Characterisation of virulent and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus

The extracellular proteases of 395 isolates of B. nodosus from ovine, bovine and caprine foot lesions were classified as either thermostable or thermolabile. Stable protease was associated with one and unstable protease with four distinctive isoenzyme patterns, each pattern differentiated by the relative mobility of paired isoenzymes. Pathogenicity tests on 64 isolates showed a correlation between the production of stable protease and the production of virulent ovine footrot lesions. The mean values for total protease activity, twitching motility and colony diameter were significantly higher for virulent compared to benign isolates, but the range of values overlapped. SDS-PAGE whole-cell electrophoretic profiles of virulent isolates were similar to the profiles of some benign isolates.     

Temporal relationships and characterisation of extracellular proteases from benign and virulent strains of Bacteroides nodosus as detected in zymogram gels

Extracellular proteases produced by Bacteroides nodosus in a peptone rich modified trypticase-arginine-serine broth medium were separated and characterised by relative mobility (Rf) in electrophoretic zymogram gels. One benign and two virulent protease banding patterns were established with isolates from sheep, cattle and goats. They correlated with other laboratory tests for virulence but were independent of serogroup. The electrophoretic zymogram method was unable to differentiate intermediate from virulent strains. The time required for the production of maximum levels and numbers of protease bands was four to five days for benign and five to six days for virulent B nodosus. Elevated temperatures (above 45 degrees C) and pH extremes (below pH 6 and above pH 9) modified the electrophoretic banding patterns. The molecular weights of the proteases ranged from 8000 to 43,000 daltons and the isoelectric points from pH 4.90 to 5.90. They are serine proteases and this property can be utilised in affinity purification of these molecules.     

The pathogenicity and cultural characteristics of virulent, intermediate and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus causing ovine foot-rot

The relationship between the cultural and biochemical characteristics of 22 strains of Bacteroides nodosus and their virulence for sheep was examined. Virulent, intermediate and benign strains were recognised. Although there was some relationship between virulence and colony morphology on hoof medium with 4% agar, colonies of one virulent and 4 intermediate strains resembled those of benign strains. However, on hoof medium with 2% agar and on blood Euonagar, colonies of this virulent and one intermediate strain differed from each other and the other 3 intermediate strains, which in turn differed from the benign. The degree of piliation, as assessed by electron microscopy, was not a reliable indicator of virulence in strains not possessing a beaded colony type. Together, the results of colony morphology and proteolytic tests such as zymogram, degrading proteinase and elastin-agar tests allowed better discrimination of virulent and benign strains. Intermediate strains generally possessed virulent protease activity. In strains with benign zymogram patterns, activity bands 2 and 3 were more labile than in strains with virulent patterns. The addition of CaCl2 to the culture medium resulted in greater stability of proteolytic activity, particularly with benign strains, and prevented the disappearance of protease activity in the band 5 position in virulent, intermediate and benign strains during prolonged incubation. There were slight differences in the sodium dodecyl sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) patterns of outer membrane proteins of some benign strains but those of intermediate category resembled virulent strains. There was some relationship between the apparent Mr of the pilin monomer on SDS-PAGE gels and serogroup specificity.     

Comparative antigenic analysis of extracellular proteins of Bacteroides nodosus isolated from virulent and benign ovine footrot

Antigens in the extracellular protein (ECP) complexes of Bacteroides nodosus, isolated from sheep with either benign or virulent footrot, were studied by immunoelectrophoresis (IEP). Rabbit antisera against ECP from virulent and benign strains, were used in homologous and heterologous crossed IEP. Four precipitin peaks unique to the virulent strain, and five peaks unique to the benign strain were identified. In an attempt to characterize the different antigens in ECP, rabbit antisera were raised against an outer membrane protein (OMP, mol. wt. 35 000 daltons), pili and various proteases of virulent and benign strains of B. nodosus. No precipitin band was observed when ECP from both B. nodosus strains were reacted against anti-OMP and anti-pilus antisera. However, single precipitin bands unique to one protease from the benign strain and one protease from the virulent strain were identified. The results suggest that specific antigens other than proteases or pili are important in determining whether a B. nodosus isolate is virulent or benign.     

