Relative Efficiency of Anther Culture and Chromosome Elimination Techniques for Haploid Induction in Triticale × Wheat and Triticale × Triticale Hybrids

Summary The study was undertaken to evaluate the relative efficiency of anther culture and chromosome elimination (by crosses with maize) techniques of haploid induction in intergenotypic triticale and triticale × wheat hybrids. For this, 15 triticale × wheat and 8 triticale × triticale F₁ hybrids were subjected to anther culture and were also simultaneously crossed with the `Madgran Local' genotype of maize (Zea mays L.) to induce haploids through the chromosome elimination technique. The haploid embryo formation frequency through the chromosome elimination technique was significantly higher in both, triticale × wheat (20.4%) and triticale × triticale (17.0%) F₁ genotypes, as compared to the calli induction frequencies through anther culture (1.6 and 1.4%, respectively). Further, four triticale × wheat and three triticale × triticale F₁ genotypes failed to respond to anther culture, whereas, all the F₁ genotypes formed sufficient number of haploid embryos through the chromosome elimination technique with no recovery of albino plantlets. The haploid plantlet regeneration frequencies were also significantly higher through the latter technique in both triticale × wheat (42.7%) and triticale × triticale (49.4%) F₁s as compared to anther culture (8.2 and 4.0%, respectively), where the efficiency was drastically reduced by several constraints like, high genotypic specificity, low regeneration frequency and albinism. The overall success rates of obtaining doubled haploids per 100 pollinated florets/anthers cultured were also significantly higher through the chromosome elimination technique (1.1% in triticale × wheat and 1.5% in triticale × triticale hybrids), proving it to be a highly efficient and economically more viable technique of haploid induction as compared to anther culture, where the success rates were only 0.2% and 0.1%, respectively.     

基因型和环境条件对小麦花药培养效果的影响

为进一步提高小麦花培育种效率,明确花药培养力的遗传控制基础,以11个小麦品种及其组配的20个F₁杂种为材料,探讨了基因型、培养基和环境条件对愈伤组织诱导率的影响。在W14D、W14gD、W14GD培养基上,Alondra、Verry、石4185、新春9号和百农3217的花药易被诱导产生愈伤组织,诱导率为25.3%~51.9%,其中石4185是目前公认的花培育种优良亲本,新春9号为新发现的优良花培基因型。以宁春4号配制的部分F₁杂种的愈伤组织诱导率较高,大多数组合高于10.0%,表明宁春4号与供试品种间具有较高的花药培养配合力。小麦花培育种技术要求亲本之一具有较高的花药愈伤组织诱导率或较高的花药培养配合力。小麦花药培养力的遗传控制复杂,表现为数量性状遗传,亲本花药培养力很高,其F₁组合花药培养力不一定很高,这与双亲配合力有关。小麦花药培养中,供体植株生长和愈伤组织诱导的适宜条件为较长的营养生长期、适宜的前期(分蘖期)温度和较高的中期(拔节后期)温度。在添加低浓度生长素和葡萄糖的液体培养基中发现小麦花药直接成苗现象,2,4-D诱导花药直接成苗效果优于Dicamba。随着年度间气候升高的影响,相同基因型花药愈伤组织诱导率呈现增加趋势。     

Effect of parental genotypes on haploid embryo and plantlet formation in wheat × maize crosses

Genotypic influence of both male and female parents on haploid production through interspecific crosses was studied using eight wheat and four maize genotypes. The average numbers of embryos and green haploid plantlets obtained per pollinated floret were 17.6% and 10.1%, respectively. Clear genotypic influence of the wheat genotype was detected, but heterozygosity of the wheat did not affect haploid production. Analogous response to anther culture and interspecific crossing was observed, still a wheat variety which did not respond to anther culture, produced 1.1 plantlets per pollinated spike upon maize pollination. This appears to be a major advantage of interspecific crossing compared to anther culture technique in wheat. Circumstantial evidence is presented for specific wheat × maize interaction on haploid plantlet formation. Rye chromatin enhanced haploid production but only in a complete 1B/1R substitution line. Ovaries with an embryo were found to be dispersed evenly all over the wheat spike, suggesting that within certain limits the developmental stage of ovaries and thus time of pollination within a spike are not as important as it was previously assumed. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

