Optimizing ex situ genetic resource collections for European livestock conservation

Ex situ collections offer the potential to reduce extinction risks, affording option to society in maintaining future breeding opportunities for productivity and heritage traits. However, how much should we be seeking to collect and conserve in gene banks, and where? We developed a mathematical model to optimize logistical decisions of breed conservation choices and to evaluate alternative scenarios for efficiently re‐allocating genetic materials currently stored in different European gene banks, allowing for cross‐country collections, cost and cryogenic capacity differentials. We show how alternative allocations for the breeds that are currently stored in 11 European gene banks could reduce overall conservation costs by around 20% by selecting cryogenic banks that have relatively lower combination of fixed and collection costs, and are geographically closer to collection regions. Our results show that centralizing collections in one gene bank would double the costs, relative to collective European collections approaches. We also calculate marginal costs of collections and show that increasing diversity within the gene banks implies in higher costs per conserved breed.     

Effect of sire mating patterns on future genetic merit and inbreeding in a closed beef cattle population

Summary Alternative breeding strategies were simulated based on the population structure of the Tajima strain of Japanese Black cattle. An analysis of the population structure revealed that some sires up to 20 years of age have been used in Tajima. In addition, 95% of newborn calves were the progeny of only 20 sires, and their mating frequencies were significantly skewed. The current average inbreeding coefficient and founder genome equivalents of the strain were estimated to be 0.199 and 2.25, respectively. Average inbreeding coefficient is expected to reach 0.394 within 27 years. Thus, different breeding strategies were assessed for their effect on the level of inbreeding and average genetic merit. We compared strategies that (1) halve the sire service period, (2) double the number of mating sires and (3) lower the skewed sire mating frequency and optimize the frequency for weighted genetic merit and diversity. Reducing the service period yielded a 7.0–12.0% reduction in the rate of inbreeding while maintaining almost the same genetic gain. Increasing the number of sires resulted in a 19.3–21.3% reduction in inbreeding with a corresponding 1.6–8.4% reduction in gain. The rates of inbreeding from the optimized strategies decreased as the weight on genetic diversity increased. However, a strategy that emphasized only genetic gain yielded lower gain than other strategies because the strategy allowed only one sire to mate, resulting in reduced genetic variance and low accuracy of genetic evaluation. In contrast, a strategy with no emphasis on genetic gain when determining mating frequency resulted in reductions of 16.0% and 63.2% in genetic gain and inbreeding, respectively. The strategies examined here are easily applicable and can be expected to reduce immediate loss of genetic diversity.     

燕麦种质资源遗传多样性ISSR研究

采用ISSR分子标记技术对来自中国、加拿大、美国和欧洲等国家的42个有代表性的饲用燕麦品种及6个裸燕麦品种进行遗传多样性分析。筛选出8个引物共扩增出多态性带144 条,多态性条带比率(PPB)为86.1%。由Nei’s指数(h)估测,应试皮燕麦、裸燕麦品种平均变异分别为0.203 6和0.201 5,平均Shannon’s信息指数估计值为0.325 9和0.305 8;48个燕麦品种间遗传相似系数为0.583 3~0.941 7,遗传距离的变化范围是 0.060 1~0.539 0。结果表明燕麦具有较丰富的遗传多样性,且皮燕麦的遗传多样性高于裸燕麦。根据ISSR数据进行了聚类分析和主成分分析,可将48 份燕麦材料分为五大类,来源相同的品种大致聚在一类,呈现出一定的地域性分布规律。皮燕麦与裸燕麦在遗传相似度0.66处被明显分为2类,与形态学及其他标记分类结果一致,由ISSR揭示的品种间遗传关系与品种实际来源基本一致。     