Measurement of protease thermostability, twitching motility and colony size of Bacteroides nodosus

Total extracellular protease activity of Bacteroides nodosus in TAS liquid culture varied directly with cell mass and buffer concentration between 20 and 50 mM HEPES, MOPS and TES buffers, but not with Tris which gave anomalous high cell counts, nor with Na2Co3 which showed a decline of protease activity and cell mass. The stability of HEPES-buffered crude protease preparations were estimated on the basis of temperature or Ca2+ activity. Variation of the estimates for cellular twitching was greater than that for colony diameter in benign and virulent strains of B. nodosus. Surface translocation, quantified on the basis of colony diameter, reached a limit after 72 h incubation on modified TAS agar, ranging from 0.04 to 0.14 mm per h for six isolates tested.     

A method to differentiate between virulent and benign isolated of Bacteroides nodosus based on the thermal stability of their extracellular proteinases

A rapid modification of the hide powder azure proteinase degrading test was devised to distinguish between benign and virulent strains of Bucteroides nodosus grown as cultures on either liquid or solid media. The assay was based on the difference in stability, at 60 degrees C, of the enzymes released in the growth medium. The assay can be completed in four hours. Results for ovine virulent strains and their culture variants were similar and were clearly distinguishable from those of the ovine benign, bovine, deer and goat isolates which were similar to each other. The proteinase isozymes from cultures of the deer and goat isolates were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and their molecular weights determined.     

Antigenic stability of fimbriae of Bacteroides nodosus

Successful vaccination of sheep against footrot and attempts to eradicate the disease depend on there being a limit to the antigenic diversity of the causative bacterium, Bacteroides nodosus. Fimbrial antigenic variation was therefore investigated in vivo, both under conditions of chronic infection and under the pressure of a vaccine-induced immune response, to ascertain whether this represented an obstacle to such goals. Material was available from 5 experiments and although B. nodosus appeared to have undergone changes in its fimbrial antigens in one of these, the possibility that superinfection was responsible for the variation detected could not be ruled out because all sheep in this case were maintained at pasture. Overall, the results provided no evidence of fimbrial antigenic shift in B. nodosus in vivo and in conclusion, the survival of the organism in the sheep's foot, both in long-term natural infection and following vaccination, must therefore be related to factors other than the ability to undergo antigenic variation in order to evade the host's immune response.     

Serotypic and biochemical characterization of Bacteroides nodosus isolates from Oregon.

Ninety-seven Bacteroides nodosus isolates were characterized by the tube agglutination test. Fourteen serotypes were identified including isolates that were serologically similar to Australian serotypes A, B and C. One additional isolate remains untyped and possibly represents another serotype. The isolates were cultured from 20 different flocks. Multiple isolates were obtained from 15 of the flocks and 13 of these had two to seven different B. nodosus serotypes. Eleven B. nodosus isolates representing one Australian and ten Oregon serotypes were nonfermentative in various carbohydrates and did not produce indole. These isolates all exhibited proteolytic activity. The prototype strains of 12 of the 14 serotypes demonstrated virulence as assessed by an elastase production assay.     

Cross-protection from Bacteroides nodosus vaccines and the interaction of pili and adjuvants

The effects of vaccination of Merino sheep with the purified pili or the whole cells of Bacteroides nodosus strain 198, either in oil or alum-oil adjuvant, on the severity of foot-rot induced with the homologous strain (198) and a heterologous strain (217) were determined in a field experiment, on flood irrigated pasture. The efficacy of the whole cell vaccines was comparable to that of purified pili vaccines, against homologous challenge, when both had a similar content of pilus antigen although the purified pili vaccines induced significantly greater homologous pilus agglutinating antibody titres than the whole cell vaccines. However, against heterologous challenge, the whole cell vaccines in oil (CO) or alum-oil (CAO) provided significantly greater protection than a purified pili-in-oil (PPO) vaccine, the number of severely affected feet in sheep vaccinated with PPO being similar to that of the unvaccinated group. The group vaccinated with purified pili in alum-oil (PPAO) was intermediate between these two extremes. The superior performance of the PPAO in comparison to the PPO vaccine, against heterologous challenge, was associated with significantly higher mean ELISA titres to the outer membrane complex. Western blot analyses implicated a role in cross-protection for outer membrane proteins, in particular a protein Mr 78,000. The PPO vaccine produced fewer, smaller and less persistent vaccination reactions at the inoculation sites than did the other vaccines. Bodyweight gains in the period prior to challenge were much lower for the groups vaccinated with CO and CAO than for the controls and those vaccinated with purified pili, due presumably to the larger vaccination reactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Classification of Bacteroides nodosus by agglutination tests

