Effects of plant residues and environmental factors on phosphorus availability in soils

Abstract

Phosphorus availability is a major nutritional problem in several northern Idaho soils. Traditionally, fertilizers containing P have been applied to improve availability in soils; however, organic materials added to soils have the ability to provide large quantities of labile P via mineralization processes and to reduce sorption of P. Using this concept, plant residues applied to soils would increase P availability for future plant needs. This research evaluated the effect of plant residue, incorporated into a Northern Idaho soil, on P availability under controlled laboratory conditions. Alfalfa (Medicago sativa), pea (Pisum sativum) and wheat (Triticum aestivum) plant residues were incorporated into soil collected from the Ap horizon of a Latahco silt loam (fine‐silty, mixed, frigid Argiaquic Xeric Argialboll) at rates of 0, 1, 5 and 10% (w/w). The soils were incubated at soil water potentials of ‐0.05, ‐0.15 and ‐0.40 MPa, and temperatures of 10, 20 and 30°C over a 20 week period. Soils were sampled at 2, 4, 8, 12, 16 and 20 weeks for determination of NaOAc extractable P. Data were analyzed by SAS‐GLM and Omega squared (ω²) values were used to identify the impact of each main effect and interaction. A significant 4‐factor interaction of plant residue x amendment rate x water potential x incubation time, four 3‐factor interactions, six 2‐factor interactions and four main effects were observed at each of the three incubation temperatures. Since all interactions and main effects significantly affected P availability, ω² values were used to assess their relative importance. Amendment rate was the most important factor and plant residue material was the second most important factor observed affecting extractable P levels. In general, NaOAc extractable P increased with increasing amendment rates and incubation time‐period. Increasing incubation temperature and soil water potential also positively affected the extracted P level. The greatest amount of P was mineralized from alfalfa residue material while the smallest amount was released from wheat residue. Pea residue contributed an intermediate quantity of extractable P. This study demonstrated that residues applied to northern Idaho soils have the ability to enhance P availability in addition to providing a usable N source.     

Use of Ion exchange membranes in routine soil testing

Abstract

We developed and assessed a method for simultaneous extraction of plant available nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur and potassium using anion and cation exchange membranes (ACEM). The technique was found to be highly suitable for routine soil testing due to its simplicity, rapidness and accuracy. The study compared the amount of nutrients extracted by ACEM with conventional chemical‐based extractants for P and K (0.5M NaHCO₃) and N and S (0.001M CaCl₂) for 135 soil samples representing a wide range of soil types in Western Canada. The nutrient availability predicted by ACEM was significantly correlated with the conventional methods. The correlation was not affected by the two different shaking times tested (one hour and 15 minutes), suggesting that extraction times as short as 15 minutes could be used in ACEM extraction. To evaluate the relative ability of ACEM and the conventional tests to predict actual nutrient availability to plants, canola plants were grown on soils in the growth chamber and actual plant uptake was compared to test‐predicted nutrient availability. Phosphorus and potassium uptake by canola plants was more closely correlated with ACEM extractable P and K (r²= 0.84*** and 0.54***) than with 0.5M NaHCO₃ P and K (r²= 0.70*** and 0.37***). Also, nitrogen and sulfur uptake by canola plants was significantly correlated with ACEM extractable‐NO₃ and ‐SO₄ (r² = 0.60*** and 0.70***) and with CaCl₂ extractable‐NC₃ and ‐SO₄ (r² = 0.57*** and 0.61***). Availability of all four macronutrients can be assessed in a single ACEM extraction. The higher correlation with plant uptake suggests that ACEM is a better index of macronutrient availability than conventional methods. The ACEM soil test could be readily adopted in routine soil analysis because of low cost and simplicity as well as its consistency over a wide range of soil types.     