垂穗披碱草种质资源繁殖相关特性遗传多样性研究

对采自甘肃、青海以及四川等地的50个垂穗披碱草居群的穗长、穗宽、每穗小穗数、种长、芒长和千粒重等6个与其繁殖相关的性状进行了遗传多样性研究。Shannon-weaver指数分析显示,50个居群在形态性状上具有丰富的遗传多样性(H′=1.873)。遗传多样性主要集中在居群内部(63.8%),居群间存在一定的遗传变异(36.2%)。各性状间的遗传变异具有不均衡性,穗宽变异较大(CV=0.347 2),种长变异最小(CV=0.118 4)。聚类分析表明,50个居群可分为3组;相关分析结果表明,海拔、经度、纬度、年均温和年均降水量对垂穗披碱草的繁殖性状变异有不同程度的影响,其中海拔和年均温对穗长和每穗小穗数影响极显著(P<0.01)。此外,提出了垂穗披碱草的利用和保护建议。     

Genetic characterization of the Blonde d'Aquitaine cattle breed using microsatellite markers and relationship with three other French cattle populations

This study was conducted to evaluate the genetic diversity of Blonde d'Aquitaine, a well-muscled native French beef breed, and to understand the relationships between Blonde d'Aquitaine, Limousin and Salers. We also compared these three beef breeds to the Holstein dairy breed. For this purpose, a set of 16 microsatellite markers were investigated. The obtained results show that Blonde d'Aquitaine has a high level of genetic diversity. Our study shows also that the French beef breeds have genetic differentiation among them, with approximately 9% of the total variation owing to breed differences. Our results show also that Blonde d'Aquitaine and Salers populations are genetically more similar to each other than to the Limousin.     

The effects of dog breed development on genetic diversity and the relative influences of performance and conformation breeding

Genetic diversity was compared among eight dog breeds selected primarily for conformation (Standard Poodle, Italian Greyhound and show English Setter), conformation and performance (Brittany), predominantly performance (German Shorthaired and Wirehaired Pointers) or solely performance (field English Setter and Red Setter). Modern village dogs, which better reflect ancestral genetic diversity, were used as the standard. Four to seven maternal and one to two Y haplotypes were found per breed, with one usually dominant. Diversity of maternal haplotypes was greatest in village dogs, intermediate in performance breeds and lowest in conformation breeds. Maternal haplotype sharing occurred across all breeds, while Y haplotypes were more breed specific. Almost all paternal haplotypes were identified among village dogs, with the exception of the dominant Y haplotype in Brittanys, which has not been identified heretofore. The highest heterozygosity based on 24 autosomal microsatellites was found in village dogs and the lowest in conformation (show) breeds. Principal coordinate analysis indicated that conformation‐type breeds were distinct from breeds heavily used for performance, the latter clustering more closely with village dogs. The Brittany, a well‐established dual show and field breed, was also genetically intermediate between the conformation and performance breeds. The number of DLA‐DRB1 alleles varied from 3 to 10 per breed with extensive sharing. SNPs across the wider DLA region were more frequently homozygous in all pure breeds than in village dogs. Compared with their village dog relatives, all modern breed dogs exhibit reduced genetic diversity. Genetic diversity was even more reduced among breeds under selection for show/conformation.     

Analysis of genetic and cultural conservation value of three indigenous Croatian cattle breeds in a local and global context

It is widely accepted that autochthonous cattle breeds can be important genetic resources for unforeseeable environmental conditions in the future. Apart from that, they often represent local culture and tradition and thus assist in the awareness of ethnic identity of a country. In Croatia, there are only three indigenous cattle breeds, Croatian Bu?a, Slavonian Syrmian Podolian and Istrian Cattle. All of them are threatened but specialized in a particular habitat and production system. We analysed 93 microsatellites in 51 animals of each breed to get thorough information about genetic diversity and population structure. We further set them within an existing frame of additional 16 breeds that have been genotyped for the same marker set and cover a geographical area from the domestication centre near Anatolia, through the Balkan and alpine regions, to the north‐west of Europe. The cultural value was evaluated regarding the role in landscape, gastronomy, folklore and handicraft. The overall results recognize Croatian Bu?a being partly admixed but harbouring an enormous genetic diversity comparable with other traditional unselected Bu?a breeds in the Anatolian and Balkan areas. The Podolian cattle showed the lowest genetic diversity at the highest genetic distance to all remaining breeds but are playing an important role as part of the cultural landscape and thus contribute to the tourist industry. The genetic diversity of the Istrian cattle was found in the middle range of this study. It is already included in the tourist industry as a local food speciality. Current and future conservation strategies are discussed.     

