Change Point in Phosphorus Release from Variously Managed Soils with Contrasting Properties

Abstract

Investigating the relation between concentration or release of phosphorus (P) into soil solution (CaCl₂‐P, determined by 0.01 M CaCl₂ extraction of soils) and soil test phosphorus (Olsen P, or 0.5 N NaHCO₃‐extractable soil phosphorus) for 10 widely ranging and variously managed soils from central Italy, a change point was evident where the slopes of two linear relationships meet. In other words, it was possible to distinguish two sections of the plots of CaCl₂‐P against Olsen P, for which increases of CaCl₂‐P per unit of soil test P increase were significantly (p<0.05) greater above than below these change points. Values of change point ranged from 14.8 to 253.1 mg kg^?1 Olsen P and were very closely correlated (p<0.001) to phosphorus sorption capacity of soils. Similar change points were also previously observed when Olsen P (and also Mehlich 3 P) of surface soils was related to the P concentration of surface runoff and subsurface drainage. Because insufficient data are available relating P in surface soils and amount of P loss by overland, subsurface, or drainage flow, using the CaCl₂ extraction of soil can be convenient to determine a change point in soil test P, which may be used in support of agricultural and environmental P management.     

Wheat p requirements on calcareous Morrocan soils: III evaluation by isotherms compared to Olsen extractable P

Abstract

Phosphorus fertilizer recommendations were compared by interpretations from P isotherms, Olsen extractable P and the Mitscherlich‐Bray model based on the Olsen method for 15 soils from the Chaouia (dryland) region of Morocco. The P isotherms were fit to straight line and second degree polynomial equations. The P buffer indexes (PBI) derived from the isotherms were not significantly correlated to P buffer capacities as measured by a single P buffer capacity index, but negatively correlated to Olsen P (r = ‐0.63), relative yield (r = ‐0.76) and P uptake (r = ‐0.66). Phosphorus in solution was a quadratic function of P added in 0.01 M CaCl₂equilibrium solution. The P fertilizer recommendations to maintain soil solution P concentrations at 0.01, 0.12 and 0.20 mg P L^‐1were higher than recommended by direct interpretation of plant response to Olsen extractable P and the quantity based on the Mitscherlich‐Bray model as calculated from Olsen available P values. The P fertilizer recommended to maintain soil solution P of 0.10 mg P L^‐1was significantly correlated with Olsen P (r = 0.71) as was that recommended Mitscherlich‐Bray log transformation model (r = 0.81), and nonlinear least square estimation (r = 0.78). Field research will be needed to evaluate if the P fertilizer recommended to maintain this solution P concentration is adequate for maximum economic wheat grain yield under field conditions     

A comparison of 5 soil phosphorus extraction methods applied to different soils of South of Iran

Phosphorus (P) fertilization is commonly based on soil testing, for which a variety of different soil P extraction methods are in use. In this research, the correlation and calibration of five extraction techniques for available P were studied: Soltanpour and Schwab, Olsen, EDTA-Na₂, Paauw and Morgan in 168 different soil samples from 63000 ha of Sirjan pistachio orchards of Kerman province, Iran. The Morgan reagent extracted the most P and then EDTA-Na₂> Olsen> Soltanpour and Schwab> Paauw extracted more phosphorus, respectively. Positive and significant correlation (P < 0.05) existed among all extractants. The correlation coefficients between different extractants and plant P concentration indicated that, EDTA-Na₂ (P < 0.01), Olsen and Paauw methods (P < 0.05) had positive and significant correlation with leaf P concentration and thus with due attention to acceptable relationship with plant indices, the Olsen and EDTA-Na₂ methods could be used to advise on available P.     

