Comparison of Compounded Deslorelin and hCG for Induction of Ovulation in Mares

Ovulation-inducing agents are routinely used in broodmare practice. The objective of this study was to compare the efficacy of two compounded deslorelin products and human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) in inducing ovulation in a clinical reproduction program. Breeding records of 203 mares administered an ovulation-inducing agent during the 2006 breeding season were reviewed. Estrous cycles were included for comparison if agents were administered when the largest follicle was 35 to 45 mm in diameter and endometrial edema was present. There was no significant difference (P > .05) in interval to ovulation for mares receiving deslorelin (1.9 ± 0.7 days) or hCG (2.0 ± 0.7 days). The percentage of mares that ovulated within 48 hours after treatment was also not significantly different between the agents (90.1% and 88.3%, respectively). In summary, clinical efficacy at inducing a timed ovulation in estrual mares with follicles 35 to 45 mm was similar between compounded deslorelin and hCG.     

Clinical experience with deslorelin (ovuplantTM) in a kentucky thoroughbred broodmare practice (1999)

Palpation records of 155 Throughbred broodmares maintained on one of seven farms (3–80 mares per farm) that were administered deslorelin on one or more estrous cycles (204 treated cycles) during the 1999 breeding season were retrospectively examined. Some deslorelin-treated mares were also treated with hCG (2500 units intravenously), or had no ovulation-inducing drugs administered, during different estrous cycles of the same season. Most mares were treated with an ovulation- inducing drug after returning to their resident farm following breeding and were subsequently examined by transrectal ultrasonography daily until ovulation was confirmed, and again 13–14 and 15–16 days after ovulation for determination of pregnancy status.Per-cycle pregnancy rate for all 155 mares bred was 53%, and for all deslorelin breeding was 57%. Per-cycle pregnancy rates for mares ovulating 0–1 days, 1–2 days, and 2–3 days after treatment with deslorelin did not differ (P>0.05). Forty-six mares received more than one treatment during the breeding season, yielding 115 breedings (estrous cycles) for comparison of pregnancy rates among treatment. Per-cycle pregnancy rates for these mares did not differ among treatments (P>0.10).No differences due to treatment were detected in mean interval to ovulation (P>0.10). Mean interovulatory interval was longer for deslorelin-treated mares than for untreated or hCG treated mares (P>0.01). Eighty percent (80%) of deslorelin-treated mares had interovulatory intervals of 18–25 days, and 19% had interovulatory intervals>25 days. Ninety-seven percent (97%) of untreated or hCG-treated mares had interovulatory interovulatory intervals>25 days. More deslorelin-treated mares had extended (>25 days) interovulatory intervals than hCG- or nontreated-mares (P>0.05). In this group of Thoroughbred mares, it appeared that season (month) and management (farm) factors had only minor effects on the incidence of extended interovulatory intervals following use of deslorelin.     

Superovulation in cycling mares using equine follicle stimulating hormone (eFSH)

Superovulation would potentially increase the efficiency and decrease the cost of embryo transfer by increasing embryo collection rates. Other potential clinical applications include improving pregnancy rates from frozen semen, treatment of subfertility in stallions and mares, and induction of ovulation in transitional mares. The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of purified equine follicle stimulating hormone (eFSH; Bioniche Animal Health USA, Inc., Athens, GA) in inducing superovulation in cycling mares. In the first experiment, 49 normal, cycling mares were used in a study at Colorado State University. Mares were assigned to 1 of 3 groups: group 1, controls (n = 29) and groups 2 and 3, eFSH-treated (n = 10/group). Treated mares were administered 25 mg of eFSH twice daily beginning 5 or 6 days after ovulation (group 2). Mares received 250 (of cloprostenol on the second day of eFSH treatment. Administration of eFSH continued until the majority of follicles reached a diameter of 35 mm, at which time a deslorelin implant was administered. Group 3 mares (n = 10) received 12 mg of eFSH twice daily starting on day 5 or 6. The treatment regimen was identical to that of group 2. Mares in all 3 groups were bred with semen from 1 of 4 stallions. Pregnancy status was determined at 14 to 16 days after ovulation.In experiment 2, 16 light-horse mares were used during the physiologic breeding season in Brazil. On the first cycle, mares served as controls, and on the second cycle, mares were administered 12 mg of eFSH twice daily until a majority of follicles were 35 mm in diameter, at which time human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) was administered. Mares were inseminated on both cycles, and embryo collection attempts were performed 7 or 8 days after ovulation.Mares treated with 25 mg of eFSH developed a greater number of follicles (35 mm) and ovulated a greater number of follicles than control mares. However, the number of pregnancies obtained per mare was not different between control mares and those receiving 25 mg of eFSH twice daily. Mares treated with 12 mg of eFSH and administered either hCG or deslorelin also developed more follicles than untreated controls. Mares receiving eFSH followed by hCG ovulated a greater number of follicles than control mares, whereas the number of ovulations from mares receiving eFSH followed by deslorelin was similar to that of control mares. Pregnancy rate for mares induced to ovulate with hCG was higher than that of control mares, whereas the pregnancy rate for eFSH-treated mares induced to ovulate with deslorelin did not differ from that of the controls. Overall, 80% of mares administered eFSH had multiple ovulations compared with 10.3% of the control mares.In experiment 2, the number of large follicles was greater in the eFSH-treated cycle than the previous untreated cycle. In addition, the number of ovulations during the cycle in which mares were treated with eFSH was greater (3.6) than for the control cycle (1.0). The average number of embryos recovered per mare for the eFSH cycle (1.9 ± 0.3) was greater than the embryo recovery rate for the control cycle (0.5 ± 0.3).In summary, the highest ovulation and the highest pregnancy and embryo recovery rates were obtained after administration of 12 mg of eFSH twice daily followed by 2500 IU of hCG. Superovulation with eFSH increased pregnancy rate and embryo recovery rate and, thus, the efficiency of the embryo transfer program.