Evaluation of Selected Extractants for Plant-Available Silicon in Rice Soils of Southern India

The extractable silicon (Si) using selected extractants irrespective of the soils used for the study was in the order of 0.005 M sulfuric acid (H₂SO₄) > 0.1 M citric acid > N sodium acetate (NaOAc) 2 > N NaOAc 1 > 0.5 M acetic acid 3 > 0.5 M acetic acid 2 > 0.5 M acetic acid 1> 0.01 M calcium chloride (CaCl₂) > 0.5 M ammonium acetate (NH4OAc) > distilled water 4 > distilled water 1. Silicon extraction with N NaOAc 1 appeared to be the most suitable for evaluating Si, followed by extraction with 0.5 M acetic acid 2 and N NaOAc 2. These extractants showed the greatest degree of significant correlation with the percentage of Si in straw and grain, as well as Si uptake by straw and grain. These methods also rapidly extract soil Si in comparison to the other methods and appear to be the most suitable for routine soil testing for plant-available Si in the rice soils of southern India.     

Extraction of soil boron for predicting its availability to plants

Abstract

Field and greenhouse studies were conducted in Prince Edward Island (P.E.I.) on soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.), red clover (Trifolium pratense L.), alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.), and rutabaga (Brassica napobrassica, Mill). Plant B concentrations were compared to soil B extracted by hot water, 0.05M HCl, 1.5M CH₃COOH, and 0.01M CaCl₂. The r values for extractable soil B versus plant B were: hot water (0.67), 0.05M HCl (0.82), 1.5M CH₃COOH (0.78), and hot 0.01M CaCl₂(0.61). Results of soil B from the 0.05M HCl extracts were generally found to give the best correlation and linear regression among the four extractants tested for predicting the B availability to plants. Overall, the 0.05M HCl proved to be the best extractant and is recommended for predicting the available B status of acid soils. The probability of error with 0.05M HCl is less since it is shaken for a fixed period of time as opposed to subjective error which could be introduced in monitoring the boiling time using hot water. Since HCl is the cheapest among the chemical extractants used it would be most suited for determining soil B in countries with poor economic resources.     

Influence of Tithonia diversifolia and triple superphosphate on dissolution and effectiveness of phosphate rock in acidic soil

An incubation and a pot experiment were conducted to evaluate the dissolution and agronomic effectiveness of a less reactive phosphate rock, Busumbu soft ore (BPR), in an Oxisol in Kenya. Resin (anion and anion + cation)‐extractable P and sequentially extracted P with 0.5 M NaHCO₃, 0.1 M NaOH, and 1 M HCl were analyzed. Dissolution was determined from the increase in anion resin (AER)–, NaHCO₃‐, and NaOH‐extractable P in soil amended with PR compared with the control soil. Where P was applied, resin P significantly increased above the no‐P treatment. Busumbu‐PR solubility was low and did not increase significantly in 16 weeks. Anion + cation (ACER)‐extractable P was generally greater than AER‐P. The difference was greater for PR than for triple superphosphate (TSP). The ACER extraction may be a better estimate of plant P availability, particularly when poorly soluble P sources are used. Addition of P fertilizers alone or in combination with Tithonia diversifolia (TSP, BPR, TSP + Tithonia, and BPR + Tithonia) increased the concentration of labile inorganic P pools (NaHCO₃‐ and NaOH‐P_i). Cumulative evolved CO₂ was significantly correlated with cumulative N mineralized from Tithonia (r, 0.51, p < 0.05). Decrease in pH caused NH ‐N accumulation while NO ‐N remained low where Tithonia was incorporated at all sampling times. However, when pH was increased, NH ‐N declined with a corresponding rise in NO ‐N. Tithonia significantly depressed soil exchangeable acidity relative to control with time. A significant increase (p < 0.05) was observed for P uptake but not dry‐mass production in maize where BPR was applied. The variations in yield and P uptake due to source and rates of application were statistically significant. At any given P rate, highest yields were obtained with Tithonia alone. Combination of Busumbu PR with TSP or Tithonia did not enhance the effectiveness of the PR. The poor dissolution and plant P uptake of BPR may be related to the high Fe content in the PR material.     

Assessment of Suitable Extractants for Predicting Plant-available Potassium in Indian Coastal Soils

The suitability of seven chemical extractants was evaluated on 24 Indian coastal soils for prediction of plant-available potassium (K) to rice (Oryza sativa L. var. NC 492) grown in modified Neubauer technique. Average amounts of soil K extracted were in descending order: 0.5 M NaHCO₃ > neutral 1 N NH₄OAc > 0.02 M CaCl₂ > Bray and Kurtz No.1 > 1 N HNO₃ > 0.1 N HNO₃ > distilled water. The highest simple correlation with plant K uptake was obtained with 0.1 N HNO₃-K (r = 0.848) and lowest with CaCl₂-K (r = 0.805). Predictive models were developed using plant K uptake as the dependent variable and extractable soil K, sand, silt, soil pH, and electrical conductivity as the independent variables. Based on the final R² and ease of measurement, distilled water, 1 N NH₄OAc, and 0.1 N HNO₃ models were the best predictors of plant-available K in coastal soils when used along with sand or soil pH.     

