Multielement Extraction from Southern Brazilian Soils

To evaluate the effectiveness of multielement extraction of Mehlich 1 and Mehlich 3 solutions in soils from southern Brazil, correlation studies are needed. The amounts of phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), copper (Cu), and zinc (Zn) extracted with Mehlich 1 solution, 1.0 M potassium chloride (KCl), and 0.1 M hydrochloric acid (HCl) for representative soil types of the Rio Grande do Sul state (Brazil) were compared with those extracted with Mehlich 3 solution. The amount of nutrients extracted with different methods indicated high correlation coefficients. On average, Mehlich 3 solution extracted greater amounts of P (50%) and K (20%) than Mehlich 1 solution. Calcium amounts extracted with all solutions were similar. Magnesium amounts extracted with Mehlich 3 solution were on average 20% less than the amounts extracted with 1.0 M KCl solution. Mehlich 3 solution extracted similar amounts of Cu as the 0.1 M HCl but lesser amounts of Zn. Simultaneous multielement soil-test methods such as Mehlich 1 and Mehlich 3 solutions are efficient in soils from southern Brazil and are a feasible alternative to improving the efficiency of soil-testing laboratories.     

Phosphorus Availability to Corn and Soybean Evaluated by Three Soil-Test Methods for Southern Brazilian Soils

To select and evaluate the effectiveness of multi-element soil-test methods for extracting plant-available phosphorus (P), correlation studies are needed. Under natural conditions, corn (Zea mays L.) and soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] were sequentially cultivated in 9-L microplots for 45 days to determine the amount of P that would be absorbed from 49 diverse soils of Rio Grande do Sul State in southern Brazil. Before planting, soil P was extracted with Mehlich 1 solution, Mehlich 3 solution, and ion- exchange resin. The abilities of Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, and resin to extract plant-available P were then compared. The coefficients of determination obtained between plant P and the amounts extracted by Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, and resin were 0.59, 0.45, and 0.59, respectively, for corn and 0.57, 0.57, and 0.52 for soybean. Soil P extracted by the three methods was highly correlated; however, the amount of P extracted by the methods was affected by the clay content of the soils. As the clay content increased, the amount of P extracted by the resin also increased, whereas P extracted by the Mehlich 3 solution decreased. Because soil clay content influences extractable P values, soil clay classes are needed to properly calibrate soil P status and fertilizer recommendations for corn and soybean grown on these soils.     

Soil Phosphorus Extracted by Bray 1 and Mehlich 3 Soil Tests as Affected by the Soil/Solution Ratio in Mollisols

Different relationships between soil-test methods results have been reported in several agricultural regions. Differences in the same soil-test procedure (e.g., soil/solution ratio) exist between soil-testing laboratories from different agricultural regions. Our objectives were to (1) determine the effect of soil/solution ratio on the amount of phosphorus removed by Bray 1 and Mehlich 3 methods, (2) compare the amounts of phosphorus removed by Bray 1 and Mehlich 3 in Mollisols from the Pampean region, and (3) determine whether soil/solution ratio affects the relationship between Bray 1 and Mehlich 3. Soil phosphorus availability was determined with two extractants (Bray 1 and Mehlich 3), using two soil/solution ratios (1:10 and 1:8, wt/v) in 72 soils (noncalcareous, loess-derived Molisolls) from the Pampean region. The amount of phosphorus removed was 20–24% greater when using 1:10 than 1:8 (wt/v) soil/solution ratio. This effect was significantly greater in Bray 1 than in Mehlich 3 (p = 0.04). When compared using the same soil/solution ratio, Mehlich 3 removed 4 to 8% more phosphorus than Bray 1. The soil/solution ratio used in the comparison affected the relationship between both extractants. The difference between extractants was slightly greater with a soil/solution ratio of 1:8 than of 1:10 (p = 0.03). Our results showed that even when using the same method, changes in the procedure (like soil/solution ratio) may cause different soil-test results and also differences in the relationship between two extracting solutions. Therefore, reported relationships between two methods are only valid for the soils and region where the relationship was developed and should not be extrapolated to other regions, even with similar soils.     