Introduction

Induction of multiple ovulations or superovulation has been an elusive goal in the mare. Superovulation would potentially increase the efficiency and decrease the cost of embryo transfer by increasing embryo collection rates.[1 and 2] Superovulation also has been suggested as a critical requirement for other types of assisted reproductive technology in the horse, including oocyte transfer and gamete intrafallopian transfer. [2 and 3] Unfortunately, techniques used successfully to superovulate ruminants, such as administration of porcine follicle stimulating hormone and equine chorionic gonadotropin have little effect in the mare. [4 and 5]The most consistent therapy used to induce multiple ovulations in mares has been administration of purified equine pituitary gonadotropins. Equine pituitary extract (EPE) is a purified gonadotropin preparation containing approximately 6% to 10% LH and 2% to 4% FSH.[6] EPE has been used for many years to induce multiple ovulations in mares [7, 8 and 9] and increase the embryo recovery rate from embryo transfer donor mares. [10] Recently, a highly purified equine FSH product has become available commercially.The objectives of this study were to evaluate the efficacy of purified eFSH in inducing superovulation in cycling mares and to determine the relationship between ovulation rate and pregnancy rate or embryo collection rate in superovulated mares.

Materials and methods

Experiment 1

Forty-nine normally cycling mares, ranging in age from 3 to 12 years, were used in a study at Colorado State University. Group 1 (control) mares (n = 29) were examined daily when in estrus by transrectal ultrasonography. Mares were administered an implant containing 2.1 mg deslorelin (Ovuplant, Ft. Dodge Animal Health, Ft. Dodge, IA) subcutaneously in the vulva when a follicle 35 mm in diameter was detected. Mares were bred with frozen semen (800 million spermatozoa; minimum of 30% progressive motility) from 1 of 4 stallions 33 and 48 hours after deslorelin administration. The deslorelin implants were removed after detection of ovulation.[11] Pregnancy status was determined at 14 and 16 days after ovulation.Group 2 mares (n = 10) were administered 25 mg of eFSH (Bioniche Animal Health USA, Inc., Athens, GA) intramuscularly twice daily beginning 5 or 6 days after ovulation was detected. Mares received 250 g cloprostenol (Estrumate, Schering-Plough Animal Health, Omaha, NE) intramuscularly on the second day of eFSH treatment. Administration of eFSH continued until a majority of follicles reached a diameter of 35 mm, at which time a deslorelin implant was administered. Mares were subsequently bred with the same frozen semen used for control mares, and pregnancy examinations were performed as described above.Group 3 mares (n = 10) received 12 mg of eFSH twice daily starting 5 or 6 days after ovulation and were administered 250 μg cloprostenol on the second day of treatment. Mares were randomly selected to receive either a deslorelin implant (n = 5) or 2500 IU of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) intravenously (n = 5) to induce ovulation when a majority of follicles reached a diameter of 35 mm. Mares were bred with frozen semen and examined for pregnancy as described above.

Experiment 2

Sixteen cycling light-horse mares were used during the physiologic breeding season in Brazil. Reproductive activity was monitored by transrectal palpation and ultrasonography every 3 days during diestrus and daily during estrus. On the first cycle, mares were administered 2500 IU hCG intravenously once a follicle 35 mm was detected. Mares were subsequently inseminated with pooled fresh semen from 2 stallions (1 billion motile sperm) daily until ovulation was detected. An embryo collection procedure was performed 7 days after ovulation. Mares were subsequently administered cloprostenol, and eFSH treatment was initiated. Mares received 12 mg eFSH twice daily until a majority of follicles were 35 mm in diameter, at which time hCG was administered. Mares were inseminated and embryo collection attempts were performed as described previously.

Statistical analysis

In experiment 1, 1-way analysis of variance with F protected LSD was used to analyze quantitative data. Pregnancies per ovulation were analyzed by x² analysis. In experiment 2, number of large follicles, ovulation rate, and embryo recovery rate were compared by Student,'s t-test. Data are presented as the mean S.E.M. Differences were considered to be statistically significant at p < .05, unless otherwise indicated.

Results

In experiment 1, mares treated with 25 mg eFSH twice daily developed a greater number of follicles 35 mm in diameter (p = .001) and ovulated a greater number of follicles (p = .003) than control mares (Table 1). However, the number of pregnancies obtained per mare was not significantly different between the control group and the group receiving 25 mg eFSH (p = .9518). Mares treated with 12 mg eFSH and administered either hCG or deslorelin to induce ovulation also developed more follicles 35 mm (p = .0016 and .0003, respectively) than untreated controls. Mares receiving eFSH followed by hCG ovulated a greater number of follicles (p = .003) than control mares, whereas the number of ovulations for mares receiving eFSH followed by deslorelin was similar to that of control mares (p = .3463). Pregnancy rate for mares induced to ovulate with hCG was higher (p = .0119) than that of control mares, whereas the pregnancy rate for eFSH-treated mares induced to ovulate with deslorelin did not differ from that of controls (p = .692). Pregnancy rate per ovulation was not significantly different between control mares (54.5%) and mares treated with eFSH followed by hCG (52.9%). The lowest pregnancy rate per ovulation was for mares stimulated with 25 mg eFSH and induced to ovulate with deslorelin. The mean number of days mares were treated with 25 mg or 12 mg of eFSH was 7.8 ± 0.4 and 7.5 ± 0.5 days, respectively. Overall, 80.0% of mares administered eFSH had multiple ovulations compared with 10.3% of control mares.     

