Pilus ELISA and an anamnestic test for the diagnosis of virulent ovine footrot and its application in a disease control program in Nepal

The immunological memory (anamnestic) responses in sheep recovered from virulent footrot (VFR) can be aroused by subcutaneous injection of outer membrane protein (OMP) antigens of Dichelobacter nodosus. The magnitude of this response is directly correlated to the highest antibody response attained during infection and memory lasts at least a year after recovery from VFR. However, some older animals show non-specific responses to OMP antigens. In this study an evaluation of D. nodosus pilus antigen for the anamnestic diagnosis of footrot in sheep was undertaken. The results indicated that the primary and anamnestic responses to pilus were similar in character to OMP antigen but were highly specific. The sensitivity of the procedure for detection of sheep with a history of VFR was approximately 80%. A low proportion of sheep with mild lesions due to virulent strains of D. nodosus reacted to anamnestic challenge. Anamnestic challenge with 10 microg pilus was used in a VFR surveillance program in migratory sheep flocks in Nepal. Conventional diagnostic methods could not be applied during the disease transmission periods in these flocks because of their migration to alpine pastures far away from human habitation. The results supported clinical and bacteriological findings suggesting that virulent strains of D. nodosus have apparently been eliminated from these flocks in Nepal.     

Improved diagnosis of virulent ovine footrot using the intA gene

Footrot is a mixed bacterial infection of the hooves of sheep. The gram-negative anaerobic bacterium Dichelobacter nodosus is the principal causative agent, with different strains causing diseases of different severity, ranging from benign to virulent. In Australia, in the state of New South Wales (NSW), only virulent footrot is subject to regulatory action, including quarantine. However, it is often difficult to distinguish benign footrot from virulent footrot in the initial stages of infection, or under adverse climatic conditions. The gelatin gel test, which measures the thermostability of secreted bacterial proteases, is the laboratory test most widely used in Australia to aid in the differential diagnosis of footrot. The proteases of virulent strains are, in general, more thermostable than the proteases of benign strains. However, there are some false positives in the gelatin gel test, which may lead to unnecessary quarantine procedures. We used Southern blot analysis on 595 isolates of D. nodosus from 124 farms on which sheep had benign or virulent footrot to test for the presence of the intA gene. We found that for D. nodosus strains which are stable in the gelatin gel test, there is a high correlation between the presence of the intA gene and the ability of the strain to cause virulent footrot. We also developed a PCR-based assay for the rapid detection of intA, which can be used to test DNA extracted from colonies grown on plates, or DNA extracted from cotton swabs of culture plates.     

Comparative antigenic analysis of extracellular proteins of Bacteroides nodosus isolated from virulent and benign ovine footrot

Antigens in the extracellular protein (ECP) complexes of Bacteroides nodosus, isolated from sheep with either benign or virulent footrot, were studied by immunoelectrophoresis (IEP). Rabbit antisera against ECP from virulent and benign strains, were used in homologous and heterologous crossed IEP. Four precipitin peaks unique to the virulent strain, and five peaks unique to the benign strain were identified. In an attempt to characterize the different antigens in ECP, rabbit antisera were raised against an outer membrane protein (OMP, mol. wt. 35 000 daltons), pili and various proteases of virulent and benign strains of B. nodosus. No precipitin band was observed when ECP from both B. nodosus strains were reacted against anti-OMP and anti-pilus antisera. However, single precipitin bands unique to one protease from the benign strain and one protease from the virulent strain were identified. The results suggest that specific antigens other than proteases or pili are important in determining whether a B. nodosus isolate is virulent or benign.     

