Nerve insensitivity resistance to pyrethroids in Heliothine Lepidoptera

A neurophysiological assay developed previously was used to assess the incidence of nerve insensitivity resistance to synthetic pyrethroids in field strains of Helicoverpa armigera. Almost 70% of individuals from a sample of a highly pyrethroid-resistant population from Jiangsu Province, China were nerve-insensitive. Subsequent selection resulted in a strain homogeneous for expression of this mechanism. Likewise, over 95% of a sample from a strain of the insects from Andhra Pradesh, India were nerve-insensitive and a homogeneous strain was developed. Development of a nerve-insensitive laboratory strain of Heliothis virescens was undertaken but homozygosity could not be obtained. It is suggested that high fitness costs may be associated with this mechanism. The incidence of nerve insensitivity in Heliothine pests is reviewed and the role of phenotypic expression assays in molecular studies highlighted. ©1997 SCI     

Depolarization of motor nerve terminals by pyrethroids in susceptible and kdr-resistant house flies

When applied at concentrations of one nM or higher to a house fly larval neuromuscular preparation, deltamethrin (DM) and fenvalerate (FV) greatly increased miniature excitatory postsynaptic potential (mepsp) rate and blocked neuromuscular transmission. The DM-induced mepsp discharge was abolished by tetrodotoxin (TTX), removal of Ca²⁺ from the saline, or by application of hyperpolarizing stimuli to the nerve, indicating that it was due to depolarization of the presynaptic terminals. Also, in the presence of TTX, K⁺ depolarization increased mepsp rate at the same external K⁺ concentration before and after DM treatment, confirming that DM released transmitter by depolarizing the nerve terminals rather than by altering the voltage dependence of transmitter release. The potassium channel blocker tetraethylammonium (TEA) increased mepsp rate somewhat, while aconitine (20 μM), which keeps sodium channels open, increased mepsp rate consistently. Pretreatment of nerves with a subthreshold dose of TEA greatly increased the mepsp rate-increasing activity of DM and aconitine, while a subthreshold level of aconitine did not synergize DM. These observations suggest that DM, like aconitine, depolarized nerves by modifying the sodium channels. Knockdown resistant (kdr) larvae were resistant to the depolarizing action of DM and aconitine but not to that of TEA, indicating that the kdr gene produced a modified sodium channel which was less sensitive to the action of pyrethroids and aconitine. During sustained transmitter release by DM, evoked release gradually declined, resulting in a condition called early block in which spontaneous release was high and release could be evoked by electrotonic depolarization of the nerve terminals, but not by a nerve action potential. Early block was probably due to conduction block in the nerve terminals. Early block eventually gave way to late block, characterized by the decline of spontaneous release to subnormal levels and complete failure of evoked release. After late block, the calcium ionophore X-537A could not release transmitter, suggesting that late block was due to depletion of available transmitter. DM did not have a direct effect upon extrasynaptic muscle membrane. However, after late block, muscles were left insensitive to the putative transmitters glutamate and aspartate when these were bath or iontophoretically applied. A low rate of mepsps persisted after late block, indicating that the muscles were still sensitive to the natural transmitters.     

Toxicity of spinosad to susceptible and resistant strains of house flies,Musca domestica

The toxicity of spinosad, a new insecticide derived from the bacterium Saccharopolyspora spinosa, was evaluated against susceptible and resistant strains of house fly (Musca domestica L.). Spinosad was highly toxic to house flies based on 72-h LD₅₀ values and the symptoms of poisoning were consistent with a neurotoxic mechanism of action. Spinosad was relatively slow acting, with the maximum toxicity noted at 72 h. Piperonyl butoxide and S,S,S,-tribu-tylphosphorotrithioate synergized the toxicity of spinosad by 3·0- and 1·8-fold, respectively, while diethyl maleate had no significant effect. These results suggest that there is a small degree of monooxygenase-mediated spinosad detoxification in house flies, while hydrolases may be only minimally important and glutathione transferases may have no role. There were no substantial levels of cross-resistance detected, except in the LPR strain where a low 4·3-fold cross-resistance was observed. The cyclodiene-resistant OCR strain was 2·7-fold more sensitive to spinosad than the susceptible strain (CS). These results suggest that cross-resistance may not be a limiting factor for the use of spinosad against house flies. © 1998 Society of Chemical Industry     