Effects of soil flooding on P transformations in soils of the Mesopotamia region,Argentina

In the Mesopotamia region (Argentina), rice is cropped on a wide range of soil types, and the response of rice to fertilizer application has been inconsistent even in soils with very low levels of available phosphorus. Phosphorus transformations in flooded soils depend on soil characteristics that may affect phosphorus availability. This study was conducted to determine which soil characteristics were related to the changes in P fractions during soil flooding. Soils were chosen from ten sites within the Mesopotamia region that are included in five different soil orders: Oxisols, Ultisols, Alfisols, Mollisols, and Vertisols. Soil phosphorus (P) was fractionated by a modified Hedley method before and after a 45 d anaerobic‐incubation period. Changes in the inorganic P extracted with resin depended on soil pH and were related to the exchangeable‐Fe concentration of soils (extracted with EDTA). Inorganic P extracted with alkaline extractants (NaHCO₃ and NaOH) increased due to soil flooding. This increase was related to the organic‐C (OC) percentage of soils (r² = 0.62, p < 0.01), and ranged from 13 to 55 mg kg^–1. Even though previous studies showed that P associated with poorly crystalline Fe played an important role in the P nutrition of flooded rice, in this study, there was no relationship between ammonium oxalate–extractable Fe and P changes in soils due to flooding. Our results suggest that in the Mesopotamia region, changes in P fractions due to soil flooding are related to soil OC, soil pH, and soluble and weakly adsorbed Fe.     

Transformation and bioavailability of specifically sorbed phosphate on variable-charge minerals in soils

Crop production on red soils in China is largely limited by the low availability of phosphorus, which is frequently attributed to the adsorption of phosphate by variable-charge minerals including Fe and Al oxides and kaolinite. Isotopic tracing analysis and soil incubation were carried out to investigate the desorption and microbial transformation of applied specifically sorbed P in two pH-contrasting light-textured soils. A rapid release of P from the added mineral-P surface complex in the two tested soils was observed. Most of the released P was recovered in a 0.5MNaHCO₃ extract and in soil microbial biomass. Microbial biomass-³²P was detected at early stages of incubation and reached up to 10–30% of the added ³²P. Approximately 50–70% of the added complex ³²P, varying between minerals and soils, was extractable in the 0.5MNaHCO₃ at 75 days after incubation for the acid soil but up to 120 days for the neutral soil. Microbial biomass-P plus 0.5MNaHCO₃-extractable ³²P accounted for more than 60–80% of total added complex-³²P, implying high desorption and transformation of the specifically sorbed P in the two soils. There was more inorganic ³²P than organic ³²P in the NaHCO₃ extract, suggesting that chemical release of specifically sorbed P was dominant. Ligand exchange and chemical desorption due to a change in environmental conditions such as pH and ionic strength are likely the major mechanisms responsible for the chemical release of specifically sorbed ³²P in the tested soils. Received: 29 September 1996     

Modified Soil‐Test Methods for Extractable Phosphorus in Acidic,Neutral, and Alkaline Soils

Abstract

Although numerous soil‐test methods for estimating extractable phosphorus (P) have been developed around the world, their results are difficult to compare because of the very different scale levels used. In the present study, the Bray–Kurtz method (Bray‐P) is used as a reference value. Two other methods [lactate‐P and sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO₃)‐P] were modified to facilitate the comparison of extractable‐P determinations, mainly by adjusting the shaking time. These three methods were applied to 101 soil samples from an extensive region of Argentina with soil pH values ranging from 5.5 to 8.5. The results confirm that the Bray‐P and the two modified methods (lactate‐P and NaHCO₃‐P) determine similar contents of extractable P but are not applicable to all types of soils and conditions. Equations that minimize the statistical error were selected for soil properties such as organic carbon (OC) content, pH, soluble salts, and calcium carbonate content. Correlation coefficients between Bray‐P and NaHCO₃‐P increased to 0.91 and 0.95 in soils with high and low OC levels, respectively. It was also demonstrated that the lactate‐P test is not suitable for soils rich in calcium carbonate or soluble salts. These two modified methods are expected to be useful for testing P values that impact agricultural production.     