Effect of climatic region on the clinical expression of footrot of lesser clinical severity (intermediate footrot) in sheep

OBJECTIVE: To determine if the clinical classification of intermediate footrot (IFR) is changed to virulent footrot (VFR) by a transfer of the infected flock to a region where climatic conditions are more favourable for the transmission of the disease. DESIGN: Clinical examination of two groups of Merino wethers infected with IFR; one group of 309 in a region considered less favourable for footrot and another group of 343 at a second site considered more favourable. PROCEDURES: After characterising the form of footrot at the first site, infection was established at the second site by mixing 142 wethers from the first site with 201 unrelated wethers considered to be free of IFR and VFR. Observations of clinical characteristics were made over a 16 month period during which an outbreak of footrot occurred. Clinical assessments were made by inspecting every foot of every sheep at regular intervals and allocating a footscore. Evidence that the same clonal lines of D. nodosus were responsible for the footrot at both sites was provided by serotyping of isolates and using omp gene RFLP as a molecular epidemiological tool. RESULTS: The disease at the first site was classified as IFR because 7% of the sheep developed a maximum footscore (MFS) of 4, the most severe category, despite relatively low rates of transmission. When the outbreak occurred at the second site, which was more suitable for footrot transmission, the maximum proportion of the flock that developed a MFS of 4 was 3.6%, confirming the initial classification of IFR. CONCLUSIONS: When a flock infected with IFR was moved to a region where climatic conditions were more favourable for footrot transmission, the clinical classification of the disease remained the same in both the original flock and in sheep exposed to the infection for the first time.     

The thermostability of proteases from virulent and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus

Protease enzymes, produced by Bacteroides nodosus strains isolated from animals with virulent and benign forms of ovine footrot, were partially purified by ultra-filtration, ion exchange chromatography and gel permeation chromatography. Each enzyme had a similar pH optimum, was inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF), ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and ethyleneglycot-bis-aminoethylether-N,N-tetraacetic acid (EGTA), but was not inhibited by 1,10-phenanthroline. The results suggest that these enzymes are serine proteases that require divalent cations for activity. The enzymes could be distinguished by their differential temperature stability and differing susceptibility to irreversible inactivation by EDTA. Both enzymes were stabilised by incubation in the presence of Ca2+, but the enzyme purified from the virulent isolate required less Ca2+ for maximum stability. These results suggest that the differential thermostability of the protease activity detected in virulence tests is an intrinsic property of the protease enzymes.     

The role of elastase in the differentiation of Bacteroides nodosus infections in sheep and cattle

Eighty-seven Bacteroides nodosus isolates were examined for elastase production by clearing of elastin particles in TAS agar medium. These included 54 ovine virulent isolates, 28 ovine benign isolates and five bovine isolates. In addition 22 ovine virulent, 16 ovine benign and two bovine isolates were examined for decline in proteolytic activity over a 13-day period in the degrading proteinase test using hide power-azure as substrate. There was a remarkable correlation between elastase production, relative stability of proteolytic activity in the hide powder-azure test and virulence of B nodosus. Ovine virulent isolates invariably produced elastase whereas ovine benign isolates and bovine isolates were elastase negative. Bovine isolates produced only mild lesions in the feet of challenged sheep.     

Eradication of virulent footrot from sheep and goats in an endemic area of Nepal and an evaluation of specific vaccination

Programmes based on the identification and treatment of cases and the culling of animals refractory to treatment had failed to eradicate virulent footrot from two districts in the western region of Nepal. From 1993 to 1996 vaccination against two endemic virulent strains of Dichelobacter nodosus was tested for its potential to contribute to the eradication of footrot from the region. Only sheep and goats which had been free of signs of footrot at three inspections at monthly intervals before their annual migration to alpine pastures were eligible for inclusion. From November 1992, the treatment of cases identified during inspections included the injection of specific vaccine. Successfully treated cases migrated with their flocks but were excluded from the vaccine trial. Non-responding cases were culled. Forty combined flocks of sheep and goats (approximately 9500 animals) were used initially to compare three vaccination regimens. Eleven flocks (sheep and goats) were treated with two doses of specific vaccine (group A), nine (sheep and goats) were treated with commercial vaccine followed by specific vaccine (group B) and 10 (sheep and goats) were treated with two doses of commercial vaccine (group C) in March to April 1993 before the annual migration; 10 flocks (sheep and goats) remained unvaccinated (group D). Only sheep and goats free of signs of footrot were allowed to migrate. Nevertheless, virulent footrot recurred in many flocks three months later. However, its prevalence was significantly lower in group A than in the other three groups combined. Groups A, B and C then received the specific vaccine before their migrations in 1994 to 1996; group D remained unvaccinated. The annual programme of inspection and identification and treatment of cases continued for seven years, but the vaccinations ceased after four years. There was no recurrence of virulent footrot after November 1993. After the first season the virulent strains of D nodosus used in the specific vaccine could no longer be isolated, although antigenically distinct, benign strains of the organism persisted in cases of benign footrot.     

