Application of marker‐assisted selection and genome‐wide association scanning to the development of winter food barley germplasm resources

Barley (Hordeum vulgare) is an important component of heart‐healthy whole grain diets because it contains β‐glucan. All current US barley varieties with high β‐glucan are spring habit and have waxy starch. Winter varieties have agronomic advantages but require low‐temperature tolerance (LTT). Vernalization sensitivity (VS) is associated with higher levels of LTT. To rapidly develop fall‐sown varieties with LTT and higher grain β‐glucan, we therefore used marker‐assisted selection (MAS) at the WX and VRN‐H2 loci. The MAS‐derived lines, together with unrelated non‐waxy germplasm developed via phenotypic selection (PS), were used for a genome‐wide association scan (GWAS). The panel was phenotyped for grain β‐glucan, LTT and VS. It was genotyped with 3072 single‐nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and allele‐specific primers. Marker‐assisted selection fixed target alleles at both loci but only one of the target phenotypes (higher β‐glucan percentage) was achieved. Variation for VS and LTT is attributable to (i) incomplete information about VRN‐H1 at the outset of the project and (ii) unexpected allelic variation at VRN‐H3 with a large effect on VS and LTT.     

Gain from marker‐based recurrent selection for increased heterozygosity in barley

Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) is a highly adaptable cereal crop grown under a wide range of agro‐ecological conditions. Various literature reports demonstrate that heterozygosity may enhance the yielding level and stability of barley particularly in stress‐prone environments. The major aim of this study was to investigate whether recurrent selection (RS) for heterozygosity at highly polymorphic codominant molecular marker loci increases outcrossing in a genetically broad‐based population. Four to six SSR marker loci were used for this purpose. Selection was conducted over four cycles. Progress from selection was evaluated in a terminal experiment comprised of population samples from all four RS cycles. All experiments were conducted under greenhouse conditions. The starting population was composed of 201 gene bank accessions (178 lines, 12 landraces and 11 wild barley populations) sampled in West Asia and North Africa. Selection led to a stepwise increase in heterozygosity from 0.23% to 1.50%. Correspondingly, the estimated multilocus outbreeding rate rose from 1.4% to 3.5%. This positive selection response offers new perspectives for improving the productivity of barley in stress‐prone areas.     

Breeding for boron tolerance in lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.) using a high‐throughput phenotypic assay and molecular markers

This study describes the identification of a quantitative trait locus (QTL) in the recombinant inbred line population of ILL2024 × ILL6788 and subsequent validation of associated molecular markers. A high‐quality genetic linkage map was constructed with 758 markers that cover 1,057 cM, with an average intermarker distance of 2 cM. QTL analysis revealed a single genomic region on Lc2 to be associated with B tolerance and accounted for up to 76% of phenotypic variation (Vp). The best markers for B tolerance were assessed for their utility in routine breeding applications using validation panels of diverse lentil germplasm and breeding material derived from ILL2024. A marker generated from the dense genetic map of this study was found to be the most accurate of all markers available for B tolerance in lentil, with a success rate of 93% within a large breeding pool derived from ILL2024. However, given the number of the unrelated lines for which the marker–trait association was not conserved, B tolerance screening is still required at later stages to confirm predicted phenotypes.     

Development of a molecular marker for self‐compatible S4′ haplotype in sweet cherry (Prunus avium L.) using high‐resolution melting

Sweet cherry (Prunus avium L.) has stylar gametophytic self‐incompatibility, which is controlled by the multi‐allelic S‐locus and encompasses the highly polymorphic genes for the S‐ribonuclease (S‐RNase) and S‐haplotype‐specific F‐box (SFB), which are female and male determinants, respectively. The self‐compatible mutant SFB4′ corresponds to an allele variant of SFB4 and presents a frameshift mutation. Even though male‐determinant molecular markers can discriminate between SFB4 and SFB4′ alleles, the methods required are laborious, time‐consuming and expensive, and not suitable for massive analysis and integration into breeding programmes. Our aim was to develop molecular markers for the evaluation of self‐compatibility alleles in sweet cherry, that could be used as a high‐throughput screening strategy to identify SFB4 and SFB4′ alleles, based on a marker for male determinacy. Our results were consistent using primers flanking the mutation responsible for the SFB4′ allele. We designed a specific molecular marker and confirmed it in sweet cherry commercial varieties. This new molecular marker is feasible for self‐compatibility alleles in the male determinant in sweet cherry‐assisted breeding programs.     

