Effect of Single Strain and Traditional Mixed Strain Starter Cultures on Rheological Properties of Wheat Dough and on Bread Quality

Investigations were made to test the effect of two different sourdough starter culture types on wheat dough and bread quality. Two single‐strain starter cultures consisting of well‐defined strains of lactic acid bacteria (Lactobacillus plantarum, L. brevis) and a traditional mixed‐strain sourdough culture (containing L. crispatus, L. pontis, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae) were evaluated for their effects on the rheological characteristics of wheat dough using both fundamental rheological and standard baking tests. Two other doughs were also evaluated, one which was chemically acidified to a comparable pH value by the addition of lactic acid, and a control which was not acidified. Dynamic oscillation tests were performed using a controlled stress rheometer. The phase angle and the absolute value of the complex dynamic modulus were measured for all doughs at frequencies of 0.1–10 Hz. The addition of sourdough prepared using single‐strain or mixed‐strain cultures significantly increased the phase angle and reduced the complex modulus of the doughs at all frequencies (P < 0.05). Significant differences were found between the dough which was chemically acidified and those doughs which were biologically acidified. The addition of sourdough effected an increase in loaf specific volume relative to both the chemically acidified and the nonacidified doughs.     

Combined effect of sourdough lactic acid bacteria and additives on bread firmness and staling

The effect of various sourdoughs and additives on bread firmness and staling was studied. Compared to the bread produced with Saccharomyces cerevisiae 141, the chemical acidification of dough fermented by S. cerevisiae 141 or the use of sourdoughs increased the volume of the breads. Only sourdough fermentation was effective in delaying starch retrogradation. The effect depended on the level of acidification and on the lactic acid bacteria strain. The effect of sourdough made of S. cerevisiae 141-Lactobacillus sanfranciscensis 57-Lactobacillus plantarum 13 was improved when fungal alpha-amylase or amylolytic strains such as L. amylovorus CNBL1008 or engineered L. sanfranciscensis CB1 Amy were added. When pentosans or pentosans, endoxylanase enzyme, and L. hilgardii S32 were added to the same sourdough, a greater delay of the bread firmness and staling was found. When pentosans were in part hydrolyzed by the endoxylanase enzyme, the bread also had the highest titratable acidity, due to the fermentation of pentoses by L. hilgardii S32. The addition of the bacterial protease to the sourdough increased the bread firmness and staling.     

Formation of Oligosaccharides and Polysaccharides by Lactobacillus reuteri LTH5448 and Weissella cibaria 10M in Sorghum Sourdoughs

Gluten‐free breads, which are composed of gluten‐free flours, starch, and hydrocolloids, differ from wheat and rye breads in relation to texture, volume, and crumb structure. Moreover, the dietary fiber content is lower compared with wheat or rye breads. Cereal isolates of lactic acid bacteria frequently produce oligo‐ and homopolysaccharides from sucrose, which can improve the nutritional and technological properties of gluten‐free breads as prebiotic carbohydrates and hydrocolloids, respectively. Sorghum sourdough was fermented with Lactobacillus reuteri LTH5448 or Weissella cibaria 10M, which synthesize fructooligosaccharides (FOS) and levan, and isomaltooligosaccharides and dextran, respectively. The gluten‐free bread was produced with 14% sourdough addition. L. reuteri LTH5448 formed FOS and 1.5 g of levan/kg DM in quinoa sourdoughs. FOS were digested by the baker's yeast during proofing, and the levan could be qualitatively detected in the bread. W. cibaria 10M produced >60 g of isomaltooligosaccharides/kg DM and 0.6 g of dextran/kg DM, which could still be detected in the bread. Breads prepared with W. cibaria 10M were less firm compared with breads prepared with L. reuteri LTH5448 or a FOS and levan‐negative mutant of L. reuteri LTH5448. The addition of sourdoughs fermented with oligo‐ and polysaccharide forming starter cultures can increase the content of prebiotic oligosaccharides in gluten‐free breads.     