Effect of Deslorelin and/or Human Chorionic Gonadotropin on Inducing Ovulation in Mares During the Transition Period Versus Ovulatory Season

The objective of this study was to compare the rate of ovulation when deslorelin and/or human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) was administered in mares in both the transition period and the ovulatory season. A total of 200 Paint Horses, Quarter Horses, and crossbred mares were used during the transition season (July to September) and the ovulatory season (October to February) of the southern hemisphere. The animals were divided into four groups. In the control group (n = 72), mares received 1 mL of saline; in deslorelin group (n = 171), 1.5 mg of deslorelin was administered by intramuscular (IM) injection; in hCG group (n = 57), 1,667 IU of hCG was administered IV; and in hCG + deslorelin group (n = 438), 1.5 mg of deslorelin (IM) and 1,667 IU of hCG (IV) were administered. The drugs were administered after follicles ≥35 mm in diameter were identified and grade III uterine edema was observed. At 48 hours after application, ultrasonography was performed to detect ovulation. During the transition period, the ovulation rates were 4.3% (control), 78.6% (deslorelin), 50% (hCG), and 73.3% (hCG + deslorelin). During ovulatory season, the ovulation rates were 16.4% (control), 68.8% (deslorelin), 60% (hCG), and 73% (hCG + deslorelin). There was no significant difference (P > .05) in the ovulation rate between the groups or the periods, except that the control group was lower than all others. Furthermore, both hCG and deslorelin are viable options for inducing ovulation during the transition period before ovulation season.     

The Effect of Sulpiride Treatment During the Periovulatory Period on Prolactin Concentration and Ovulation in the Mare

Sixteen estrous cycles from 10 cyclic mares were randomly assigned to a control or sulpiride group (n = 8 each). All mares received 1,500 IU of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) (hour 0) during estrus with a follicular diameter ≥32 mm. Mares were scanned every 12 hours until ovulation. In the treatment group, beginning at hour 0, each mare received 1.5 mg/kg of sulpiride every 12 hours intra-muscularly until ovulation or formation of a luteinized unruptured follicle (LUF). Concentrations of luteinizing hormone (LH) and prolactin (PRL) were measured by radioimmunoassay. In each group, there were 10 preovulatory follicles for the eight cycles. The ovulation rate (9/10, 90%) was similar in the control and sulpiride groups. Two mares formed an LUF, which was first detected at hours 48 and 72 for the sulpiride and control mares, respectively. The interval from hCG to ovulation was 49.5 ± 11.1 and 43.5 ± 5.8 hours, for the control and sulpiride groups, respectively (P > .5). LH followed the typical preovulatory surge pattern, with no difference between groups (P > .5). Sulpiride administration increased PRL concentration in treated mares at 24 (P < .1), 36, and 48 hours (P < .05) after treatment. In conclusion, sulpiride administration every 12 hours increased PRL concentration in treated mares after 24 hours of the beginning of treatment. However, at this time window and concentration, PRL did not have any effect on ovulation. The control mare that developed an LUF had a PRL concentration similar to other ovulatory control mares (always ≤10 ng/mL).     

Does Clinical Treatment with Phenylbutazone and Meloxicam in the Pre‐ovulatory Period Influence the Ovulation Rate in Mares?

The presence of anovulatory haemorrhagic follicles during the oestrous cycle of mares causes financial impacts, slowing conception and increasing the number of services per pregnancy. Non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) such as meloxicam and phenylbutazone are used in the treatment of several disorders in mares, and these drugs can impair the formation of prostaglandins (PGs) and consequently interfere with reproductive activity. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of treatment with NSAIDs on the development of pre‐ovulatory follicles in mares. In total, 11 mares were studied over three consecutive oestrous cycles, and gynaecological and ultrasound examinations were performed every 12 h. When 32‐mm‐diameter follicles were detected, 1 mg of deslorelin was administered to induce ovulation. The first cycle was used as a control, and the mares received only a dose of deslorelin. In the subsequent cycles, in addition to receiving the same dose of deslorelin, each mare was treated with NSAIDs. In the second cycle, 4.4 mg/kg of phenylbutazone was administered, and in the third cycle, 0.6 mg/kg of meloxicam was administered once a day until ovulation or the beginning of follicular haemorrhage. All of the mares ovulated between 36 and 48 h after the induction in the control cycle. In the meloxicam cycle, 10 mares (92%) did not ovulate, while in the phenylbutazone cycle, nine mares (83%) did not ovulate. In both treatments, intrafollicular hyperechoic spots indicative of haemorrhagic follicles were observed on ultrasound. Thus, our results suggested that treatment with meloxicam and phenylbutazone at therapeutic doses induced intrafollicular haemorrhage and luteinization of anovulatory follicles.     

Effect of Follicle Size and Follicle-Stimulating Hormone on Ovulation Induction and Embryo Recovery in the Mare

