Development and application of solvent-free extraction for the detection of aflatoxin M1 in dairy products by enzyme immunoassay

The official methods for the quantification of aflatoxin M1 in dairy products (cheese and yogurt) include extraction into dichloromethane or chloroform, evaporation of the solvent, partitioning of the reconstituted residue with hexane, and subsequent analysis. To secure a rapid and inexpensive screen for aflatoxin M1 contamination, a sensitive competitive ELISA, using a rabbit polyclonal antibody, was developed for measuring aflatoxin M1 in milk and used in a comparative study for measuring the extraction efficiency of aflatoxin M1 in aqueous or organic solvent buffers using yogurt samples. An aqueous sodium citrate solution was found to be suitable for extracting aflatoxin M1, thus eliminating the need for organic solvents. The citrate extraction proved to be efficient (recovery ranged from 70 to 124%) in fortified samples of very different kinds of dairy products, including yogurt and six types of cheese. Fourteen yogurt and cheese samples were extracted with citrate solution and analyzed by ELISA. A good correlation was observed (y=0.95x-0.59, r2=0.98) when the data were compared with those obtained through the official method, across a wide range of aflatoxin M1 contaminations (10-200 ng/kg).     

Comparison of radioimmunoassay and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for determining aflatoxin M1 in milk

Using a highly specific antibody against aflatoxin M1, a radioimmunoassay (RIA) and an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) were developed for the quantitation of M1 in milk. RIA was sensitive in the range of 5-50 ng per assay but was subject to interference by whole milk. Extraction and cleanup were therefore necessary for the detection of M1 in milk at 0.5 ng/mL. An ELISA procedure was developed by using an aflatoxin M1-carboxymethyl-horseradish peroxidase conjugate as the ligand. Competitive assays revealed that this system was relatively more sensitive for M1 than for B1, and had a much lower degree of cross-reactivity for aflatoxins B2, G1, G2, B2a, and aflatoxicol. As low as 0.25 ng M1/mL in artificially contaminated milk (raw, whole, skim) could be detected by ELISA in 3 h without extraction or cleanup. Because of its simplicity, sensitivity, and specificity, ELISA is the preferred method for monitoring aflatoxin M1 in milk.     

Interactive effects of duration of storage and addition of formaldehyde on levels of aflatoxin M1 in milk

Spray-dried skim milk, naturally contaminated with aflatoxin M1, was added to either raw or pasteurized whole milk to a final concentration of 1.1 microgram aflatoxin M1/L milk. Formalin (37% w/w) was added to the milk solutions to final concentrations of 0, 0.025, 0.05, and 0.1% formaldehyde. Samples were stored in the dark at 21 degrees C in plastic and glass containers and were analyzed for aflatoxin M1 at 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4 weeks. This experiment was repeated using only raw milk and glass containers. Aflatoxin M1 analyses were done at 0, 1, and 2 weeks. Aflatoxin M1 losses increased over time and with increased formaldehyde concentration. With both experiments, aflatoxin M1, levels after 2 weeks were less than 0.05 micrograms/L in samples containing 0.1% formaldehyde.     

Direct enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for determining aflatoxin M1 at picogram levels in dairy products

Protocols for detecting picogram quantities of aflatoxin M1 in dairy products were established. Milk samples were subjected to a reverse phase Sep-Pak C18 cartridge treatment before analysis by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) according to previously published procedures. M1 in yogurt, brick cheddar, and ripened Brie cheese was extracted by a modified Pons method, subjected to a normal phase silica cartridge treatment, and analyzed by ELISA. The detection limits for M1 in milk, yogurt, cheddar, and Brie were 10, 10, 50, and 25 ppt (ng/kg), respectively. Recovery for M1 added to these products was in the range 70-110%. Good agreement was found for M1 levels in several naturally contaminated milk samples analyzed by both ELISA and liquid chromatography.     

Simultaneous determination of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M1 residues in milk by triple quadrupole liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

A reliable, rapid, and sensitive liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) method for simultaneous determination of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M(1) in milk has been developed. This method includes simple extraction of sample with acetonitrile, separation on a MGIII-C(18) column using 5 mM ammonium acetate aqueous solution/methanol (60:40, v/v) as mobile phase, and MS/MS detection using multiple reaction monitoring mode. The method was validated according to Commission Decision 2002/657/EC. The limits of detection (LODs) were 0.05 μg/kg for chloramphenicol and 0.005 μg/kg for aflatoxin M(1.) The limits of quantification (LOQs) were 0.2 μg/kg for chloramphenicol and 0.02 μg/kg for aflatoxin M(1). The recovery values ranged from 88.8% to 100.6%, with relative standard deviation lower than 15% in all cases, when samples were fortified at three different concentrations. The decision limits (CCα) and detection capability (CCβ) of the method were also reported. This method has been successfully applied for simultaneous analysis of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M(1) residues in milk from local supermarkets in China.     