Serological classification and virulence determination of Dichelobacter nodosus isolated from Alberta and British Columbia sheep.

Ovine footrot is a contagious disease of sheep that occurs in temperature climates. It is caused by the strict anaerobe, Dichelobacter nodosus. Benign and virulent organisms are differentiated according to serotype and protease production. This study was conducted to identify the presence of virulent serotypes of D. nodosus in sheep flocks in Alberta and British Columbia. Dichelobacter nodosus was detected in lame sheep from 11 of 15 (73%) flocks in Alberta and in 4 of 5 (80%) British Columbia flocks. It was recovered from 57 of 107 (53%) lame sheep. In Alberta, 4 distinct serotypes were isolated from the 11 positive flocks while in British Columbia a total of 6 different serotypes were isolated. One British Columbia isolate could not be classified into existing serotypes. Of the 19 field strains tested, all but 3 were defined as virulent based upon the rapid rise in protease activity in vitro which was maintained between 3 and 5 d. The knowledge of the serotype and virulence of the D. nodosus isolated from affected animals can assist in the control and prevention of ovine footrot.     

Characterisation of virulent and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus

The extracellular proteases of 395 isolates of B. nodosus from ovine, bovine and caprine foot lesions were classified as either thermostable or thermolabile. Stable protease was associated with one and unstable protease with four distinctive isoenzyme patterns, each pattern differentiated by the relative mobility of paired isoenzymes. Pathogenicity tests on 64 isolates showed a correlation between the production of stable protease and the production of virulent ovine footrot lesions. The mean values for total protease activity, twitching motility and colony diameter were significantly higher for virulent compared to benign isolates, but the range of values overlapped. SDS-PAGE whole-cell electrophoretic profiles of virulent isolates were similar to the profiles of some benign isolates.     

A method to differentiate between virulent and benign isolated of Bacteroides nodosus based on the thermal stability of their extracellular proteinases

A rapid modification of the hide powder azure proteinase degrading test was devised to distinguish between benign and virulent strains of Bucteroides nodosus grown as cultures on either liquid or solid media. The assay was based on the difference in stability, at 60 degrees C, of the enzymes released in the growth medium. The assay can be completed in four hours. Results for ovine virulent strains and their culture variants were similar and were clearly distinguishable from those of the ovine benign, bovine, deer and goat isolates which were similar to each other. The proteinase isozymes from cultures of the deer and goat isolates were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and their molecular weights determined.     

Motility in relation to virulence of Bacteroides nodosus

Fourteen Bacteroides nodosus isolates from footrot lesions of sheep were examined microscopically and all were found to have twitching motility. The mean percentage of cells showing motility was 40% and 9% for virulent and benign strains, respectively. This corresponded with mean agar colony diameters of 17 mm and 7 mm, respectively, for these strains. Two strains of intermediate virulence had values of motility and colony diameter similar to the benign strains. However, the intermediate and the virulent strains produced relatively stable protease compared to the benign strains. All virulent, benign and intermediate strains produced abundant pili. Included for comparison in this study was an avirulent variant strain which was highly motile, formed large colonies and produced stable protease, but showed no pili on electron microscopy. It was concluded that the properties of motility and protease stability may be used to distinguish, in the laboratory, wild-type virulent, benign and intermediate strains of B. nodosus.     