Critical Olsen P and CaCl2‐P levels as related to soil properties: results from micropot experiments

The usefulness of soil phosphorus (P) tests used in routine soil analyses is limited by the fact that a single measurement cannot encompass all P‐related factors potentially affecting plant performance. In this work, we performed micropot (15 mL) experiments to test the hypothesis that the predictive value of two common soil P tests (Olsen P and CaCl₂‐P) can be improved by considering properties commonly measured in laboratory analyses. Forty‐nine sets of soils ranging widely in properties were used for this purpose, each set consisting of samples with similar properties but differing in P status. Ryegrass and turnip were grown in a chamber for 30 days in two separate experiments and their yields at harvest recorded. The critical Olsen P and CaCl₂‐P levels, which were taken to be those corresponding to 95% asymptotic yield as calculated from data fitted to a Mitscherlich equation, were greater for turnip than for ryegrass, probably as a result of the difference in yield (49 and 160 mg dry matter/micropot on average for ryegrass and turnip, respectively) and hence in P requirements between the two species. Critical Olsen P spanned narrower ranges than critical CaCl₂‐P in both crops and is therefore seemingly the more robust of the two tests. Both critical P values exhibited moderate correlations with soil properties. Thus, critical Olsen P was (a) lower in soils with a medium pH – which is consistent with the fact that the bicarbonate solution method tends to overestimate plant‐available P in strongly acid and calcareous soils; (b) positively correlated with pH and carbonate content in calcareous soils; and (c) uncorrelated with soil properties in noncalcareous soils. On the other hand, critical CaCl₂‐P in some soil groups was negatively correlated with some properties increasing the P buffering capacity of soil (e.g. Fe oxide content). Taken together, our results suggest that routinely measured soil properties help to predict critical Olsen P better than critical CaCl₂‐P.     

Addition of phosphorus to soils with low to medium phosphorus retention capacities. II. effect on soil phosphorus extractability

Abstract

Knowledge of the change in soil extractable phosphorus (P) as a consequence of soil P fertilization could be useful in discriminating soils with a potential for soil P release to runoff or movement of P along the soil profile. In this research, soils with low to medium P retention capacity were equilibrated for 90 days with soluble P (KH₂PO₄) at rate of 100 mg P kg^‐1 soil. After this period, soil samples both with and without the P addition were analyzed using six conventional methods: 1) Olsen, 2) Bray 1,3) Mehlich3,4) Egner, 5) Houba, dilute CaCl₂ solution, and 6) distilled water, and three “innovative”; P‐sink methodologies: 1) Fe oxide‐coated paper strip, 2) anion exchange resin membrane, and 3) cation‐anion exchange resin membrane. The soils without P addition had low levels of extracted P as determined by all nine procedures. Net increases in the amount of P extracted from the soils with added P ranged from 4.2 mg kg^‐1 (CaCl₂ extraction) to 57.6 mg kg^‐1 (cation‐anion resin membrane extraction). Relationships between change in extracted P and i) physical and chemical characteristics, and ii) soil P sorption properties are also presented and discussed.     

Determination of Soil Feature Effects on Plant-Available Phosphorus Extraction using Response Surface and Cate–Nelson Methodology

In this study, four soil extraction methods (Olsen, Soltanpour, Mehlich 3, and water saturation) were used to identify optimal concentrations of phosphorus (P) required for plant growth. Olsen soil extraction for P was the most appropriate method for soil types of this study as the greatest correlation coefficient for soil-test P and with plant factors was achieved. The optimal amount of soil features (pH, organic carbon, lime, gypsum, and clay) determined by using response surface methodology (a new optimization method) were 7.49, 0.66, 41.82, 4.21, and 31.34, respectively. More soil P was extracted when the soil had optimal amounts of these features, showing each feature had a significant effect on extracted soil P. Furthermore, the graphical method of Cate–Nelson determined the optimal amounts of P using Olsen, Soltanpour, Mehlich 3, and saturation extract methods for wheat as 15, 6.5, 35, and 1.5 mg kg^?1 soil in nongypsic soils and 17, 3.5, 45, and 2.5 mg kg^?1 soil in gypsic soils.     

Comparison of Two Soil Phosphorus Analytical Methods in Croatia

Abstract

The purpose of this article was to compare soil phosphorus (P) extraction by sodium bicarbonate solution (Olsen P) and by ammonium lactate (AL P) and to create a model for prediction of Olsen P using ordinary soil‐fertility control data. The soils data used in this study included Olsen P, pH_KCl, pH_H2O, organic matter, AL P, and AL K. Soil pH_KCl ranged from 3.5 to 8, organic matter up to 5%, AL K up to 400 mg kg^?1, and AL P up to 200 mg kg^?1. Olsen P and AL P were significantly correlated, and the difference between them was influenced by soil pH. Regression models included all soil data grouped by soil pH range, which significantly decreased the difference between predicted and measured Olsen P. The validation of the model was conducted on new data sets from field fertilization trials. The results show that Olsen P can be related to AL P and used for fertilizer recommendations instead of AL P.     