Rapid high pressure liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk and nonfat dry milk

A modification of the current revised AOAC method, 26.A10-26.A15, is described for the rapid analysis of aflatoxin M1 in milk and nonfat dry milk. The method incorporates chloroform extraction and eliminates the need for column chromatography by using liquid-liquid partition for sample extract cleanup. Quantitation is carried out by using fluorescence detection combined with high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) of aflatoxin M1 which has been converted to aflatoxin M2a with trifluoroacetic acid. The method has a detection limit of 0.014 micrograms/L (2 X signal/noise) for whole milk. For 6 samples of naturally contaminated nonfat dry and freeze-dried milk, the modified method gave an average result of 0.698 micrograms/L; the AOAC method gave an average result of 0.386 micrograms/L.     

Rapid liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxins M1 and M2 in artificially contaminated fluid milks: collaborative study

An international collaborative study involving 14 collaborators from 5 different countries was conducted to test a rapid liquid chromatographic (LC) method for detecting aflatoxins M1 and M2 in fluid milk. Each collaborator prepared artificially contaminated milk samples (0.078-1.31 ng M1/mL and 0.030-0.13 ng M2/mL) by adding solutions containing various concentrations of aflatoxins M1 and M2 to fresh milk. Recoveries ranged from 85.2 to 102.5% (av. 93.7%) for aflatoxin M1 and from 99.5 to 126.7% (av. 109.8%) for aflatoxin M2. Coefficients of variation averaged 21.4% (M1) and 35.9% (M2). An analysis of variance was calculated from combined data to determine variance components. The within-laboratory variations (So) (repeatability) were 27.9% (M1) and 23.9% (M2), and the among-laboratory variations (Sx) (reproducibility) were 44.5% (M1) and 64.7% (M2). No visual differences were determined between normal or reverse phase LC for contaminated samples; however, there were an insufficient number of collaborators using normal phase to give meaningful separate statistical data. For 26 observations of uncontaminated milk, 3 false M1 positives were reported for normal phase LC determinations and 2 false M1 positives were reported for reverse phase LC determinations. Three normal phase and 11 reverse phase false M2 positives were reported for 104 observations in uncontaminated milk. The reverse phase LC method for determination of aflatoxins M1 and M2 in fluid milk has been adopted official first action.     

Determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk by liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection

A liquid chromatographic (LC) method is proposed for the determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk. The method was successfully applied to both liquid whole and skim milk and also whole and skim milk powder. The samples are initially extracted with acetonitrile-water followed by purification using a silica gel cartridge and a C18 cartridge. Final analysis by LC was achieved using a radial compression module equipped with a 5 micron C18 column and a fluorescence detector. The method was successfully applied to samples at levels of 10 to 0.08 ppb added aflatoxin M1 with recoveries in the range of 70-98%.     

Automated liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk using on-line dialysis for sample preparation

A procedure has been developed for the automated isolation of aflatoxin M1 from decreamed milk. The method uses on-line stopped flow dialysis and subsequent trace enrichment on a reverse-phase column. After a back-flush to the analytical liquid chromatography column, aflatoxin M1 is determined with fluorescence detection. Fully automated analysis is possible with reproducible dialysis recoveries above 50% (CV = 7.5%, n = 25 at the 50 ng/kg level) and determination levels of 20 ng/kg within 20 min.     

Simple, rapid cleanup method for analysis of aflatoxins and comparison with various methods

A method is described for simple and rapid determination of aflatoxins in corn, buckwheat, peanuts, and cheese. Aflatoxins were extracted with chloroform-water and were purified by a Florisil column chromatographic procedure. Column eluates were concentrated and spotted on a high performance thin layer chromatographic (HPTLC) plate, which was then developed in chloroform-acetone (9 + 1) and/or ether-methanol-water (94 + 4.5 + 1.5) or chloroform-isopropanol-acetone (85 + 5 + 10). Each aflatoxin was quantitated by densitometry. The minimum detectable aflatoxin concentrations (micrograms/kg) in various test materials were 0.2, B1; 0.1, B2; 0.2, G1; 0.1, G2; and 0.1, M1. Recoveries of the aflatoxins added to corn, peanut, and cheese samples at 10-30 micrograms/kg were greater than 69% (aflatoxin G2) and averaged 91%, B1; 89%, B2; 91%, G1; 78%, G2; and 92%, M1. The simple method described was compared with the AOAC CB method, AOAC BF method, and AOAC milk and cheese method. These methods were applied to corn, peanut, and cheese composites spiked with known amounts of aflatoxins, and to naturally contaminated buckwheat and cheese. Recoveries were much lower for the BF method compared with our simple method and the CB method.     

