Comparison of Multi-element to Single‐Element Extractants for Macro‐ and Micronutrients in Acid Soils from Spain

Abstract

Different chemical reagents are used to assess plant‐available nutrients from soils with similar properties. The use of different extractants is a serious limitation when comparing results between different soil‐testing laboratories, often leading to large differences in fertilizer recommendations for similar crops.

In this study, 80 samples from acid soils from Galicia (Spain) were used to compare several soil nutrient extractants. Traditional and tested extractants for acid soil such as Bray 2 and ammonium acetate were used to evaluate multielement extractants such as ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid–ammonium acetate (EDTA‐aa), ammonium bicarbonate–diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (AB‐DTPA), and Mehlich 3.

Linear regression analyses were performed to relate the amount of each nutrient obtained by traditional soil extractants to the amount obtained by multielement extractants. Strong correlation was found between extractable Bray 2 P and Mehlich 3 P (r²=0.97, slope=0.87, and intercept=?0.48). The slope of the regression line between EDTA‐aa‐extractable calcium (Ca) and that from ammonium acetate (Aa) approached 1∶1 (r²=0.86). Similar results were obtained for magnesium (Mg) (r²=0.99). Soil zinc (Zn) concentrations extracted by Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa were similar; slope of the regression line was 0.95 (r²=0.88). With regard to copper (Cu), Mehlich 3 extracted approximately 20% more Cu than EDTA‐aa.

The results showed that Mehlich 3 and EDTA‐aa are suitable for assessment of plant available phosphorus (P), potassium (K), Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn, and iron (Fe) in acid soils.     

Anion‐exchange membrane,water, and sodium bicarbonate extractions as soil tests for phosphorus

Abstract

Three techniques were evaluated as soil P tests for western Canadian soils: anion‐exchange membrane (AEM), water, and bicarbonate extraction. The AEM, water, and bicarbonate‐extractable total P represented novel approaches to compare to the widely used bicarbonate‐extractable inorganic P (traditional Olsen) soil test. In a range of Saskatchewan soils, similar trends in predicted relative P availability were observed for AEM, water extraction, bicarbonate‐extractable total P, and bicarbonate‐extractable organic P. Correlations between soil test values revealed AEM and water‐extractable P to be most closely correlated, consistent with the similar manner of P removal in the two tests.

Phosphorus availability, as predicted by the tests, was compared to actual P uptake by canola and wheat grown on 14 soils in a growth chamber experiment. P uptake by canola was highly correlated with AEM (r² = 0.86–0.90), water (0.87 ‐0.94), and bicarbonate‐extractable total (0.91) and inorganic (0.92) P. Uptake of P by wheat was not quite as highly correlated with test‐predicted values: AEM (r² = ‐0.73–0.78), water (0.72–0.77), bicarbonate total (0.82), bicarbonate‐inorganic P (0.75).

The similarity in coefficients of determination among test methods indicated nearly identical abilities of the tests to predict soil P availability in the range of soils examined. The AEM and water extractions, unlike bicarbonate, are largely independent of soil type and may prove superior when a wider range of soils is being tested. Bicarbonate‐extractable total P and water‐extractable P suffer limitations in analytical simplicity and cost. In testing for P alone, AEM was considered superior to the other methods due to low cost, simplicity, independence of soil type, and high correlation with plant uptake.     

Comparison of routine soil tests and EPA method 3050 as extractants for heavy metals in Delaware soils

Abstract

Agricultural use of sewage sludges can be limited by heavy metal accumulations in soils and crops. Information on background levels of total heavy metals in soils and changes in soil metal content due to sludge application are; therefore, critical aspects of long‐term sludge monitoring programs. As soil testing laboratories routinely, and rapidly, determine, in a wide variety of agricultural soils, the levels of some heavy metals and soil properties related to plant availability of these metals (e.g. Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, pH, organic matter, texture), these labs could participate actively in the development and monitoring of environmentally sound sludge application programs. Consequently, the objective of this study was to compare three soil tests (Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, and DTP A) and an USEPA approved method for measuring heavy metals in soils (EPA Method 3050), as extractants for Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn in representative agricultural soils of Delaware and in soils from five sites involved in a state‐monitored sludge application program.