Divergent Relationships of Phosphorus Soil Tests in Temperate Grassland Soils

Abstract

Various soil tests are used to estimate phosphorus (P) availability for both crop uptake and potential loss to water. Conversion equations may provide a basis for comparison between different tests and regions, although the extent to which information can be interchanged is uncertain. The objective was to determine and quantify relationships between specific soil test extractants for samples taken annually in October and February over 4 years from four sites in each of eight soil series under grassland. The extractants comprised Mehlich‐3, Morgan, Olsen, Bray‐1, lactate–acetate, CaCl₂ (1∶2 and 1∶10 soil–solution ratios), and resin. The results showed distinct relationships for each soil series, for which individual lines regression models (different intercepts and slopes) were superior to a single conversion equation across all soils. The ensuing difference between soils was large and ranged from 1.9 to 8.0 and 9.2 to 15.6 mg kg^?1 P for Morgan and Olsen, respectively, at 20 mg kg^?1 Mehlich‐3 P. Generally, the environmentally oriented tests CaCl₂ and resin correlated best with Morgan. Some soil‐specific limitations were also observed. CaCl₂ was less efficient than Morgan, and Morgan less efficient than Mehlich‐3 on a high Fe–P soil derived from Ordovician‐shale diamicton, compared with the general trend for other soils. This finding suggests that further disparity may arise where evaluation of critical, or other, limits across regions involves even a limited sequence of tests.     

Predictive Model for Phosphorus Accumulation in Paddy Soils with Long-Term Inorganic Fertilization

Prediction of accumulation of available phosphorus (P) in paddy soils is crucial for the best management of P fertilizers. Based on the long-term double-rice rotation systems, a predictive model for accumulation rates of Olsen P in paddy soils with chemical fertilization was developed. In paddy soils with more than 40 kg applied P ha^?1, the accumulation of Olsen P in the soils could occur. With the target rice yield of 10 tons ha^?1 per year, the increases in Olsen P in paddy soils were estimated by the model as 0.7, 2.2, and 3.8 mg kg^?1 when P application rates are 40, 60, and 80 kg P ha^?1, respectively. The accumulation rate of Olsen P was relatively high in paddy soils. The predictive model can be used to predict accurately the concentrations of Olsen P in paddy soils based on initial Olsen P, P application rate, and crop yield and to optimize P fertilization for rice crop production and environmental protection.     

Phosphate adsorption by soils 1. Influence of time and ionic environment on phosphate adsorption

Abstract

The influence of reaction time and ionic environments, on phosphate adsorption were studied using one calcareous soil from India, and one calcareous and two latosols from Hawaii.

Phosphorus adsorption by soils has a initial rapid phase followed by a slow process. For plant nutrition studies, where emphasis is on P concentration of solutions from which plants derive P, isotherms should be constructed using data obtained after near‐equilibration has been attained. This condition does not obtain in a few hours and may require 6 days or more.

Calcium chloride as suspending electrolyte always gave lower phosphate solubility than when KC1 was used as electrolyte. Phosphate retention increased with increasing ionic strength. The necessity for obtaining clear supernatant solutions and the desirability for maintaining reasonable constant equilibrium conditions make 0.01 M CaCl₂ a reasonable choice for constructing P sorption isotherms, even though 0.01 M CaCl₂ is not representative of Ca concentrations in many soil solutions. Saturation extracts of soils investigated here were in the range 0.0002 to 0.005 M Ca.

Adsorption of calcium by highly weathered soils was high suggesting specific adsorption. Calcium adsorption was increased by phosphate additions to a Hydrandept.     