A high-throughput, low cost gel-based SNP assay for positional cloning and marker assisted breeding of useful genes in cereals

Several SNP (single nucleotide polymorphism) genotyping methods have been developed in the past most of which require sophisticated instrumentation and large initial investments. We describe here a high-throughput SSCP (single strand conformation polymorphism) system on our HEGS (high efficiency genome scanning) platform, which is simple, accurate, cost effective and requires neither restriction digestion of the amplification products nor elaborate post-PCR processing detection. Several parameters critical to SSCP analysis were optimized viz., gel matrix and concentration, gel running temperature, buffer composition, running conditions and PCR primer design so as to identify SNPs in amplicons ranging from 100 to 750 bp in size. A simple post-PCR processing system was developed using fluorescent dye for quick and easy detection of SNP polymorphism. HEGS-SSCP was also found to be useful in uncovering simple sequence repeat differences between different genotypes that differ by one or few di/tri nucleotide repeats. The practical utility of this system is illustrated with two successful efforts towards construction of high resolution linkage maps of a lesion mimic locus on chromosome 7 and a major quantitative trait locus conditioning field blast resistance on chromosome 4 in rice.     

Marker-assisted characterization of frost tolerance in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

Five molecular markers associated to two frost tolerance QTLs ( Fr-H1 and Fr-H2 ) were tested both on nine Turkish accessions, classified by breeders as highly frost-tolerant, and on a previously described sample of 26 barleys, winter, facultative and spring. Accessions were characterized in terms of frost tolerance under both field conditions and artificial freezing test at −12°C. The Turkish lines resulted to be equal or superior to the most tolerant European genotypes tested, showing that they can be used to improve the frost tolerance of the EU barley germplasm. The marker Hv BM5A ( Vrn-H1 and Fr-H1 ) resulted to be the best predictor for assisted selection within this germplasm, because of its high correlation between allelic variation and phenotypic traits. Only Hv CBF4 of the three Hv CBF markers tested at Fr-H2 was associated to the trait, but at lower significance than HvBM5A . The PCR-based molecular marker of Vrn-H1 can thus be used in barley breeding not only for selection of facultative and winter types, but also for fast routine selection of frost tolerant genotypes.     

Development of an STS marker and SSRs suitable for marker-assisted selection for the BaMMV resistance gene rym9 in barley

Based on the RAPD marker OP‐C04H910 which is closely linked to the barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) resistance gene rym9 derived from the variety ‘Bulgarian 347’ the marker STS‐C04H910 cosegregating with OP‐C04H910 and generating a single additional band on plants carrying the recessive resistance encoding allele has been developed. Furthermore, the simple sequence repeats (SSRs) WMS6 and HVM67 have been integrated into the genetic map of the rym9 region on chromosome 4HL. Because of their close linkage to rym9 and distinct banding pattern STS‐C04H910 and HVM67 are well‐suited for marker‐ assisted selection, enhanced backcrossing procedures and pyramiding of resistance genes.     

Marker-assisted backcross introgression of the Yd2 gene conferring resistance to barley yellow dwarf virus in barley

YLM, a codaominant polymerase chain reaction (PCR) marker linked to Yd2, could substantially improve the precision and efficiency of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV) resistance breeding. The aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness of YLM in a marker‐assisted introgression programme and to quantify associations between the presence of Yd2 and other agronomic and quality traits. The Yd2 gene was introgressed into a BYDV‐susceptible background through two cycles of marker‐assisted backcrossing. BC₂ F₂‐derived lines, either carrying or not carrying the YLM allele associated with resistance, were compared in the presence and absence of BYDV. The YLM marker was shown to be effective in the introgression of Yd2. Lines carrying the YLM allele associated with resistance produced significantly fewer leaf symptoms and showed a reduction in yield loss when infected with BYDV. There were no deleterious effects associated with the introgression of Yd2 on grain yield, grain size or malting quality. The implications of marker‐assisted selection for Yd2 on barley improvement are discussed.     

