysis of variance of disease data (AUDPC) for genotypes, locations x seasons was highly significant (P<0.001) indicating the differential response of the geno-types and the need for stability analysis. The Additive Main Effects and Multiplicative Interaction (AMMI) statistical model, showed that the most stable genotypes were 392127.256, 381471.18, 387121.4 (resistant) and 391049.255 (susceptible to late blight). Within environments, the ranking of genotypes was not consistent. The variety Kabale was ranked as the most susceptible genotype while clone 381471.18 and Rutuku were ranked the most resistant. Selective deployment of resistant and stable varieties is critical in minimizing economic loss and damage attributed to late blight in low input farming systems.     

Biochemical and morphological characterization of potato clones differing in their resistance to late blight

Summary Morphological and biochemical parameters that could be involved in resistance to late blight were studied in non-infected and in infected potato hybrids resulting from a cross betweenSolanum phureja, resistant toPhytophthora infestans, and a susceptibleSolanum tuberosum. Some morphological differences between resistant and susceptible hybrids, indicating a positive correlation between stem diameter and phloem thickness in the stem and resistance toP. infestans, were observed. The lignin content in the leaves of the resistant hybrid rose upon infection byP. infestans. In the leaves of the susceptible hybrid, a diminution of the lignin content could be observed upon infection byP. infestans. In the same context, peroxidasic activity raised upon infection byP. infestans in both resistant and susceptible hybrids. Further characterization of the hybrid clones based on the polymorphism of peroxidases was attempted using isoelectric focusing.     

A Study of the relationship of late blight resistance to glycoalkaloid content in fifteen potato clones

Tuber glycoalkaloid (TGA) content, leaf glycoalkaloid (LGA) content, and the level of multigenic resistance to late blight were determined for 15 potato clones. There was no association between the level of blight resistance and the TGA or LGA contents in these clones. However, TGA and LGA contents were highly correlated. The genotypic correlation coefficient between TGA and LGA contents for the 15 clones was 0.82 (SE = 0.115). TGA contents from blight-infected plants were not significantly higher than TGA contents from healthy (fungicide-protected) plants. The results indicate that breeders should be able to select for multigenic late blight resistance withohut increasing TGA contents of clones in their breeding programs.     

Breeding for resistance to late blight in the potato

American Journal of Potato Research -     

Correlation between resistance to late blight in foliage and tubers in potato clones from parents of contrasting resistance

Summary The relationship between resistance to late blight in foliage and tuber was examined on 50 clones of each of five progenies from crosses where one parent was resistant in both foliage and tuber and the other susceptible. Foliage resistance was assessed in a field trial and tuber resistance in a laboratory test on glasshouse-grown tubers. The genetical and environmental components of variance and the phenotypic and genetical correlations between foliage and tuber blight scores were determined for each progeny. Foliage and tuber resistance were correlated, indicating either that both are determined by the same genes or by different linked genes. The environmental component of variation was greater for tuber blight than foliage blight. We suggest that the most effective way of selecting for resistance to both aspects of the disease in a breeding programme is to select those resistant in the foliage and then screen them for tuber resistance.     

Testing the resistance of potato genotypes to tuber late blight

Summary The method hitherto used in Norway for testing for tuber resistance to late blight, inoculating newly harvested unwounded tubers, is described. Superficial wounding of the tubers prior to inoculation increased the level of infection. Tests on wounded and unwounded tubers ranged the cultivars in the same order, but the significance level was higher for wounded tubers. When the tubers were harvested 16 days before inoculation instead of the same day, unwounded tubers of susceptible genotypes were less infected, but using the mean for wounded and unwounded tubers, the distinction between susceptible and resistant genotypes was still clear. Tubers inoculated 7 days after harvest were most infected when wounded shortly before inoculation, but tubers wounded two days before inoculation were infected more than unwounded tubers, and the separation between susceptible and resistant genotypes was more distinct than for unwounded tubers.