Soil test calibration studies for formulation of phosphorus fertilizer recommendations for maize in Morogoro district,Tanzania. I. evaluation of soil test methods

Abstract

Optimum crop production depends, among other things, on the maintenance of adequate plant nutrients in the root zone. The objective of this study was to find a reliable index for assessing needs for supplemental phosphorus (P) in soils of Morogoro District, Tanzania. Six indices of P availability, namely: Bray and Kurtz No. 1 (BK1), Bray and KurtzNo.2 (BK2), Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, Olsen and ammonium bicarbonate‐DTPA (AB‐DTPA), were evaluated. Evaluation of the P indices involved relating extractable P contents by different methods with crop response data expressed as relative yields. The response data was obtained from pot trials with soil samples from ten repesentative soils designated as benchmark soils of the district. Treatments were absolute control, 0, 10, 20, and 30 mg P kg^‐1 of soil. Correlation of maize relative yields with soil test values by the six indices of P availability resulted in correlation coefficients ranging from 0.65 to 0.90. The Olsen method gave the highest r value suggesting that it was superior to the others. However, using the Cate and Nelson approach, the Olsen and ammonium bicarbonate‐DTPA methods were found to be at par and superior to the others. They each accounted for 76% of the variations observed in maize relative yields, respectively. The critical P levels for the indices were 10.50 mg P kg^‐1 for Olsen and 2.80 mg P kg^‐1 for the AB‐DTPA method. Phosphorus fertility categories were delineated in relation to Olsen extractable P as: low (<6.50 mg P kg^‐1), medium (6.50 to 23.0 mg P kg^‐1), and high (>23.0 mg P kg^‐1). Based on this classification it was determined that 16%, 25 %, and 59% of the surveyed area had low, medium, and high P levels, respectively. About 40% of the surveyed area may, therefore, require fertilization with P for optimum yields.     

Comparison of four phosphorus extraction methods on three acid southeastern soils

Abstract

Phosphorus extractants have not been tested extensively in the Southeast. An experiment was carried out to compare four P extractant methods using samples from a field P‐K factorial experiment with soybeans (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) at three locations in Georgia over four years. There were five P rates ranging from none to 80 kg ha^‐1. Soils and plant tissue were sampled at mid‐summer and yields were recorded. The four P extractants compared were Olsen, Mehlich 1, Mehlich 2, and Bray 1. Quadratic regressions for soil P versus plant P and P rates were not significant compared to linear regressions. There were no significant yield responses to P. All extractants except Olsen were similar in their response to added fertilizer P as measured by linear r² values. Olsen P gave lower linear r² values both with P rate and with plant P. Mehlich 1 values were highly correlated with Mehlich 2 (0.94**) and Bray 1 (0.96**). Mehlich 2 and Bray 1 gave nearly the same soil P values with linear regressions of slope of 1.0 and low intercepts. Results from these experiments show that Mehlich 1, Mehlich 2, or Bray 1 could be used successfully on these soils, but that Olsen should be avoided.     

Effect of liming and phosphate application on sudangrass growth and phosphorus availability in two temperate acid soils

Abstract

A pot experiment was carried out in the greenhouse with two loamy sand Dystric Cambisols derived from schist to investigate the effect of liming and phosphorus (P) application on plant growth and P availability and its assessment by four soil test methods: 0.01M calcium chloride (CaCl₂), cation anion exchange membrane (CAEM), Egnér‐Riehm, and Olsen procedures. Soils were first incubated for two weeks with lime at four levels, depending on their content of exchangeable aluminum (Al). Phosphorus was added at two rates (75 and 150 mg P kg^‐1) and the incubation proceeded for an additional two‐week period. Sudangrass (Sorghum sudanenses cv. Tama) was then planted and harvested four weeks later. During incubation and plant growth, soils were maintained at 70% of field moisture capacity. Although pH value and soil extractable P in original soils were similar, the results showed a significant difference on the effect of liming and P application. Acidity was the major limitation for DM yield in the soil with the highest amount of exchangeable Al, while P availability was the main constraint in the other soil. Liming above pH (0.01M CaCl₂) 5.3–5.5 did not increase DM yield in either soil and showed a negative effect on one soil (9.7 to 6.9 and 10.2 to 7.8 g pot^‐1). Phosphorus content and uptake by sudangrass increased with liming, revealing a positive effect of lime on the availability of P to plants. Added P showed a lower efficiency in the soil with highest amounts of Al compounds. Soil tests performed after the execution of the pot experiment showed variable tendencies to predict P availability, according to the nature of the procedures and soils. Soluble‐P in 0.01M CaCl₂ increased with the rise of soil pH. Extractable CAEM‐P and Egnér‐Riehm‐P also increased with liming, but reflected the soil depletion caused by plant uptake. Extractable Olsen‐P presented the most inconclusive results, suggesting the limitation of this method for acid soils which have been limed.     