Soil tests extracted less than 30% of total (EPA 3050) metals from most soils, with average percentages of total metal extracted (across all soils and metals) of 15%, 32%, and 11% for the Mehlich 1, Mehlich 3, and DTPA, respectively. Statistically significant correlations between total and soil test extractable metal content were obtained with all extractants for Cu, Pb, and Zn, but not Cd and Ni. The Mehlich 1 soil test was best correlated with total Cu and Zn (r=0.78***, 0.60***, respectively), while the chelate‐based extractants (DTPA and Mehlich 3) were better correlated with total Pb (r=0.85***, 0.63***). Multiple regression equations for the prediction of total Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn, from soil test extractable metal in combination with easily measured soil properties (pH, organic matter by loss on ignition, soil volume weight) had R² values ranging from 0.41*** to 0.85***, suggesting that it may be possible to monitor, with reasonable success, heavy metal accumulations in soils using the results of a routine soil test.     

Chelating resin method for estimation of sludge‐cadmium bioavailability

Abstract

A chelating resin procedure was developed to predict the plant uptake of Cd by municipal sewage sludges applied to land. Seventeen anaerobically digested sludges were sampled to give a range of total Cd content of 0.07 to 2.02 mmol/kg. Sludge suspensions [20 g in 100 mL 0.05 M Ca(NO₃)₂] were equilibrated with 1 g Chelex 100 resin placed in dialysis tubing and shaken at 200 rpm for 16 h. Resin‐extractable Cd was compared with sludge solution Cd (CdT and Cd²⁺) in equilibrium with 0.05 M Ca(NO₃)₂, and 0.05 M Ca(NO₃)₂ containing 50 (μM Na‐EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetate). Resin extractable Cd was correlated with Cd uptake by sudax, a sorghum/sudangrass hybrid (Sorghum bicolar), grown in Spinks loamy sand (Typic Udipsamment) amended with each of the sludges to give a constant Cd concentration of 22 μmol/kg soil.

Resin extractable Cd ranged from < 0.1 to 48 μmol/kg. Resin extracted between zero and 5.3% of total sludge Cd. Resin extractable Cd was highly correlated with CdT and Cd²⁺ in 0.05 M Ca(NO₃)₂ (R² = 0.97 and 0.98, respectively), and with 0.05 M Ca(NO₃)₂ containing 50 μM NaEDTA (R² = 0.97 and 0.98, respectively). There was a lower correlation with total sludge Cd and soil solution Cd (R² = 0.53 and 0.63, respectively). Cadmium concentration in sudax was highly correlated with resin extractable sludge Cd (R² = 0.92). When the two sludges with highest total sludge Cd were dropped, the correlation dropped (R² = 0.57), but resin extractable Cd predicted Cd uptake as effectively as CdT and Cd²⁺ in Ca(NO₃)₂ or Ca(NO₃)₂/EDTA. Resin extraction appears to be a promising method of assessing the potential bioavailability of sludge Cd.     

Prediction of available heavy metals by six chemical extractants in a sewage sludge‐amended soil

Abstract

In a field experiment conducted during three years in a sandy‐loam, calcareous soil, one aerobically digested sewage sludge (ASL) and another anaerobically digested sewage sludge (ANSL) were applied at rates of 400, 800, and 1,200 kg N/ha/year, and compared with mineral nitrogen fertilizer at rates of 0, 200, 400, and 600 kg N/ha/year in a cropping sequence of potato‐corn, potato‐lettuce, and potato, the first, second, and third year, respectively. Results showed that the highest values of soil extractable metals were obtained with aqua regia, whereas the lowest levels with DTPA. All metal (Zn, Cu, Cd, Ni, Pb, and Cr) gave significant correlations between metal extracted with the different extractants and metal loading applied with the sludges. The metal extractable ion increased over the control for Zn, Cu, Cd, Ni, Pb, and Cr extracted with DTPA, EDTA (pH 8.6) and 0.1 N HC1, for Zn, Cd, Ni, Pb, and Cr extracted with EDTA (pH 4.65) and AB‐DTPA, and for Zn, Cd, Ni, and Cr extracted with aqua regia. The level of metal‐DTPA extractable resulted highly correlated with that obtained by the other methods, except the Ni‐aqua regia extractable. The soil extractable elements which showed significant correlations with metals in plant were: Zn, Cu, Cd, and Ni in potato leaves, Cd, Ni, and Pb in corn grain, and Zn and Cd for lettuce wrapper leaves. In general, all the chelate based extractants (DTPA, EDTA pH 4.6, EDTA pH 8.6, AB‐DTPA) were equally useful as indicator of plant available metals in the soil amended with sludge.     