The timing of ovulation is an important component to many equine breeding strategies. The action of luteinizing hormone on ovulation induction has been recognized; however, potential effects of follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) have been less defined. Objectives of this study were to determine whether (1) mares could be induced to ovulate follicles ≤30 mm; (2) equine FSH (eFSH) has a positive effect on ovulation induction, and (3) ovulation of small follicles would affect embryo recovery. Light-horse mares (n = 12) between 4 and 10 years of age were assigned to treatments when they had a dominant growing follicle with a mean diameter of 24, 28, or 35 ± 2 mm and endometrial edema. Treatments were (1) H35, human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) at 35 ± 2 mm; (2) F35, eFSH at 35 ± 2 mm; (3) H28, hCG at 28 ± 2 mm; (4) FH28, eFSH and hCG at 28 ± 2 mm; (5) D28, deslorelin (gonadotropin-releasing hormone [GnRH] analog) at 28 ± 2 mm; (6) FH24/H24, hCG or eFSH and hCG at 24 ± 2 mm. Mares’ reproductive tracts were scanned at 24 ± 2-hour intervals after treatment to detect ovulation. Mares were inseminated, and embryos were collected. Numbers of mares that ovulated within 48 ± 2 hours after treatment were: H35, 8/8 (100%); F35, 8/14 (57%); H28, 7/12 (58%); FH28, 9/12 (75%); D28, 3/7 (43%) and FH/H24, 4/14 (29%). The number of mares that ovulated in 48 ± 2 hours for H35 was not different from that for FH28 but was higher (P < .05) than all other groups. Embryo recovery rates, diameters, developmental stages, and morphology scores were not different for mares ovulating 48 hours or less versus more than 48 hours after treatment or among treatment groups. Results of this study demonstrate that follicles ≤30 mm can be induced to ovulate with no effect on embryo recovery or quality, as assessed by stereomicroscopy.     

Follicular dynamics after treatment with hCG for ovulation induction in mares

In this study the use of hCG for induction of ovulation is described. Factors such as follicle diameter at the time of administration of hCG (3000 IE hCG i.v.), follicular growth after hCG and the rate of double ovulations were evaluated. A total of 168 mares presented for artificial insemination were used. In 249 estrous periods hCG was given to mares exhibiting standing estrous when a minimum follicle diameter of 30 mm and a well developed edema of the endometrium could be detected by ultrasonography. In nine estrous periods ovulation occurred within 24 hours after hCG. The majority of mares (216; 86.7%) ovulated 24 to 48 hours after hCG and in 24 cases ovulation was delayed beyond 48 hours. Follicle size at the time of hCG administration (30-34 mm, 35-39 mm, > or = 40 mm) had no influence on the percentage of mares ovulating 24 to 48 hours after hCG (89.2%, 87.9%, and 83.7%, respectively). Double ovulations could be observed in 17.7% of estrous periods. The one cycle pregnancy rate was not influenced by follicle size (small 45.9%; medium 41.6%; large 47.5%). Repeated treatments with hCG during successive estrous cycles within one year did not influence the rate of responding to hCG. Mares in standing estrous respond well to hCG if a minimum follicle size of 30 mm and a well developed endometrial folding is present.     

Pregnancy and twinning rates in Thoroughbred mares following the administration of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG)

AIM: To determine the effect of hCG administration to cycling Thoroughbred mares, on pregnancy and twinning rates and the number of serves in the treated cycle. METHODS: A retrospective case control approach was conducted involving 2119 mare ovulatory cycles, on 1110 mares over a 7-year period. Data were collected by 1 of the authors during routine stud work at 3 commercial Thoroughbred farms in the Waikato region of New Zealand. The hCG (1500 IU) was administered by intravenous injection to selected mares 24 h before the expected time of breeding. Mares were scanned for pregnancy (singleton or twins) 14 days after the onset of dioestrus or detection of ovulation. Multilevel logistic regression analyses were used to identify the risk factors associated with the outcomes of interest while simultaneously controlling for possible confounding factors. RESULTS: Treatment with hCG tended to improve the odds of pregnancy (p=0.06), produced a 3-fold increase in the odds of twins (p<0.001), and increased the odds of a mare having a single serve in the treated ovulatory cycle (p=0.036). The first ovulatory cycle of a season in which a mare was bred was associated with a lower odds of pregnancy (p=0.02), and a lower odds of twins (p=0.003), when compared with subsequent cycles. Lactating mares were less likely to be diagnosed with twins (p=0.005), and were more likely to have a single serve (p<0.001), in any one ovulatory cycle than non-lactating mares. CONCLUSIONS: This report supports the role of hCG as an important therapeutic tool in veterinary management of broodmares for optimal reproductive performance. Mares treated with hCG must be managed in the knowledge that they have an increased likelihood of twins.     

Timing of induction of ovulation in mares treated with Ovuplant or Chorulon

Reliable induction of timed ovulation is an important managerial tool in any horse-breeding operation. Not only does breeding close to ovulation increase pregnancy rates when using cooled, frozen, or poor-quality semen, but it also reduces the number of inseminations needed per cycle, resulting in a more efficient breeding program. To better predict ovulation time in the long estrus period of the mare, one could increase the frequency of transrectal palpations and ultrasounds and/or implement hormonal therapies to induce ovulations. However, previous studies have been unclear on the exact timing of ovulation of mares treated with human chorionic gonadotropin (Chorulon, Intervet Inc, Millsboro, DE) or deslorelin acetate (Ovuplant, Pharmacia and UpJohn Co, Kalamazoo, MI). This study was designed to determine the timing of ovulation after Ovuplant or Chorulon treatment in normal cycling mares presented to the veterinary clinic. In addition, the pregnancy rates were determined for mares bred when a single insemination, using frozen or chilled semen, was performed at a fixed time (36 hours) after Ovuplant or Chorulon treatment. Thirty-two mares were given a subcutaneous injection of 7.5 mg of prostaglandin F2α (Lutlyse, Ft Dodge Animal Health, Ft Dodge, IA) 5 days after the last ovulation and were examined every 48 hours until estrus was detected based on a dominant follicle and the presence of endometrial edema as determined by ultrasonographic examination. Group 1 (N = 12) was treated intravenously with 2,500 units of Chorulon, and group 2 (N = 20) was treated subcutaneously with Ovuplant as soon as mares were determined to be in estrus. Once treated all mares were examined by rectal palpation and ultrasound at 0, 12, 24, 28, 30, 32, 34, 36, 38, 40, 42, 44, 48, 60, 72, 84, 96, hours or until ovulation was detected. Ovulation rate in response to Chorulon was 83.3% at 48 hours, 91.6% at 72 hours, and 100% at 96 hours. All of the mares in the Ovuplant-treated group had ovulated by 48 hours. Chi-square analysis of the data showed a significant (P < .01) variation in the distribution of ovulation times between mares treated with Chorulon and mares treated with Ovuplant. This study provides enough evidence to support the hypothesis that timing of ovulation is a more reliable event in mares treated with Ovuplant compared with those treated with Chorulon.     

