A comparison of vitamin B12 levels in the liver and serum of sheep receiving treatments used to correct cobalt deficiency

The efficacies of four methods, used for the prophylaxis of cobalt deficiency in sheep as measured by the elevation of liver and serum vitamin B12 levels, were compared in marginally deficient sheep over 14 weeks. The methods used were weekly drenches of either cobalt sulphate or cobalt chelate (EDTA) three-weekly injections of hydroxocobalamin, and ruminal cobalt pellets. On the basis of elevated liver and serum vitamin B12 levels, chelated cobalt was shown to be available to rumen microflora for the synthesis of vitamin B12. However, at no stage were liver and serum vitamin B12 levels of sheep receiving the chelate significantly different from those receiving the same amount of cobalt as the sulphate. After five, three-weekly injections of hydroxocabalamin liver vitamin B12 levels were significantly higher (p<0.01) than for the other treatments, with the exception of cobalt sulphate. Cobalt pellets led to an initial rapid and significant rise in serum vitamin B12 when compared with the other treatments. However, at four weeks there was no significant difference between treatment groups for serum vitamin B12. Fourteen weeks after the administration of cobalt pellets, serum and liver.vitamin B12 levels in this group were not significantly different from those of untreated sheep. At this time, three out of 12 sheep had lost their pellets.     

Reference curves to diagnose cobalt deficiency in sheep using liver and serum vitamin B12 levels

Reference curves demonstrating the relationship between serum or liver vitamin B12 and weight gain were derived from the examination of 16 published and 48 unpublished N.Z. trials. From these curves probability of obtaining an economic reponse (>10g/day body weight increase) for any serum or liver vitamin B12 can be determined. No significant (P<0.05) weight gain responses occurred to vitamin B12 or cobalt treatment in trials with mean serum vitamin B12 levels above 500 pmol/l or liver vitamin B12 levels greater than 500 nmol/kg. The reference curves were therefore derived from trials with vitamin B12 levels below these levels; 36 trials with serum vitamin B12 and 19 trials with liver vitamin B12 data. The mean vitamin B12 level at the mid point of the weight gain response period was selected from each trial. Examination of serum vitamin B12 reference curves for spring, summer, autumn and winter indicated that curves derived from data closest to the middle of January (summer) adequately reflected response to treatment at any time during the first year of life. Reference curves for liver vitamin B12 also used data closest to middle of January. This was partly because insufficient liver data was available to compare seasonal variations. The fitted response curve approached 0 gram/day at 500 pmol/l for serum vitamin B12 and 375 nmol/kg for liver vitamin B12. The minimum vitamin B12 level at which an economic response to treatment (>10 g/day) is not likely was 336 pmol/l for serum and 282 nmol/kg for liver.     

Measurement of vitamin B12 in the livers and sera of sheep and cattle and an investigation of factors influencing serum vitamin B12 levels in sheep

Modifications of a radioassay method for the analysis of vitamin B12 using chicken serum as the binder are described. This obviates the need to use individual serum blanks to correct for non-specific binding in vitamin B12 assays of the sera and livers of sheep and cattle. Samples with high vitamin B12 levels can be diluted prior to assay without loss of linearity. Recoveries of added cyanocobalamin or hydroxocobalamin were better than 95% and results correlated significantly with those obtained using a microbiological assay (Poteriochromonas malhamensis). Sera and liver samples stored for four weeks at temperatures ranging from -20 degrees to 22 degrees showed no change in vitamin B12 levels. Withholding food from sheep for 44 hours led to a marked increase in serum vitamin B12. This effect was also evident in sheep eating a limited amount of cut grass. In sheep at pasture there was no evidence of a diurnal variation in serum vitamin B12 levels. Serum vitamin B12 levels in sheep at pasture were shown to be an unreliable indicator of liver vitamin B12.     