Targeted transfer of trait for Verticillium wilt resistance from Gossypium barbadense into G. hirsutum using SSR markers

Verticillium wilt (VW) is a soil‐borne disease of cotton that is destructive worldwide. Transferring desired traits from Gossypium barbadense is challenging through traditional interspecific introgression. We previously demonstrated that a molecular marker, BNL3255‐208, is associated with VW resistance in G. barbadense. This breakthrough opens the way for marker‐assisted selection (MAS) breeding. Here, the highly resistant G. barbadense cv. ‘Pima90‐53’ and the severe diseased Gossypium hirsutum cv. ‘CCRI8’ were used as donor parent and recipient parent, respectively. Our goal was to transfer the disease resistance from donor to recipient via MAS. Among 71 MAS obtained lines, as many as 19 lines had enhanced resistance. Among those lines, 11 lines showed high resistance and four lines displayed resistance to VW. Moreover, seven lines displayed improved fibre quality. After combining the markedly improved resistance and fibre properties, we identified two elite innovated introgression lines – ZY2 and ZY31 – that did not seem to differ in other agronomic traits from the recipient parent. This study first successfully transferred of G. barbadense resistance into G. hirsutum by MAS.     

Alleles at a quantitative trait locus for stem solidness in wheat affect temporal patterns of pith expression and level of resistance to the wheat stem sawfly

The stem solidness trait in wheat has been the most effective mechanism for management of the wheat stem sawfly (WSS) for six decades. However, recent results have shown that in certain genotypes, the degree of stem solidness is not a useful indicator of WSS resistance. A morphological characterization of solidness expression indicated that in the genotype ‘Conan’, very solid pith undergoes rapid retraction during stem maturation, resulting in significantly less solidness at maturity. In other solid‐stemmed genotypes, including the standard WSS‐resistant cultivar ‘Choteau’, dense pith in the stem remains nearly unchanged throughout plant development. In cage trials, ‘Conan’ plants were less preferred for oviposition by the WSS when paired with ‘Choteau’ plants. Field bioassays using near‐isogenic lines differing for alleles at Qss.msub‐3BL showed that the Conan allele provides higher levels of early stem solidness and rapid pith retraction during stem maturation. These results suggest that the traditional approach for increasing WSS resistance by selecting for increasing stem solidness needs to be modified to consider temporal variations in pith expression associated with alleles at Qss.msub‐3BL.     

Evaluation of a barley (Hordeum vulgare) chromosome 2 drought tolerance quantitative trait locus in genomic backgrounds of two cultivars

A barley drought tolerance Quantitatif Trait Locus (QTL) on chromosome 2 was transferred from tolerant cultivar ‘Tadmor’ to susceptible ‘Baronesse’ and ‘Aydanhanım’. Effects of this QTL on drought tolerance and other traits were studied using near-isogenic lines under controlled environments and field trials for two years. This QTL resulted in 5.0% and 9.1% improvement in leaf relative water content of ‘Baronesse’ and ‘Aydanhanım’ cultivars, respectively, under controlled environments. The QTL accelerated heading and maturity by 2.5 days in ‘Baronesse’ and by 5–6 days in ‘Aydanhanım’. It was associated with shorter stature and more ears. This QTL region increased grain yields by 1.1 and 0.6 t/ha in ‘Baronesse’ and ‘Aydanhanım’, respectively, mainly by increasing the number of tillers. There were previous reports related to yield promoting effects of this region harbouring flowering locus eps2 (barley HvCEN gene). However, sequencing of 1025 bp fragment encompassing HvCEN coding region revealed that our parents and near-isogenic lines had no Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) variation, ruling out direct involvement of eps2. These findings pointed to the possible effect of another flowering locus in the QTL region.     

Multiplex PCR genotyping for five bacterial blight resistance genes applied to marker‐assisted selection in rice (Oryza sativa)

Bacterial blight (BB) is the most economically damaging disease of rice in Asia and other parts of the world. In this study, a multiplex PCR genotyping method was developed to simultaneously identify genotypes of five BB resistance genes, Xa4, xa5, Xa7, xa13 and Xa21. The resistance R alleles were amplified using five functional markers (FMs) to generate amplicons of 217, 103, 179, 381 and 595 bp in IRBB66. Amplicons of 198, 107, 87, 391 and 467 bp corresponded to susceptible alleles in Taiwanese japonica rice cultivars. In backcross breeding programmes, the multiplex PCR assay was integrated into selection from a population using BB resistance donor IRBB66 crossed to rice cultivar ‘Tainung82’. Two plants with homozygosity for Xa4, xa5, Xa7, xa13 and Xa21 were selected from 1100 BC₂F₂ plants. In addition, the five BB resistance genes were also accurately identified in F₂ populations. This multiplex PCR method provides a rapid and efficient method for detecting various BB resistance genes, which will assist in pyramiding genes to improve durability of BB resistance in Taiwanese elite rice cultivars.     