Efficacy of the gnrh agonist deslorelin acetate for inducing ovulation in mares relative to age of mare and season

Deslorelin acetate (Ovuplant™, Fort Dodge), a GnRH agonist, is commonly used to induce ovulation in cycling mares. Although its efficacy in hastening ovulation has been previously reported, the effects of age of mare and month of administration on percent of mares responding and interval to ovulation have not been studied.Data was gathered from reproduction records of 376 mares receiving deslorelin acetate at the Equine Reproduction Laboratory, Colorado State University, from 1995 to 1999. Age of mare, date of administration, size of largest follicle at treatment, and interval to ovulation were recorded. Age of mare was categorized into five groups: 2–4, 5–9, 10–14, 15–19, and greater than or equal to 20 years. Date of administration was divided into four groups: March and April, May and June, July and August, and September and October.A higher (p < 0.05) percentage of mares aged 10–14 (98.5%) ovulated in response to deslorelin acetate than mares aged 2–4 or 5–9 (90.2% or 91.0%, respectively) or mares aged 15–19 or ≥ 20 (87.9% or 83.8%, respectively). Mares ≥ 20 had the lowest ovulation rate (83.8%). However, mares ≥ 20 that responded to deslorelin acetate had a shorter (p < 0.05) interval from treatment to ovulation (1.7 ± 0.1 days) than mares 2–4 and 5–9 years of age (1.9 ± 0.1 and 1.9 ± 0.0 days, respectively).Deslorelin acetate was more effective in inducing ovulation in the July and August (95.4%) (p < 0.01) and September and October (95.7%) (p = 0. 04) than in the March and April (81.1%). Mares treated in May through October also experienced shorter (p < 0.05) intervals to ovulation than mares treated in March and April.     

Sustained-release deslorelin acetate implants disrupt oestrous cyclicity in the mare

There is a need for a safe, effective and practical method of oestrus suppression in the mare. The aim of this study was to monitor ovarian activity in mares exposed to either 9.4 or 28.2 mg deslorelin acetate, a GnRH agonist, in the form of a sustained-release implant. Following oestrus synchronisation, mares were randomly assigned to one of three groups (n = 4 per group) and administered either one (Des1 group; 9.4 mg) or three (Des3 group; 28.2 mg) implants of deslorelin acetate (Suprelorin-12, Virbac Australia) or one blank implant (Control group; Virbac Australia). Mares underwent weekly blood sampling for 12 weeks following implant placement (Day 0–Day 84), with transrectal palpation and ultrasonography of the reproductive tract at all sampling timepoints except Days 56, 70 and 77. All mares showed baseline serum progesterone concentrations (SPC; ≤1.3 nmol/L or 0.4 ng/ml) on Day 0. Cycling Control mares showed typical oestrous cyclicity characterised by peaks and troughs in SPC over time. Four of eight treated mares demonstrated a sustained elevation in SPC after the initial ovulation after implant placement; SPC declined to baseline levels (Des1 group; 2 mares) or remained elevated (Des3 group; 2 mares) at the final sampling timepoint on Day 84. Oestrous cyclicity was erratic in three of the remaining four treated mares. In total, 87.5% (7 of 8) of treated mares showed atypical oestrous cyclicity after implant placement. These results suggest that deslorelin acetate disrupts oestrous cyclicity in the mare, which warrants further research.     

Effect of deslorelin acetate on gonadotropin secretion and ovarian follicle development in cycling mares

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate gonadotropin secretion and ovarian function after administration of deslorelin acetate to induce ovulation in mares. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. ANIMALS: 16 healthy mares with normal estrous cycles. PROCEDURE: 8 control mares were allowed to ovulate spontaneously, whereas 8 study mares received deslorelin to induce ovulation when an ovarian follicle > 35 mm in diameter was detected. Follicle development and serum concentrations of gonadotropins were monitored daily during 1 estrous cycle. Pituitary responsiveness to administration of gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) was evaluated 10 days after initial ovulation. RESULTS: Interovulatory intervals of mares treated with deslorelin (mean +/- SD, 25.6 +/- 2.6 days) were longer than those of control mares (22.9 +/- 1.8 days). Diameter of the largest follicle was significantly smaller during 2 days of the diestrous period after ovulation in deslorelin-treated mares than in control mares. Concentrations of follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) were lower in deslorelin-treated mares on days 5 through 14 than in control mares. Concentrations of luteinizing hormone were not different between groups during most of the cycle. Gonadotropin release in response to administration of GnRH was lower in mares treated with deslorelin acetate than in control mares. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Administration of deslorelin was associated with reduction in circulating concentrations of FSH and gonadotropin response to administration of GnRH during the estrous cycle. Low concentration of FSH in treated mares may lead to delayed follicular development and an increased interovulatory interval.     