---

Zusammenfassung Die derzeit in Norwegen verwendete Methode zur Prüfung der Knollenresistenz gegen Braunf?ule wird beschrieben. Die Knollen werden vorsichtig geerntet und auf feuchten Filterpapier in Styropor-Boxen (‘Fischboxen’) gelegt. Am gleichen Tag werden die Knollen mit einer Zoosporen/Sporangien-Suspension vonPhytophthora infestans besprüht. Nach Inokulation werden die Boxen bei 15°C gelagert und dabei 20 Stunden lang zwecks Erhaltung hoher Feuchtigkeit gestapelt. Danach k?nnen die Knollen abtrocknen. In Untersuchungen erh?hte sich die Zahl der Infektionen nach Rollen der Knollen über 10 Nagelspitzen, 2 mm hoch und von einer h?lzernen Basis aufw?rts weisend (Tabellen 2 und 3). Bei verwundeten und nichtverwundeten Knollen waren die Rangfolgen der Sorten nicht signifikant unterschiedlich. Für die getesteten Sorten jedoch war die Unterscheidung zwischen resistent und anf?llig, wie derF-Test aus der Varianzanalyse zeigte, bei verwundeten Knollen besser (Tabelle 3). Das Vorkommen von Braunf?ule in unverwundeten Knollen anf?lliger Sorten wurde reduziert, wenn die Knollen 16 Stunden vor der Inokulation anstatt am gleichen Tag geerntet wurden (Tabellen 1 und 2). Bei Verwendung des Durchschnitts bei verwundeten und nichtverwundeten Knollen war die Unterscheidung resistenter Sorten von anf?lligen Sorten noch klar m?glich (Tabelle 1). 7 Tage nach der Ernte inokulierte Knollen wurden am st?rksten infiziert, wenn sie kurz vor Inokulation verwundet wurden (Tabelle 4). Zwei Tage vor Inokulation verwundete Knollen zeigten zudem noch st?rkere Infektion als unverwundete Knollen. Für die in dieser Studie verwendeten Knollen war die Unterscheidung der Sorten etwas besser bei einem Tag vor Inokulation verwundete Knollen m?glich als bei Knollen, die am gleichen Tag oder zwei Tage vor Inokulation verwundet worden waren. Nichtverwundete Knollen von. Pflanzen aus 3 verschiedenen Pflanzterminen waren nahezu gleich anf?llig (Tabelle 5). Es liess sich kein signifikanter Effekt der Knollenreife auf die Resistenz feststellen.

---

Résumé La méthode utilisée jusqu'ici en Norvège pour apprécier la résistance des tubercules au mildiou est décrite. Les tubercules sont récoltés soigneusement et placés sur papier filtre dans des bacs à poisson en polystyrène. Le jour même, les tubercules sont soumis à la pulvérisation d'une suspension de zoospores et de sporanges dePhytophthora infestans. Après l'inoculation, les bo?tes sont placées à 15°C et empilées pendant 20 heures afin de conserver un niveau élevé d'humidité. Après ce temps, les tubercules peuvent sécher. Lors d'expériences de blessures superficielles des tubercules en les faisant rouler sur 10 pointes (de 2 mm de haut) de clous fixés sur un support de bois, on augmente le niveau de l'infection (tableaux 2 et 3). Le classement des cultivars n'est pas significativement différent entre les tubercules blessés et non blessés mais chez les cultivars éprouvés, la distinction entre les résistants et les sensibles est meilleure chez les tubercules blessés, comme le montre la valeur duF des analyses de variance (tableau 3). L'incidence de la maladie chez les tubercules non blessés de cultivars sensibles est réduite quand les tubercules sont récoltés 16 jours avant l'inoculation, comparée à une récolte réalisée le jour même (tableaux 1 et 2). En utilisant la moyenne des valeurs obtenues avec des tubercules blessés et non blessés, la distinction entre cultivars sensibles et résistants est encore claire (tableau 1). Les tubercules inoculés 7 jours après la récolte sont plus infectés quand ils sont blessés peu de temps avant l'inoculation (tableau 4). De plus, les tubercules blessés deux jours avant l'inoculation sont encore plus infectés que les tubercules non blessés. Avec les cultivars utilisés dans l'étude, la distinction entre cultivars est nettement meilleure chez les tubercules blessés un jour avant l'inoculation que chez ceux blessés le jour même ou deux jours avant. Les tubercules non blessés de récoltes issues de plantations différées toutes les 6 semaines possèdent quasiment la même sensibilité (tableau 5). Aucun effet de la maturité des tubercules sur la résistance ne peut être déterminé.

     

Field resistance to late blight of four indian potato cultivars

Summary The nature and extent of field resistance to late blight, and the effect of plant age and inoculum level on resistance components and host attributes, were studied on the Indian potato cultivars Kufri Chandramukhi, Kufri Jyoti, Kufri Badshah and Kufri Sherpa. Latent period, infection efficiency, colonization rate and sporulation were found to operate in cvs Kufri Jyoti, and Kufri Badshah. Based on component analysis cv. Kufri Jyoti was similar to or sometimes more resistant than Kufri Badshah. No correlation was observed between any of the host attributes and resistance to late blight, except that the erect canopy of Kufri Badshah was associated with its slow blighting rate. At high inoculum, colonization rate and total sporulation were increased but infection efficiency was decreased.     

Differential resistance to tuber late blight in potato cultivars without R-genes

Summary In 1983 and 1984 there were reports in Norway of more severe late blight infection than usual on tubers of cv. Pimpernel, a cultivar without R-genes known to be somewhat resistant to both haulm and tuber infection. Results from routine tests confirmed earlier experience that cv. Pimpernel shows stable resistance to tuber late blight, although the ranking of cultivars may vary between years. In experiments during three harvest seasons tubers of different cultivars were inoculated with isolates ofP. infestans obtained from stocks of cv. Pimpernel with severe tuber late blight and with other isolates. In these experiments the isolates from cv. Pimpernel caused more rot on tubers of Pimpernel than did other isolates.     