Neubauer seedling technique to determine availability of nutrient elements for wheat from selected South African soils

Abstract

The quantity of plant nutrient elements removed from soil by wheat (Triticum aestivum) seedlings were compared with the results of soil tests. Four soils were selected to represent the major parent material and climatic factors responsible for the formation of important agricultural soils in the central eastern Cape Province of South Africa. Acid‐washed sand was used as control. Seedlings were grown for 21 days and nutrient element content in both plant material and soil were determined. Soils derived from dolerite rocks had significantly (P<0.05) higher calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), potassium (K), sodium (Na), and phosphorus (P) than those derived from sedimentary rocks. However, iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), and copper (Cu) were higher in soils derived from sedimentary rocks compared to those from dolerite rocks. The differences are attributed to elemental composition of minerals in the two parent rock materials. Within each rock group, soils derived from sites with higher temperature and low rainfall (semi‐arid climate) had significantly (p<0.05) higher nutrient element content than those from sites with lower temperatures and higher rainfall (humid climate). As far as plant growth is concerned, all the soils were well supplied with Ca, Mg, K, Na, and zinc (Zn), but were deficient in P, Fe, and Mn. The trend in uptake of soil nutrient elements by wheat seedlings mirrored their concentration in the soils. Estimates of plant‐available nutrient elements as determined by soil tests and their uptake as determined by tissue concentration were highly correlated for some nutrient elements (r²=0.83, 0.79, 0.94, 0.54, 0.69, and 0.61 for Ca, Mg, K, P, Na, and Zn, respectively) and weak for others (r²=0.47, 0.35, and 0.37 for Fe, Mn, and Cu, respectively). Notwithstanding the shortcomings of extrapolating pot derived results to field conditions, it is concluded that the Neubauer technique may offer a rapid and relatively inexpensive way of relating extractable nutrient elements with plant uptake and growth. Further in country correlation studies are, however, recommended.     

Plant Availability of Cadmium in Soils: II. Factors Related to the Extractability and Plant Uptake of Cadmium in Cultivated Soils

Abstract

Eighty four soil samples collected from southeastern Norway were analyzed for Cd by extraction with NH₄OAc, DTPA, NH₄OAc-EDTA, NH₄NO₃, HCl and CaCl₂. The total Cd, pH, exchangeable K and Ca, dithionite-extractable Mn, available P and fine sand (0.2–0.02 mm) contents were the principal factors related to the extractable Cd, with some inter-extractant variations. Cadmium extracted by NH₄NO₃, NH₄OAc, HCl and CaCl₂ decreased with increasing soil pH, but the Cd extracted by all the extractants increased with increasing total Cd, exchangeable K and Ca, available P, and Mn-oxide contents in the soils. The Cd concentrations in plants were significantly related to the extractable Cd, exchangeable Ca and Mg, pH, Mn-oxides and organic matter content.     

Plant Availability of Cadmium in Soils: I. Extractable Cadmium in Newly and Long-Term Cultivated Soils

Abstract

Effects of long-term use of phosphate fertilizers on extractable soil Cd in relation to its concentrations in plants were investigated. “Paired” soil samples were collected from newly and long-term cultivated fields and analyzed for Cd by extraction with NH₄OAc, DTPA, NH₄OAc-EDTA, NH₄NO₃, HCl and CaCl₂. Plant samples were also collected and analyzed for Cd. Significant differences in extractable Cd by all the extractants except NH₄NO₃ were observed between the newly and long-term cultivated soils. The Cd concentrations in plants were not increased by the elevated extractable Cd. Although significant relationships were observed between plant Cd and extractable soil Cd, none of the extractants used alone gave a good assessment of plant-available Cd for all the samples used in this study.     