Retrospective study on the incidence of postinsemination uterine fluid in mares inseminated with frozen/thawed semen

Uterine fluid accumulation has been reported after insemination or natural breeding of mares. This retrospective study examined the factors affecting the incidence of uterine fluid after insemination of frozen semen. Specifically, this study determined the association between mare age, reproductive status, fluid accumulation, and pregnancy rates in mares. Records were available from 283 warmblood mares throughout 496 cycles. Mares were divided into maiden, foaling, and barren and age groups of 3 to 9, 10 to 16, and more than 16 years. Mares were inseminated only once with frozen semen within 4 to 8 hours before or after ovulation. Ultrasound examinations were performed 12 to 18 hours after insemination. A depth of at least 20 mm of fluid was considered significant. Mares with less than 20 mm were treated with oxytocin, and those with more than 20mm of fluid were given oxytocin and uterine lavage. Pregnancy determination was performed at 14 to 16 and 30 to 50 days after ovulation. Fluid level of more than 20 mm was recorded in 25% of the cycles. Barren mares and aged mares (10-16 and > 16 years) had a higher incidence of uterine fluid accumulations. Per-cycle pregnancy rate was lower (45%) in mares with uterine fluid than in mares without uterine fluid (51%). This difference was primarily due to the reduction in fertility of mares who were older than 16 years and retained fluid after insemination. Apparently, oxytocin and lavage treatments provided acceptable fertility in the other groups of mares that had uterine fluid.

Introduction

Use of equine frozen semen is accepted by the majority of horse registries. According to several field studies,[1, 2, 3, 4 and 5] insemination of frozen semen has resulted in acceptable pregnancy rates. Postbreeding fluid accumulation is a physiologic inflammation that clears the uterus of foreign material such as excess spermatozoa, seminal plasma, bacteria, and extenders. [6, 7, 8, 9 and 10] Uterine fluid can be easily diagnosed with ultrasonography. [10, 11 and 12] Persistent postbreeding uterine fluid has been associated with a decrease in fertility after natural mating or artificial insemination (AI) of fresh semen. [11, 12 and 13] Predisposing factors to persistent fluid accumulations are reduced myometrial contractions, poor lymphatic drainage, large overstretched uterus, and cervical incompetence. [7, 14 and 15] Normal mares are able to expel uterine fluid quickly after inseminations, whereas susceptible mares accumulate fluid in their uterine lumen for more than 12 hours after breeding or insemination. [10]It is commonly stated that insemination with frozen semen leads to greater post-AI fluid accumulation than insemination with fresh or cooled semen or after natural mating. Apparently, there is only 1 controlled study on this comparison.[7] The authors reported that infusion of frozen semen resulted in a greater inflammatory response than natural breeding. In a field study, [16] 16% of mares naturally mated had persistent postbreeding fluid accumulations compared with a 30% rate reported for mares inseminated with frozen semen. [1 and 2] More recently, Watson et al. [17] reported a postbreeding fluid accumulation rate of 16%, which is identical to that reported for natural mating. [16] It is difficult to compare studies because details of mare selection and insemination or breeding frequencies are not always reported. Obviously, a higher proportion of barren and aged mares in a study would increase the incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation. [1 and 2]The study presented herein was a retrospective study designed to determine the incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation in a large number of mares inseminated with frozen semen. Associations were determined between mare age, reproductive status and fluid accumulation, and pregnancy rate in mares with and without uterine fluid accumulation.

Materials and methods

Mares

Records were available from 283 warmblood mares inseminated with frozen semen at the Cristella Veterinary Clinic in Italy during 1998 to 2001. Mares ranging in age from 3 to 20 years were inseminated with semen that was frozen in 10 centers and was from 34 stallions. The broodmare population was subdivided into 3 reproductive groups: 89 maiden mares (mean age, 7.2 years), 106 foaling mares (mean age, 9.4 years), and 87 barren mares (mean age, 11.9 years). Maiden mares older than 7 years were selected with biopsy scores of 1 or 2 only. Barren mares were open for no more than 2 consecutive seasons and had negative cytology and bacteriology scores. Age groups were divided as follows: 3 to 9 years (n = 132), 10 to 16 years (n = 137) and older than 16 years (n = 14). Data from 496 cycles were used. Distribution of the estrous cycles was 172, 157, and 167 in the maiden, foaling, and barren groups, respectively; and 224, 244, and 28 in the youngest, intermediate, and oldest groups, respectively.

Mare reproductive management and artificial insemination protocol

During estrus, all mares underwent a daily ultrasound examination with a 5-mHz transrectal probe (SA 600 Vet; Medison Inc., Seoul, South Korea) until 1 or more 35-mm ovarian follicles were detected. Ovulation was then induced by the intravenous administration of 2000 IU of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG). Ultrasound examination was performed 12 hours after hCG treatment and then every 4 to 8 hours until ovulation occurred. Mares were inseminated only once within a period of 4 to 8 hours before or after ovulation. The semen used was thawed according to the distribution center's instructions and had the following minimum post-thaw quality requirements: not less than 200 × 10⁶ progressively motile spermatozoa per dose and a minimum of 30% progressive spermatozoal motility. Foaling mares were not inseminated at their first postpartum (“foal heat”) estrous period, because pregnancy rates are recognized to be lower than during the subsequent estrous periods.[18] During the first postpartum estrus, ovarian ultrasound scan examinations were performed every 2 to 3 days until an ovulation was detected. A prostaglandin F₂α injection was given 5 days later to short-cycle the mare.

Postinsemination monitoring

An ultrasound examination of the reproductive tract was performed 12 to 18 hours after insemination to detect any intrauterine fluid accumulation. The presence and depth of intrauterine fluid was recorded. Twenty millimeters or more of grade II or III intrauterine fluid[19] was recorded as a significant amount of fluid. Mares with less than 20 mm of fluid were treated with an intravenous injection of 20 IU oxytocin. For mares with more than 20 mm of fluid, oxytocin was administered, and the uterus was flushed daily with buffered saline solution: 1-L aliquots were infused and recovered until the recovered fluid was clear. In these mares, oxytocin treatment was repeated up to 3 times daily. Post insemination treatments were performed for no more than 4 days after ovulation had occurred.Pregnancy diagnosis was performed with ultrasound at 14 to 16 days after ovulation. Scans were then repeated at 30 and 50 days of gestation to confirm the presence in the uterus of an apparently healthy developing conceptus.

