Early growth responses from weed control and planting larger stock of Pinus radiata are greater than that obtained from mechanical soil cultivation

Early growth of two grades ofbare-root Pinus radiata D.Don seedlingswere studied in response to four soilcultivation treatments and two weed controltreatments.Soil cultivation treatments included (i) pitsmade by hand, (ii) pits made with an auger,(iii) ripping alone, and (iv) ripping plusdisking. Weed treatments included (i) manualrelease 1 year after planting or (ii) totalweed control for 1 year involving the use ofherbicides and additional hoeing. Bare-rootseedlings were separated into either medium(4.1-mm average root-collar diameter; height25–31 cm) or small (2.8-mm average root-collardiameter; height 14–20 cm) size classes.Growth on this site was excellent and 7 yearsafter treatment, trees in the least expensivetreatment averaged 12.8 m in height. Use ofmedium seedlings and extra weed controlincreased merchantable volume by20 m³ ha^{minus 1} and 19 m³ ha^{minus 1},respectively. When combined, the increase was39 m³ ha^{minus 1}. However, none of the soilcultivation treatments caused a significantincrease in merchantable volume. Disking onthis site proved to be of no benefit. Aboundary-line analysis was used to examine themarginal returns from investing in intensivesilviculture.