Production of Two Types of Pocket‐Forming Flat Bread by the Sponge and Dough Method

Two types of flat bread (thin and thick) were produced from straight‐grade flour by the traditional straight dough (SD) and sponge and dough (SPD) methods using 50 and 60% sponges. Quality of the resulting bread was evaluated with respect to specific volume, crumb distribution between layers, moisture content, overall sensory quality, and rate of staling. The results showed that the method of production has a significant effect (P < 0.05) on the specific volume of the crumb‐rich thick flat bread but not on the almost crumb‐free thin type. The study showed that breads produced with the SPD method were superior to those produced by the SD method with respect to their overall quality and resistance to staling, and that using 50% sponge gave bread with superior overall sensory quality to that obtained using 60% sponge. The results indicate that the Structograph can be used to follow the staling of these breads. Nonetheless, using the SPD method has some drawbacks, mainly longer fermentation time, and more space, mixing, and labor requirements that are expected to limit its use in commercial production of flat bread types.     

Effect of Glutamate Accumulation During Sourdough Fermentation with Lactobacillus reuteri on the Taste of Bread and Sodium‐Reduced Bread

NaCl is an important contributor to the taste and texture of bread; therefore, it is challenging to reduce NaCl in bread without compromising quality. This study investigated sensory properties of bread with sourdough fermented with Lactobacillus reuteri accumulating glutamate or γ‐aminobutyrate (GABA). Sourdough was fermented with the GABA‐producing L. reuteri 100‐23 and LTH5448 as well as the glutamate‐accumulating L. reuteri 100‐23ΔgadB and TMW1.106. A consumer panel detected significant differences in the taste of bread with 6% addition of sourdough fermented with glutamate‐ or GABA‐producing L. reuteri. Remarkably, this difference was also detected when GABA‐producing L. reuteri 100‐23 was compared with its glutamate‐producing isogenic mutant L. reuteri 100‐23ΔgadB. The intensity of the salty taste of sourdough bread produced with 1% (flour basis) salt was equivalent to the intensity of the salty taste of reference bread produced with 1.5% salt. A trained panel found that sourdough breads (1 or 2% NaCl flour base) had a higher sour and umami taste intensity when compared with reference bread with the same salt content. Bread produced with sourdough fermented with L. reuteri 100‐23ΔgadB consistently had a higher umami taste intensity when compared with other sourdough breads. Neither sourdough addition nor NaCl level influenced bread volume or texture. In conclusion, the use of sourdough fermented with glutamate‐accumulating lactobacilli allowed reduction of NaCl without adverse effects on the taste or other quality attributes of bread.     

Effect of Baking Method and Fermentation on Folate Content of Rye and Wheat Breads

The effect of baking method on folates of rye and wheat breads, as well as the effect of sourdough fermentation of rye, were examined. Sourdough fermentations were performed both with and without added yeast, and samples were taken throughout the baking process. Samples were analyzed microbiologically for their total folate content after trienzyme extraction. Individual folate vitamers were determined by HPLC after affinity chromatographic purification. The lowest folate contents for both rye and wheat breads were found from breads baked without added yeast. Total folate content increased considerably during sourdough fermentation due to increased amounts of 10‐HCO‐H₂folate, 5‐CH₃‐H₄folate, and 5‐HCO‐H₄folate. Baker's yeast contributed markedly to the final folate content of bread by synthesizing folates during fermentation. Proofing did not influence total folate content but changes in vitamer distribution were observed. Folate losses in baking were ≈25%. The variety of sourdoughs and baking processes obviously lead to great variation in folate content of rye breads. The possibilities to enhance natural folate content of rye bread by improving folate retention in technological processes and by screening and combining suitable yeasts and lactic acid bacteria should be further investigated.     

