Comparative evaluation of commercially available aflatoxin test methods

Five qualitative methods and 1 quantitative aflatoxin analytical method were compared with the Holaday-Velasco (HV) minicolumn and thin-layer chromatography (TLC) methods for corn in an evaluation involving 4 U.S. Department of Agriculture Federal Grain Inspection Service (USDA-FGIS) laboratories, 1 laboratory at the University of Georgia, and 1 laboratory at the University of Arizona. Samples analyzed included 1 set of artificially contaminated corn containing both aflatoxin B1 and B2 (ratio of B1:B2 of 92:8), 1 set of artificially contaminated corn containing only aflatoxin B1, and 1 set of naturally contaminated corn. Levels of total aflatoxin tested were 0, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, and 40 ppb. Results of analysis of these samples with each method evaluated are reported. Chi-square analyses indicated that performance of the Afla-20-Cup, Aflatest, EZ-Screen, OXOID, and SAM-A methods was not statistically different from that of the HV minicolumn. Agri-Screen results were not statistically different from those obtained with TLC.     

Simple, rapid, and inexpensive cleanup method for quantitation of aflatoxins in important agricultural products by HPLC

A chemical cleanup procedure for low-level quantitative determination of aflatoxins in major economically important agricultural commodities using HPLC has been developed. Aflatoxins were extracted from a ground sample with MeOH/H2O (80:20, v/v), and after a cleanup step on a minicolumn packed with Florisil, aflatoxins were quantified by HPLC equipped with a C18 column, a photochemical reactor, and a fluorescence detector. Water/MeOH (63:37, v/v) served as the mobile phase. Recoveries of aflatoxins B1, B2, G1, and G2 from peanuts spiked at 5, 1.7, 5, and 1.7 ng/g were 89.5+/-2.2, 94.7+/-2.5, 90.4+/-1.0, and 98.2+/-1.1, respectively (mean+/-SD, %, n=3). Similar recoveries, precision, and accuracy were achieved for corn, brown and white rice, cottonseed, almonds, Brazil nuts, pistachios, walnuts, and hazelnuts. The quantitation limits for aflatoxins in peanuts were 50 pg/g for aflatoxin B1 and 17 pg/g for aflatoxin B2. The minimal cost of the minicolumn allows for substantial savings compared with available commercial aflatoxin cleanup devices.     

Minicolumn detection method applied to almonds: collaborative study.

The minicolumn screening method for aflatoxins was collaboratively tested on naturally contaminated almonds. The nuts were extracted, and the extract was cleaned up and applied to a Velasco-type minicolumn. This permits the detection of total aflatoxins (B1, B2, G1, G2) as a fluorescent band on the Florisil layer of the column. The results of 20 collaborators are presented. Samples containing 0, 2, 5, 10, and 25 ng aflatoxin/g were analyzed. Ninety-six per cent of the samples containing 5--25 ng total aflatoxins/g and 83% of the negative samples were correctly identified. The method has been adopted as official first action for detection of total aflatoxin levels of greater than or equal to 5 ng/g.     

Rapid thin layer chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in powdered milk

A method has been developed for the detection of aflatoxin M1 in milk. The toxin is extracted with chloroform, the extract is evaporated, and the residue is partitioned between carbon tetrachloride and an aqueous saline-methanol solution. The toxin is once again extracted with chloroform from the methanol solution and analyzed by thin layer chromatography. The limit of detection of M1 in powdered milk is 0.5 microgram/kg; recoveries of added M1 are about 83%. The limit of detection can be improved to 0.3 microgram/kg if the plate is sprayed with an aqueous solution of H2SO4 after development.     