Development of a fluorescence polarization assay for the determination of aflatoxins in grains

Aflatoxins produced by Aspergillus flavus are commonly found in human and animal foods including grains, cereals, peanut products, sorghum, and soy seeds. Exposure to aflatoxins has been associated with carcinogenicity. This paper reports a simple, portable, and rapid fluorescence polarization (FP) assay for aflatoxin determination in grains. This immunoassay is field portable, homogeneous, and without any washing and cleaning steps. The assay is based upon the competition between free aflatoxin and an aflatoxin-fluorescein tracer for an aflatoxin-specific monoclonal antibody in solution. A series of naturally contaminated corn, sorghum, peanut butter, and peanut paste samples were analyzed by FP and compared with HPLC results. Similarly, spiked popcorn samples were analyzed by FP. FP results of naturally contaminated samples correlated well with HPLC (r (2) = 0.97). FP analysis of spiked popcorn samples (with a mixture of B(1)/B(2)/G(1)/G(2), 7/1/3/1, w/w) gave a good correlation with spiked values (r (2) = 0.99). However, FP consistently underestimated the aflatoxin contents. This was perhaps due to low cross-reactivity of the antibody used toward B(2), G(1), and G(2) aflatoxins. These results combined with the portability and simplicity of the assay suggest that the assay can be used for screening total aflatoxin in grains.     

Determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk and milk products contaminated at low levels

A new method is described for the determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk and dairy products by thin layer chromatography. The main characteristic is the extraction system using an alkaline solution. Lipids are removed by centrifuging at low temperatures, and the aflatoxins are then extracted with CHCl3. The method has 2 options: Technique II (detection limit 0.02 ppb) requires cleanup on a chromatographic column; this is not necessary in Technique I (detection limit 0.1 ppb). The recovery rate in both techniques is over 92.8% in milk and yoghurt. This method may also be used for other aflatoxins. Because of the advantages of the method, Technique II is recommended for aflatoxin M1 control in milk, where a low detection limit is necessary. Technique I is proposed for experimental aflatoxin production studies in dairy products, which require analysis of a large number of samples but which do not require a very low detection limit.     

Optimum conditions for formation of aflatoxin M1-trifluoroacetic acid derivative

Because thin-layer chromatographic (TLC) confirmation of identity and reverse-phase liquid chromatographic (LC) determination with fluorescence detection of aflatoxin M1 both require the derivative formed in the reaction of M1 and trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), various reaction conditions were studied to obtain complete derivative formation. Of the various organic solvents tested, the reaction between M1 and TFA proceeded best in the nonpolar solvents hexane and isooctane. Other parameters investigated were reaction temperature and time, aflatoxin M1 concentration, and solvent volume. The following procedure is considered optimum: 200 microL each of hexane and trifluoroacetic acid are mixed with M1 standard in a silylated glass vial or with milk residue in a regular glass vial with a Teflon-lined screw cap and heated 10 min at 40 degrees C. The mixture is evaporated to dryness under N2, and the derivative is saved for TLC or LC. No unreacted aflatoxin M1 was detected by reverse-phase LC after this procedure was incorporated for analysis of milk samples.     

Rapid thin layer chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in powdered milk

A method has been developed for the detection of aflatoxin M1 in milk. The toxin is extracted with chloroform, the extract is evaporated, and the residue is partitioned between carbon tetrachloride and an aqueous saline-methanol solution. The toxin is once again extracted with chloroform from the methanol solution and analyzed by thin layer chromatography. The limit of detection of M1 in powdered milk is 0.5 microgram/kg; recoveries of added M1 are about 83%. The limit of detection can be improved to 0.3 microgram/kg if the plate is sprayed with an aqueous solution of H2SO4 after development.     

Rapid reverse phase liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk

A rapid, economical, and reliable liquid chromatographic (LC) method is described for determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk. The method includes an improved AOAC extraction procedure, cleanup of the extract on a silica cartridge, and LC quantitation. Alternatively, a rapid column cleanup procedure can be used. Milk artificially spiked with aflatoxin M1 at 0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 ppb was analyzed using both new approaches as well as an AOAC method coupled with LC for quantitation of the toxin. Recovery of aflatoxin M1 by the first approach of the new method ranged between 93.4 and 99.1%, and for the alternative procedure between 92.4 and 96.8%. The AOAC method gave lower recovery (85.6-90.7%) of toxin, but the results from this method had a somewhat smaller standard deviation for replicate analyses than did results of the new method.     

