Quantitation by ELISA of pili and sheep antibodies to the pili of Bacteroides nodosus

ELISA systems have been developed to quantitate the isotypic antibody response of sheep naturally infected with B. nodosus isolate 198 or injected with pili from isolate 198 in oil emulsion vaccines. The predominant humoral antibody detected following vaccination was IgG1, with substantially lower amounts of IgG2 and IgM. The antibody response was relatively specific for the pilus antigen from isolate 198. Although weak cross reactivities were detected with antiserums to some other isolates, ELISA IgG antibody titres in excess of 200 offer a tentative identification of the isolates of B. nodosus involved in natural outbreaks of footrot. A related ELISA was also developed to quantitate the amount of pili in cell suspensions and crude preparations of pili used in vaccines.     

Electron microscopic study of Bacteroides nodosus pili and associated structures.

Surface structures of Bacteroides nodosus were examined by electron microscopy. Collodion film and chrome shadowing were used for maximizing the visualization of B nodosus pili and ring structures. The existence of B nodosus pili in foot rot lesions was confirmed. Contrary to previous reports, it was found that B nodosus pili production can be retained through serial broth transfer under certain conditions. Capsule production by B nodosus was irregular in that it could be either lacking or variable in thickness. A bacteriophage capable of infecting B nodosus also was detected.     

Monoclonal antibodies against pili of serologically distinct Bacteroides nodosus.

Several monoclonal antibodies (McAbs) against pili of Bacteroides nodosus were examined to determine their reactivity with 11 different serotypes. One McAb was identified by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) analysis that bound to nine of the 11 serotypes and another that bound to the remaining two serotypes tested. In addition, some McAbs demonstrated specificity for a single serotype, while others displayed specificities for up to five other serotypes. Comparison of immunoblot analysis with the ELISA revealed that the former method was not as sensitive in that all McAbs positive by the ELISA, were not positive by immunoblot. Possible explanations of these findings are discussed. There appear to be several antigenic determinants on B. nodosus pili and considerable sharing of these determinants between pili types. The 11 serotypes analyzed by the McAbs in this report are representative of all 20 US serotypes as well as the A-set and D-set categories of Australia. Therefore, the two epitopes recognized by two of the McAbs reported herein encompass all of the currently characterized B. nodosus serotypes and may provide a basis for bivalent vaccines efficacious for all types of B. nodosus induced footrot in sheep.     

Importance of pilus-associated antigen in Bacteroides nodosus vaccines

The performances of two cellular vaccines, one sparsely piliated and the other well piliated, were compared on irrigated pasture with those of vaccines containing their respective, purified pili. There were statistically significant differences among the four vaccines in the mean numbers of feet per sheep which developed severe foot rot during 27 weeks of exposure. The incidence of severe foot rot was significantly lower in the two pili-vaccinated groups than in the group vaccinated with well-piliated cells, which were in turn substantially more effective than the sparsely piliated. However, the two pili vaccines did not prevent infection of the interdigital skin so that the differences in vaccine performance were much less marked when interdigital skin lesions were included. The number of feet affected by blowfly strike was closely associated with the presence of the most severe lesions and consequently there were far fewer struck feet in the two pili vaccine groups than in the two cellular vaccine groups. Analysis of serum agglutinin titres led to the same assessment of vaccinal efficacy as that derived from the analysis of severe foot rot lesions. Individually the agglutinin response to vaccination was not universally associated with resistance or susceptibility to severe foot rot but mean titres were significantly higher in the two pili vaccine groups than in the highly piliated-cell vaccine group, which were all in turn significantly higher than in the poorly piliated-cell vaccine group.     

Protection of sheep against experimental footrot by vaccination with pili purified from Bacteroides nodosus

Merino sheep vaccinated with either whole Bucteroides nodosus organisms, a crude surface antigen preparation or highly purified pili (>99% homogeneity) in oil adjuvant, developed significant resistance to artificial footrot infection when compared with unvaccinated control sheep inoculated with saline-in-oil emulsion (Freund's incomplete adjuvant) alone. The pili-vaccinated sheep generally had higher K-agglutinating antibody titres than sheep vaccinated with whole B. nodosus. These results confirmed the role of B. nodosus pilus protein both as a protective antigen and the K-agglutinogen.

Vaccines prepared with Freund's incomplete adjuvant containing either purified pili, crude pili or B. nodosus whole cells did not produce significantly different injection-site reactions.     