Influence and Interactions of Processing Conditions and Starter Culture on Formation of Acids,Volatile Compounds,and Amino Acids in Wheat Sourdoughs

The aim of this work was to study the influence of process parameters and the starter culture on the characteristics of wheat sourdough by using response surface methodology. Influence of fermentation temperature (16–32°C), ash content of flour (0.6–1.8%), and fermentation time (6–20 hr) were considered as independent factors and their effects were studied in sourdough fermented with Lactobacillus plantarum, L. brevis, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, or with a combination of yeast and lactic acid bacteria. Formation of acidity, free amino acids, and volatile compounds were considered the main responses. A possibility to enhance formation of potential flavor compounds and precursors without excessive acidity formation in wheat sourdoughs was established. The total amount of amino acids increased by 25–50%, depending on the strain and fermentation conditions. The total amount of volatile compounds increased seven‐ to 100‐fold, depending on the strain and fermentation conditions. Sourdough started with S. cerevisiae was an effective way to optimize the amount of volatile compounds without excessive acidity formation in appropriate processing conditions. Ash content of flour and fermentation time were the most significant factors to modify metabolic activity of wheat sourdoughs. Frequent interactions between the studied factors were observed on the formation of acidity, amino acids, and volatile compounds with most of the strains studied. Possibility to improve current industrial fermentation processes and control flavor attributes of breads by using optimized sourdough was established.     

Textural Comparisons of Gluten‐Free and Wheat‐Based Doughs,Batters, and Breads

Studies were conducted with two newly developed gluten‐free bread recipes. One was based on corn starch (relative amount 54), brown rice (25), soya (12.5), and buckwheat flour (8.5), while the other contained brown rice flour (50), skim milk powder (37.5), whole egg (30), potato (25), and corn starch (12.5), and soya flour (12.5). The hydrocolloids used were xanthan gum (1.25) and xanthan (0.9) plus konjac gum (1.5), respectively. Wheat bread and gluten‐free bread made from commercial flour mix were included for comparison. Baking tests showed that wheat and the bread made from the commercial flour mix yielded significantly higher loaf volumes (P < 0.01). All the gluten‐free breads were brittle after two days of storage, detectable by the occurrence of fracture, and the decrease in springiness (P < 0.01), cohesiveness (P < 0.01), and resilience (P < 0.01) derived from texture profile analysis. However, these changes were generally less pronounced for the dairy‐based gluten‐free bread, indicating a better keeping quality. Confocal laser‐scanning microscopy showed that the dairy‐based gluten‐free bread crumb contained network‐like structures resembling the gluten network in wheat bread crumb. It was concluded that the formation of a continuous protein phase is critical for an improved keeping quality of gluten‐free bread.     

Reduced Gelatinization,Hydrolysis, and Digestibility in Whole Wheat Bread in Comparison to White Bread

Wheat, an important crop in North Dakota and the United States, is often used for bread. Health concerns related to chronic diseases have caused a shift toward consumption of whole wheat bread. There has been some indication that the rate and amount of starch digestibility of whole wheat breads may be lower than for their refined flour counterparts. This research investigated the components of whole wheat bread that may reduce starch digestibility and impact nutritional quality. Six formulations of flour were used, which included two refined flours, two whole wheat flours, and two whole wheat flours with added starch. The starch was added to whole wheat flours to increase the starch level to that of the refined flour so that we can determine whether or not the dilution of the starch in whole wheat bread was a factor in lowering the estimated glycemic index (eGI) of whole wheat bread. White and whole wheat flours and breads were evaluated for chemical composition, baking quality by 1 , and eGI by the Englyst assay. Whole wheat breads had significantly (P < 0.05) higher mineral, protein, arabinoxylan, and phenolic acid contents, as well as significantly (P < 0.05) lower eGI. The starch molecular weight was also significantly (P < 0.05) higher for whole wheat and whole wheat + starch breads compared with white breads. The eGIs of refined flour breads were 93.1 and 92.7, whereas the eGIs of whole wheat and whole wheat + starch breads ranged from 83.5 to 85.1. Overall, several factors in the whole wheat bread composition can be found to affect the quality and starch hydrolysis.     