Rapid determination of aflatoxins in raw peanuts by liquid chromatography with postcolumn iodination and modified minicolumn cleanup

A method is described for rapid cleanup followed by reverse-phase liquid chromatographic (LC) quantitation of aflatoxins in raw peanuts. A modified minicolumn cleanup is used for sample preparation, and a preliminary estimation of aflatoxin content by minicolumn can be made so that highly contaminated samples can be diluted before LC analysis. The use of the simple, quick minicolumn cleanup eliminates the need for further column or cartridge cleanup, thus greatly reducing sample preparation time. Sensitive quantitation is achieved using a phenyl column, a mobile phase of water-tetrahydrofuran (80 + 20, v/v), and postcolumn derivatization with water-saturated iodine followed by fluorescence detection. The recoveries of aflatoxins B1, B2, G1, and G2 from peanut meal spiked at 3 levels ranged from 71.7 to 88.3% (average 80%) with coefficients of variation from 2.7 to 10.4%.     

Fluorometric measurement of aflatoxin adsorbed on florisil in minicolumns.

Filter fluorometers have been adapted to measure the fluorescence intensity of aflatoxin absorbed on a Florisil layer in minicolumns. The relationship between concentration and intensity is near linear in the aflatoxin range from 10 to 100 ng. Although individual aflatoxin fractions cannot be resolved, since the measure is one of total intensity, fluorometric measurements advance the minicolumn screening procedure to a semiquantitative level. The detection of 1 ng aflatoxin B1 is well within the limits of a filter fluorometer with a photomultiplier detector. A precision, expressed as per cent coefficient of variation, ranging from 1.2 to 4.2%, was obtained for standard B1 columns.     

Reverse phase liquid chromatographic determination and confirmation of aflatoxin M1 in cheese

A systematic method is proposed for determination and confirmation of aflatoxin M1 in cheese by liquid chromatography (LC). A sample of cheese is extracted with chloroform, cleaned up on 2 silica gel columns followed by a Sep-Pak C18 cartridge, and chromatographed on a 5 microns octadecyl silica column with fluorometric detection. The sample extract or standard is treated with n-hexane-trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) (4 + 1) for 30 min at 40 degrees C. Analysis by LC with TFA-treatment of the extract provides quantitative data. Multiple assays of 5 samples of Gouda cheese spiked with aflatoxin M1 at levels of 0.5, 0.1, and 0.05 ng/g showed average recoveries of 93.2, 91.6, and 92.4%, with coefficients of variation of 2.63, 3.97, and 4.52%, respectively. Assay of 5 naturally contaminated cheeses resulted in 0.051-0.448 ng/g of aflatoxin M1. Limit of quantitation is about 0.01 ng/g. The identity of aflatoxin M1 is confirmed by treating aflatoxin M1 or the M2a derivative with TFA-methanol (or ethanol) (3 + 1). The TFA-methanol reaction products of M2a could be detected quantitatively.     

Rapid high pressure liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk and nonfat dry milk

A modification of the current revised AOAC method, 26.A10-26.A15, is described for the rapid analysis of aflatoxin M1 in milk and nonfat dry milk. The method incorporates chloroform extraction and eliminates the need for column chromatography by using liquid-liquid partition for sample extract cleanup. Quantitation is carried out by using fluorescence detection combined with high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) of aflatoxin M1 which has been converted to aflatoxin M2a with trifluoroacetic acid. The method has a detection limit of 0.014 micrograms/L (2 X signal/noise) for whole milk. For 6 samples of naturally contaminated nonfat dry and freeze-dried milk, the modified method gave an average result of 0.698 micrograms/L; the AOAC method gave an average result of 0.386 micrograms/L.     