A comparison of serum vitamin B12 and serum methylmalonic acid as diagnostic measures of cobalt status in cattle

In two trials an assessment was made of serum methylmalonic acid as a diagnostic criterion of cobalt status in housed cattle. Despite the small number of animals used the method showed some promise, and normal concentrations are tentatively suggested as being less than 2 mumole/litre, subclinically cobalt deficient 2 to 4 mumole/litre and cobalt-deficient greater than 4 mumole/litre. However, for assessing how cobalt status is likely to influence the rate of liveweight gain of cattle, measurements of both serum methylmalonic acid and vitamin B12 concentrations would appear to be better.     

Development of a specific radioimmunoassay for vitamin B12 and its application in the diagnosis of cobalt deficiency in sheep

A radioimmunoassay (RIA) for vitamin B₁₂ is described. Antisera were raised in rabbits using a conjugate between 5-O-succinyl cyanocobalamin and chicken serum albumin. The antibody is largely specific for the (upper) face of the vitamin B₁₂ molecule. The RIA can detect vitamin B₁₂ down to concentrations of 37 pmol/L and correlated well (r=0.980, p<0.001) with a commercial radioassay. The use of this RIA, together with an assay for plasma methylmalonic acid, in the diagnosis of cobalt/vitamin B₁₂ deficiency in sheep is described.     

A comparison of vitamin B12 levels in the livers and sera of sheep measured by microbiological and radioassay methods

Five radioassay methods (commercial kits) were evaluated for the determination of vitamin B₁₂ in sheep serum. They provided results that correlated significantly (P<0.01) with those obtained using a microbiological assay.

One radioassay method was evaluated for analysing vitamin B₁₂ in liver, and the results were in excellent agreement with those obtained by the microbiological method.

Little correlation between serum and liver vitamin B₁₂ levels was found. The limited diagnostic value of serum vitamin B₁₂ concentrations for detecting cobalt deficiency in sheep is discussed.     

A critical evaluation of serum methylmalonic acid and vitamin B12 for the assessment of cobalt deficiency of growing lambs in New Zealand

AIM: To derive reference ranges for serum methylmalonic acid (MMA) for the diagnosis of cobalt/vitamin B12-responsiveness in lambs and critique existing serum vitamin B12 reference ranges. METHODS: Individual animal data from earlier supplementation trials, involving 225 ewes, 106 suckling lambs, 301 lambs during the suckling and post-weaning periods and 414 weaned lambs, for which weight gain to supplementation was observed, were used to derive relationships between serum vitamin B12 and MMA, and liveweight gain. RESULTS: Serum MMA concentrations were rarely elevated above the norm of <2 micromol/L when serum vitamin B12 concentrations were >375 pmol/L, and not elevated into the range where a liveweight response to supplementation occurred (>10 micromol/L) unless serum vitamin B12 concentrations were below 200 pmol/L. Suckling lambs were able to maintain high growth rates despite elevated serum MMA concentrations (>20 micromol/L). CONCLUSIONS: The current reference ranges used in New Zealand for serum vitamin B12 are set conservatively high. Serum MMA concentrations appear to allow better differentiation of a responsive condition than vitamin B12 concentrations. Serum MMA concentrations >13 micromol/L indicate responsiveness to supplementation whilst concentrations <7 micromol/L indicate unresponsiveness. In the range 7-13 micromol/L, variation in response was observed and predictability of response is less certain, but supplementation is advisable. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The current reference ranges for vitamin B12 responsiveness are conservatively high and lead to over-diagnosis of vitamin B12 deficiency in ill-thriftiness of sheep.     

A critical evaluation of serum methylmalonic acid and vitamin B12 for the assessment of cobalt deficiency of growing lambs in New Zealand

AIM: To derive reference ranges for serum methylmalonic acid (MMA) for the diagnosis of cobalt/vitamin B₁₂-responsiveness in lambs and critique existing serum vitamin B₁₂ reference ranges.