不同地域长爪沙鼠群体间遗传状况分析

应用27个生化基因位点,分别对首都医科大学实验动物科学部和浙江省实验动物中心饲育的2个长爪沙鼠群体进行了遗传分析。结果显示,首都医科大学实验动物科学部长爪沙鼠群体遗传适应性、遗传多样性水平、遗传变异程度都明显高于浙江省实验动物中心沙鼠群体（P〈0.05）,并且这2个沙鼠群体间未出现较为明显的遗传分化（FST〉0.05）。     

The assessment of genetic diversity within and among the eight subpopulations of Japanese Black cattle using 52 microsatellite markers

Japanese Black cattle are at risk for genetic homogeneity due to intensive use of a few sires. Therefore, assessment of the actual genetic diversity of this breed is important for future breeding plans. In the present study, we investigated the genetic diversity within and among eight subpopulations of Japanese Black cattle using 52 microsatellite markers. The parameters for genetic diversity of Japanese Black cattle were comparable to those of other cattle breeds, suggesting that the relatively high genetic diversity of the breed. However, upon comparison among the eight subpopulations, the Hyogo subpopulation showed markedly low genetic diversity. The results of the pairwise F_ST values, phylogenetic network and structure analysis indicated that the Hyogo population has remarkably high level of genetic differentiation from other populations, while Yamagata, Niigata, Hiroshima and Kagawa populations have low levels of genetic differentiation. Furthermore, multidimensional scaling plots indicated that individuals in some subpopulations were separated from individuals in the other subpopulations. We conclude that while the overall genetic diversity of Japanese Black cattle is still maintained at a relatively high level, that of a particular subpopulation is significantly reduced, and therefore the effective population size of the breed needs to be controlled by correct mating strategies.     

种群遗传变异及基因多样度分析

阐述了种群遗传学和生态遗传学研究的基本单位－种群的定义和意念含义,其一是种系变异含义,其二是生态适应含义,并概述了遗传变异的研究历史。从３个方面及质量性状变异,数量性状变异与基金变异,介绍了种群遗传变异的研究方法,重点介绍了基因变异的测量和亚种群基因多样度的测量,并且依据研究所得的遗传参数对中国苜蓿不同种群遗传结构和多样度进行了例证分析。     