Development and application of solvent-free extraction for the detection of aflatoxin M1 in dairy products by enzyme immunoassay

The official methods for the quantification of aflatoxin M1 in dairy products (cheese and yogurt) include extraction into dichloromethane or chloroform, evaporation of the solvent, partitioning of the reconstituted residue with hexane, and subsequent analysis. To secure a rapid and inexpensive screen for aflatoxin M1 contamination, a sensitive competitive ELISA, using a rabbit polyclonal antibody, was developed for measuring aflatoxin M1 in milk and used in a comparative study for measuring the extraction efficiency of aflatoxin M1 in aqueous or organic solvent buffers using yogurt samples. An aqueous sodium citrate solution was found to be suitable for extracting aflatoxin M1, thus eliminating the need for organic solvents. The citrate extraction proved to be efficient (recovery ranged from 70 to 124%) in fortified samples of very different kinds of dairy products, including yogurt and six types of cheese. Fourteen yogurt and cheese samples were extracted with citrate solution and analyzed by ELISA. A good correlation was observed (y=0.95x-0.59, r2=0.98) when the data were compared with those obtained through the official method, across a wide range of aflatoxin M1 contaminations (10-200 ng/kg).     

Rapid screening method for deoxynivalenol in agricultural commodities by fluorescent minicolumn

A rapid screening procedure based on the selective adsorption of deoxynivalenol (DON) from extracts of wheat and corn has been developed. DON is extracted from the sample with acetonitrile-water (85 + 15) and partially purified on a preparative minicolumn. Solvent is evaporated and the residue is dissolved in toluene-acetone (95 + 5) and chromatographed on a novel detector minicolumn which selectively adsorbs DON. A blue fluorescence is produced when the column is heated 5 min at 100 degrees C. The procedure is capable of detecting DON at greater than or equal to 500 ng/g. Forty-three wheat samples, contaminated with DON at 60-6300 ng/g, were assayed by gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy (GC-MS) of the heptafluorobutyryl derivative of DON and by the selective adsorption procedure. Comparison of results showed 91% agreement between data from the 2 methods. Selective adsorption assays were positive for all samples that were greater than or equal to 500 ng/g by GC-MS (no false negatives) and were negative for 85% of samples less than 500 ng/g (4/27 false positives). These four samples contained greater than 200 ng/g by GC-MS. Samples of wheat (64), corn (23), soybeans (8), and sorghum (6) were extracted and extracts were assayed by thin-layer chromatography and the selective adsorption procedure. Selective adsorption assays agreed with TLC results.     

Derivatization procedure for identification of aflatoxin M1 on a thin layer chromatogram.

A commodity extract containing presumptive aflatoxin M1 is placed on an origin spot of a thin layer chromatographic plate and overspotted with trifluoroacetic acid. The mixture is held in the dark 30 min at ambient temperature and then 30 min at 55 degrees C. The plate is developed with CHCL3-acetone-2-propanol (85+10+7). The Rf values of reacted and unreacted aflatoxin M1 are compared with authentic M1 similarly treated for identification. The lowest concentration that has been identified is 0.1 mug/kg.     

Development of milk powder reference materials certified for aflatoxin M1 content (Part II): Certification of milk powder RM 283

The development of a full cream milk powder reference material, certified for its aflatoxin M1 content (target concentration: 0.1 microgram/kg), is described. The material (RM 283) was prepared and certified within the Reference Material Programme of the Community Bureau of Reference, along with other members of a series of milk powder reference materials. Homogeneity, evaluated by determining the aflatoxin M1 content of 30 units, was found to be acceptable (coefficient of variation of analysis results: 9.1%); stability has been demonstrated in a long-term study. The certification exercise involved 7 laboratories. Calibration, control of recoveries, blank values, and independence of the replicate measurements were emphasized. All sets of results of the certification exercise were accepted for statistical evaluation. A certified value for the aflatoxin M1 content: 0.09(+0.04)(-0.02) micrograms/kg was derived. The certification of RM 283 completes the series of 4 milk powder reference materials having certified aflatoxin M1 contents.     