Application of Response Surface Methodology in the Development of Gluten‐Free Bread

The formulation of gluten‐free (GF) bread of high quality presents a formidable challenge as it is the gluten fraction of flour that is responsible for an extensible dough with good gas‐holding properties and baked bread with good crumb structure. As the use of wheat starch in GF formulations remains a controversial issue, naturally GF ingredients were utilized in this study. Response surface methodology was used to optimize a GF bread formulation primarily based on rice flour, potato starch, and skim milk powder. Hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC) and water were the predictor variables. Analyses of the treatments from the design were made 24 hr after baking. Specific volume and loaf height increased as water addition increased (P < 0.01). Crumb firmness decreased as water levels increased (P < 0.01). Significant interactions (P < 0.01) between HPMC and water were found for the number of cells/cm². The number of large cells (>4 mm²) decreased with increasing levels of HPMC and water. Optimal ingredient levels were determined from the data obtained. The optimized formulation contained 2.2% HPMC and 79% water flour/starch base (fsb) and measured responses compared favorably to predicted values. Shelf‐life analysis of the optimized formulation over seven days revealed that, as crumb firmness increased, crust firmness and crumb moisture decreased.     

Breadmaking Use of Andean Crops Quinoa,Kañiwa,Kiwicha, and Tarwi

The effect of addition of flours from the highly nutritious Andean crops quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa), kañiwa (Chenopodium pallidicaule), kiwicha (Amaranthus caudatus), and tarwi (Lupinus mutabilis) has been investigated in wheat doughs and fresh bread quality. The thermomechanical profile of wheat doughs and bread quality has been explored by increasing substitution of wheat flour at 0–100% by Andean crop flours. Dough blends were evaluated using the Chopin Mixolab device, whereas bread quality assessment comprised sensory (overall acceptability) and physicochemical (moisture, specific volume, texture, color) determinations in composite breads. In general, no breads with aerated crumb structure could be obtained from 100% Andean crop flours, with the exception of quinoa breads that had overall sensory values about half a completely perfect score, and which were not significantly different from the breads made from a 50:50 blend of wheat and quinoa. Replacement of wheat flour by ≤12.5% (tarwi), 25% (kañiwa), and 50% (kiwicha), respectively, still produced breads with good sensory acceptability but variable color and doughs with acceptable thermomechanical patterns. Partial substitution of wheat flour by Andean crop flours constitutes a viable option to improve the nutritional value of the breads, with acceptable technological performance of dough blends and composite breads.     

Characteristics of Noodles and Bread Prepared from Double‐Null Partial Waxy Wheat

Double‐null partial waxy wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) flours were used for isolation of starch and preparation of white salted noodles and pan bread. Starch characteristics, textural properties of cooked noodles, and staling properties of bread during storage were determined and compared with those of wheat flours with regular amylose content. Starches isolated from double‐null partial waxy wheat flours contained 15.4–18.9% amylose and exhibited higher peak viscosity than starches of single‐null partial waxy and regular wheat flours, which contained 22.7–25.8% amylose. Despite higher protein content, double‐null partial waxy wheat flours, produced softer, more cohesive and less adhesive noodles than soft white wheat flours. With incorporation of partial waxy prime starches, noodles produced from reconstituted soft white wheat flours became softer, less adhesive, and more cohesive, indicating that partial waxy starches of low amylose content are responsible for the improvement of cooked white salted noodle texture. Partial waxy wheat flours with >15.1% protein produced bread of larger loaf volume and softer bread crumb even after storage than did the hard red spring wheat flour of 15.3% protein. Regardless of whether malt was used, bread baked from double‐null partial waxy wheat flours exhibited a slower firming rate during storage than bread baked from HRS wheat flour.     