Comparison of DTPA and resin extractable soil Zn to plant Zn uptake

Abstract

Extraction of soil zinc with routine chemical extractants does not always reflect differences in Zn availability as detected by plant uptake. This study was undertaken to explore and compare the use of an ion exchange resin and diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA) for extracting soil Zn as related to plant Zn uptake. Beans were grown in 1989 following differential cropping with corn and beans or fallow in 1988 on a Portneuf silt loam near Kimberly, Idaho. Two Zn fertilizer treatments were imposed across previous cropping treatments. A batch method for determining resin extractable soil Zn was established.

Both plant Zn concentration and Zn uptake by beans in 1989 were significantly higher in Zn fertilized than unfertilized treatments regardless of previous crop; and higher in plots previously cropped with corn than beans or fallow, regardless of Zn treatment. DTPA and resin extractable soil Zn were significantly higher in Zn fertilized plots compared to unfertilized plots but did not differ between previous cropping treatments. Resin and DTPA extractable soil Zn concentrations were positively correlated. Resin extracted soil Zn correlated better with plant Zn concentration and Zn uptake throughout the growing season than DTPA extracted soil Zn, particularly in plots that had been fallowed or previously cropped with corn. Resin may be extracting labile soil Zn not extracted with DTPA and, therefore, be better simulating plant uptake. Both extraction methods correlated better with Zn uptake when evaluated within cropping treatments, emphasizing the need to consider previous crop when calibrating soil tests.     

Extractability and plant uptake of heavy metals in alum shale soils

Abstract

Fifty soil samples (0–20 cm) with corresponding numbers of grain, potatoes, cabbage, and cauliflower crops were collected from soils developed on alum shale materials in Southeastern Norway to investigate the availability of [cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), zinc (Zn), lead (Pb), nickel (Ni), and manganese (Mn)] in the soil and the uptake of the metals by these crops. Both total (aqua regia soluble) and extractable [ammonium nitrate (NH₄NO₃) and DTPA] concentrations of metals in the soils were studied. The total concentration of all the heavy metals in the soils were higher compared to other soils found in this region. Forty‐four percent of the soil samples had higher Cd concentration than the limit for application of sewage sludge, whereas the corresponding values for Ni, Cu, and Zn were 60%, 38%, and 16%, respectively. About 70% the soil samples had a too high concentration of one or more of the heavy metals in relation to the limit for application of sewage sludge. Cadmium was the most soluble of the heavy metals, implying that it is more bioavailable than the other non‐essential metals, Pb and Ni. The total (aqua regia soluble) concentrations of Cd, Cu, Zn, and Ni and the concentrations of DTPA‐extractable Cd and Ni were significantly higher in the loam soils than in the sandy loam soils. The amount of NH₄NCyextractable metals did not differ between the texture classes. The concentrations of DTPA‐extractable metals were positively and significantly correlated with the total concentrations of the same metals. Ammonium nitrate‐extractable metals, on the other hand, were not related to their total concentrations, but they were negatively and significantly correlated to soil pH. The average concentration of Cd (0.1 mg kg^‐1 d.w.) in the plants was relatively high compared to the concentration previously found in plants grown on the other soils. The concentrations of the other heavy metals Cu, Zn, Mn, Ni, and Pb in the plants were considered to be within the normal range, except for some samples with relatively high concentrations of Ni and Mn (0–11.1 and 3.5 to 167 mg kg‘¹ d.w., respectively). The concentrations of Cd, Cu, Zn, Ni, and Mn in grain were positively correlated to the concentrations of these respective metals in the soil extracted by NH₄NO₃. The plant concentrations were negatively correlated to pH. The DTPA‐extractable levels were not correlated with plant concentration and hence DTPA would not be a good extractant for determining plant availability in these soils.     