ISOLATION AND CHARACTERISATION OF BACTEROIDES NODOSUS FROM FOOT LESIONS OF CATTLE IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA

SUMMARY Thirty one isolates of Bacteroides nodosus were obtained from foot lesions observed on cattle at 3 abattoirs. All isolates were similar to the B. nodosus of ovine benign footrot (BFR) in their response to the degrading proteinase test. At one abattoir, where the interdigital lesions were examined in detail, 9 of 10 isolates were obtained from hyperkeratotic lesions with deep fissures. Traceback to 8 of the farms of origin which carried both sheep and cattle, revealed BFR in sheep on 4 farms. The significance of B. nodosus in interdigital lesions in cattle, and its possible pathogenicity, are discussed.     

Prevalence of footrot in Swedish slaughter lambs

Background

Footrot is a world-wide contagious disease in sheep and goats. It is an infection of the epidermis of the interdigital skin, and the germinal layers of the horn tissue of the feet. The first case of footrot in Swedish sheep was diagnosed in 2004. Due to difficulties in distinguishing benign footrot from early cases of virulent footrot and because there is no possibility for virulence testing of strains of Dichelobacter nodosus in Sweden, the diagnosis is based of the presence or absence of clinical signs of footrot in sheep flocks. Ever since the first diagnosed case the Swedish Animal Health Service has worked intensively to stop the spread of infection and control the disease at flock level. However, to continue this work effectively it is important to have knowledge about the distribution of the disease both nationally and regionally. Therefore, the aims of this study were to estimate the prevalence of footrot in Swedish lambs at abattoirs and to assess the geographical distribution of the disease.

Methods

A prevalence study on footrot in Swedish lambs was performed by visual examination of 2000 feet from 500 lambs submitted from six slaughter houses. Each foot was scored according to a 0 to 5 scoring system, where feet with score ≥2 were defined as having footrot. Moreover, samples from feet with footrot were examined for Dichelobacter nodosus by culture and PCR.

Results

The prevalence of footrot at the individual sheep level was 5.8%, and Dichelobacter nodosus was found by culture and PCR in 83% and 97% of the samples from feet with footrot, respectively. Some minor differences in geographical distribution of footrot were found in this study.

Conclusions

In a national context, the findings indicate that footrot is fairly common in Swedish slaughter lambs, and should be regarded seriously.     

Severity and persistence of footrot in Merino sheep experimentally infected with a protease thermostable strain of Dichelobacter nodosus at five sites

Objective To test the hypothesis that ovine footrot associated with a thermostable protease strain of Dichelobacter nodosus undergoes self cure or is sustained as an annually recurring disease, depending on the environment.
Design and procedure Forty Merino sheep from a single blood line were infected with a protease thermostable strain of D nodosus a t each of five sites in Western Australia. Footrot lesions and microscopic evidence of D nodosus were recorded every fortnight for 2.5 years, supplemented by laboratory culture. Rainfall, soil and air temperature, pasture quantity and composition and soil types were also recorded. Flocks that apparently self cured were relocated to a more favourable site for footrot in the final spring season.
Results The maximum prevalence of feet with clinical footrot lesions was 80.6, 1.3, 14.4, 3.8 and 88.1% at the five sites. Severe footrot occurred for three consecutive spring seasons at one site that had clay loam soil and at least 3500 kg/ha total pasture dry matter annually. However, the infection was asymptomatic for up to 10 weeks between outbreaks. D nodosus was isolated from flocks for 2.5 years at only two sites, although there was microscopic evidence of the organism at other sites in the final year. A thermolabile variant (strain U6) of D nodosus was isolated from the two sites where footrot persisted.
Conclusion Depending on time and location, ovine footrot induced by a protease thermostable strain of D nodosus either self cured or persisted as annual outbreaks interspersed with periods of asymptomatic infection.     