Aflatoxin, a human carcinogen: determination in foods and biological samples by monoclonal antibody affinity chromatography

We have used monoclonal antibody technology to produce antibodies that recognize aflatoxins in order to develop noninvasive methods in conjunction with other chemical analytical techniques to monitor human exposure to environmental carcinogens. These methods require the ability to quantitate aflatoxins and their metabolites, including DNA and protein adducts, in readily accessible compartments such as serum and urine. The techniques permit efficient analysis of many samples in a relatively short time. Also, these monoclonal antibody affinity columns have been extremely useful for rapid isolation of aflatoxins from food and grain samples, as well as aflatoxin M1 from milk. Monoclonal antibody affinity methods are nondestructive to the aflatoxin molecule, so the sample aliquot can be used for confirmation. The use of monoclonal antibody preparative affinity columns represents a major, substantive breakthrough for analytical chemists and will be a generally applicable technology for isolation of many different substances.     

Thin layer chromatographic confirmation of aflatoxin M1 extracted from milk

Aflatoxin M1 can be confirmed directly on a thin layer plate by reacting the toxin with a mixture of reagents containing p-anisaldehyde. This confirmatory procedure requires only 2 elutions in the same direction using 2 different solvents. The mixture containing p-anisaldehyde is overspotted on M1 after the plate has been developed in toluene-ethyl acetate-ethyl ether-formic acid (25 + 35 + 40 + 5). The plate is heated at 110 degrees C for 10 min and then developed in hexane-acetone-chloroform (15 + 50 + 35). The Rf value of the green fluorescent derivative is less than that of the M1 standard. This confirmatory procedure requires only one-dimensional TLC, so several sample extracts and the standard can be run simultaneously. The minimum detectable quantity of aflatoxin M1 on the TLC plate with this test is 0.3 ng. p-Anisaldehyde reagent solution may also be used as a spray reagent for the confirmation of aflatoxin M1. The procedures described were satisfactory for confirming the mycotoxin in spiked samples of powdered and liquid milk.     

Development of milk powder reference materials certified for aflatoxin M1 content (Part II): Certification of milk powder RM 283

The development of a full cream milk powder reference material, certified for its aflatoxin M1 content (target concentration: 0.1 microgram/kg), is described. The material (RM 283) was prepared and certified within the Reference Material Programme of the Community Bureau of Reference, along with other members of a series of milk powder reference materials. Homogeneity, evaluated by determining the aflatoxin M1 content of 30 units, was found to be acceptable (coefficient of variation of analysis results: 9.1%); stability has been demonstrated in a long-term study. The certification exercise involved 7 laboratories. Calibration, control of recoveries, blank values, and independence of the replicate measurements were emphasized. All sets of results of the certification exercise were accepted for statistical evaluation. A certified value for the aflatoxin M1 content: 0.09(+0.04)(-0.02) micrograms/kg was derived. The certification of RM 283 completes the series of 4 milk powder reference materials having certified aflatoxin M1 contents.     

Liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk

The official AOAC method for aflatoxin M1 in milk was modified by replacing cellulose column chromatography with cartridge chromatographic cleanup and replacing thin layer chromatographic (TLC) determination with liquid chromatographic (LC) quantitation to yield a new method for bovine and porcine milk. An acetone extract of milk is treated with lead acetate and defatted with hexane, and M1 is partitioned into chloroform as in the AOAC method. Chloroform is removed by evaporation under a stream of nitrogen at 50 degrees C. The residue is dissolved in chloroform, the vessel is rinsed with hexane, and the 2 solutions are applied in sequence to a hexane-activated silica Sep-Pak cartridge. Less polar impurities are removed with hexane-ethyl ether, and M1 is eluted with chloroform-methanol, and determined by C18 reverse phase LC using fluorescence detection. Recoveries of M1 added to bovine milk at 0.25, 0.50, and 1.0 ng/mL were 90.8, 93.4, and 94.1%, respectively. The limit of detection was less than 0.1 ng M1/mL for both bovine and porcine milk.     

Modification of the rapid screening method for aflatoxin in corn for quantitative use

A study was made to determine if the official AOAC method for screening of aflatoxin in corn could be modified for use as a quantitative method. Several different corn products were analyzed using the modified method, with an average savings of over 1 h/sample vs the CB method. Average recoveries for aflatoxin B1 were 94% for the low level spiked samples and 108% for the high level. Samples of corn and corn products containing naturally incurred aflatoxin were also analyzed with the modified method, and the results compared favorably with those obtained by the CB method.