Performance indices for tests of soil nutrient status: Extractable phosphorus

Abstract

Soil phosphorus (P) extractants are often selected according to the correlation or regression between test values and crop performance (e.g., P uptake and/ or yield). Although this criterion is an essential determinant of extractant performance, it is often inadequate for evaluating whether extractants accurately discriminate between P‐deficient and P‐sufficient soils, or whether they produce reliable critical level estimates or repeatable soil P measurements. Four supplementary indices were evaluated that may provide a more direct assessment of extractant performance. The potential use and reliability of the indices were investigated in an evaluation of four soil P extractants, Modified Truog, Mehlich 3, Olsen, and ion‐exchange resin, using data from a greenhouse experiment. Coefficients of determination between relative dry matter yield and extractable P failed to identify differences among the extractants, ranging from 0.95 to 0.97. Coefficients of determination between extractable P and P added ranged from 0.96 to 0.97 except for one method at 0.83. The proposed indices, however, produced a ranking of the extractants related to their performance. The Kappa efficiency (K _EFF) index indicated that Mehlich 3 provided better detection of P‐sufficient and P‐deficient soils than either Olsen or Truog (K _FFF values of 0.92, 0.83, and 0.68, respectively). These index values reflect that the extradants correctly detected P deficiency in 17 of 18, 17 of 18, and 15 of 18 soils. The slight superiority of Mehlich 3 over Olsen was due to its correct detection of 9 of 9 P‐sufficient soils while the Olsen and Truog extradants correctly detected 8 of 9 P‐sufficient soils. Further studies are needed, especially field studies, to determine whether these indices accurately reflect the reliability of the extradants for use in diagnosis and recommendation. Because these indices directly assess success in identifying deficient and sufficient conditions, their use in extractant evaluations should provide more specific, purposeful evaluations than methods based solely on correlation and regression.     

Anion‐exchange membrane,water, and sodium bicarbonate extractions as soil tests for phosphorus

Abstract

Three techniques were evaluated as soil P tests for western Canadian soils: anion‐exchange membrane (AEM), water, and bicarbonate extraction. The AEM, water, and bicarbonate‐extractable total P represented novel approaches to compare to the widely used bicarbonate‐extractable inorganic P (traditional Olsen) soil test. In a range of Saskatchewan soils, similar trends in predicted relative P availability were observed for AEM, water extraction, bicarbonate‐extractable total P, and bicarbonate‐extractable organic P. Correlations between soil test values revealed AEM and water‐extractable P to be most closely correlated, consistent with the similar manner of P removal in the two tests.

Phosphorus availability, as predicted by the tests, was compared to actual P uptake by canola and wheat grown on 14 soils in a growth chamber experiment. P uptake by canola was highly correlated with AEM (r² = 0.86–0.90), water (0.87 ‐0.94), and bicarbonate‐extractable total (0.91) and inorganic (0.92) P. Uptake of P by wheat was not quite as highly correlated with test‐predicted values: AEM (r² = ‐0.73–0.78), water (0.72–0.77), bicarbonate total (0.82), bicarbonate‐inorganic P (0.75).

The similarity in coefficients of determination among test methods indicated nearly identical abilities of the tests to predict soil P availability in the range of soils examined. The AEM and water extractions, unlike bicarbonate, are largely independent of soil type and may prove superior when a wider range of soils is being tested. Bicarbonate‐extractable total P and water‐extractable P suffer limitations in analytical simplicity and cost. In testing for P alone, AEM was considered superior to the other methods due to low cost, simplicity, independence of soil type, and high correlation with plant uptake.     