Evaluation of Mehlich III as an extractant for available soil sulfur

Abstract

Among the identified universal extractants, Mehlich III is one of the more reliable multielement extractant for acid soils and soilless mixes. However, the universality of the Mehlich III extractant does not include an important nutrient element, sulfur (S). This study was conducted in order to evaluate the Mehlich III extractant as an index of S availability, and comparing with four other extractants, monocalcium phosphate (MCP), MCP+HOAc, Morgan's Reagent, and calcium chloride. Soil samples representing tea growing areas of several parts of India were collected from selected tea gardens to compare S extractability. These extractants were also evaluated in a young tea plantation (3+ year old) field experiment which is situated near the foot hill soils (Typic Hapludalfs) of Indian western Himalaya. It was found that Mehlich III‐extractable S was significantly correlated with the S extracted by the other extractants from both the top and subsoils of the tea growing region. However, the largest correlation coefficient was found between the Morgan's Reagent and Mehlich III. MCP, MCP+HOAc, and Morgan reagents extracted S mainly from the adsorbed fraction, although some degree of correlation was found with water‐soluble and ester sulfate‐sulfur (SO₄‐S) fractions. In case of the Mehlich III extractant, 83 and 87% of the variability was explained by water‐soluble and adsorbed SO₄ in the respective top and subsoils. Except for the regression equation between Morgan's Reagent‐extractable S and the S content in tea shoots, all other equations were statistically significant. But, only available S extracted from the top soil by Mehlich III was found significantly correlated with S uptake, which was further confirmed by a significant coefficient of regression (r=0.552*). This suggests that the Mehlich III reagent could be a useful index for predicting the S requirement for a tea crop.     

The effect of plant material on the relationship between sodium acetate and sodium bicarbonate extractable phosphorus in a Latahco silt loam soil

Abstract

Standardization of the P soil test procedures is desirable; however, both NaOAc and NaHCO₃ are currently used to extract P from soils in the Pacific Northwest region of the USA. The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between NaOAc and NaHCO₃ extractable P in soils and to evaluate the effect of plant material on this relationship in a northern Idaho soil. The Ap horizon of a Latahco silt loam was used and alfalfa (Medicago sativa), pea (Pisum sativum) and wheat (Triticum aestivum) plant materials were added as amendments at rates of 0%, 1%, 5% and 10% (w/w). The soils were incubated for 20 weeks under controlled conditions. In addition, other parameters studied included soil water potential (‐0.05, ‐0.15 and ‐0.40 MPa), incubation temperature (10, 20 and 30°C and incubation period. P in samples was extracted by NaOAc and NaHCO₃ extractants. A statistically significant linear relationship between NaOAc and NaHCO₃ extractable P was observed (r² = 0.96). In addition, the types of plant residues added to soil differently affected P extraction by the two extractants. The difference between NaOAc and NaHCO₃ extractable P was greatest in the wheat material treatment while alfalfa material resulted in the smallest effect. Sodium acetate extractable P values increased faster than NaHCO₃ extractable P with increasing amendment rate.

A simple regression relationship will allow conversion between NaOAc and NaHCO₃ extractable P in the Latahco soil. Additions of less than 5 mt/ha plant material will have a minimal impact on this relationship.     

Correlation of Mehlich 3, bray 1, and ammonium acetate extractable P,K, Ca,and Mg for Alaska agricultural soils

Abstract

Soil test recommendations currently used in Alaska are based on a limited amount of in‐state data along with consideration of data from other states. Recently, Mehlich 3 extractable P has been found to be highly correlated to yield on representative agricultural soils in Alaska. To fully use its multi‐element capability, a study was conducted to correlate Mehlich 3 extractable P and cations (K, Ca, and Mg) with the P and cations extracted by the Bray 1 and ammonium acetate methods respectively.