The impact of genetic merit on ewe performance and efficiency parameters

The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of ewe genetic merit on ewe performance and efficiency parameters. The study consisted of three genetic merit groups (New Zealand [NZ], High Irish, and Low Irish) and ran from 2016 to 2019, inclusive. Each genetic merit group contained 30 purebred Suffolk and 30 purebred Texel ewes, which were selected based on their maternal genetic indexes in their country of origin, namely Ireland (€uro-star Replacement index) or New Zealand (New Zealand Maternal worth). Ewe body condition score (BCS), ewe body weight (BW), milk yield, milk composition, dry matter intake (DMI), and efficiency parameters were all analyzed using linear mixed models. Ewe BW was similar across all genetic merit groups at each time point (P > 0.05). In comparison to both High and Low Irish ewes, NZ ewes had a higher BCS at mating, mid-pregnancy, lambing, week 10 post-lambing (PL, P < 0.05). Ewe BW change was similar across genetic merit groups, except between mating and mid-pregnancy where ewe BW loss was greater for NZ ewes than Irish ewes (P < 0.05) and between weeks 6 PL and 10 PL, where NZ ewes gained BW and High and Low Irish ewes lost BW (P < 0.01). Ewe milk yield, milk fat, total solids, and gross energy content were superior for milk produced by NZ ewes at week 6 PL in comparison to milk produced by High Irish and Low Irish ewes (P < 0.01). NZ ewes produced a greater quantity of milk solids/kg of BW at week 6 PL compared with High Irish ewes (P < 0.01), whereas Low Irish ewes did not differ from either NZ or High Irish (P > 0.05). Low Irish ewes had a greater daily DMI than High Irish ewes in late lactation (week 10 PL, P < 0.05) and had a greater DMI/kg of ewe BW compared with the High Irish ewes at the same time point (P < 0.05). NZ ewes weaned a litter BW equivalent to 60.4% of their mating BW, which was more than the Low Irish ewes who weaned 57.1% of the ewe’s BW at mating (P < 0.01), whereas the High Irish ewes did not differ from either the NZ or Low Irish ewes at 59.3% of the ewe’s BW at mating (P > 0.05). This study presents a range of parameters across ewes of high and low genetic merit, demonstrating the ability to achieve gains through selection of animals of high genetic merit. Sheep producers should consider genetic indexes as a tool to assist in the decision-making process of selecting replacement ewes and/or breeding rams, once satisfied the animal is correct, and meeting the breeding objectives of the system.     

The impact of direct-maternal genetic correlations on international beef cattle evaluations for Limousin weaning weight

In beef cattle maternally influenced traits, estimates of direct-maternal genetic correlations (r_dm) are usually reported to be negative. In international evaluations, r_dm can differ both within countries (r_{dm_WC}) and between countries (r_{dm_BC}). The r_{dm_BC} are difficult to estimate and are assumed to be zero in the current model for international beef cattle evaluations (Interbeef). Our objective was to investigate re-ranking of international estimated breeding values (IEBVs) in international beef cattle evaluations between models that either used estimated values for r_dm or assumed them to be 0. Age-adjusted weaning weights and pedigree data were available for Limousin beef cattle from ten European countries. International EBVs were obtained using a multi-trait animal model with countries modeled as different traits. We compared IEBVs from a model that uses estimated r_{dm_BC} (ranging between −0.14 and +0.14) and r_{dm_WC} (between −0.33 and +0.40) with IEBVs obtained either from the current model that assumes r_{dm_BC} to be 0, or from an alternative model that assumes both r_{dm_BC} and r_{dm_WC} to be 0. Direct and maternal IEBVs were compared across those three scenarios for different groups of animals. The ratio of population accuracies from the linear regression method was used to further investigate the impact of r_dm on international evaluations, for both the whole set of animals in the evaluation and the domestic ones. Ignoring r_{dm_BC}, i.e., replacing estimated values with 0, resulted in no (rank correlations > 0.99) or limited (between 0.98 and 0.99) re-ranking for direct and maternal IEBVs, respectively. Both r_{dm_BC} and r_{dm_WC} had less impact on direct IEBVs than on maternal IEBVs. Re-ranking of maternal IEBVs decreased with increasing reliability. Ignoring r_{dm_BC} resulted in no re-ranking for sires with IEBVs that might be exchanged across countries and limited re-ranking for the top 100 sires. Using estimated r_{dm_BC} values instead of considering them to be 0 resulted in null to limited increases in population accuracy. Ignoring both r_{dm_BC} and r_{dm_WC} resulted in considerable re-ranking of animals’ IEBVs in all groups of animals evaluated. This study showed the limited impact of the current practice of ignoring r_{dm_BC} in international evaluations for Limousin weaning weight, most likely because the estimated r_{dm_BC} was close to 0. We expect that these conclusions can be extended to other traits that have reported r_dm values in the range of r_{dm_WC} values for weaning weight in Limousin.     