Sulfuric acid effects on iron and phosphorus availability in two calcareous soils

An attempt was made to study the effects of sulfuric acid additions to iron (Fe)‐ and phosphorus (P)‐deficient calcareous soils. Several greenhouse experiments were conducted with sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.) grown in two calcareous soils. Addition of sulfuric acid to soils increased soil acidity, salinity, DTPA‐extractable Fe, available P (NaHCO₃‐extractable), and crop yield. The change in soil pH is the primary cause of increased nutrient availability and thus crop yield. Leaching after acid application is highly beneficial in decreasing salinity during germination and seedling stages and therefore has a direct impact on the yield. The beneficial effects of acid carried over for at least two greenhouse cropping seasons (approximately 4.5 months).     

Organic amendments differ in their effect on microbial biomass and activity and on P pools in alkaline soils

Organic amendments could be used as alternative to inorganic P fertilisers, but a clear understanding of the relationship among type of P amendment, microbial activity and changes in soil P fractions is required to optimise their use. Two P-deficient soils were amended with farmyard manure (FYM), poultry litter (PL) and biogenic waste compost (BWC) at 10 g?dw?kg^?1 soil and incubated for 72 days. Soil samples were collected at days 0, 14, 28, 56 and 72 and analysed for microbial biomass C, N and P, 0.5 M NaHCO₃ extractable P and activity of dehydrogenase and alkaline phosphomonoesterase. Soil P fractions were sequentially extracted in soil samples collected at days 0 and 72. All three amendments increased cumulative CO₂ release, microbial biomass C, N and P and activity of dehydrogenase and alkaline phosphomonoesterase compared to unamended soils. The increase in microbial biomass C and N was highest with PL, whereas the greatest increase in microbial biomass P was induced with FYM. All three biomass indices showed the same temporal pattern, with the highest values on day 14 and the lowest on day 72. All amendments increased 0.5 M NaHCO₃ extractable P concentrations with the smallest increase with BWC and the greatest with FYM, although more P was added with PL than with FYM. Available P concentrations decreased over time in the amended soils. Organic amendments increased the concentration of the labile P pools (resin and NaHCO₃-P) and of NaOH-P, but had little effect on the concentrations of acid-soluble P pools and residual P except for increasing the concentration of organic P in the concentrated HCl pool. Resin P and NaHCO₃-P_i pools decreased over time whereas NaOH-P_i and all organic P pools increased. It is concluded that organic amendments can provide P to plants and can stimulate the build-up of organic P forms in soils which may provide a long-term slow-release P source for plants and soil organisms.     

Comparison of EDTA and ammonium Bicarbonate-DTPA for the extraction of phosphorus in calcareous soils from Kerman,Iran

Developing a fast and reliable soil testing method is critical for improving soil testing efficiency and ensuring reliable fertilizer recommendation. The objectives of this study were to evaluate sodium ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid (Na₂-EDTA) as a replacement for ammonium bicarbonate-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (AB-DTPA) to extract phosphorus (P) to determinate the relationships between extractable P and its uptake by crop in calcareous soils. Na₂-EDTA and AB-DTPA was compared by the amounts of extracted P by analyzing soil samples collected from agricultural production areas. There were significant correlations between Na₂-EDTA and AB-DTPA for soil test P based on soils collected from the agricultural field. Soil test P by both extractants was significantly correlated with plant P concentration. Na₂-EDTA was identified as an alternate improved extraction method instead of AB-DTPA in calcareous soils based on this study. However, more work will be needed to identify the correlation of the two extractants and crop responses under a field condition.     

Pressurized Hot Water and DTPA‐Sorbitol as Viable Alternatives for Soil Boron Extraction. II. Correlation of Soil Extraction to Responses of Boron‐Fertilized Alfalfa

Abstract

Pressurized hot water and DTPA‐Sorbitol are two relatively new, proposed alternative soil boron (B) extraction methods for which no data on yield or plant nutrient uptake have been reported for validation. Both methods initially have shown significant correlation with the hot water extraction method in untreated soils as well as soils incubated with various levels of B. The objective of the research was to extract samples of B‐treated soils by using all three extraction methods and correlate the B values obtained to yield, B tissue concentration, and total B removal of alfalfa (Medicago sativa). Greenhouse and field experiments on alkaline and limed acid soils naturally low in hot water‐extractable B were conducted to test alfalfa response to B fertilizer. In the greenhouse, highly significant relationships exist between plant uptake and extractable B with all three methods at varying levels of applied B, but no alfalfa yield response was observed. All three methods result in accurate predictions of plant B tissue concentrations and total B removal. The field experiment exhibited a significant positive relationship between total alfalfa yield and extractable B using hot water and pressurized hot water extractions. Extractable B using DTPA‐Sorbitol was not related to total alfalfa yield in the field experiment. This work, coupled with the earlier incubation studies, supports the pressurized hot water extraction method as an improvement over hot water in diverse soil types. The lack of relationship in the acid soil supports DTPA‐Sorbitol as an improvement over hot water in alkaline soils.     