Determination of Soil Feature Effects on Plant-Available Phosphorus Extraction using Response Surface and Cate–Nelson Methodology

In this study, four soil extraction methods (Olsen, Soltanpour, Mehlich 3, and water saturation) were used to identify optimal concentrations of phosphorus (P) required for plant growth. Olsen soil extraction for P was the most appropriate method for soil types of this study as the greatest correlation coefficient for soil-test P and with plant factors was achieved. The optimal amount of soil features (pH, organic carbon, lime, gypsum, and clay) determined by using response surface methodology (a new optimization method) were 7.49, 0.66, 41.82, 4.21, and 31.34, respectively. More soil P was extracted when the soil had optimal amounts of these features, showing each feature had a significant effect on extracted soil P. Furthermore, the graphical method of Cate–Nelson determined the optimal amounts of P using Olsen, Soltanpour, Mehlich 3, and saturation extract methods for wheat as 15, 6.5, 35, and 1.5 mg kg^?1 soil in nongypsic soils and 17, 3.5, 45, and 2.5 mg kg^?1 soil in gypsic soils.     

Comparison of extractable phosphorus from two sulfuric acid methods with the Mehlich phosphorus test number one

Abstract

All mineral phosphates in soil dissolve more completely when HCl is mixed with H₂SO₄ than with the HCl alone. It was hypothesized that a new extracting solution of H₂SO₄ alone with the same ionic strength or the same acidity as the Mehlich P1 extractant would extract similar amounts of soil phosphorus (P) as the Mehlich P1 soil test. Thirty six acid soils from Alabama, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Colorado were used in this study. These acid soils reflect wide ranges in parent materials, texture, pH, organic matter, and available soil P. They were analyzed for available soil P with the Mehlich P1 soil test and with the two H₂SO₄ methods: Method A has an extracting solution of same ionic strength (0.0875M) as the Mehlich P1 extractant, and Method B was an extracting solution of the same acidity (0.0375M) as the Mehlich P1 extractant. Correlations between the results of Mehlich P1 with Method A and Method B were 0.994 and 0.997, respectively. The measured test precision was <3.5% for all three methods. The new H₂SO₄ methods are simple and faster to conduct under routine operations than the original Mehlich P1 extractant, and because of the high correlations, the H₂SO₄ methods should predict crop response to P as well as the original Mehlich P1 extractant for acid soils.     

Phosphorus Fertilizer Calibration for Sugarcane on Everglades Histosols

A calibrated soil test for phosphorus (P) fertilizer application to sugarcane (Saccharum spp.) grown on organic soils in southern Florida is an important best-management practice for minimizing P loads in water draining to the Everglades. The current calibration uses water as the soil extractant, which has the limitations of being very sensitive to pH and being most applicable to short-season crops. Phosphorus fertilizer rate studies at six locations (20 total crop years) were analyzed to develop an updated soil-test P calibration for sugarcane on organic soils. Phosphorus extracted with water, acetic acid, and Bray 2 did not consistently relate well to crop response. A new P soil-test calibration for sugarcane is proposed based on Mehlich 3 soil extraction, with a maximum rate of 36 kg P ha^?1 with ≤ 10 g P m^?3 in preplant soil samples and no P recommended with >30 g P m^?3.     

土壤中磷、钾、钙、镁的同时提取以及对巴西南部作物的钾肥推荐

Simultaneous multi-element extraction has been increasing worldwide to improve soil laboratory testing quality and effciency. This study sought to investigate the applicability of the Mehlich-1, Mehlich-3, and resin methods for simultaneous extraction of soil available P, K, Ca, and Mg as well as the effect of using conversion equations on nutrient recommendations for crops. Topsoil (0-20 cm) samples were taken from the most representative soil types used for crop production in southern Brazil with a wide range of chemical, physical, and mineralogical properties. Soil P, K, Ca, and Mg were simultaneously extracted using 1.0 mol L-1 KCl, Mehlich-1 and Mehlich-3 solutions, and membrane resin. The amounts of P extracted with the Mehlich-1 method were, on average, 50% lower than those extracted with the resin and Mehlich-3 methods. However, the resin method extracted the lowest amounts of K, Ca, and Mg. The use of conversion equations was suitable and it did not a?ect negatively the K recommendations for crops grown on soils of southern Brazil.     