The genetic diversity and structure of 18 sheep breeds exposed to isolation and selection

The phylogenetic layout of the genotyped (30 microsatellite) 18 sheep breeds in this study demands and provides the opportunity to evaluate both neutral and adaptive components of genetic diversity in a naturally and artificially selected and subdivided sheep population. Seven Pramenka strains from Bosnia and Herzegovina and Croatia characterized by a very low intensity of artificial selection, preserved the highest neutral genetic variability. Eight central and north‐western European breeds under considerable artificial isolation and selection preserved the lowest genetic variability. Only combinations of various phylogenetic parameters offer a reasonable explanation for underlying evolutionary forces working in the investigated island and mainland sheep breeds under variable natural and artificial selection. More than 60% of total genetic, diversity was allocated to virtually unselected Pramenka strains, and an additional 25% to native moderately selected Graue Gehoernte Heidschnucke and intensively selected Ostfriesische Milchschafe. Some economically very important breeds and strains did not contribute to a pool with maximal genetic diversity, while they play an important role in the cultural heritage of respective countries.     

30份野牛草种质的遗传多样性

以从美国及中国收集的30份野牛草（Buchloe dactyloides）种质为研究对象,对供试材料的基本坪用性状如叶长、叶宽、株高、茎粗、分蘖数、匍匐茎数量、匍匐茎长度、匍匐茎节数、叶色、叶片枯黄程度等进行田间观测。利用简单重复序列（ISSR）分子标记技术,对供试野牛草的遗传多样性进行分析。研究结果显示,1）供试材料的叶色呈现显著差异（P<0.05）,叶长、叶宽、茎粗、株高、匍匐茎长度和匍匐茎节数差异极显著（P<0.01）,分蘖数、匍匐茎数目和叶片枯黄程度没有显著差异;2）7个ISSR引物对30份不同地理来源的野牛草进行扩增,共检测到108个扩增位点,其中多态性位点90个,多态性比率（PPB）为82.6%,平均每条引物可以扩增出15.6条带,说明供试的野牛草材料间遗传差异较大;3）30份野牛草的遗传相似系数（GS）值变化范围为0.546~0.880,表明了供试材料具有丰富的遗传多样性;4）在遗传距离的基础上进行UPGMA聚类分析,30份野牛草可被分为5组,该结果表明遗传距离的差异是导致供试野牛草材料整体遗传差异较大的主要原因。     

The status and need for characterization of Nordic animal genetic resources

ABSTRACT

The Nordic countries are committed to conserving farm animal genetic diversity. National reports on phenotypic and genetic characterization point towards a lack of characterization for many Nordic native breeds. Little to no knowledge on the traits of the animals and their derived products leads to potential remaining untapped. The objective of this study was to provide a quantitative assessment of phenotypic and genetic characterization of Nordic native breeds, through a literature search and obtaining census data. Six species and a total of 85 breeds were included. Studies were classified according to six different categories of characterization. Results showed that a large percentage of the breeds are not characterized at all. Moreover, most breeds have extremely low census sizes. A substantial effort to increase population sizes and document characteristics of Nordic native breeds, to promote conservation and sustainable use, is needed.     

大额牛的群体生存现状与保种措施

本文阐述了大额牛的品种特性、种群现状和保种措施.大额牛保种可采用原产地活体保种,迁地活体保种和现代生物技术保种.大额牛体型较大,产肉性能好、行动敏捷、结构紧凑、肌肉发达、肉质优良、耐粗饲、适应性、繁殖力和抗病力均较强等特点.种群体数量极小.大额牛是云南省一个地方品种,保种工作刻不容缓.     

Desert island papers—A life in variance parameter and quantitative genetic parameter estimation reviewed using 16 papers

I review my scientific career in terms of eight areas and 16 papers. The first two areas are associated with childhood. The other six are associated with residual maximum likelihood (REML), canonical transformation, inbreeding in selected populations, average information residual maximum likelihood (AIREML), the computer program ASReml and sampling‐based estimation.     