Laboratory studies on the mechanisms of resistance to permethrin in a field-selected strain of house flies

Enhanced oxidative metabolism appeared to be a major factor involved in resistance to permethrin in a field strain of house flies, selected with permethrin over 4 years. This was shown in the 7.8-fold synergism by piperonyl butoxide which reduced the resistance ratio from 97 to 15. The rate of permethrin detoxication was significantly higher (P=0.05) in the resistant flies compared with a susceptible strain or resistant flies pretreated with piperonyl butoxide. The esterase inhibitor S,S,S-tributyl phosphorotrithioate did not reduce the level of resistance to permethrin in the resistant strain, although some hydrolytic metabolism was apparent. Rates of penetration were similar in susceptible and resistant flies and in resistant flies pre-treated with piperonyl butoxide. A minor unidentified resistance factor, possibly reduced sensitivity of the nervous system, may also have been present in the resistant strain.     

Linkage group analysis of nerve insensitivity in a pyrethroid-resistant strain of house fly

Nerve insensitivity was a major factor of mechanism of resistance to pyrethroids in the 228e2b strain of house fly. Reciprocal crosses between the resistant and susceptible SRS strains showed that resistance to permethrin was recessive in nerve sensitivity. Linkage group analysis by the F₁ male backcross method using multichromosomal marker strains was investigated electrophysiologically, following 10⁻⁵ M permethrin application to the exposed thoracic ganglia of the backcross progenies. Results of the experiment showed that the recessive genetic factor responsible for nerve insensitivity to permethrin in the resistant strain is located only on the third chromosome.     

Development of resistance to pyrethroids in insects resistant to other insecticides

Resistance to pyrethroids in insects is rare, but its recent rapid development in the field suggests that this resistance may be facilitated by previous exposure to or by resistance to insecticides of unrelated groups. To test this houseflies of strain 49_r2b, originally resistant to dimethoate in the field, were selected eight times during ten generations with either pyrethrum extract or bioresmethrin with or without piperonyl butoxide or with dimethoate. Selecting with any of the pyrethroids led to resistance to these insecticides and in particular to pyrethrum/piperonyl butoxide. Selecting with pyrethrum/piperonyl butoxide resulted in strongest resistance to the pyrethroids tested, whereas selecting with bioresmethrin/piperonyl butoxide resulted in least resistance. These results show that dimethoate-resistant flies selected with pyrethroids can readily develop resistance to these insecticides, but development of resistance can be minimised by using bioresmethrin/piperonyl butoxide. The implications of these findings on the sequential use of insecticides are discussed.     

Toxicodynamics of malaoxon in house flies

The fate of malaoxon was studied in a susceptible and a resistant strain of house fly following topical application. Sublethal doses were used: 160 pmol for the S-strain (0.17 × LD₅₀) and 1570 pmol for the R-strain (0.1 × LD₅₀). The penetration rates are dose dependent and semilog plots of the external amount vs time show that these rates are not proportional to this external amount. Internal concentrations of malaoxon rapidly increase following administration, reach maximum values between 30 min and 2 hr (depending on dose), and then slowly decrease. The rate of metabolic degradation is highest in the early stage of the intoxication process. A three-compartment pharmacokinetic model is postulated to explain the experimental data quantitatively. The first compartment represents external malaoxon, the other two represent internal parent compound. Statistical analysis shows that the penetration rate is better described with a sum of two exponentials rather than with a single exponential decay. In the model, degradation occurs in the first internal compartment and is assumed to be first order. Malaoxon is distributed between the two internal compartments slowly with first-order kinetics. Parameter estimation with curve-fitting procedures for the internal processes (degradation and exchange) shows that there is not one set of parameter values that can be used for both strains simultaneously. This prompted a study of possible interstrain differences in degradation capacities. It was found that in vitro the R-strain had a fourfold higher oxidative breakdown rate of malaoxon. Taking this difference into account it is possible to explain the two sets of data with one kinetic model, although other alternatives cannot be excluded.     