Laboratory testing of potato tubers for multigenic resistance to late blight

Resistance in the tubers of potato clones with various levels of foliar multigenic resistance toPhytophthora infestans was measured to detect possible correlations between tuber and foliar resistance. A highly significant correlation was found using wound-healed tuber tissues. High levels of tuber resistance were detected in most foliar-resistant clones when inoculations with race 1,2,3,4 were made after 24–48 hours of wound periderm formation at 20 C. The resistance of wound-healed tissues increased as the time between wounding and inoculation increased. This increase in resistance was significantly greater for clones with foliar resistance than for clones with susceptible foliage.     

A detached-leaf method to evaluate late blight resistance in potato and tomato

We developed a detached leaf method for evaluating potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) and tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) germplasm for reactions toPhytophthora infestans, the causal organism of late blight. Primary leaves from the third to the sixth node of potato plants, and the fourth to sixth node of tomato plants were excised at the stem. Their petioles were inserted into 14 mm × 100 mm floral aqua tubes containing 9 ml of sterilized distilled water. The leaves in the aqua tubes were placed with abaxial sides down on galvanized metal hardware cloth (12.5 × 12.5 mm mesh). A 12.5 mm sensi-disc containing 50μl of 2 × 10⁴ zoospores was placed in the centers of the terminal leaflet and the second leaflet pair of the potato leaf. A single disc was placed on the center of the tomato leaf. The supporting hardware cloth was placed 2.5 cm above distilled water (2.5 cm deep) in 31 cm × 17 cm × 8 cm clear plastic boxes with tight fitting lids. Leaves on intact tomato and potato plants were inoculated in a similar manner and placed in a mist chamber. Lesion growth was determined 4, 5, and 6 days following inoculation. There were no significant differences in reactions to isolates ofP. infestans on detached and intact leaves of potato cultivars Green Mountain and Kennebec and the tomato cultivar Bonnie Best.     

The expression of general resistance to late blight (Phytophthora infestans) in potato leaves

Summary Resistance toPhytophthora infestans was evaluated histologically using leaves of potato cultivars with different levels of general resistance. Host genotype did not influence the preinfectional processes of encysted zoospores, e.g. frequency of germination, length of germ tubes, or frequency of formation of appressoria. Most of the appressoria on the leaf surface were attached to epidermal cells, but they were also found on cells of the stomatal complexes, on hairs and glands, and on cells adjacent to vascular tissue. There were significant differences between cultivars in the extension of intercellular hyphal growth and branching 24 and 48 h after inoculation, the differences increasing with time. In contrast to cv. Bintje, the hyphae in the most resistant cultivar Matilda were mostly confined to the epidermal and palisade cells even 48 h after infection, the number of hyphae per section was much lower, and sporulation capacity was reduced.     

Systemic induced resistance to late blight in potato by treatment with salicylic acid andPhytophthora cryptogea

Summary Tests for systemic induced resistance (SIR) to late blight were performed with different potato cultivars in field trials and in growth chamber experiments. The non-pathogenPhytophthora cryptogea (Pc) and salicylic acid (Sa) were used as inducer agents. In the field, plants were naturally infected byPhytophthora infestans while the indoor plants were inoculated. The degree of SIR obtained varied with the cultivar used and also with the type of inducer. For example in the field the susceptible cv. St. Cecilia had enhanced resistance with Pc whereas Sa caused increased susceptibility. Inbred resistant cvs acquired increased resistance after treatment with Sa. In a separate pilot experiment in a growth chamber, Sa at two different concentrations was injected into potato seed tubers before planting. The higher Sa concentration increased resistance in genetically resistant cultivars while the lower Sa concentration brought about increased susceptibility.     

The use of area under the disease progress curve to assess resistance to late blight in potato germplasm

The multiple evaluation of potato cultivais and breeding selections (clones) for disease during the season can be costly and may not be necessary for accurate assessments of disease resistance or susceptiblity. For diseases whose progression can be described by sigmoid curves, an estimate of the area under the disease progress curve from two data points may provide as much information as from repeated assessments. Twentythree clones were planted in a randomized complete block design in Hastings, FL, in 1997 and evaluated for percent diseased foliage 14 times during a 31-day period after late blight was first noticed in the plots. The area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) was calculated for all 14 assessments. The AUDPC was also calculated for nine sub-sets of the original data set. There was a high correlation between all the methods in the calculation of the AUDPC. The AUDPC calculated based on two dates (representing the beginning of the epidemic and the time until two of the clones were dead from late blight) was as informative as the AUDPC calculated on the entire data set. The AUDPC could be calculated based on any two dates from this time frame as long as one date was shortly after the epidemic started and the other date was as the epidemic was reaching its peak. Much information was lost if AUDPC was calculated based on dates involved only in the early part of the epidemic. A considerable savings in time and effort can be realized by only a few assessments.