One thousand two hundred and sixty seven isolates of Bacteroides nodosus from 292 sheep in 58 flocks were examined. Of these, 1260 could be classified by slide agglutination into 8 serogroups designated A to H. Up to 6 serogroups were detected in individual flocks, with up to 4 serogroups being detected in a single foot. Of the 292 sheep examined, 38 (13%) carried mixed serogroup infections. Determination of the range of serological types infecting a flock frequently required the examination of a number of isolates from each of a number of sheep. Cross-tube agglutination tests carried out on 44 isolates and their antiserums indicated that members of some serogroups could be divisible into subgroups or serotypes. These results suggested that 16 or more serotypes of B. nodosus might exist. The nature of the antigens responsible for both slide and tube agglutination reactions needs to be determined.     

Motility in relation to virulence of Bacteroides nodosus

Fourteen Bacteroides nodosus isolates from footrot lesions of sheep were examined microscopically and all were found to have twitching motility. The mean percentage of cells showing motility was 40% and 9% for virulent and benign strains, respectively. This corresponded with mean agar colony diameters of 17 mm and 7 mm, respectively, for these strains. Two strains of intermediate virulence had values of motility and colony diameter similar to the benign strains. However, the intermediate and the virulent strains produced relatively stable protease compared to the benign strains. All virulent, benign and intermediate strains produced abundant pili. Included for comparison in this study was an avirulent variant strain which was highly motile, formed large colonies and produced stable protease, but showed no pili on electron microscopy. It was concluded that the properties of motility and protease stability may be used to distinguish, in the laboratory, wild-type virulent, benign and intermediate strains of B. nodosus.     

The occurrence, prevalence and transmission of Bacteroides nodosus infection in cattle

Following reports of findings of ovine foot-rot flora in the feet of cattle, a study was undertaken to determine the prevalence of Bacteroides nodosus infection in the apparently normal cattle population. We found that 34.5 to 74.2 per cent of the animals examined on different farms had B nodosus present in one or more feet. B nodosus was not the most prevalent bacterium observed in smears from cattle. Other Gram negative species including Fusiformis necrophorus and many Gram positive cocci and coccobacilli were also present. Macroscopic lesions in the interdigital skin characterised by erosion and hyperkeratosis were usually associated with the occurrence of B nodosus. B nodosus isolated from cattle induced mild interdigital dermatitis in experimental cattle and sheep and the infection was transmitted to recipient cattle and sheep under field conditions. Virulent foot-rot of sheep was not transmitted to recipient cattle in conditions where the disease spread to susceptible sheep.     

Susceptibility of Bacteroides nodosus to various antimicrobial agents

The susceptibility of 18 strains of Bacteroides nodosus to 21 antimicrobial agents was tested in vitro. Penicillin was the most effective antibiotic tested. Other antibiotics tested, in order of relative efficacy, were cefamandole, clindamycin, tetracycline, chloramphenicol, erythromycin, sodium cefoxitin, tylosin tartrate, nitrofurazone, tinidazole, and dihydrostreptomycin sulfate. Tests of solutions of 4 antibiotics in 70% ethanol indicated that ethanol served primarily as a diluent and did not contribute substantially to the curative effect of such topical medications on foot rot lesions in sheep. Of the chemicals commonly used in foot baths for treatment of ovine foot rot, copper sulfate was most effective, followed by zinc sulfate, then formalin. Several commercial disinfectants and iodine were quite effective against B nodosus, whereas 5.25% sodium hypochlorite and 70% ethanol alone were relatively ineffective.     