我国部分主推小麦品种组织培养再生能力评价

小麦细胞工程育种和基因工程育种存在强烈的基因型特异性, 从目前推广的优良小麦品种中筛选不同外植体再生能力强的基因型, 对于提高小麦生物技术育种效率和加速育成品种的生产应用具有重要意义。本研究以全国大面积推广的24个优良小麦品种和抗白粉病优良品系CB037为材料, 连续2年进行花药培养、幼胚培养和成熟胚培养, 统计愈伤组织诱导率、愈伤组织分化率和植株再生率, 分析、评价这些小麦品种(系) 3种外植体的组织培养再生性能。结果表明, 25个小麦品种(系)花药、幼胚、成熟胚的植株再生率分别为0~41.75%、2.25%~531.92%和3.24%~84.34%, 基因型差异显著; 组织培养再生能力以幼胚最强(119.79%), 成熟胚其次(36.23%), 花药最弱(4.91%)。CB037的3种外植体组织培养再生效率均最高, 轮选987、扬麦16、内麦836、科农199、新春6号、郑麦366、郑麦9023、新冬20、烟农19和川麦42幼胚培养植株再生能力表现较强, 新春6号、京冬8号、石麦4185、科农199和轮选987成熟胚培养植株再生率较高, 石麦4185和邯6172花药培养绿苗诱导率较高。小麦组织培养效率与基因型和外植体类型密切相关, 不同品种同一外植体再生能力差异显著, 同一品种不同外植体再生能力也存在显著差异, 并且3种外植体的组织培养再生能力不存在相关性。本研究筛选到不同外植体再生能力较好的优良小麦基因型, 可进一步用于小麦转基因育种和单倍体育种。     

Comparative analysis of in vitro anther- and isolated microspore culture in hexaploid Triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) for androgenic parameters

Two haploid induction media (190-0 and W14mi) were tested in isolated microspore culture of two triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) genotypes. The W14mi medium proved superior for the production of green plantlets in both genotypes. This basic medium (W14) was used to compare two doubled haploid production methods (isolated microspore culture and anther culture) with the same genotypes. The induction of androgenesis was more effective in isolated microspore culture than in anther culture. The number of embryo-like structures was 9.2 times higher in microspore culture (511.0/100 anthers) compared to anther culture (55.5/100 anthers) and the number of regenerant plantlets was also 3.4 times higher (anther culture—20.15/100 anthers; isolated microspore culture—67.6/100 anthers). However, the regenerant plantlets from isolated microspore culture were mainly albinos while predominantly green plantlets were regenerated from anther culture. The production of green plantlets from anther culture (16.8/100 anthers) was 2.9 times higher than from isolated microspore culture (5.8/100 anthers). The efficiency of anther culture was tested with eight winter triticale genotypes. The phenomenon of albinism did not hinder the green plant production in anther culture. Mean green plantlet production was 10.87/100 anthers. This value was two times higher than the number of albinos (5.01/100 anthers) and higher than previously published reports. The anther culture protocol described in this study is an efficient tool for the production of microspore-derived green plantlets in triticale.     

Genetic,quantitative and microscopic evidence for fusion of haploid nuclei and growth of somatic calli in cultured <Emphasis Type="Italic">ms10</Emphasis><Superscript><Emphasis Type="Italic">35</Emphasis></Superscript> tomato anthers

In plant breeding, androgenic doubled haploids represent powerful tools to save time and resources for pure line generation. While in many species efficient protocols are known, in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), the knowledge on the induction of androgenesis is still very scarce, and little is known about the particularities of this highly recalcitrant species. The only known method capable of yielding haploid/doubled haploid tomato plants is anther culture. However, this method has important limitations, including low efficiency of haploid induction and a low proportion of spontaneously doubled haploids. To understand these limitations better, we have analyzed the process of callus formation in anthers of tomato lines carrying the ms10 ³⁵ gene for male-sterility, using light and electron microscopy, flow cytometry and genetic analysis with morphological and molecular markers. Our results demonstrate that haploid, doubled haploid and diploid calli occur in tomato anthers, although at different frequencies. Diploid calli derived either from somatic cells or from the fusion of two genetically different haploid nuclei account for more than 90% of the total of calli produced. Somatic calli are derived from the stubs of connective tissue present in the interlocular septa of anthers. This growth is markedly increased in the ms10 ³⁵ mutants, which explains their higher callogenic rates than standard tomato lines. Together, our results reveal serious drawbacks that explain the low efficiency of anther-derived, doubled haploid production in tomato, and stress the need for alternatives towards doubled haploidy.     