Effects of Transglutaminase on Rheology,Microstructure, and Baking Properties of Frozen Dough

The improving effects of transglutaminase (TGase) were investigated on the frozen dough system and its breadmaking quality. Rheological properties and microstructure of fresh and frozen doughs were measured using a Rapid Visco‐Analyser (RVA), dynamic rheometer, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The frozen doughs with three storage periods (1, 3, and 5 weeks at –18°C) were studied at three levels (0.5, 1.0, and 1.5%) of TGase. As the amount of TGase increased, hot pasting peak viscosity and final viscosity from the RVA decreased, but breakdown value increased. The TGase content showed a positive correlation with both storage modulus G′ (elastic modulus) and the loss modulus G″ (viscous modulus): G′ was higher than G″ at any given frequency. The SEM micrographs showed that TGase strengthened the gluten network of fresh, unfrozen dough. After five weeks of frozen storage at –18°C, the gluten structure in the control dough appeared less continuous, more disrupted, and separated from the starch granules, while the dough containing 0.5% TGase showed less fractured gluten network. Addition of TGase increased specific volume of bread significantly (P < 0.05) with softer bread texture. Even after the five weeks of frozen storage, bread volume from dough with 1.5% TGase was similar to that of the fresh control bread (P < 0.05). The improving effects of TGase on frozen dough were likely the result of the ability of TGase to polymerize proteins to stabilize the gluten structure embedded by starch granules in frozen doughs.     

Relationship Between Solvent Retention Capacity and Protein Molecular Weight Distribution,Quality Characteristics,and Breadmaking Functionality of Hard Red Spring Wheat Flour

This research aims to investigate the relationship between the solvent retention capacity (SRC) test and quality assessment of hard red spring (HRS) wheat flour samples obtained from 10 HRS cultivars grown at six locations in North Dakota. The SRC values were significantly (P < 0.05) correlated with flour chemical components (protein, gluten, starch, and damaged starch contents, except arabinoxylan); with farinograph parameters (stability [FST], water absorption, peak time [FPT], and quality number); and with breadmaking parameters (baking water absorption [BWA], bread loaf volume [BLV], and symmetry). Differences in locations and cultivars contributed significantly to variation in quality parameters and SRC values. Suitability of SRC parameters for discriminatory analysis of HRS wheat flour is greatly influenced by molecular weight distribution (MWD) of SDS‐unextractable proteins. SRC parameters, except for sucrose SRC, showed significant (P < 0.01) and positive correlations with high‐molecular‐weight (HMW) polymeric proteins in SDS‐unextractable fractions, whereas only lactic acid SRC exhibited significant (P < 0.01) correlations with low‐molecular‐weight polymeric proteins. HMW polymeric proteins also exhibited positive associations with FPT, FST, BWA, and BLV. The discrepant variation in association of SRC parameters with respect to MWD of SDS‐unextractable proteins could improve segregation of HRS wheat flour samples for quality.     

Konjac Polysaccharides Affect the Quality,Cell Structure,and Moisture Balance of Baked Bread

The effect of addition of konjac glucomannan (KGM) and its derivative konjac superabsorbent polymer (KSAP) on fresh bread quality and its influence on bread staling were investigated. Both KGM and KSAP decreased the hardening rate of the bread crumb and retarded amylopectin retrogradation. Loaf quality of the KGM bread and KSAP bread were therefore improved, because collapse of gas cells during bread processing was prevented. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) showed that the presence of KGM and KSAP increased compartmentalized water and slowed release of the compartmentalized water. Deconvolution of TGA showed an alteration of the distribution of free and bound water and its interaction with starch and gluten. Additionally, by monitoring water‐binding strength and changes during storage by a_w measurements, it was found that water release from konjac polysaccharide‐enriched bread was extended over time compared with the release from control bread. The presence of KGM and KSAP significantly reduced the staling rate of bread.     