Efficient marker‐assisted backcross conversion of seed‐parent lines to cytoplasmic male sterility

For many crops, cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) is a cornerstone of hybrid production. Efficient conversion of elite lines to CMS by marker‐assisted backcrossing is therefore desirable. In contrast to gene introgression, for which donor segments around target genes have to be considered, background selection for CMS conversion focuses solely on recovery of the recurrent parent genome. The optimal selection strategies for CMS conversion will consequently differ from those for gene introgression and have not yet been investigated. The objectives of our study were to evaluate and optimize the resource requirements of CMS conversion programmes and to determine the most cost‐effective use of single‐marker (SM) and high‐throughput (HT) assays for this purpose. We conducted computer simulations for CMS conversion of genetic models of sugar beet, rye, sunflower and rapeseed. CMS conversion required fewer resources than gene introgression with respect to population size, marker data points and number of backcross generations. Combining HT assays in early backcross generations with SM assays in advanced backcross generations further increased the cost‐efficiency of CMS conversion for a broad range of cost ratios.     

Discovery and genotyping of high-throughput SNP markers for crown rust resistance gene Pc94 in cultivated oat

Crown rust caused by Puccinia coronata f. sp. avenae Eriks is a serious problem for oat production worldwide and pyramiding multiple resistance genes into new cultivars is a key objective of breeders. Many race specific resistance genes have been mapped and markers that are closely linked to them have been identified. However, the use of these markers in oat breeding practice has been limited due to the economics of marker assisted selection (MAS) deployment. Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers have been demonstrated to have a high-throughput capability with relatively low cost and numerous semi-automated SNP scoring platforms exist. Gene Pc94 has remained highly effective since it was first tested on the Canadian crown rust populations in 1993 and is one of the few effective genes available in Western Canada. In the present study, PCR products were amplified using primers derived from sequences of amplified fragment length polymorphism bands which have been shown to be linked to Pc94 . Genomic DNA from genotypes, with and without the Pc94 gene, were used as the PCR templates. By comparative sequence alignment amongst the PCR fragments, many putative SNP sites were identified. From these sites, four SNP sites were selected and validated by the single base extension method. One SNP site, Pc94 -SNP1a, was tested on two F_2:3 populations segregating for the resistance gene. The map distances between the SNP marker and Pc94 were 2.1 and 5.4 cM in the two different populations. Various oat cultivars and germplasm lines were also tested for a wider application of the SNP marker. Fluorescent technology and capillary electrophoresis allowed for the semi-automated, fairly high-throughput scoring of the SNP markers.     

Marker‐assisted breeding of Pi‐1 and Piz‐5 genes imparting resistance to rice blast in PRR78, restorer line of Pusa RH‐10 Basmati rice hybrid

Rice blast, caused by fungus Magnaporthe grisea, is a serious disease causing considerable economic damage worldwide. Best way to overcome disease is to breed for disease‐resistant cultivars/parental lines of hybrids. Pusa RH10, first aromatic, fine‐grain rice hybrid released and cultivated extensively in India. Hybrid and its parental lines, Pusa 6A and PRR78, are highly susceptible to blast. CO39 pyramid carrying two dominant, broad‐spectrum blast‐resistance genes, viz. Pi‐1 and Piz‐5, used as a donor parent to introgress these genes into PRR78 using marker‐assisted backcrossing (MABC). Microsatellite markers RM5926 and AP5659‐5 tightly linked to Pi‐1 and Piz‐5 genes, respectively, were used for foreground selection to derive introgression lines. Further, these lines were evaluated for agronomic performance, disease reaction and cooking quality traits along with PRR78. Most of the improved lines were on par with PRR78 for all traits evaluated except gelatinization temperature. Recurrent parent genome percentage (RPG) study also revealed similarity of these lines with PRR78. Hybrids derived using improved PRR78 lines were superior over Pusa RH10 in terms of yield.