Importance of pilus-associated antigen in Bacteroides nodosus vaccines

The performances of two cellular vaccines, one sparsely piliated and the other well piliated, were compared on irrigated pasture with those of vaccines containing their respective, purified pili. There were statistically significant differences among the four vaccines in the mean numbers of feet per sheep which developed severe foot rot during 27 weeks of exposure. The incidence of severe foot rot was significantly lower in the two pili-vaccinated groups than in the group vaccinated with well-piliated cells, which were in turn substantially more effective than the sparsely piliated. However, the two pili vaccines did not prevent infection of the interdigital skin so that the differences in vaccine performance were much less marked when interdigital skin lesions were included. The number of feet affected by blowfly strike was closely associated with the presence of the most severe lesions and consequently there were far fewer struck feet in the two pili vaccine groups than in the two cellular vaccine groups. Analysis of serum agglutinin titres led to the same assessment of vaccinal efficacy as that derived from the analysis of severe foot rot lesions. Individually the agglutinin response to vaccination was not universally associated with resistance or susceptibility to severe foot rot but mean titres were significantly higher in the two pili vaccine groups than in the highly piliated-cell vaccine group, which were all in turn significantly higher than in the poorly piliated-cell vaccine group.     

Biochemical and biological studies on the lipopolysaccharide of Bacteroides nodosus

Lipopolysaccharides (LPS) were extracted from three Bacteroides nodosus isolates by the aqueous phenol method and purified by ultracentrifugation. The structure of B nodosus LPS appears to be similar to enterobacterial LPS, with the polysaccharide component joined to the lipid A moiety through an acid-labile 2-keto-3-deoxyoctonic acid (KDO) linkage. B nodosus LPS contained glucose, galactose, hexosamine, KDO and heptose and no sugars apart from ribose, which was possibly a nucleic acid contaminant, were unique to any of the isolates. Electron microscopic examination indicated a similar morphology to LPS derived from other Gram-negative bacteria. B nodosus LPS was found to exhibit biological properties characteristic of endotoxins, such as pyrogenicity, leucopenic and leucocytotic activity, production of the primary inflammatory response in rabbit skin and Shwartzman reactivity. However, the toxicity of B nodosus LPS was low.     

Studies on the antigenic structure of Bacteroides nodosus.

The antigenic mosaics of three Bacteroides nodosus isolates (198, 199 and 127) were studied to elucidate the nature of the protective immunogen. In vaccinated sheep the three isolates induced high homologous serum agglutinin titres but it was also apparent that 198 and 199 shared a major surface antigen not present on 217. This major cross-reacting antigen was not detected with rabbit antisera. The fimbriae, consisting predominantly of protein, induced high homologous titres in rabbits and represented the type-specific antigen. Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from each of the isolates induced low agglutinin titres and high 2-mercaptoethanol-sensitive indirect haemagglutinating antibody titres. The heat-stable LPS contained at least two common carbohydrate O antigen determinants but no type-specific O antigens were detected.     

Studies on the ultrastructural morphology of Bacteroides nodosus.

The morphology of Bacteroides nodosus was examined with the electron microscope. B nodosus stained with solium phosphotungstate and uranyl acetate possessed fimbriae and in addition organisms negatively stained with sodium phosphotungstate often possessed rings on their surface. Phage-like particles were also observed in negatively stained preparations. In thin sections, B nodosus had a multilayered cell envelope and the type of cell division characteristic of Gram-negative bacteria. The cytoplasmic region contained a diffuse nucleoid area, ribosomes and, sometimes, concentrically arranged membranous lamellae. Fimbriae and capsular material were also seen in sections of B nodosus fixed with glutaraldehyde-osmium. Their visualisation appeared to be enhanced when ruthenium red was incorporated n the glutaraldehyde-osmium fixative but only when sections were stained with heavy metal salts, indicating that the fimbriae and capsule were not predominantly polysaccharide in nature.