Statistical analysis

χ² Analysis was used to determine the effect of reproductive status and age on the incidence of fluid accumulation. In addition, the influence of persistent uterine fluid accumulation on pregnancy rates per cycle was determined for each reproductive class and age by using χ² analysis.

Results

The per-cycle pregnancy rate at 14-16 days after ovulation was 49.3% (245/496 cycles). By the end of the season, 245 of 283 mares (86.5%) were confirmed pregnant. Fluid level of at least 20 mm (grade II or III) was recorded in 126 of the 496 cycles (25.4%). Barren mares had a higher (P < .05) incidence of postbreeding fluid accumulation (64/167; 38.3%) than maiden (34/172; 19.7%) and foaling (28/157, 17.8%; Table 1) mares. The incidence of fluid accumulation was also higher in mares older than 16 years (19/28; 67.8%) than those aged 10 to 16 years (69/244; 28.2%) and 3 to 9 years (38/224; 17%). The incidence of uterine fluid was also higher (P < .05) for mares aged 10 to 16 years than those aged 3 to 9 years (Table 2). Overall, the per-cycle pregnancy rate was lower (P < .05) for mares with post-AI fluid accumulations than for those with no uterine fluid or only a small quantity of fluid (57/126, 41.9% vs 188/360, 56.2%). Pregnancy rates were similar (P > .05) for mares with or without uterine fluid when comparisons were made within maiden and barren mare groups. However, more foaling mares became pregnant when no fluid was detected after insemination. Pregnancy rate for this group (68.1%) was higher than that for maiden (44.2%) and barren (44.6%) mares (Table 3). Older mares with uterine fluid accumulations had a lower per-cycle pregnancy rate (36.8%) than mares in the same group but without fluid. Surprisingly, if no fluid was detected, the highest pregnancy rates were in mares older than 16 years ( Table 4).     

Treatment of transition phase mares with progesterone intravaginally and with deslorelin or hCG to assist ovulations

Over four years, four investigators in the Northern Hemisphere treated 413 privately owned transition phase mares between late February and early April, for the purpose of breeding such mares early in the season. Mares received an intravaginal device (CIDR-B) carrying 1.9 g progesterone, for about 12 days. Thereafter mares forming preovulatory follicles >30 mm were either treated with a short acting implant releasing the GnRH analog deslorelin (Ovuplant™) or with 1,500—2,500 IU hCG, or not. Follicle sizes were determined with ultrasonography at admission to the study (i.e. day of CIDR-B insertion), at intervals during treatment, at device removal and in 24 (to 48) hour intervals thereafter to determine the time for treatment to induce and accelerate ovulation and to ovulation, respectively. Pregnancies were determined by ultra-sonography between Days 14 to 18 after breeding, mostly 12 to 14 days after ovulation. Based on the size of the largest follicle at admission, mares were grouped into Classes with a ollicle diameter of 10 mm or less in Class I, and mares with follicles 11-20 mm, 21-30 mm and >30 mm in Classes II, III and IV, respectively. Overall, 80.2% of all mares responded to treatment with estrus and 80.7% ovulated. For mares in Classes I to IV, the rate of mares bred and becoming pregnant was 53.4% and 66.7%, 65.6% and 58.7%, 87.5% and 52.3%, and 75.0% and 52.0%, respectively. The overall pregnancy rate was 55.6% for the first breeding in response to treatment. Mares not assisted with Ovuplant or hCG were bred at a significantly lower rate (<0.0001) and the pregnancy rate was lower, 44.4% vs. 54.2% and 60.5%, respectively. Treatments with Ovuplant or hCG ensured ovulation rates of 96.0 and 84.9% versus 53.3% in unassisted mares overall. Follicle diameters increased significantly with CIDR-B in situ, and progressed after device removal to >30 mm within 4.0 days and to ovulation 5.3 days. Those mares in Class I responding to treatment (ca 60%) did not differ from Class II to IV mares in almost all the parameter evaluated. Significant differences were seen in the UK in response to treatment between years for the percentage of mares showing heat, ovulated, were bred and became pregnant.     

Comparison of HCG, buserelin and luprostiol for induction of ovulation in cycling mares

Sixty nonlactating light-horse mares were used to compare the efficacy of hCG, buserelin (a GnRH analog) and luprostiol (a PGF₂α analog) for induction of ovulation in cycling mares. Mares were assigned to 1 of 4 treatments: 1) controls; 2) 40 μg buserelin IM at 12 hr intervals during estrus until ovulation; 3) 7.5 mg IM luprostiol; and 4) 3,300 IU hCG. Treatments were given once a mare obtained a ≥35mm follicle and had been in estrus ≥2 days. Both buserelin and hCG shortened (p<0.05) the interval from treatment to ovulation compared to controls; whereas, luprostiol failed to hasten ovulation. Number of follicles ovulated was similar among all 4 groups. Although buserelin and hCG were equal in their ability to induce ovulation, an average of 3.8 injections of buserelin was required for hastening of ovulation.     