Phosphorus availability and sorption under alternating waterlogged and drying conditions

Abstract

The effect of alternating waterlogged and drying conditions on phosphorus (P) availability and sorption was studied in three soils of contrasting chemical and physical properties. Soils were treated with two levels of P (0 and 50 mg kg^‐1; P0 and P50), waterlogged for 21 days, then allowed to dry at room temperature for 14 days. The availability of P, iron (Fe), and manganese (Mn) over the waterlogged and drying periods was determined by shaking samples of each soil with 1M NaOAc (pH 3). Increasing concentrations of 1M NaOAc (pH 3) extractable P (P_ac) over the waterlogged period was attributed to solubilization of Fe(OH)₃ materials under reducing conditions with the release of sorbed and occluded P. The released P appeared to be resorbed by freshly precipitated amorphous Fe(OH)₂ material since earlier studies showed that water soluble P concentrations in these soils were reduced to negligible levels under waterlogged conditions. The Fe(OH)₂ material remained readily extractable with 1M NaOAc (pH 3) since Fe_ac increased dramatically with waterlogging. Drying the waterlogged soils caused a rapid decrease in P_ac, Fe_ac and Mn_ac suggesting the Fe(OH)₂ may have been transformed into more stable forms [e.g., Fe(OH)₃]. Much of the changes in P_ac appeared to be due to changes in Fe_ac, with limited influence from Mn_ac. and mineralization of organic P. Phosphate sorption isotherms were determined using the standard batch technique for air‐dry, waterlogged (with and without ponded water), and waterlogged/dried conditions. Sorption isotherms were not affected by waterlogging and subsequent drying. Most soils sorbed all of the added phosphate irrespective of moisture treatment.     

EFFECT OF VESICULAR-ARBUSCULAR MYCORRHIZAL FUNGI ON THE RELATIONS OF PLANT GROWTH, INTERNAL PHOSPHORUS CONCENTRATION AND SOIL PHOSPHATE ANALYSES

The effect of infection by vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhiza on the predictive value of soil analysis for available P was tested in a glasshouse experiment. Leeks (Allium porrum) were grown on ten Rothamsted soils with a wide range of initial NaHCO₃-soluble P, each of which also received 5 levels of added P. Soils were partially sterilized with 1 Mrad of γ-radiation, or left untreated; plants on sterilized soil were infected with yellow-vacuolate endophyte (Glomus mosseae) or left non-mycorrhizal. The NaHCO₃-soluble P in the soils was measured 5 days after phosphate addition. Yields from all P levels on all soils were plotted against soil NaHCO₃-soluble P content and separate smooth response curves were obtained for non-infected and artificially-infected plants. Infection increased yield only on soils with less than 100 mg P kg^?1. In contrast, naturally-infected plants gave no clearly defined response curve to P, and on three soils the yields were consistently low. These soils gave very low natural infections and had low spore densities probably due to the cropping history of the sites. Artificially-infected plants had much higher shoot P concentrations than did uninfected plants of similar dry weight, over a large range of soil phosphate levels; this effect was also noted with the endophyte G. fasciculatus. Naturally-infected plants showed a poor relationship between shoot P concentration and yield.     