Comparison of Iron Oxide–Impregnated Paper Strips with Other Extractants in Determining Available Soil Phosphorus

Abstract

Iron oxide–coated strips (P_i) can serve as a sink to continuously remove phosphorus (P) from solution. In this way, P extraction is analogous to the P absorption by plant roots. The objective of this study was to compare the iron oxide–coated paper strips with other chemical extraction methods to estimate the plant P availability for corn (Zea mays) growing in the greenhouse in some soils of Hamadan province of Iran. Sixteen soil samples with different physicochemical properties were analyzed for available P using Olsen, Colwell, Mehlich‐1, 0.01 M CaCl₂, AB‐DTPA, and 0.1 M HCl methods and p_i. Furthermore, the effects of two P levels (0 and 200 mg P kg^?1) on the plant indices (P uptake, relative yield, and plant responses) were studied in a greenhouse experiment using 10 soil samples. The results showed that the amount of extractable P decreased in the order of 0.01 M CaCl₂<AB‐DTPA<p_i<Olsen<Colwell<Mehlich‐1<0.1 M HCl. The amount of P extracted by the p_i method was significantly correlated with other extractants. The amounts of P extracted by all chemical methods were significantly correlated. The results of a pot experiment showed that the amount of P extracted by the p_i method was significantly correlated with the plant P uptake. However, the other methods were not significantly correlated with P uptake. The results of this experiment showed that p_i method was able to predict the plant availability of soil P.     

Malachite green method compared to ascorbic acid for estimating small amounts of phosphorus in water, 0.01 M calcium chloride,and olsen soil extracts

Abstract

Malachite green method has been evaluated for estimating minute quantities of phosphorus (P) in water, 0.01M calcium chloride (CaCl₂), and Olsen [sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO₃)] extracts often soils of varying properties. The precision and accuracy of the malachite green method was better than that of the ascorbic acid method to estimate P in these three extracts. The recovery of added P ranged from 95.3–99.3% in water, 96–100% in 0.01M CaCl₂, and 96.7–100% in Olsen extracts. The ascorbic acid method underestimated the amounts of 0.01M CaCl₂‐P and its precision was also lower than the malachite green method. It is possible to predict the P concentration in the three extracts equal to malachite green method from the ascorbic acid P values by using regression equations.     

Effect of some soil properties on extractable boron content in argentine pampas soils

Abstract

The influence of some soil properties on hot 0.02 M calcium chloride (CaCl₂) extractable boron in the Argentine Pampas was studied. The selected soils represent an extensive area in the middle west of the country where most of the grain crops are produced. Soils have all developed on loess and cover a wide range of organic matter, pH, and exchangeable calcium. The most representative soils are Typic Argiudolls and Typic Haplustolls. Two hundred soil samples were taken in order to characterize their 0.02 M CaCl₂ extractable boron content and study the boron behavior with regard to other soils properties and environmental conditions. The amounts of extracted boron on all samples had a significant correlation with soil organic carbon (positive), and soil pH (negative). The regression equation between extractable boron and organic carbon content was y=0.1021+0.3722 OC R²: 0.51. Since solubility in hot CaCl₂, 0,02 M is considered an availability index, these results support the hypothesis that organic carbon content is the main boron reserve for plants. When a multiple regression was calculated, both variables organic carbon and pH explained 57% of variation in extractable boron. The studied area can be subdivided into regions with different boron content, within each region the relationship between boron content and organic carbon and pH were also different. The exchangeable calcium content had a light influence especially in the subsuperficial layer. The influence of environmental conditions on boron content and its relationship with soil properties were discussed.     