Observations on the indirect transmission of virulent ovine footrot in sheep yards and its spread in sheep on unimproved pasture

SUMMARY: Virulent ovine footrot was transmitted accidentally to a group of 23 adult Merino sheep (flock B) after holding for 1 hour in sheep yards, which earlier the same day had contained another flock (flock A) with < 1% prevalence of sheep with footrot lesions. Sheep in flock B were rendered susceptible to virulent footrot by grazing 600 mm high unimproved pasture dominated by paspalum ( Paspalum dilatatum ) and kangaroo grass ( Themeda australis ) during warm, humid and wet weather. In addition to moisture, interdigital abrasions caused by the pasture might have predisposed the interdigital skin to infection with Dichelobacter nodosus .     

Occurrence of different strains of Dichelobacter nodosus in new clinical lesions in sheep exposed to footrot associated with multi-strain infections

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the occurrence of S1, U1 and T strains of Dichelobacter nodosus in new clinical lesions in sheep exposed to footrot associated with multi-strain infections. DESIGN: Seventy-seven donor sheep were grazed with 84 recipients for 33 weeks. The donor sheep were Merinos with a history of clinically virulent footrot associated with protease type S1, U1 and T strains of D nodosus that hybridised with gene sequences pJIR314B, pJIR318 and/or pB645-335. The recipient sheep were Merinos with no history of footrot. PROCEDURE: Each fortnight, all feet were examined, their lesion scores were recorded and samples of lesion material were taken for laboratory tests. RESULTS: Eighty-nine percent (299 of 336) of feet of recipient sheep developed new clinical lesions. S1, U1 and T strains of D nodosus were recovered from 58%, 22% and 18%, respectively, of these lesions at a ratio that remained constant during two apparent peaks in footrot transmission. Gene sequences homologous to pJIR314B and pB645-335 were detected in 56% (93 of 166) and 29% (48 of 166), respectively, of S1 strains of D nodosus at a ratio that was not constant during the experiment. CONCLUSIONS: S1 was the dominant protease type of D nodosus in new clinical lesions. The occurrence of S1 strains did not increase relative to U1 and T strains of D nodosus during the experiment. S1, U1 and T strains of D nodosus remained in equilibrium despite changes in environment, genetic types in the population of S1 strains, and host resistance to footrot.     

Serum antibody responses in sheep after natural infection with Bacteroides nodosus

Soluble outer membrane protein of Bacteroides nodosus extracted with potassium thiocyanate (KSCN) was employed as antigen in an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to detect serum antibody in sheep naturally infected with a heterologous serogroup. Serum antibody responses in 55 sheep were monitored for 2 years and maximum levels were directly related to the severity of clinical foot lesions. Serum antibody levels rose 2 weeks after foot lesions developed and declined within several months of resolution of lesions. After the first footrot transmission period, antibody levels persisted significantly (P less than 0.001) longer in sheep that did not become affected in the next transmission period compared with sheep in which footrot recurred. Antibody response did not appear to result in resolution of foot lesions. ELISA using KSCN antigen gave similar results to whole cell ELISA where cells prepared from an homologous serogroup were used as antigen. Both these assays were more sensitive than ELISA in which heterologous whole cell antigen was used. Proteins extracted from the outer membrane of B. nodosus, which are known to be immunogenic in natural infection and common to different serogroups of B. nodosus, appear to be useful antigens for serological investigations of ovine footrot.     

The virulence of Dichelobacter nodosus,measured by the elastase test,is an important predictor for virulent footrot diagnosis in New South Wales sheep flocks