METHODS: Individual animal data from earlier supplementation trials, involving 225 ewes, 106 suckling lambs, 301 lambs during the suckling and post-weaning periods and 414 weaned lambs, for which weight gain to supplementation was observed, were used to derive relationships between serum vitamin B₁₂ and MMA, and liveweight gain.

RESULTS: Serum MMA concentrations were rarely elevated above the norm of <2 µmol/L when serum vitamin B₁₂ concentrations were >375 pmol/L, and not elevated into the range where a liveweight response to supplementation occurred (>10 µmol/L) unless serum vitamin B₁₂ concentrations were below 200 pmol/L. Suckling lambs were able to maintain high growth rates despite elevated serum MMA concentrations (>20 µmol/L).

CONCLUSIONS: The current reference ranges used in New Zealand for serum vitamin B₁₂ are set conservatively high. Serum MMA concentrations appear to allow better differentiation of a responsive condition than vitamin B₁₂ concentrations. Serum MMA concentrations <13 µmol/L indicate responsiveness to supplementation whilst concentrations <7 µmol/L indicate unresponsiveness. In the range 7–13 µmol/L, variation in response was observed and predictability of response is less certain, but supplementation is advisable.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The current reference ranges for vitamin B₁₂ responsiveness are conservatively high and lead to over-diagnosis of vitamin B₁₂ deficiency in ill-thriftiness of sheep.     

Serum vitamin B12 and methylmalonic acid determinations in the diagnosis of cobalt deficiency in pregnant ewes

Serum vitamin B12 and methylmalonic acid (MMA) concentrations were used to monitor the development of cobalt (Co) deficiency and repletion from the deficient state in housed pregnant hill sheep. Serum MMA concentrations were less variable and provided a more accurate diagnosis of Co deficiency than serum vitamin B12. This was particularly the case for subclinical disease. However, unlike serum MMA, concentrations of the vitamin in serum could be used prognostically. The most precise diagnosis was provided by serum vitamin B12 and MMA data used in conjunction, but where one technique is to be used, serum MMA determinations are preferred.     

An evaluation of the efficacy of injectable microencapsulated vitamin B12 in increasing and maintaining the serum and liver vitamin B12 concentrations of lambs

AIM: To develop a long-acting Vitamin B12 injection to prevent Co deficiency in sheep. METHODS: Formulations of microencapsulated Vitamin B12 in lactide-glycolide polymers were injected intramuscularly or subcutaneously into the anterior neck region of groups of 10 lambs and their efficacy determined from changes in serum and liver Vitamin B12 concentrations. RESULTS: The 95:5 lactide glycolide and the 100 lactide formulations containing more than 12.5% Vitamin B12 w/w significantly increased and maintained serum Vitamin B12 concentrations for at least 210 days as well as liver Vitamin B12 concentrations in treated lambs when compared with untreated controls. CONCLUSIONS: Injections of microencapsulated Vitamin B12 in lactide/glycolide copolymers are able to increase and maintain the Vitamin B12 status of lambs for at least 210 days. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Another option for the prevention of Co deficiency in sheep is now available using a long acting injectable Vitamin B12.     

The effect of sporidesmin toxicity on ovine serum vitamin B12 levels

A field outbreak of facial eczema occurred during a vitamin B12 response trial in young growing sheep. Pasture cobalt levels were in the low range for sheep (<0.08 mg/kg, 1.358 micromol/kg) and mean (of 3) liver vitamin B12 levels in the sheep were low (<400 nmol/kg) during the period in which facial eczema occurred. Mean serum vitamin B12 levels of the untreated group were low (<485 pmol/l) for the two months (January and February) preceding the period of facial eczema. However, levels showed an approximate 3.5 fold increase in both cobalt supplemented and unsupplemented groups with the onset of facial eczema in March. From February to March the mean serum vitamin B12 and glutamyl transferase (GGT) activity showed parallel increases with a positive correlation (r = 0.73) between log serum vitamin B12 and log serum GGT activity during the period January to July for both groups. This finding suggested that the increase in serum vitamin B12 was due to sporidesmin induced liver damage. The diagnostic implication is that, in areas where facial eczema is a problem, liver is the sample of choice for determining vitamin B12 status. because sporidesmin toxicity can elevate low serum vitamin B12 levels to diagnostically normal levels.     