Optimum conditions for formation of aflatoxin M1-trifluoroacetic acid derivative

Because thin-layer chromatographic (TLC) confirmation of identity and reverse-phase liquid chromatographic (LC) determination with fluorescence detection of aflatoxin M1 both require the derivative formed in the reaction of M1 and trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), various reaction conditions were studied to obtain complete derivative formation. Of the various organic solvents tested, the reaction between M1 and TFA proceeded best in the nonpolar solvents hexane and isooctane. Other parameters investigated were reaction temperature and time, aflatoxin M1 concentration, and solvent volume. The following procedure is considered optimum: 200 microL each of hexane and trifluoroacetic acid are mixed with M1 standard in a silylated glass vial or with milk residue in a regular glass vial with a Teflon-lined screw cap and heated 10 min at 40 degrees C. The mixture is evaporated to dryness under N2, and the derivative is saved for TLC or LC. No unreacted aflatoxin M1 was detected by reverse-phase LC after this procedure was incorporated for analysis of milk samples.     

Automated liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxin M1 in milk using on-line dialysis for sample preparation

A procedure has been developed for the automated isolation of aflatoxin M1 from decreamed milk. The method uses on-line stopped flow dialysis and subsequent trace enrichment on a reverse-phase column. After a back-flush to the analytical liquid chromatography column, aflatoxin M1 is determined with fluorescence detection. Fully automated analysis is possible with reproducible dialysis recoveries above 50% (CV = 7.5%, n = 25 at the 50 ng/kg level) and determination levels of 20 ng/kg within 20 min.     

Development and validation of an ultrasensitive chemiluminescent enzyme immunoassay for aflatoxin M1 in milk

A fast and ultrasensitive chemiluminescent enzyme immunoassay for aflatoxin M(1) in milk samples has been developed and validated. The method is an indirect competitive type format involving the immobilization of an aflatoxin M(1)-bovine serum albumin conjugate on 384 well black polystyrene microtiter plates and the use of a secondary antibody labeled with horseradish peroxidase detected with a luminol-based substrate. Aflatoxin M(1) standard solutions were prepared in milk-based buffer, and milk samples were analyzed without any cleanup procedure. The limit of quantification was 1 ppt, the coefficient of variation was below 9% for both intra- and interassay precision, and the recovery ranged from 96 to 122%. The method is specific, and other aflatoxins do not significantly cross-react with the antibody. Twenty-four milk samples were analyzed, and a good correlation was observed (y = 0.98x + 1.71, r(2) = 0.98, n = 24) when the data were compared with a reference high-performance liquid chromatography method with a fluorescent detector. The developed method is suitable for an accurate, sensitive, and high-throughput screening of aflatoxin M(1) in milk samples with a reduction of costs and increased detectability, as compared with previously developed immunoassays.     

Degradation of the herbicides clomazone, paraquat, and glyphosate by thermally activated peroxydisulfate

Activated sodium peroxydisulfate has the potential to in situ destruct many organic contaminants because of the generation of the stronger oxidant sulfate radical. From photochemical activation of peroxydisulfate in flash-photolysis experiments, the bimolecular rate constants for the reaction of sulfate radical with glyphosate (1.6 × 10(8) M(-1) s(-1)) and paraquat (1.2 × 10(9) M(-1) s(-1)) at 25 °C were obtained. Thermal activation of peroxydisulfate was shown to degrade the herbicides clomazone, paraquat, and glyphosate. Although the herbicide degradation was observed to take place in less than 1 h, the mineralization of the organic carbon required longer reaction times, because of the formation of stable organic intermediates. For similar initial total organic carbon (TOC) values, TOC profiles were similar for experiments with different substrates (the herbicides, humic acids, and a mixture of glyphosate and humic acids), which indicates that the mineralization of all of the samples is limited by the production of SO(4)(?)?(-) radicals. A linear correlation between the initial amount of SO(4)(?)?(-) needed per mole of C and the average oxidation state was found.     