Evaluation of an anion‐exchange membrane for extracting plant available phosphorus in soils

Abstract

Anion‐exchange resins (AER) have been used to determine plant available phosphorus (P) since the fifties and their results have shown strong relationships with plant growth and P uptake irrespective of soil properties. However, this procedure is still not widely used by laboratories because of difficulties in handling resin beads under routine conditions. New kinds and different shapes of resins are being produced each with specific characteristics that must be evaluated before use in laboratory procedures. Thus the objective of this work was to evaluate an AER manufactured in membranes reinforced with a Modacrylic fabric. These anion‐exchange membrane (AEM) sheets are commercially available, making them suitable for soil testing. The membranes were cut in pieces (1.0×7.5 cm) identified as AEM‐strips. The AEM‐strips were soaked in 0.5M HCl for a few days and transferred, after being rinsed with deionized water (DI), to 0.5M NaHCO₃ to convert them to HCO₃ ^‐ form. The AEM‐strips and resin beads in nylon bags recovered 98.4 and 98.0% of the P content in an aqueous P solution, respectively. Three eluent solutions were evaluated with different shaking times. The 0.1M H₂SO₄ and 1.0M NaCl in 0.1M HCl were equally suitable for the molybdenum blue color development without any pH adjustment, while the pH of the 0.5M HCl was too low. The elution of P from the AEM‐strips was independent of time with a 15‐min shaking being adequate for removal of all P from the strips. A comparison of soil sample preparation demonstrated that it was not necessary to vigorously grind or sieve the soil to improve the repeatability of the results. The AEM‐strips were compared with other methods (Pi impregnated filter paper, Mehlich I and Bray 1) using 32 soils from Guatemala with widely varying physico‐chemical and mineralogical properties. Phosphorus extracted by the AEM and Pi procedures (similar principle) were highly correlated and gave similar results irrespective of soil type. The acid extraction (Mehlich I and Bray 1 methods) attacked soil components (apatites) resulting in higher and inconsistent amounts of P extracted which may not be available to plants; the correlation between these methods within soils of similar properties was good, but when all soils were considered together the relationship was not significant. This demonstrated that the acid extraction method for P is not suitable for soils containing apatites, while those based on a sink for P (AEM and Pi) can be applied irrespective of the type of soil.     

Extraction Methods for Phosphorus and Their Relationship with Soils Phosphorus‐Buffer Capacity Estimated by the Remaining‐Phosphorus Methodology‐A Pot Study with Maize

Abstract

This work aimed to calibrate Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, Bray 1, Olsen, and ion‐exchange resin extraction methods with maize phosphorus (P) responses in a pot study with lowland and upland soils with different P‐buffer capacities and to evaluate whether the calibration can be enhanced through the knowledge of remaining P. The experimental design was completely randomized with four replications in a factorial arrangement involving five P concentrations and four lowland or seven upland soils. The remaining P for each soil was determined, P‐buffer capacity was estimated, and the soils were grouped according to the results. Correlation coefficients showed that the remaining P is strongly dependent on clay and soil organic‐matter content, and its determination was useful to the evaluation of the extractants. The classification and grouping of soils according to their P‐buffer capacity improved the correlations between extracted P and plant response for Mehlich 1 and Bray 1 extractants. The Mehlich 3, Olsen, and resin methods presented better performances, independent of soil grouping.     

Application of low‐phosphorus‐containing legume residues reduces extractable phosphorus in a tropical Ultisol

Application of legume green manure (GM) is suggested to be effective in increasing the availability of native soil phosphorus (P) and the dissolution and utilization of phosphate rock (PR)‐P by food crops. Experiments were conducted to study the dynamics of extractable P (P extracted by Bray‐1‐extracting solution) of an Ultisol amended with or without GM residues of contrasting P concentrations in the absence of growing plants. In two separate experiments, GM residues of Aschynomene afraspera (a flood‐tolerant legume) and of Crotalaria micans (upland) with varying P concentrations were added to an acidic soil amended with PR‐P or triple superphosphate (TSP) in plastic bottles. Soil moisture was brought to field capacity of the soil in the upland experiment and saturated with distilled water in the lowland setup. This was done to simulate aerobic upland and anaerobic lowland soil conditions in the relevant plastic bottles. Only P concentration of the residues added varied, while lignin and C : N ratios were similar. A temperature of 25°C was maintained throughout the experiment. Changes in soil extractable Bray‐1‐P were measured at the end of the incubation period (60 or 80 d). In the aerobic soils, extractable P in the combined PR+GM or TSP+GM treatments was significantly lower than in the PR‐ or TSP‐ treated soils. The amendment with GM residues alone significantly increased Bray‐1‐P over the unamended control in the case of the inorganic P‐fertilized GM residues. The trend in extractable P was similar in the soils incubated under anaerobic conditions. However, in the case of PR, concentrations of P extracted by Bray‐1 solution did not significantly change in the presence or absence of GM. The results suggest that the incorporation of GM residues with low P concentration does not lead to a net P release in upland or lowland soils. These results have implications for nutrient cycling in farming systems in W Africa as most of the soils are poor and very low in available P.     