The effect of phenobarbital induction on glutathione conjugation of diazinon in susceptible and resistant house flies

The relationship between glutathione S-transferase activity toward 3,4-dichloronitrobenzene and O-alkyl or O-aryl conjugation of diazinon was investigated in eight strains of house flies. No significant difference was found in the amount of O-aryl conjugation. In contrast, house flies which had higher glutathione S-transferase activity toward 3,4-dichloronitrobenzene also had higher O-alkyl conjugating activity toward diazinon. The glutathione S-transferase(s) in phenobarbital-pretreated flies degraded diazinon faster than those in the nontreated ones. The present results showed that the formation of the O-alkyl conjugate was enhanced by phenobarbital pretreatment, while the formation of the O-aryl conjugate was not affected by induction. Based on these findings, it would appear that one of the multiple forms of glutathione S-transferase is specifically induced and responsible for the increase in O-alkyl conjugation.     

Relation of acetylcholinesterase sensitivity to cross-resistance of a resistant house fly strain to organophosphates and carbamates

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE, E.C. 3.1.1.7) from an organophosphate-resistant strain of house fly, Musca domestica (L.) exhibited a decrease in sensitivity towards four organophosphates and two carbamates in comparison with enzyme from the parent susceptible strain. Sensitivity was less, as measured by the bimolecular reaction constant (k_i), by a factor of 117 for dichlorvos, 94 for paraoxon, 11 for diazoxon, 7 for Tetram, 62 for propoxur, and 50 for dimetilan. These differences in bimolecular reaction constants were attributed entirely to differences in their affinity for the enzyme, as measured by the dissociation constant, K_d. It is suggested that the cross resistance to these inhibitors is due at least in part to insensitive acetylcholinesterase.     

Synergism of DDT effects by DMC on labellar receptors of resistant and susceptible house flies

Electrophysiological responses of labellar hairs of resistant and susceptible strains of the house fly were recorded at times following treatment of the hairs with DDT. Under the influence of DDT, the receptors of a hair discharged groups of impulses in high-frequency trains instead of the usual regular volley. The effect was observed to gradually spread to nontreated hairs. Among four strains chosen for gradation from high resistance to high susceptibility, in general the relative effectiveness of DDT corresponded to overall resistance as indicated by LD₅₀ data. The highly resistant strain showed essentially no effects, and the other strains showed effects with some degree of recovery. Results for the highly susceptible strain were anomalous in not differing significantly from those of the moderately resistant strai. Unexpectedly small effects in the highly susceptible strain point to a strain characteristic not necessarily correlated with LD₅₀ data.     

In vitro metabolism of EPN and EPNO in susceptible and resistant strains of house flies

EPN is twice as toxic as EPNO to house flies from both the Diazinon-resistant strain and the susceptible strain. EPN and EPNO are also eight times more toxic to the susceptible than the resistant strain. This is due to the ability of the resistant strain to metabolize these compounds to a greater extent. Metabolism by the glutathione S-transferases present in the 100,000g supernatant is more extensive than that by the NADPH-dependent microsomal mixed-function oxidases. The glutathione S-transferases are the major route of metabolism for EPN and appear to be the principal mechanism conferring resistance. EPN was metabolized by the microsomal fraction via oxidative desulfuration to the oxygen analog, EPNO, and by oxidative dearylation to p-nitrophenol. EPNO was metabolized by the same system to p-nitrophenol and desethyl EPNO as well as to an unknown metabolite. The soluble fraction metabolized EPN to p-nitrophenol, S-(p-nitrophenyl)glutathione, O-ethyl phenylphosphonothioic acid, and S-(O-ethyl phenylphosphonothionyl)glutathione. The identification of the latter conjugate demonstrates a new type of metabolite of organophosphorus compounds. EPNO was metabolized by the soluble fraction to p-nitrophenol and S-(p-nitrophenyl)glutathione.     