Effect of purified equine follicle-stimulating hormone on follicular development and ovulation in transitional mares

Horse owners want to have their mares bred as early as possible in the breeding season after February 1. Numerous medical treatments, such as progesterone, dopamine antagonists, and gonadotropin-releasing hormone have been administered to anestrous or transitional mares in an attempt to induce follicular development. Some of these treatments are ineffective or impractical, so there is a need in the horse industry to develop alternative techniques to stimulate follicular development and ovulation early in the breeding season. Twenty transitional mares were assigned to one of two treatment groups. Mares in group 1 (n = 10) served as untreated controls, and mares in group 2 (n = 10) were administered 12.5 mg of purified equine follicle-stimulating hormone (eFSH) (Bioniche Animal Health USA, Inc., Athens, Ga) intramuscularly twice daily for a maximum of 15 consecutive days. Mares were considered to be in transition when the diameter of the largest follicle was ≥25 mm. Once one or more follicles >35 mm were detected, eFSH treatment was discontinued and human chorionic gonadotropin was administered intravenously. The percentage of mares ovulating during the 15-day observation period was compared by means of chi-square analysis. The interval to ovulation and the number of ovulations per mare were compared between the two groups by Student t test. In 8 of 10 mares treated with eFSH follicles developed and ovulation occurred during the 15-day observation period, compared with 0 of 10 control mares. Interval from onset of treatment to ovulation was 7.6 ± 2.4 days for these eight mares. The eight mares were treated for an average of 5.2 ± 1.3 days with eFSH. Thus, the eFSH treatment was effective in advancing the first ovulation of the year in transitional mares.     

Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG): the effect of dose on ovulation and pregnancy rate in Thoroughbred mares experiencing their first ovulation of the breeding season

AIM: To determine the effect of hCG dose on ovulation and pregnancy rate in Thoroughbred mares experiencing their first ovulation of the breeding season. METHODS: Over 3 successive breeding seasons, a total of 101 mares were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 treatment groups (intravenous injection of either saline, 1500, 3000, or 6000 IU hCG), as they approached their first ovulation of the breeding season. Mares were bred 1 day post-injection to 1 of 11 stallions, and every other day until ovulation occurred. Data were analysed using multivariable logistic regression with correction for over-dispersion due to clustering. RESULTS: Mares treated with hCG were more likely to ovulate within 72 h of treatment than mares treated with saline (p<0.001); there was no significant difference between doses of hCG on risk of ovulation (p>0.15). Farm also had a significant impact on the risk of ovulation (p=0.027). Mares treated with hCG were more likely to be diagnosed pregnant 14 days post ovulation than saline-treated mares (p=0.081, p=0.029 and p=0.026 for the 1500, 3000 and 6000 IU doses, respectively); there was no significant difference between doses of hCG on risk of pregnancy (p>0.45). CONCLUSIONS: A single injection of hCG (1500-6000 IU) is effective at inducing ovulation in late transitional mares and increases the likelihood of pregnancy at 14 days post ovulation. This paper supports the use of hCG as an integral part of optimal broodmare management.     

Effect of Dose of Cloprostenol on the Interval to Ovulation in the Diestrous Mare: A Retrospective Study

Although the ovulatory effects of prostaglandins are well documented in several domestic species including horses, there has been little attention paid to the use of this ovulatory effect for clinical purposes. Mares often grow large follicles during the luteal phase that may or may not ovulate before progesterone levels decline. Clinical observations of administering prostaglandins in diestrous mares with large follicles suggest that there may be a negative correlation between follicular diameter and interval from treatment to ovulation. The objectives of this study were twofold: to investigate the cloprostenol dose rate effect on interval to ovulation and to confirm the negative correlation between follicular diameter and interval to ovulation. The hypothesis tested was that high doses of cloprostenol given in diestrus to mares with larger follicles would induce ovulation more rapidly than in mares given lower doses or with smaller follicles. To test the hypothesis, a total of 1,234 estrous cycles were induced with different doses of cloprostenol (ranging from 8.75 to 625 μg). All mares had at least one follicle of 28 mm or larger. Dominant follicles were followed by transrectal ultrasound examinations every other day until ovulation was detected. There was a significant effect of dose (P < .000) and follicular diameter (P < .000) on the interval from treatment to ovulation. The shortest mean interval (2.4 days) was observed after administration of 625 μg in mares with follicles 36 mm or larger, whereas the longest (4.9 days) occurred after 8.75 μg in follicles of 28 to 31 mm.     

Folliculogenesis, embryo parameters and post-transfer recipient pregnancy rate following equine follicle-stimulating hormone (eFSH) treatment in cycling donor mares

Background Induction of multiple ovulations, or superovulation, may potentially increase the efficiency of equine embryo transfer programs. Our objective was to investigate the effects of equine follicle‐stimulating hormone (eFSH) treatment on the success rate of embryo transfer programs in mares. Methods In the research facility of the University of Saskatchewan, Canada, we studied 12 donor mares and 37 recipient mares during the physiological breeding season. Donor mares were used in two consecutive oestrous cycles: the first served as the control cycle and in the second an eFSH regimen was applied (eFSH cycle). In the control cycle, mares were administered human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) to induce ovulation when a follicle ≥35 mm in diameter was detected by transrectal ultrasonographic examination. In the second oestrous cycle, twice‐daily eFSH treatment was initiated when a follicle ≥25 mm was detected and treatment ceased when a follicle ≥35 mm was present, at which time hCG was administered. All donor mares were artificially inseminated while in oestrus using fresh semen collected from a stallion of proven fertility. At 8 days post‐ovulation, embryos were recovered transcervically and transferred individually to the uterus of a synchronised recipient mare. Results The eFSH treatment stimulated the ovary and resulted in greater numbers of ovulations and recovered embryos; however the recovered embryos tended to have a lower morphological grade than the control embryos, and the recipient pregnancy rate per transferred embryo was lower than anticipated. Conclusion The numbers of recipient pregnancies and foals born that resulted from eFSH treatment were not different from the control.