Addition of phosphorus to soils with low to medium phosphorus retention capacities. II. effect on soil phosphorus extractability

Abstract

Knowledge of the change in soil extractable phosphorus (P) as a consequence of soil P fertilization could be useful in discriminating soils with a potential for soil P release to runoff or movement of P along the soil profile. In this research, soils with low to medium P retention capacity were equilibrated for 90 days with soluble P (KH₂PO₄) at rate of 100 mg P kg^‐1 soil. After this period, soil samples both with and without the P addition were analyzed using six conventional methods: 1) Olsen, 2) Bray 1,3) Mehlich3,4) Egner, 5) Houba, dilute CaCl₂ solution, and 6) distilled water, and three “innovative”; P‐sink methodologies: 1) Fe oxide‐coated paper strip, 2) anion exchange resin membrane, and 3) cation‐anion exchange resin membrane. The soils without P addition had low levels of extracted P as determined by all nine procedures. Net increases in the amount of P extracted from the soils with added P ranged from 4.2 mg kg^‐1 (CaCl₂ extraction) to 57.6 mg kg^‐1 (cation‐anion resin membrane extraction). Relationships between change in extracted P and i) physical and chemical characteristics, and ii) soil P sorption properties are also presented and discussed.     

Comparisons of phosphorus availability between anion exchange resin and mehlich‐1 extractions among Oxisols with different capacity factors

Abstract

Acid and dilute‐salt chemical extractants are commonly used to assess and adjust phosphorus (P) availability in soils. Soybean was grown for 45 days under greenhouse conditions on samples of 10 Oxisols treated with variable levels of soluble P to compare critical soil P levels between an anion exchange resin (AER) and the Mehlich‐1 extractant, and to evaluate the influence of the soil P capacity factor (PCF) on the critical soil P levels. Variation among soils in the quantities of extracted P and critical P levels with the AER was less than that with Mehlich‐1. Low correlation values between soil characteristics related to PCF and measurements of AER soil P suggested that the AER method was not as sensitive to variations in soil PCF as Mehlich‐1. Interpretations of AER critical P levels, therefore, do not need auxiliary measures of PCF as with the Mehlich‐1 extractant. The reverse was true, however, for P uptake. Therefore, the criteria used to assess plant response to P (P uptake or dry matter production) in soils with variable PCF will influence the results obtained in correlations between methods used to extract soil P.     

Comparison of phosphate rock and triple superphosphate on a phosphorus‐deficient Kenyan soil

Abstract

Soil phosphorus (P) deficiency is a constraint to crop production in many regions of sub‐Saharan Africa, which could be overcome through use of either soluble P fertilizer or sufficiently reactive phosphate rock (PR). A field study was conducted with corn (Zea mays L.) for three growing seasons (18 months) on a P‐deficient, acid soil in Kenya to compare a soluble P source (triple superphosphate, TSP) and relatively reactive Minjingu PR from Tanzania. In the 18 months following application of 250 kg P ha^‐1, bicarbonate extractable inorganic soil P (P_i) was higher for application of TSP than PR, but Pi extracted with a mixed anion‐cation resin was comparable for TSP and PR. Inorganic P extracted by 0.1M NaOH, without prior extraction of resin and bicarbonate P_i, decreased during the 18 months following TSP application, but increased following PR application. After 18 months, about 7% of the added PR‐P remained as Ca‐bound P that was extracted with 1M HCl. The 1M HCl extractable P., however, underestimated residual PR‐P that gradually dissolved and supplied plant‐available P, as indicated by recovery of <40% of PR‐P added to soil in laboratory incubations even though PR solubility in HCl was >90%. Minjingu PR was an effective source of P for corn. Corn yields were comparable for TSP and PR, and the relative agronomic effectiveness of PR averaged 107% in Season 1 and 79% in Season 3. Anion resin and mixed anion‐cation resin appeared to be superior to bicarbonate and NaOH as a soil P test for use with both TSP‐ and PR‐treated soils.     