不同基因型冬小麦花药出愈率及其愈伤组织的蛋白质电泳分析

用不同基因型的冬小麦品种花药在Ｗ１４２培养基（改进的Ｗ１４培养基）上获得较高的出愈率，但不曲因型之间仍存在着显著的差异。用Ｐｈａｒｍａｃｉａ公司ＰｈａｓｔＳｙｓｔｅｍ电泳仪对不同基因型小麦花药及其愈伤组织蛋白质进行等电聚焦电泳和ＳＤＳ－聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳分析，观察到不同基因型花药蛋白质之间存在着差异，并且初步认为这种蛋白质差异与出愈率有相关性。不同基因型花药愈伤组织之间观察不到明显的带型区别，但它     

Haploidy breeding and mutagenesis for drought tolerance in wheat

Several intraspecific crosses between known drought tolerant wheat varieties and stable high yielding recombinants were made with the objective to develop improved cultivars for the moisture stressed rainfed areas of Pakistan. Five of these crosses were selected for further creation of useful mutations through the application of low doses of gamma rays and development of doubled haploids through anther culture. Anther culture response of the selected irradiated F₁ generations was studied on liquid and solid induction media. The highest number of calli among almost all crosses was produced on Potato-2induction medium. All the crosses varied greatly in response to callus induction and maximum calli (75%) were obtained from Lyl-73/vee’s’ cross. Similarly, genotypic differences were found for green vs. albino regenerants. The highest number of green plantlets (12.1%) was recorded for Lu-26/3062. From the developed doubled haploid population 25 DH-mutants were initially selected and nine lines were finally included in multi-locational field tests. Two DH-mutants (i.e. DHML-50 and DHML-9) have potential for better grain yield, earliness, disease resistance and moisture stress tolerance. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

大豆花药愈伤组织的分化及其内源激素分析

选用３１个栽培大豆基因型进行花药培养。愈伤组织诱导率２．２％￣３６．６％,８个基因型的出愈率在２５％以上,６个基因型产生了芽或胚状体,只有丰收黄、鲁豆１０呈二个基因型既产生了芽,又产生了胚状体,具有相对高的培养力。３年内共产生了１４个再生芽、９个胚状体、６个芽状物和一个根、芽齐全的小再生植株。虽然获得花粉植株属于１５年来的第一例,但愈伤组织分化率仍然很低,这与愈伤组织的状态和质量较差有很大关系。愈     

High frequency of plant regeneration from anther culture in flax, Linum usitatissimum L.

The effects of induction medium compositions on flax anther culture were investigated in order to improve the efficiency of callus induction and plant regeneration. Anthers were inoculated onto the modified MS medium supplemented with five different combinations of plant growth regulators. The medium containing the combination of 2mg/l 2,4- dichlorophenoxy-acetic acid (2,4-D) and 1 mg/1 6-benzylaminopurine (BAP) produced a significantly higher number of calli forming shoots/100 responded anthers and a significant increase in overall efficiency of regeneration than the same basal medium containing 1 mg/1 a-naphthalene-acetic acid (NAA) and 2 mg/1 BAP (CK). Among the five levels of thiamin hydrochloride tested, the modified MS medium containing 10 mg/1 thiamin hydrochloride significantly increased the number of calli forming shoots/100 responded anthers and the overall efficiency of regeneration compared with the same basal medium containing 0.1 mg/1 thiamin hydrochloride. Maltose concentration had a significant effect on the percentage of anthers producing call, the number of calli forming shoots/100 responded anthers and the overall efficiency of regeneration. The medium containing 6% or 9% maltose produced the highest overall efficiency of regeneration among the five levels of maltose evaluated. Sucrose concentration significantly affected the number of calli forming shoots/100 responded anthers and the overall efficiency of regeneration, and dramatically affected the frequency of microspore-derived plants and the frequency of spontaneous chromosome doubling in microspore-derived plants. The efficiency of doubled haploid line production obtained in this study appears adequate for applied breeding programmes.     