Differences in genetic structure assessed using Y‐chromosome and mitochondrial DNA markers do not shape the contributions to diversity in African sires

Up to 173 African sires belonging to 11 different subpopulations representative of four cattle groups were analysed for six Y‐specific microsatellite loci and a mitochondrial DNA fragment. Differences in Y‐chromosome and mtDNA haplotype structuring were assessed. In addition, the effect of such structuring on contributions to total genetic diversity was assessed. Thirty‐five Y‐chromosome and 71 mtDNA haplotypes were identified. Most Y‐chromosomes analysed (73.4%) were of zebu origin (11 haplotypes). Twenty‐two Y‐haplotypes (44 samples) belonged to the African taurine subfamily Y2a. All mtDNA haplotypes belonged to the “African” taurine T1 haplogroup with 16 samples and nine haplotypes belonging to a recently identified subhaplogroup (T1e). Median‐joining networks showed that Y‐chromosome phylogenies were highly reticulated with clear separation between zebu and taurine clusters. Mitochondrial haplotypes showed a clear star‐like shape with small number of mutations separating haplotypes. Mitochondrial‐based F_ST‐statistics computed between cattle groups tended to be statistically non‐significant (p > .05). Most F_ST values computed among groups and subpopulations using Y‐chromosome markers were statistically significant. AMOVA confirmed that divergence between cattle groups was only significant for Y‐chromosome markers (Φ_CT = 0.209). At the mitochondrial level, African sires resembled an undifferentiated population with individuals explaining 94.3% of the total variance. Whatever the markers considered, the highest contributions to total Nei's gene diversity and allelic richness were found in West African cattle. Genetic structuring had no effect on patterns of contributions to diversity.     

Estimation of genetic parameters for heat stress,including dominance gene effects,on milk yield in Thai Holstein dairy cattle

Heat stress in tropical regions is a major cause that strongly negatively affects to milk production in dairy cattle. Genetic selection for dairy heat tolerance is powerful technique to improve genetic performance. Therefore, the current study aimed to estimate genetic parameters and investigate the threshold point of heat stress for milk yield. Data included 52 701 test‐day milk yield records for the first parity from 6247 Thai Holstein dairy cattle, covering the period 1990 to 2007. The random regression test day model with EM‐REML was used to estimate variance components, genetic parameters and milk production loss. A decline in milk production was found when temperature and humidity index (THI) exceeded a threshold of 74, also it was associated with the high percentage of Holstein genetics. All variance component estimates increased with THI. The estimate of heritability of test‐day milk yield was 0.231. Dominance variance as a proportion to additive variance (0.035) indicated that non‐additive effects might not be of concern for milk genetics studies in Thai Holstein cattle. Correlations between genetic and permanent environmental effects, for regular conditions and due to heat stress, were ? 0.223 and ? 0.521, respectively. The heritability and genetic correlations from this study show that simultaneous selection for milk production and heat tolerance is possible.     

Effect of selection for scrapie resistance on genetic diversity in a rare and locally adapted sheep breed: The case of Sambucana

In Italy, since 2005 a breeding plan to increase scrapie resistance has been adopted. The impact of this selection on genetic diversity was assessed on Sambucana, an autochtonous sheep breed reared in southern Piedmont, by analysing the evolution of allele frequencies at different levels: PRNP (prion protein) gene, microsatellite loci on OAR13 (where PRNR maps), and microsatellite loci on other chromosomes, not subjected to selection for scrapie resistance. A total of 147 young rams, 80 born in 2004 and 67 in 2008–2009 were analysed. Evidence of diversity loss was observed for PRNP gene as a consequence of the directional selection. Diversity was affected in the immediate vicinity of PRNP but the effect on more distant loci on the same chromosome was trivial. With regard to neutral markers, lack of heterozygosis with no changeover of allele frequencies was observed suggesting an increase of inbreeding. Mating policies would be sufficient to solve these problems. A selection scheme based on genotyping rams and eliminating carriers of both susceptible and high susceptible alleles is the best way to improve natural resistance to scrapie with low costs and minimal problems in the current conservation programmes targeting rare breeds.