Simultaneous determination of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M1 residues in milk by triple quadrupole liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

A reliable, rapid, and sensitive liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) method for simultaneous determination of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M(1) in milk has been developed. This method includes simple extraction of sample with acetonitrile, separation on a MGIII-C(18) column using 5 mM ammonium acetate aqueous solution/methanol (60:40, v/v) as mobile phase, and MS/MS detection using multiple reaction monitoring mode. The method was validated according to Commission Decision 2002/657/EC. The limits of detection (LODs) were 0.05 μg/kg for chloramphenicol and 0.005 μg/kg for aflatoxin M(1.) The limits of quantification (LOQs) were 0.2 μg/kg for chloramphenicol and 0.02 μg/kg for aflatoxin M(1). The recovery values ranged from 88.8% to 100.6%, with relative standard deviation lower than 15% in all cases, when samples were fortified at three different concentrations. The decision limits (CCα) and detection capability (CCβ) of the method were also reported. This method has been successfully applied for simultaneous analysis of chloramphenicol and aflatoxin M(1) residues in milk from local supermarkets in China.     

Extraction, cleanup, and quantitative determination of aflatoxins B1 ANd M1 in beef liver

A method for the determination of aflatoxin B1 in eggs was applicable for aflatoxin B1 in liver, but ineffective for aflatoxin M1 in liver because of poor recovery of added aflatoxin and interferences in thin layer chromatography. The method was modified by the addition of citric acid to the extracting solvent and ammonium sulfate to the extract solution for removing protein. The elution system for silica gel column cleanup was also changed by substituting methanol for acetone, and adding a step for confirmation of aflatoxin M1 identity. The method has been used successfully for survey and research on aflatoxin residues in animal tissues.     

Development of milk powder reference materials certified for aflatoxin M1 content (Part I)

The development of 3 full-cream milk powder reference materials, certified for their aflatoxin M1 content, is described. The materials were prepared and certified within the Reference Material Programme of the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR). The 3 reference materials, RMs 282, 284, and 285, contain aflatoxin M1 at concentrations of less than 0.05, 0.31 +/- 0.06, and 0.76 +/- 0.05 micrograms/kg, respectively. The preparation, testing for homogeneity, stability of the reference materials, and the certification exercise, which was preceded by 2 intercomparisons of methods, are discussed. Particular emphasis was placed on the independence of the measurements in the certification exercise and the control of errors associated with extraction efficiency and the aflatoxin M1 calibrant. Finally, some guidance is given on avoiding the principal sources of errors in the determination of aflatoxin M1. Details concerning the supply of the reference materials will be provided by BCR on request.     

Rapid liquid chromatographic determination of aflatoxins M1 and M2 in artificially contaminated fluid milks: collaborative study

An international collaborative study involving 14 collaborators from 5 different countries was conducted to test a rapid liquid chromatographic (LC) method for detecting aflatoxins M1 and M2 in fluid milk. Each collaborator prepared artificially contaminated milk samples (0.078-1.31 ng M1/mL and 0.030-0.13 ng M2/mL) by adding solutions containing various concentrations of aflatoxins M1 and M2 to fresh milk. Recoveries ranged from 85.2 to 102.5% (av. 93.7%) for aflatoxin M1 and from 99.5 to 126.7% (av. 109.8%) for aflatoxin M2. Coefficients of variation averaged 21.4% (M1) and 35.9% (M2). An analysis of variance was calculated from combined data to determine variance components. The within-laboratory variations (So) (repeatability) were 27.9% (M1) and 23.9% (M2), and the among-laboratory variations (Sx) (reproducibility) were 44.5% (M1) and 64.7% (M2). No visual differences were determined between normal or reverse phase LC for contaminated samples; however, there were an insufficient number of collaborators using normal phase to give meaningful separate statistical data. For 26 observations of uncontaminated milk, 3 false M1 positives were reported for normal phase LC determinations and 2 false M1 positives were reported for reverse phase LC determinations. Three normal phase and 11 reverse phase false M2 positives were reported for 104 observations in uncontaminated milk. The reverse phase LC method for determination of aflatoxins M1 and M2 in fluid milk has been adopted official first action.