小麦花药培养在春小麦群体改良中应用的初步研究

以太谷核不育基因为桥梁选用有关亲本组配了6个春小麦轮回选择集团,经轮选过一轮后,从中选择150个优良可育株,进行花药培养,其平均花药出愈率为22.09%,绿苗诱导率9.22%,均高于同年及上年度品种间杂交 F_1的花药培养结果。白苗分化率21.93%,与上述两年的 F_1培养结果相近。说明不育基因对花药培养无不良影响。加倍花粉植株二代     

小麦与玉米杂交产生小麦单倍体与双单倍体的稳定性

小麦与玉米杂交是诱导小麦单倍体最有效的途径之一, 但单倍体和双单倍体产生频率不稳定影响了该技术的应用。选用13个小麦杂种F₁代单交组合与玉米杂交, 研究了不同小麦生长环境、生长素处理、培养基和壮苗处理对单倍体及双单倍体产生频率的影响。小麦生长在大田, 去雄后割穗培养与玉米杂交平均得胚率为23.9%, 每个杂交穗平均得胚数6.8个, 均是返青后从大田移回冷温室盆栽的3倍以上;不同小麦杂交组合间胚产生频率存在明显差异。生长素Dicamba蘸穗处理平均得胚率是21.5%, 与2,4-D处理得胚率(21.1%)无显著差异, 但不同杂交组合间差异显著。B5培养基幼胚萌发率为70.9%~88.3%, 平均82.0%;1/2 MS培养基胚萌发率为70.0%~86.0%, 平均76.6%;两种培养基平均胚萌发率无显著差异。试管苗经壮苗培养基壮苗处理与试管苗经移栽壮苗处理后加倍效率分别是67.6%和8.6%。移栽壮苗处理的苗分蘖少, 生长较弱, 加倍处理后存活率低和加倍率低是其单倍体加倍效率低的原因。     

Plant regeneration from anther culture in Canadian cultivars of flax (Linum usitatissimum L.)

The effect of culture of anthers at 35 °C for one to four days prior to culture at 25 °C in darkness, genotype, anther orientation on callus induction and shoot regeneration in anther culture of flax was investigated. The influence of type and concentrations of cytokinins in the regeneration medium on shoot regeneration was also investigated. The results suggested that culture of anthers at 35 °C prior to continuous culture at 25 °C in darkness did not significantly improve the percentage of anthers producing calli. However, culture of anthers at 35 °C for one day significantly increased the overall efficiency of regeneration compared to no culture temperature treatment. Genotypic effects were significant for the percentage of anthers producing calli and the overall efficiency of regeneration. Anther orientation showed no significant differences. The regeneration medium containing 4.5 μM zeatin had significantly higher percentage of calli forming shoots than the same basal medium containing 0.01 μM TDZ. The importance of these findings for flax breeding was discussed. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Assessment of different anther culture approaches to produce doubled haploids in cucumber (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cucumis sativus</Emphasis> L.)

Cucumber is one of the most important vegetable crops worldwide, which makes it a good candidate to produce doubled haploid (DH) lines to accelerate plant breeding. Traditionally, these approaches involved induction of gynogenesis or parthenogenesis with irradiated pollen, which carries some disadvantages compared to androgenesis. Despite this, studies on anther/microspore cultures in cucumber are surprisingly scarce. Furthermore, most of them failed to unambiguously demonstrate the haploid origin of the individuals obtained. In this work we focused on anther cultures using two cucumber genotypes, different previously published protocols for anther culture, different in vitro culture variants to make it more efficient, and most importantly, a combination of flow cytometry and microsatellite molecular markers to evaluate the real androgenic potential and the impact of anther wall tissue proliferation. We developed a method to produce DH plants involving a bud pretreatment at 4 °C, a 35 °C treatment to anthers, culture with BAP and 2,4-D, and induction of callus morphogenesis by an additional 35 °C treatment and sequential culture first in liquid medium in darkness and second in solid medium with light. We also found that factors such as genotype, proliferation of anther wall tissues, orientation of anthers in the culture medium and growth regulator composition of the initial anther culture medium have a remarkable impact. Our rate of chromosome doubling (81%) was high enough to exclude additional chromosome doubling steps. Together, our results present androgenesis as an improvable but yet more convenient alternative to traditional gynogenesis and parthenogenesis-based approaches.     

小麦花药培养的基因型差异与亲本选配分析

对104份不同基因型材料进行花药培养,结果表明：F1代愈伤组织诱导率为13.28%,高于F3代的6.02%; 绿苗产率F1代为2.88%,F3代为1.10%,F1相当于F3的2.6倍。同样的培养条件下,不同基因型材料间花药培养力差异很大,愈伤诱导率在 0～111.43% 之间、绿苗产率在 0～49.29% 之间;愈伤诱导率、绿苗分化率与绿苗产率三者之间成正相关关系。同时筛选出了一批如宁春4号等具有高培养力、高产和优质基因的花培桥梁亲本,为有目的配制杂交组合提供依据。     