Polysubstrate monooxygenases (cytochrome P-450) in larvae of susceptible and resistant strains of house flies

The polysubstrate monooxygenases (PSMO or cytochrome P-450) of house fly larvae were studied at the mature larval or “clear gut” stage. Fat body and gut tissues were most efficient in the conversion of aldrin to dieldrin. Microsomal fractions of larval homogenates had the highest PSMO activities, with lower PSMO activities also found associated with mitochondrial fractions. Microsomes from Rutgers (resistant) larvae had higher levels of NADPH:cytochrome c reductase (2×), cytochrome P-450 (2×), aldrin (4×), and heptachlor (9×) epoxidases than microsomes from CSMA (susceptible) larvae. Cytochrome P-450 of Rutgers larvae had an absorption maximum at 449 nm, 2 nm lower than the cytochrome P-450 of CSMA larvae. n-Octylamine spectra showed that the level of high-spin cytochrome P-450 was higher in Rutgers larvae. NADPH:cytochrome c reductase, cytochrome P-450, and aldrin epoxidase were induced by phenobarbital, and Rutgers larvae were shown to be more sensitive to this inducer than CSMA larvae. Induction of larval PSMO by phenobarbital did not affect the expression or the inducibility of PSMO in adults.     

Characterization of the structure-activity relationship of kdr and two variants of super-kdr to pyrethroids in the housefly (Musca domestica L.)

Structure-activity relationships (SARs) for 10 pyrethroids against susceptible, kdr and super-kdr strains of houseflies (Musca domestica L.) were investigated by Principal Components Analysis. In the three strains with kdr_Latina' all only slightly to moderately (2.6 to 26-fold) resistant to pyrethroids, no correlation between the structure and Levels of resistance could be discerned. In flies with super-kdr, SARs were influenced by the nature of the alcoholic portion of the ester. Resistance was strongest to esters of a-cyano-3-phenoxybenzyl alcohol (74 to 430-fold) and to permethrin (48 to 55-fold). It was weak (6.2 to 11-fold) to cyclopentenone derivatives, being barely stronger than for flies with kdr (2-6 to 6.3-fold). Two variants of super-kdr (3D and A2) were distinguished on the basis of their differential response to esters of 5-benzyl-3-furylmethanol. It is presumed that kdr_Latina, super-kdr_A2 and super-kdr_3D form an allelic series in which kdr_Latina represents ground level insensitivity, and the two super-kdrs the progressive extension of strong resistance to more types of ester. The strong differences in resistance to different pyrethroid esters by super-kdr flies provides scope for improving management of resistance to pyrethroid insecticides and for modifying the SAR of pyrethroids to favour weak resistance.     

Resistance to synthetic pyrethroids in a DDT-resistant strain of Boophilus microplus

The susceptibility of a standard reference strain of the cattle tick Boophilus microplus, to a group of synthetic pyrethroids, has been compared with that of a DDT-resistant strain. Cross resistance has been demonstrated in laboratory and field tests.     

Resynthesis of multiple resistance to organophosphorus insecticides from strains with factors of resistance isolated from the SKA strain of house flies

Individual factors of resistance to insecticides attributable to chromosomes II, III and ^V of the SKA strain of houseflies (Musca domestica L) were combined in pairs to determine how their presence affects resistance. The re-synthesised strains with resistance factors on chromosomes II and V, and on chromosomes III and V, were tested with several organophosphorus insecticides and DDT. The penetration delaying mechanism Pen on chromosome III, which alone gives little or no resistance, slightly increased the resistance of flies with the microsomal detoxifying factor Ses on chromosome V to diazinon and malaoxon-ethyl (c. × 1.5), but was more effective in increasing resistance to DDT (× 6). There was no effect on the response to other insecticides tested. The combined effect of the mechanisms of resistance on chromosome II (glutathione S-ethyl transferase and phosphatase) and on chromosome V (microsomal detoxication) approximated to the product of the resistance conferred by each of these mechanisms singly, suggesting that the mechanisms of resistance on the two chromosomes act independently. Therefore, most of the strong resistance to organophosphorus insecticides in the SKA strain results from the interaction between delayed penetration (chromosome III) and the factors of resistance on chromosome II, and the independent action of the resistance factors on chromosomes II and V.     