Network Formation in Gluten‐Free Bread with Application of Transglutaminase

One of the main problems associated with gluten‐free bread is obtaining a good structure. Transglutaminase (TGase), an enzyme that catalyzes acyl‐transfer reactions through which proteins can be cross‐linked could be a way to improve the structure of gluten‐free breads. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of TGase at different levels (0, 0.1, 1, and 10 U of TGase/g of protein) on the quality of gluten‐free bread. The recipe consisted of white rice flour (relative amount: 35), potato starch (30), corn flour (22.5), xanthan gum (1), and various protein sources (skim milk powder [SMP] [12.5], soya flour, and egg powder). The influence of the various proteins in combination with the different addition levels of TGase on bread quality (% bake loss, specific volume, color, texture, image characteristics, and total moisture) was determined. Confocal laser‐scanning microscopy (CLSM) was used to evaluate the influence of TGase on the microstructure of the bread. Baking tests showed that TGase had an effect on the specific volume of the bread. For instance, the SMP bread with 10 U of enzyme contained the most compact structure, which was reflected in the crumb texture profile analysis results (highest values) (P < 0.05), digital image analysis (highest level of cells/cm²) (P < 0.05), and CLSM micrographs (network formation). Finally, it can be concluded that it is possible to form a protein network in gluten‐free bread with the addition of TGase. However the efficiency of the enzyme is dependent on both the protein source and the level of enzyme concentration.     

Frequency Dependence of Viscoelastic Properties of Bread Crumb and Relation to Bread Staling

The viscoelastic behavior of bread crumb was studied using dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) in the compression mode with the frequency sweep. The dynamic storage modulus (E′), loss modulus (E″), and tanδ (E″/E′) were measured for bread crumb aged up to three days at ambient temperature. The viscoelastic properties of bread crumb showed a characteristic frequency dependence similar to that of a soft rubberlike solid. Typical behavior of bread crumb involved a transition from rubberlike to glasslike consistency with increasing frequency. At a low frequency region, the E′ and E″ values were relatively small and nearly constant, showing characteristics of the rubbery plateau. Then, they increased rapidly with increasing frequencies and approached a glasslike state. Tanδ was low and almost constant at low frequencies before the transition, then went through a prominent peak with increasing frequency. The frequency at which the tanδ of bread crumb started to rapidly increase was defined as the onset frequency (ƒ_o) of the transition. The ƒ_o values increased with the aging of bread crumb samples, which correlated highly to bread staling (r = 0.942). Both dynamic moduli E′ and E″ at ƒ_o also increased with the aging of bread, which correlated highly to firmness obtained using a texture analyzer in a static compression mode (r = 0.941 and 0.943, respectively). DMA measurements could be helpful in characterizing bread staling.     

Effects of LAB Fermentation on Physical Properties of Oat Flour and Its Suitability for Noodle Making

Flour was obtained from oats fermented with lactic acid bacteria (LAB) to study the effect of fermentation on the physical properties and the suitability of fermented oats for use in starch noodle production. The results showed that fermented samples had a significantly lower pH than control samples. Gel strength and amylose content initially increased and then decreased (P < 0.05) with fermentation time. The peak viscosity, breakdown, final viscosity, and setback value decreased with fermentation time. Fermented noodles showed a higher hardness and springiness. In particular, Lactobacillus plantarum (LP) induced the highest springiness, cohesiveness, gumminess, chewiness, and resilience over 12 hr of fermentation. The cooking quality evaluation indicated that fermentation improved the quality of oat starch noodles. Fermented oats resulted in noodles with low cooking loss and higher cooking weight compared to noodles made from fresh flour. The use of LP for 12 hr of fermentation time yielded noodles of the best quality.     

Selenium‐Enriched Breads and Their Benefits in Human Nutrition and Health as Affected by Agronomic,Milling, and Baking Factors

Bread is among the three top foods that provide most of the dietary selenium (Se) for most of the world population. Selenomethionine present in flour and bread is the major organic moiety (>65%). The Se concentration assayed in wheat kernels is mainly affected by agronomic factors such as soil fertility. The dry milling of wheat to produce refined flour and the technology to produce leavened breads also greatly affect Se concentration and bioavailability. The supranutritional intakes of inorganic and mainly organic Se have long been linked to the prevention of cancer, oxidative stress, and cardiovascular diseases. This review provides an overview of the different Se sources and agronomic, milling, and processing factors that affect Se concentration and bioavailability in yeast‐leavened and sourdough breads and the nutritional and health implications that have been documented by food, medical, and nutrition scientists.