In Situ Soil Phosphorus Monitoring Probe Compared with Conventional Extraction Procedures

In this work, selective chemical sensors of phosphorus (PO₄ ^3?) installed in PVC probes and their associated instrumentation were evaluated in soil solution phosphorous monitoring. The evaluation was carried out with the addition of a 0.1 mol L^?1 P‐PO₄ ^3? solution in the soil, followed by data acquisition supplied by the probes; by collecting soil samples in the region where the probes were installed; and by phosphorus determination through conventional laboratory techniques. The phosphorus amounts were determined by spectrophotometry after the following extraction methodologies: Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, and ionic exchange resin. The results, compared with the potentials registered by the probes, express the best correlation with the results obtained with the resin method. The results indicate good response of the sensors and the potential applicability of these probes to assist in the monitoring of soil nutrients, helping to establish rational processes in the use of fertilizers in crops.     

Correlation of solution and extractable phosphorus with vegetative growth of teff

Abstract

Three soils, Hiwassee loam (clayey, kaolinitic, thermic, Typic Rhodudults), Vaiden clay (very fine, montmorillonitic, thermic, Vertic Hapludalfs) and Marvyn sand (fine, loamy, siliceous, thermic, Typic Hapludults), were used in this study. Phosphorus sorption and desorption isotherms of the soils were determined in the laboratory. Average P sorption maximum (b) was calculated using the Langmuir isotherm equation. Based on the P sorption capacity, each soil was fertilized with different P rates and teff [Eragrostis tef (Zucc)] was grown in the greenhouse. The amount of P sorbed and desorbed increased as the concentration of equilibrating solution P increased. Phosphorus sorption maximum from sorption and desorption isotherms was 278, 251, and 37 mg P/kg for Hiwassee, Vaiden, and Marvyn soils, respectively, and for maximum dry matter yield of teff the soils needed a minimum of 0.029, 0.048, and 0.065 mg/L soil solution P, respectively, which were all below the soil solution P at P adsorption maximum.

Soil P was extracted by the Mehlich I, Mehlich III, modified Mississippi, Bray P‐l and Olsen methods. Plant‐available P extracted by each of the five methods was significantly correlated with teff dry matter yield, and statistically any of the five methods can be used as the basis for predicting teff yield responses.     

Comparison of Multi-element to Single‐Element Extractants for Macro‐ and Micronutrients in Acid Soils from Spain

Abstract

Different chemical reagents are used to assess plant‐available nutrients from soils with similar properties. The use of different extractants is a serious limitation when comparing results between different soil‐testing laboratories, often leading to large differences in fertilizer recommendations for similar crops.

In this study, 80 samples from acid soils from Galicia (Spain) were used to compare several soil nutrient extractants. Traditional and tested extractants for acid soil such as Bray 2 and ammonium acetate were used to evaluate multielement extractants such as ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid–ammonium acetate (EDTA‐aa), ammonium bicarbonate–diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (AB‐DTPA), and Mehlich 3.

Linear regression analyses were performed to relate the amount of each nutrient obtained by traditional soil extractants to the amount obtained by multielement extractants. Strong correlation was found between extractable Bray 2 P and Mehlich 3 P (r²=0.97, slope=0.87, and intercept=?0.48). The slope of the regression line between EDTA‐aa‐extractable calcium (Ca) and that from ammonium acetate (Aa) approached 1∶1 (r²=0.86). Similar results were obtained for magnesium (Mg) (r²=0.99). Soil zinc (Zn) concentrations extracted by Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa were similar; slope of the regression line was 0.95 (r²=0.88). With regard to copper (Cu), Mehlich 3 extracted approximately 20% more Cu than EDTA‐aa.

The results showed that Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa are suitable for assessment of plant available phosphorus (P), potassium (K), Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn, and iron (Fe) in acid soils.     

Evaluation of Mehlich 3 extractant for estimating phosphorus deficiency and phosphorus sorption of Zimbabwean soils

Abstract

The Mehlich 3 extractant was compared with the resin method for its ability to predict the phosphorus (P) status of Zimbabwean soils. Correlation of P extraction between the two methods and with plant growth was found to vary with soil texture. Because the Mehlich 3 extractant was less influenced by texture, it was better able to predict the P status over a wide range of soil types. The Mehlich 3 extractant correctly predicted P deficiency for all Zimbabwean soils, except for those that contained visible calcium carbonate. Mehlich 3‐extractable aluminum (Al) was very highly correlated with the maximum P‐sorption capacity of a wide range of soils, excluding those with calcium carbonate. Adoption of the Mehlich 3 extractant for multiple elemental analysis of soils in Zimbabwe is recommended, particularly if routine Al measurement is included as an indicator of soil P requirements.     