When Mehlich 3 extractable K and Mg were regressed with ammonium acetate extractable K and Mg respectively, the relationship was essentially one‐to‐one and the relationship held across all soils tested. Significant variation was observed among soils in the extraction of Mehlich 3‐P and Ca relative to Bray 1‐P and ammonium acetate‐Ca. Individual soil character appeared to affect the regressions for extractable P and Ca, even though the R² values were generally high. The regression slopes for Mehlich 3‐P versus Bray 1‐P ranged from 1.01 to 1.88 with Mehlich 3 extracting an average of 66% more P than Bray 1 in the volcanic ash soils, and 12% more in the loess soils. The regression slopes for Mehlich 3‐Ca versus ammonium acetate‐Ca ranged from 0.95 to 1.33, and the former extracted an average of 17% more Ca than the latter. It is suggested that the regression data of P and Ca can be extrapolated to other soils based on soil classification; to extend the soil test data over a geographic base.     

Comparison of ammonium bicarbonate‐DTPA,ammonium carbonate,and ammonium oxalate to assess the availability of molybdenum in mine spoils and soils

Abstract

A variety of extractants has been used to assess the availability of molybdenum (Mo) in soils. Most of the extractants have been studied from a deficiency aspect rather than for soils with Mo toxicity, and none of them have been used to extract available Mo from mine spoils. The purpose of this study was to examine the potential of different chemical extractants for assessing the availability of Mo in mine spoils and soils. One mine spoil and three soils were treated with sodium molybdate and then subjected to wetting and drying cycles for two months. These spoil/soils were extracted with ammonium bicarbonate DTPA (AB‐DTPA), ammonium carbonate, and ammonium oxalate solution for available Mo. Crested wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa) were grown in the spoil/soils in a greenhouse to determine plant uptake of Mo. Additionally, four mine spoils and six soils were extracted and analyzed for available Mo as mentioned above. The results obtained by these three extractants were highly correlated. It was found that ammonium oxalate extracts the greatest amount of Mo among the three extractants from spoil/soils since it dissolves some adsorbed Mo from Fe‐oxide and Al‐oxide. The changes in pH of spoil/soils did not have a significant effect on the amount of Mo extracted by any of these methods. The relationships between Mo uptake and Mo extracted by each method were all significant at 1% level. None of the extractants were clearly better or worse than the others. All three methods can be used to assess Mo availability, and potential toxicity from plant uptake of Mo from reclaimed spoils.     

Determination of mobile heavy metal fraction in soil: Results of a pot experiment with sewage sludge

Abstract

The development of a method using a chelating resin to assess heavy metal mobility in soil and the first results obtained from a pot experiment with sewage sludge additions were studied. The resin was Chelex 100 with the calcium (Ca)‐form of the resin proving to be best suited for the extraction. The efficiency of recovery of the heavy metals from an aqueous solution ranged from 81.2% for cadmium (Cd) to 102% for copper (Cu) within 24 hours. For heavy metal extractions from a soil sample, a 96 hour extraction period was found to be optimum. The extracted heavy metal portion was comparable with the results obtained with an ammonium acetate (NH₄AOc) extraction. Total heavy metal contents in the substrate of the pot experiment did not show a significant influence due to the sewage sludge treatments, although considerable amounts of heavy metals were added by the sewage sludge. This effect can be both due to the incomplete recovery of heavy metals by an aqua regia extraction and leaching losses of these elements from the pots. Rape (Raphanus sativus L.) plants did not have any heavy metal contents which might indicate a high availability in soil, with the Cd and Cr contents in the rape biomass being partly lower in the sewage sludge‐treated pots than in the control plants; however, zinc (Zn) uptake slightly increased with increasing sewage sludge treatments. The Chelex 100 extraction procedure was correlated with Cd plant uptake, while the NH₄AOc extraction procedure was better related to the Zn uptake by rape plants.     

Availability of Lead and Cadmium in Farmland Soil and Its Distribution in Individual Plants of Dry‐Seeded Rice

Abstract

Availability of lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd) in farmland soils and its distribution in individual plants of dry‐seeded rice were investigated utilizing graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry (GFAAS) with a matrix modification technique. Five extractants were compared, and the operating conditions for GFAAS were optimized. The detection limits were 4.2 ng for Pb with the precision of 1.54% and 0.1 ng for Cd with the precision of 2.38%. The contents of the extractable Pb and Cd in soils were determined with the five extractants, and availability of Pb and Cd in farmland soil was discussed. The contents of Pb and Cd in different parts of dry‐seeded rice were lower than those in dry‐seeded rice soil. The contents of Pb and Cd in rice were lower than in other parts. The end top leaves accumulated the highest amounts of Pb and Cd.     