Large-scale production of wheat and triticale double haploids through the use of a single-anther culture method

A total of 257 parental wheat and 38 triticale lines were used for anther culture. On average, 2.1 green wheat haploids were obtained per spike. This response occurred irrespective of the origin of the material (Germany, France, Sweden or UK) and 5 years of testing. Triticale responded with 5.3 green haploids per spike. Using the criterion that one parental line should give at least one green haploid per spike in the screening experiment, green haploids were produced from 88 out of 91 F₁ wheat breeding combinations and from each of 21 F₁ and F₂ triticale breeding combinations. An average of 4.7 green plants were obtained per spike from the wheat production programme, while the triticale programme gave an average of 6.2 green plants per spike. A single medium supplemented with different hormones for anthers and embryos was used for culture of both crops.     

Production of salt tolerant rice breeding line via doubled haploid

Summary A haploid breeding program was initiated to develop doubled haploid salt tolerant rice breeding line via anther culture. Two sensitive breeding lines BR4608-R₁-R₂ and BR4909-R₁-R₂ were crossed with a salt tolerant line IR13146-13-3-3 to transfer its salt tolerant character to the doubled haploids.Anther from confirmed F₁s of the two crosses were cultured in defined medium for callus induction and eventual plant regeneration. Fifteen doubled haploid (DH) lines were obtained from two crosses. Test for salt tolerance were done in vitro. Five out of 15 lines were found tolerant at the level of 8–10 decisiemens/m (ds/m) while the rests were sensitive to that level of salinity.Field experiment was conducted to evaluate the doubled haploids under saline and non saline soil. Five salt tolerant lines produced comparable yield with the resistant control (BR 23) under saline condition, whereas these lines yielded even higher in non saline soil under irrigated condition when evaluated with other 10 sensitive DH linesAbbreviations LSD Least Significant Difference - NAA Napthalene Acetic Acid     

Anther culture response of wild Oryza species

Thirteen different wild species of the genus Oryza were investigated for their response to anther culture and plant regeneration. Callus induction from microspores of anthers was found to be strongly dependent on the species. Although large numbers of anthers from wild Oryza species, including O. barthii, O. latifolia, O. australiensis, O. minuta, O. nivara, O. paraguagensis and O. eichingeri, were cultured, no calli could be obtained. However, calli were produced from anthers of O. punctata, O. perennis, O. alta, O. ridleyi and O. rufipogon, although the frequency of callus induction was different. Similar species-dependence was observed in plant regeneration from microspore-derived calli. In total, 62 plants were derived from anther culture, including 47 albino and 15 green plants (of which 26.7% were haploids) from O. perennis; for the first time, six albino plants were obtained from O. ridleyi. Phytohormone combinations in the callus induction medium were found to influence callus induction and different wild Oryza species exhibited their own preferred phytohormone combinations for anther culture. In general, NK medium containing suitable concentrations of auxin and cytokinin may be successfully applied for anther culture of selected wild Oryza species.     

Tal小麦花药培养出愈和分化的研究

采用Ｔａｌ小麦轮回选择集团４个不同的可育株和Ｔａｌ、矮败小麦多父本复合杂交３个世代的可育株，分别进行花药培养。结果表明：１．Ｔａｌ小麦高世代具有较高的出愈率和绿苗分化率，但与常规品种间杂交一样，出愈率和绿苗分化率有随世代提高而降低的趋势。２．不同交配方式花培效果有明显差异，其中以轮选群体的出愈率最高，其次是多父本复合杂交后代；回交转育稳定的Ｔａｌ小麦的单交出愈率最低。３．基因型对出愈率、绿苗分化率     

Improved Techniques for Haploid Production in Wheat using Chromosome Elimination

Wheat × maize and wheat × pearl millet crosses have proved efficient for haploid production using various genotypes of wheat; 22 and 27 % of florets produced embryos. In favourable conditions 6—9 haploid plants per spike were produced. The following simplifications or improvements in technique are recommended: 1. Only a single treatment with an aqueous solution of dicamba or 2,4-D (50–100 ppm) for embryo stimulation in vivo; 2. Application by spraying or dipping the spikes; 3. Application time two to four days after pollination; 4. Embryo rescue 15 to 18 days after pollination; 5. Crosses without emasculation are possible if pollination occurs 1–2 days before anthesis. More than 450 haploids and some doubled haploid (DH) lines (after colchicine treatment in vitro) were produced using these methods. No hybrid plants, chromosome additions or substitutions were found.