Ovine footrot is a contagious bacterial disease that causes foot lesions, and depending on the virulence of the causative strains, may lead to severe underrunning of the hoof and lameness. Virulent footrot can be identified, treated and controlled more effectively than less virulent benign forms. The in vitro elastase test for virulence of the causative bacteria, Dichelobacter nodosus, has been used to support clinical diagnosis. However, not all laboratory-designated virulent D. nodosus strains cause clinical signs of virulent footrot. This study evaluated retrospectively how well the elastase test supported clinical footrot diagnosis in 150 sheep flocks examined for suspect footrot in New South Wales between August 2020 and December 2021. Flocks were included if measures of clinical disease, environmental conditions and the virulence of D. nodosus isolates were available. Variation in the elastase activity result between D. nodosus isolated from the same flock made bacterial virulence hard to interpret, but calculating the mean elastase rate for all isolates from the same flock made correlations between bacterial virulence and flock footrot diagnosis possible. Simplifying bacterial virulence into whether there were any elastase-positive D. nodosus isolates before 12 days increased the predictive value of elastase results for virulent diagnosis, compared with using the first day that any isolate was elastase positive or the percentage of elastase-positive isolates by 12 days, but not all clinically virulent flocks had isolates with elastase activity before 12 days. Logistic regression models were fitted to identify the minimum number of predictors for virulent footrot diagnosis, with models suggesting that virulent footrot diagnosis was best predicted by adding the elastase test result and environmental conditions to the prevalence of severe foot lesions (score 4 and 5). However, performing the same analysis with different breeds, ages of sheep and seasons might highlight other factors important in the diagnosis of virulent footrot.     

Rapid and accurate typing of Dichelobacter nodosus using PCR amplification and reverse dot-blot hybridisation

Here we describe an approach to genotyping D. nodosus, based on variation in the fimbrial subunit gene (fimA), which uses polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and hybridisation to immobilised oligonucleotides (PCR/oligotyping).The variable region of D. nodosus fimA, amplified and labelled with digoxigenin (DIG) in a single multiplex PCR amplification, was hybridised to a panel of group- and type-specific poly-dT tailed oligonucleotides that were immobilised on a nylon membrane strip. A mixture of positive control poly-dT tailed oligonucleotides was also included on the membrane. After hybridisation the membrane was washed to a defined specificity, and DIG-labelled fragments hybridising were detected with nitroblue tetrazolium (NBT) and 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl phosphate (SCIP). The specificity of the oligonucleotides was verified by the lack of cross-reactivity with D. nodosus fimA sequences that had a single base difference. DNA from 14 footrot samples previously genotyped by PCR-SSCP/sequencing [Vet. Microbiol. 71 (2000) 113], was assayed using the PCR/oligotyping technique. All types of D. nodosus which had been detected previously with a PCR-SSCP/sequencing method were detected by this procedure. However, for three of the 14 footrot samples, PCR/oligotyping detected additional types of D. nodosus. Further PCR amplification using type-specific primers, confirmed that these types of the bacterium were present in the footrot samples. These results indicate that PCR/oligotyping is a specific, accurate, and useful tool for typing footrot samples. In combination with a rapid DNA extraction protocol, D. nodosus strains present in a footrot sample can be accurately identified in less than 2 days.     

The pathogenicity and cultural characteristics of virulent, intermediate and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus causing ovine foot-rot

The relationship between the cultural and biochemical characteristics of 22 strains of Bacteroides nodosus and their virulence for sheep was examined. Virulent, intermediate and benign strains were recognised. Although there was some relationship between virulence and colony morphology on hoof medium with 4% agar, colonies of one virulent and 4 intermediate strains resembled those of benign strains. However, on hoof medium with 2% agar and on blood Euonagar, colonies of this virulent and one intermediate strain differed from each other and the other 3 intermediate strains, which in turn differed from the benign. The degree of piliation, as assessed by electron microscopy, was not a reliable indicator of virulence in strains not possessing a beaded colony type. Together, the results of colony morphology and proteolytic tests such as zymogram, degrading proteinase and elastin-agar tests allowed better discrimination of virulent and benign strains. Intermediate strains generally possessed virulent protease activity. In strains with benign zymogram patterns, activity bands 2 and 3 were more labile than in strains with virulent patterns. The addition of CaCl2 to the culture medium resulted in greater stability of proteolytic activity, particularly with benign strains, and prevented the disappearance of protease activity in the band 5 position in virulent, intermediate and benign strains during prolonged incubation. There were slight differences in the sodium dodecyl sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) patterns of outer membrane proteins of some benign strains but those of intermediate category resembled virulent strains. There was some relationship between the apparent Mr of the pilin monomer on SDS-PAGE gels and serogroup specificity.