Evaluation of Agro Services International Soil Test Method for Phosphorus and Potassium

Soil testing is widely adopted as an essential diagnostic tool for identifying soil nutrient factors that limit sustained crop production. A systematic approach for rapid soil testing and fertilizer recommendation has been introduced and widely used in China by Agro Services International (ASI), USA. To verify the usefulness and reliability of the ASI method in soil testing and fertilizer recommendation in comparison with other commonly used traditional soil testing methods, 294 soil samples from major agricultural regions and soil types in China with a wide range of soil pH, from 5.1 to 8.9, were taken and analyzed for available phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) by the ASI multielement extraction solution and selected traditional methods, Olsen extractant for P, ammonium acetate (NH₄OAc) extractant for K, and multielement extractant Mehlich 3 for P and K. Also, 46 soils were selected from northern China regions for a greenhouse trial with sorghum seedlings to determine if the soil testing values correlate well with plant response. Results indicated that the amount of soil P extracted by the ASI method (ASI P) was correlated to both soil extractable P tested by the Olsen extractant (Olsen P) and Mehlich 3 extractant (Mehlich 3 P). The correlation coefficient of ASI P with Mehlich 3 P (R² = 0.86) was greater than that of ASI P with Olsen P (R² = 0.74) across all selected soils. A good correlation was also found between the exchangeable K from the ASI method with the traditional ammonium acetate method (R² = 0.81) and the Mehlich 3 method (R² = 0.85). The results from the greenhouse trial showed that the extractable P and exchangeable K by the ASI multielement extraction solution could be used to represent the fertility status of soil P and K for the selected soils. Regression analysis indicated that the relative dry-matter yield of the sorghum plants can be predicted with either ASI P and ASI K values with the correlation coefficients (R²) values of 0.78 and 0.72 respectively and could be a good measure for soil testing and fertilizer recommendation in the selected soils and regions in China.     

Comparison of the ammonium acetate,Mehlich 3, and sodium tetraphenylboron as extractants to evaluate crop available potassium

ABSTRACT

The 1 M ammonium acetate (NH₄OAc) (AA) is the most widely used method for soil-test potassium (K), but other methods have been also suggested to estimate crop available K. The accuracy of these extractants may be influenced by soil texture and clay mineralogy. This study evaluated the relationships among AA, Mehlich-3 (M3), and sodium tetraphenylboron (TPhB) methods using soils differing in texture and clay minerals from the agricultural area of Uruguay. The M3 and AA extractable K concentrations were highly correlated (R² > 0.97) across soils, although AA extracted slightly higher amount of K than M3. The TPhB method extracted more K than AA and M3, indicating that extracted K from different pools. The slopes of the relationships between TPhB and AA or M3 varied among soils being higher in fine-textured and illitic soils than in coarse soils. These results would be useful for evaluating the feasibility of incorporating M3 into a test program using the existing calibrations of the AA method. In addition, TPhB could be considered a complementary tool to improve the interpretations of the extractants to estimate soil-test K along with other characteristics such as the texture and clay mineralogy.     

Evaluation of four soil test extractants for Zimbabwe soils

Abstract

The objective of this research was to compare the results from anion exchange Resin extraction of P, and the acidified ammonium acetate (AA) extraction of K and Mg with the results obtained using two single extraction procedures, Mehlich 1 (M‐l) and Mehlich 3 (M‐3). Phosphorus extracted from 72 Zimbabwe soils using M‐l and M‐3 was comparable to Resin extracted P in about 80% of the soils. Mehlich 1 extracted about half the amount of P as the Resin method, and M‐3 extracted about one and one‐half times as much. Phosphorus by M‐3 was highly correlated, (r — 0.846), with Resin extracted P from soils having 0.01M CaCl₂ pH values of equal to or greater than 5.9. On soils less than pH 5.9, the r value was 0.502, and for all soils, the r value for M‐3 vs Resin P was 0.615. Mehlich 1 extracted P vs Resin P had a r value of 0.298. Acidified ammonium acetate (AA) extraction of K and Mg was comparable to M‐l and M‐3 extraction of K and Mg in 92% or more of the 72 soils. The K correlation coefficient (r) for AA vs M‐l and AA vs M‐3 was 0.918 and 0.944, respectively. The Mg correlation coefficient (r) for AA vs M‐l and AA vs M‐3 was 0.940 and 0.962, respectively.