Comparison of soil zinc extractants for detection of applied zinc and prediction of leaf zinc concentration

Abstract

Many soil extractants have been developed for determination of zinc (Zn) availability to plants. The optimum soil Zn extractant should be useful not only for prediction of plant Zn concentration but also for detection of applied Zn levels. The objectives of this study were: i) to compare soil Zn extradants for detecting applied Zn and for predicting peanut leaf Zn over a range of soil pH levels, and ii) to correlate other soil‐extractable Zn levels with Mehlich‐1. Soil and peanut leaf samples were taken from a field study testing pH levels as the main plots and Zn application rates in the sub‐plots. Extractable Zn was determined on soil samples using Mehlich‐1, Mehlich‐3, DTPA, MgNO₃, and many dilute salt extradants of varied strength and pH. Correlation of extractable soil Zn to cumulative applied Zn levels revealed Mehlich‐1, Mehlich‐3, DTPA, and AlCl₃ extradants to be among the best indicators of applied Zn. Leaf Zn concentration was best correlated with soil Zn extracted by dilute salts, such as KCl, CaCl₂, NH₄Cl, CaSO₄, and MgCl₂. Including soil pH as an independent variable in the regression to predict leaf Zn considerably improved R‐square values. The DTPA‐extractable soil Zn levels were very well correlated with Mehlich‐1‐extractable Zn. Mehlich‐3 extracted about 20% more soil Zn than Mehlich‐1, but Mehlich‐3 soil Zn was not as well correlated to Mehlich‐1 soil Zn as DTPA soil Zn. Lower pH solutions extracted more of the applied Zn, but more neutral solutions extracted Zn amounts which were better correlated with Zn uptake. On the other hand, Mehlich‐1, which had a lower pH, had better correlations with both applied Zn and leaf Zn than did Mehlich‐3. Shortening the DTPA extraction time to 30 minutes resulted in better correlations than the standard two hour extraction time. Chloride (Cl) was the best anion tested in relation to soil applied Zn recovery in combination with potassium (K), calcium (Ca), and aluminum (Al), and Cl optimized leaf Zn correlations for ammonium (NH₄), K, Ca, and magnesium (Mg). The larger the valence of the cation, the better the correlation with applied Zn and the poorer the correlation with leaf Zn.     

Residual heavy metal concentrations in sludge‐amended coastal plain soils ‐ I. Comparison of extractants

Abstract

The purposes for this research were: to examine the long‐term residual effects of farmland applications of municipal sludges from four treatment technologies on the total and extractable Zn, Cu, Mn, Fe, Pb, Ni and Cd concentrations in Coastal Plain soils; to investigate the effects of sludge sources and rates on the effectiveness of soil extractants to remove the various metals; and to determine correlation coefficients for soil extractable versus plant accumulation in tobacco. The extractants evaluated were Mehlich 1 and 3, and DTPA‐pH 7.3. Composite Ap horizon soil samples and tobacco leaf samples were obtained in 1984 from research plots at two sites in Maryland that were established in 1972 and 1976, respectively, using sludge materials from three wastewater treatment facilities in the Washington, D.C. metropolitan region. Similar application rates were used at both sites.