Plant availability of two phosphate rock materials in acid Malaysian soils

Abstract

The amount of phosphorus (P) dissolved in a closed‐incubation system, in soils receiving Christmas Island grade‐A phosphate rock (CIPR), Gafsa phosphate rock (GPR), and triple superphosphate (TSP), as measured by extraction with 0.5M NaHCO₃ (APb) or 0.5M NaOH (AP) and expressed as ?Pb/?P*100 (PDP) was compared to P uptake (?Ps) by Setaria in a glasshouse experiment. There was no direct relationship between APs and PDP for CIPR, GPR, and TSP added at 50 and 150 mgP/kg soil to three Malaysian soils (Bungor, Kundor, and Segamat) during a 10‐month period. Averaged across soils, rate of addition, and P sources, ?Ps was 17% higher than PDP. Overestimation of PDP by ?Ps could be due to the ability of the roots of Setaria to use more of the P which is dissolved from the three P sources and then chemisorbed, than can be extracted by the NaHCO₃ reagent. The chemisorbed P pool is extractable using 0.5M NaOH. There was a close relationship between ?Ps and ?P, with a correlation coefficient of 0.85**. Residual P, determined by Pb method after each harvest, successfully predicted Ps by Setaria in the subsequent harvest with correlation coefficients varying between 0.74* and 0.99** for CIPR, GPR, and TSP in five soils (Bungor, Durian, Kundor, Segamat, and Tok Yong). The critical Pb values ranged from 5 for Durian to 10 mgP/kg soil for Kundor.     

Comparison of Multi-element to Single‐Element Extractants for Macro‐ and Micronutrients in Acid Soils from Spain

Abstract

Different chemical reagents are used to assess plant‐available nutrients from soils with similar properties. The use of different extractants is a serious limitation when comparing results between different soil‐testing laboratories, often leading to large differences in fertilizer recommendations for similar crops.

In this study, 80 samples from acid soils from Galicia (Spain) were used to compare several soil nutrient extractants. Traditional and tested extractants for acid soil such as Bray 2 and ammonium acetate were used to evaluate multielement extractants such as ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid–ammonium acetate (EDTA‐aa), ammonium bicarbonate–diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (AB‐DTPA), and Mehlich 3.

Linear regression analyses were performed to relate the amount of each nutrient obtained by traditional soil extractants to the amount obtained by multielement extractants. Strong correlation was found between extractable Bray 2 P and Mehlich 3 P (r²=0.97, slope=0.87, and intercept=?0.48). The slope of the regression line between EDTA‐aa‐extractable calcium (Ca) and that from ammonium acetate (Aa) approached 1∶1 (r²=0.86). Similar results were obtained for magnesium (Mg) (r²=0.99). Soil zinc (Zn) concentrations extracted by Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa were similar; slope of the regression line was 0.95 (r²=0.88). With regard to copper (Cu), Mehlich 3 extracted approximately 20% more Cu than EDTA‐aa.

The results showed that Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa are suitable for assessment of plant available phosphorus (P), potassium (K), Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn, and iron (Fe) in acid soils.     

Evaluation of extractants for predicting availability of sulphur to mustard in inceptisols

Abstract

Mustard (Brassica juncea) is an important oilseed crop of northern India, which is widely grown in Delhi and adjoining States. This crop has a relatively high requirement of sulphur (S), and is sensitive to S‐deficiency. For predicting response of mustard to S application, several extractants have been tried with variable results. Since selection of a promising extractant for a particular soil needs careful consideration, the present investigation was planned to select the most promising extractant to predict the availability of S to mustard grown on Inceptisols of Delhi. For this purpose, a greenhouse experiment was conducted with twenty soils (two from each often important soil series from the cultivated alluvial soil belt of Delhi. Nine extractants, commonly used for estimating the availability of S, were evaluated and S in soil extract and in plant digest was estimated using the turbiditimetric method. The results indicate that the phosphate salt methods extracted comparatively more S than other extractants. The amount of S extracted by these extractants was found in the following order: KH₂PO₄‐500 ppm P>Ca(H₂PO₄)₂‐500 ppm P>0.001 M HCl>NaOAc+HOAc>heat soluble S>0.15% CaCl₂>l% NaCl> water soluble S>NH₄OAc+HOAc. Simple correlation coefficients of the amounts of S extracted by different extractants and the forms of S with the plant parameters were worked out. To determine the combined effect of soil characteristics on S extraction by different extractants, stepwise multiple regression analysis was carried out. Based on this study, the suitability of the extractants for mustard crops in Inceptisols of Delhi may be arranged as follows: 0.15% CaCl₂>water soluble S>0.001 M HCl>Ca(H₂PO₄)₂‐500 ppm>1%NaCl>NH₄OAc+HOAc>NaOAc+HOAc>KH₂PO₄‐500 ppm P>heat soluble S.