不同农业土壤中有效磷的变化与磷平衡的关系

Maintaining soil phosphorus(P) at adequate levels for plant growth requires assessing how the long-term P balance(viz., the difference between P inputs and outputs) results in changes in soil test P. The hypothesis that routinely measured soil properties can help predict the conversion factor of P balance into Olsen P was tested at 39 sites in agricultural areas of the Mediterranean region in Spain. A set of soil samples from each site was analyzed for Olsen P, inorganic P(P extracted using 0.5 mol L~(-1) H_2SO_4), pseudototal P(P extracted using 0.5 mol L~(-1) H_2SO_4 following ignition at 550℃), and organic P(the difference between pseudototal P and inorganic P). Organic and Olsen P were uncorrelated in most of the 39 soil sets, which suggests that organic P content changed little with P inputs and outputs. The slopes of the regression lines of Olsen P against pseudototal and inorganic P, which were used as two different measures of the conversion factor, ranged widely(from 0.03 to 0.25 approximately), with their average values(about 0.10) being similar to those found in long-term experiments conducted in temperate areas. Neither conversion factor was significantly correlated with any routinely measured soil property; however, the conversion factor for inorganic P was significantly lower for calcareous soils than for noncalcareous soils. Our negative results suggest the need to isolate the influence of soil properties from that of management systems and environmental factors relating to P dynamics in future studies.     

Evaluation of phosphorus management practices in East Mediterranean altered wetland soils

In this study, we re‐examined the common practice of intensive P fertilization in altered wetland soils even when soil test (Olsen‐P) indicates sufficient P levels (>10 mg/kg). We tested the effects of P fertilization on crop performance and P leaching in 36 lysimeters (1.5 m³) filled with peat, marl or alluvial materials and compared a new bone‐char‐based fertilizer to the common superphosphate. The lysimeter experiment consisted of the two fertilizer types, two application rates and a typical crop rotation of setaria (Setaria italica), pea (Pisum sativum) and tomatoes (Lycopersicon esculentum). By the end of each crop rotation, the yield was evaluated relative to P‐fertilization rates and soil‐test P. P fertilization resulted in increased Olsen‐P, soil‐solution P and P loss through leachates and a slight quality yield advantage in pea and tomato with no increase in yield of any crop. P budget calculations showed that plant uptake was not affected by the amount or type of applied P. We concluded that P fertilizer application should be significantly reduced because of limited crop response and increased P concentrations in leachates that may increase P loss to waterways especially in the marl soils. The ABC Protector exhibited slow P release, but its environmental implications should be further studied.     

Phosphorus Availability and Transformation as Affected by Repeated Phosphorus Additions in an Ultisol

Phosphorus (P) solubility and transformation in soils determine its availability to plants and loss potential to the environment, and soil P dynamics is impacted by fertilization and soil properties. A Ultisol sample was interacted with 20 mg L^?1 P solution from one to ten times. The P-reacted soils were then analyzed for water-soluble P (0.01 M calcium chloride (CaCl₂)–extractable P); plant-available P (Olsen P); ammonium chloride P, aluminum P, iron P (NH₄Cl-P, Al-P, Fe-P, respectively); and occluded P (Oc-P). The degree of P saturation (DPS) was calculated from ammonium oxalate–extractable Al, Fe, and P. The amount of P sorbed by the soil was highly correlated with the frequency of P addition with high percentage of P adsorbed initially and gradually decreased as the P addition continued. The relative abundance of the five P fractions in the P-reacted soil was in the order of Fe-P (36.5 percent) > Al-P (35.6 percent) > Oc-P (22.8 percent) > Ca-P (2.7 percent) > NH₄Cl-P (2.3 percent). Both Olsen P and CaCl₂-P were significantly increased by the repeated P addition process and highly correlated in an exponential function. The DPS was increased above the so-called critical point of 25 percent after the first P saturation process and kept increasing as the P addition continued. The P availability and adsorption in the soil were controlled by soil free and amorphous Al and Fe. The results suggest that repeated P application will build soil P to an excessive level, and consequently result in poor P-use efficiency and high P-loss potential to surface and groundwater.