A comparison of parameters used to assess liver damage in sheep treated with carbon tetrachloride.

Changes in serum enzyme levels, liver histology and liver function tests have been correlated to determine the usefulness of these tests in assessing liver status. The effects of carbon tetrachloride administration on these parameters has been determined in a group of 20 sheep. Normal levels, elevated levels after injury and the effect of elapsed time after injury are reported for serum glutamic dehydrogenase, sorbitol dehydrogenase, glutamic-oxaloacetic transaminase, glutamic-pyruvic transaminase, lactate dehydrogenase, fructose-1-phosphate adlolase, alkaline phosphatase, cholesterol and proteins. Variation in the time of elevation of enzyme activities may be useful in determining the elapsed time between acute injury and serum sampling. In comparison to sheep fed an adequate diet, a diet with a restricted protein intake was associated with increased severity of histological lesions and decreased liver function.     

Concurrent changes in serum vitamin B12 and methylmalonic acid during cobalt or vitamin B12 supplementation of lambs while suckling and after weaning on properties in the South Island of New Zealand considered to be cobalt-deficient

AIM: To compare serum analyses of vitamin B12 and methylmalonic acid (MMA) as indices of cobalt/vitamin B12 deficiency in lambs around weaning. METHODS: Lambs on five properties, considered to be cobalt- deficient, were supplemented with either cobalt bullets, or short- or long-acting vitamin B12 preparations. Blood samples, and in some cases liver biopsies, and liveweights were obtained at monthly intervals. Serum samples were assayed for vitamin B12 and MMA and liver for vitamin B12 concentrations. Pasture cobalt concentrations were measured on three of the properties. RESULTS: Pasture cobalt concentrations were generally maintained below 0.07 microg/g dry matter (DM) on the properties sampled. Growth responses to supplementation were observed on only 2/5 properties, despite serum vitamin B12 concentrations being within the currently used 'marginal' reference range (336-499 pmol/L) for at least 3 months on all properties and in the deficient reference range (0-335 pmol/L) for at least 2 months on all farms except one. Serum MMA concentrations in supplemented lambs were <2 micromol/L, except in those animals sampled 1 month after receiving treatment with a short-acting vitamin B12 injection. Serum MMA concentrations in unsupplemented animals on properties on which no growth response to supplementation occurred generally reached peak levels of between 4 and 7 micromol/L at the nadir of serum vitamin B12 concentration. When a growth response was observed, differences in weight gain between supplemented and unsupplemented lambs occurred as mean serum MMA concentrations increased from 9 to 14 micromol/L. On one property where supplementation commenced before weaning, normal growth rates were maintained despite serum vitamin B12 concentrations of 140 pmol/L and serum MMA concentrations in excess of 40 micromol/L serum. CONCLUSIONS: The possibility that current serum vitamin B12 references ranges for diagnosis of cobalt deficiency are set too high and lead to over-diagnosis of responsiveness to cobalt/ vitamin B12 supplementation is discussed. The suggestion is made that serum MMA concentrations in excess of 9-14 micromol/L will provide a more reliable diagnostic test for cobalt deficiency. However, there was sufficient variation between properties in the relationships between cobalt concentrations of pasture and serum vitamin B12 or MMA concentrations to require more rigorous testing of the reliability of using serum MMA concentration for this purpose. The possibility that differences in rumen fermentation and therefore propionate and vitamin B12 production could be involved is discussed. The measurement of serum MMA and vitamin B12 appears to be of little value whilst the lamb is still suckling. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Serum MMA concentration may offer advantages over serum vitamin B12 concentrations in the diagnosis of a cobalt/vitamin B12 responsiveness in weaned lambs.