Cytochrome P-450 in insects: 1. Differences in the forms present in insecticide resistant and susceptible house flies

Soluble cytochrome P-450 prepared from the microsomal fraction of abdomen homogenates of an insecticide resistant strain (Rutgers) and a susceptible strain (NAIDM) of the house fly, Musca domestica L., was characterized by spectral and electrophoretic methods. Six chromatographically distinct fractions were obtained after chromatography on DEAE-cellulose and hydroxylapatite. Examination of the six fractions by difference spectrophotometry indicated that the wave lengths for maximum absorption of the cytochrome P-450-carbon monoxide complexes were at 450, 451, and 452 nm for the NAIDM fractions and at 449, 450, and 451 nm for the Rutgers fractions. The type II binding spectra of the cytochrome P-450 in each fraction were measured with n-octylamine. Several of these resembled spectra which, in studies of hepatic cytochrome P-450, have been shown to be due to the presence of the high spin form of this hemoprotein. Four of the fractions from the resistant strain were of this type compared to one from the susceptible strain. Electrophoresis experiments indicated that there were at least three hemoproteins in the 40,000–60,000 molecular weight range in the fractions from the resistant strain while four could be detected in those from the susceptible strain. The specific aldrin epoxidase activity of the most active Rutgers fractions was considerably higher than that of similar fractions from the NAIDM microsomes in reconstitution experiments.     

The toxicity of two pyrethroids to Encarsia formosa and its host Trialeurodes vaporariorum; Prospecting for a resistant strain of the parasite

The toxicity of bioresmethrin and deltamethrin has been studied on the host-parasite couple Trialeurodes vaporariorum-Encarsia formosa. Long term trials were used under laboratory conditions. The insecticides were applied to the plant at all stages of host and parasite development. The two products studied showed some toxicity to E. formosa. Bioresmethrin, a poorly persistent insecticide, could be used with care in integrated control; deltamethrin, a highly persistent product, must be excluded. Attempts to obtain strains of E. formosa resistant to deltamethrin were made. The selection pressure applied during 21 successive generations failed to produce a significant and stable resistance level.     

Endogenous inhibitors of glutathione S-transferases in house flies

The inhibition of glutathione S-transferase by endogenous compounds present in the soluble fraction of house fly homogenates was investigated. The highest inhibition was found with the female abdomen and increased with incubation time and with an increase in the tissue concentration. The correlation of increased inhibition with a parallel increase in the darkening of the soluble fraction indicated a possible association with melanization, thereby suggesting quinones as the possible endogenous inhibitiors of glutathione transferase. In vitro experiments demonstrated that quinones produced by mushroom tyrosinase did indeed inhibit glutathione S-transferase. Inhibition by quinones can be prevented by including glutathione or bovine serum albumin in the homogenization buffer. The inhibitory activity of a variety of quinones and related compounds on purified glutathione S-transferase was investigated. Oxygenated aromatics with hydroxy groups in the 1,2- or 1,4-position or ketonic carbonyls in the 1,4-position are good inhibitors of glutathione S-transferase.     

Some laboratory investigations relevant to the possible use of new pyrethroids in control of mosquitoes and tsetse flies

Cypermethrin, fenvalerate, permethrin, (S)-α-cyano-3-phenoxybenzyl (1R,cis)-3-(2, 2-dibromovinyl)-2, 2-dimethylcyclopropanecarboxylate (NRDC 161) and (R,S)-α-cyano-3-phenoxybenzyl 2, 2,3, 3-tetramethylcyclopropanecarboxylate (S-3206; WL 41706) have been tested against adult mosquitoes (Anopheles stephensi) and tsetse flies (Glossina austeni). They possess many of the necessary characteristics such as high intrinsic toxicity, low volatility, and high stability but vary considerably in the contact action of their spray residues.     

In vitro metabolism of etrimfos by house flies

The metabolism of etrimfos, O,O-dimethyl-O-(6-ethoxy-2-ethyl-4-pyrimidinyl) phosphorothioate was studied in vitro in a diazinon-resistant (Rutgers) and a susceptible (CSMA) strain of house flies. Practically no metabolism of etrimfos occurred without the addition of cofactors. However, the addition of the cofactor, reduced glutathione, resulted in a substantial amount of metabolism in both strains, the metabolism being higher in the resistant strain. The major route of metabolism was via the glutathione transferase system and the predominant metabolite was desmethyl etrimfos. Although the oxygen analog could not be isolated, microsomal oxidation of etrimfos resulted in the inhibition of acetylcholinesterase, suggesting the formation of the oxygen analog. Bovine serum albumin also degraded etrimfos yielding desmethyl etrimfos and 6-ethoxy-2-ethyl-4-hydroxypyrimidine.