A wide range in soil pH values was found among treatments at each site. Significant (p ≤ 0.05) increases were observed in total Zn, Cu, Fe, Pb, Ni, and Cd for all sludge sources with increased rates; however, values for total soil Mn exhibited high variability in all cases. The rankings among the extractants varied for some elements depending on the sludge sources. For Zn, the rankings were Mehlich 1 > Mechlich 3 > DTPA‐pH 7.3 across all sources and rates. For Cu, Mehlich 3 > Mehlich 1 > DTPA‐pH 7.3 was found for soils amended with Blue Plains digested (BPD) and Piscataway limeddigested (PLD) sludges but Mehlich 1 ≥ DTPA pH 7.3 > Mehlich 3 for Blue Plains limed compost (BPLC) and Annapolis Fe and heat treated (AFH) sludges. Concerning extractable Mn, Mehlich Mehlich 1 > Mechlich 3 > DTPH pH 7.3 was the order for BPLC and AFH sludges but Mehlich 3 > Mehlich 1 > DTPA‐pH 7.3 was observed for BPD and PLD sludges. The rankings among extractants for Fe (Mehlich 3 > Mehlich 1 > DTPA‐pH7.3), Ni (Mehlich 3 ≥ Mehlich 1 > DTPA‐pH 7.3), Pb (Mehlich 3 > DTPA‐pH 7.3 > Mehlich 1) and Cd (Mehlich 1 > Mehlich 3 > DPTA‐pH7.3) were somewhat similar across all sludge sources. Significant correlation coefficients were obtained for all three extractants for soil extractable vs. plant Zn, Cu, Ni, and Cd at both sites; however, Mehlich 3 was not significant for Mn. Also, neither of the extractants produced significant coefficients for Fe and Pb.     

Use of Ion exchange membranes in routine soil testing

Abstract

We developed and assessed a method for simultaneous extraction of plant available nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur and potassium using anion and cation exchange membranes (ACEM). The technique was found to be highly suitable for routine soil testing due to its simplicity, rapidness and accuracy. The study compared the amount of nutrients extracted by ACEM with conventional chemical‐based extractants for P and K (0.5M NaHCO₃) and N and S (0.001M CaCl₂) for 135 soil samples representing a wide range of soil types in Western Canada. The nutrient availability predicted by ACEM was significantly correlated with the conventional methods. The correlation was not affected by the two different shaking times tested (one hour and 15 minutes), suggesting that extraction times as short as 15 minutes could be used in ACEM extraction. To evaluate the relative ability of ACEM and the conventional tests to predict actual nutrient availability to plants, canola plants were grown on soils in the growth chamber and actual plant uptake was compared to test‐predicted nutrient availability. Phosphorus and potassium uptake by canola plants was more closely correlated with ACEM extractable P and K (r²= 0.84*** and 0.54***) than with 0.5M NaHCO₃ P and K (r²= 0.70*** and 0.37***). Also, nitrogen and sulfur uptake by canola plants was significantly correlated with ACEM extractable‐NO₃ and ‐SO₄ (r² = 0.60*** and 0.70***) and with CaCl₂ extractable‐NC₃ and ‐SO₄ (r² = 0.57*** and 0.61***). Availability of all four macronutrients can be assessed in a single ACEM extraction. The higher correlation with plant uptake suggests that ACEM is a better index of macronutrient availability than conventional methods. The ACEM soil test could be readily adopted in routine soil analysis because of low cost and simplicity as well as its consistency over a wide range of soil types.     

Effect of Grinding on Soil Extraction by Aqua Regia, 2 M Nitric Acid,and Mehlich 3

Abstract

The effect of grinding on soil extraction was determined for two soil fractions and three extractants. Arsenic (As), beryllium (Be), cadmium (Cd), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), vanadium (V), and zinc (Zn) were extracted by aqua regia and 2 M nitric acid. Mehlich 3 extractant was used for determination of potassium (K), magnesium (Mg), calcium (Ca), phosphorus (P), iron (Fe), and aluminum (Al). One hundred forty‐seven agricultural soil samples representing all major soil types, climatic regions, and proportions of agronomic cultures in the Czech Republic were collected for the study. Particle size fractions smaller than 2 mm and smaller than 0.150 mm were chosen for investigation. Extraction of elements by aqua regia was similar for both size fractions of soil. Cold 2 M nitric acid is a weaker extractant than aqua regia, and a statistically significant increase in extractable Be (5%), Cd (6%), Co (11%), Cu (5%), Ni (5%), and V (2%) was measured with the finely ground soils. An increase for the finer fraction for K (10%) and Mn (25%) was found for Mehlich 3. A more complex nonlinear relationship was found for Mehlich 3 extractable Al and Fe. This was probably caused by a more intensive re‐adsorption of Fe and Al to the finely ground soils.