Protection of sheep against experimental footrot by vaccination with pili purified from Bacteroides nodosus

Merino sheep vaccinated with either whole Bacteroides nodosus organisms, a crude surface antigen preparation or highly purified pili (>99% homogeneity) in oil adjuvant, developed significant resistance to artificial footrot infection when compared with unvaccinated control sheep inoculated with saline-in-oil emulsion (Freund;s incomplete adjuvant) alone. The pili-vaccinated sheep generally had higher K-agglutinating antibody titres than sheep vaccinated with whole B. nodosus. These results confirmed the role of B. nodosus pilus protein both as a protective antigen and the K-agglutinogen. Vaccines prepared with Freund;s incomplete adjuvant containing either purified pili, crude pili or B. nodosus whole cells did not produce significantly different injection-site reactions.     

Effect of adjuvants on antibody responses of sheep immunised with recombinant pili from Dichelobacter nodosus

Objective To compare the effects of two oil emulsion adjuvants (incomplete Freunds adjuvant and a proprietary oil adjuvant), DEAE-dextran, L-tyrosine particles and Quil A on the humoral immune responses of sheep immunised with recombinant pili of Dichelobacter nodosus (strain A).
Procedure Antibody titres were studied for up to 32 weeks and were measured by bacterial agglutination and ELISA. The relative avidity of antibodies for pili was determined and the incidence and severity of adverse reactions at the site of injection of vaccines were recorded.
Results The oil emulsion adjuvants and Quil A were more effective than either DEAE-dextran or L-tyrosine at stimulating antibodies in sheep. The incidence and severity of adverse reactions was lower in sheep which received vaccines containing either Quil A or DEAE-dextran than in sheep which received vaccines containing oil emulsion adjuvants. L-tyrosine had no adverse effects.
Conclusion Quil A was as effective as oil adjuvants at stimulating high levels of antibodies against recombinant pili in sheep and had the significant advantage of being less irritant after subcutaneous injection.     

Generation, maintenance and reactivity of ovine T-lymphocyte clones derived from sheep immunized with pili from Bacteroides nodosus

Peripheral blood leucocytes (PBL) from sheep immunized with pilus protein purified from Bacteroides nodosus serogroup A were cultivated in vitro and cloned in the presence of the specific antigen and autologous antigen-presenting cells (APC). The efficiency of cloning was enhanced by high proliferative responses to pili during the initial week of cultivation, and the provision of recombinant human interleukin-2 (rec-IL-2). After three passages at weekly intervals, bulk cultures of PBL and cloned T-lymphocytes were greater than 99% CD4+, CD8-, sIg-, i.e. the characteristic phenotype of helper T-lymphocytes. Cloned T-lymphocytes were devoid of allo-reactivity, and were restricted by class II antigens of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Both bulk PBL and cloned T-lymphocytes exhibited similar patterns of reactivity against pili from different serogroups of B. nodosus and the T-lymphocytes reacted to three of six peptides synthesized from the amino-acid sequence of pilus from serogroup A. Although clones of T-lymphocytes could retain antigen specificity for up to 2 months of cultivation, several attempts to recover clones with specific reactivity after storage in liquid nitrogen were unsuccessful.     

Purification, characterization, and serologic characteristics of Bacteroides nodosus pili and use of a purified pili vaccine in sheep

Hair-like appendages (pili) were isolated and purified from Bacteroides nodosus, the etiologic agent of foot rot disease in sheep. Microscopic and biochemical analyses indicated that pili from organisms isolated in Australia, New Zealand, and the United States are morphologically and structurally similar. Pili are filamentous assemblies of identical protein subunits. Using specific antisera raised in rabbits against pili, 7 antigenic types were identified. A geographic pattern in the distribution of the pilus serotypes was not evident. In a preliminary vaccine trial, sheep vaccinated with purified pili developed resistance to challenge exposure to B nodosus. Protection was correlated positively with the serum anti-pilus antibody titers.     

Differences between breeds of sheep in their responses to Bacteroides nodosus vaccines

In a field experiment on irrigated pasture, sheep of several breeds were vaccinated twice, subcutaneously, in the upper neck, with Bacteroides nodosus vaccine containing either depiliated cells (DC vaccine), or whole, piliated cells (WC vaccine) and the responses were measured over the following 14 weeks. DC vaccine was as effective as WC vaccine in protecting against the development of foot-rot under conditions of moderate challenge, although the WC vaccine induced significantly higher pilus agglutinating antibody titres. Foot-rot developed in significantly more vaccinated Merinos (Peppin and Saxon strains) than in Romney Marsh, Dorset Horn or Border Leicester breeds. Agglutinating antibody titres after WC vaccination were significantly lower in the Peppin Merino than in the other sheep for the first 6 weeks, while after DC vaccination the titres remained elevated longer in the Border Leicester and Saxon Merino and were significantly higher from 6 weeks onwards. Reactions at the inoculation sites were generally larger in the British breeds than in the Merinos and among the former the reactions were largest, most numerous and most frequently discharged their contents in the Dorset Horn. Bodyweight gains in all vaccinated sheep were initially reduced, compared with controls, but the differences were no longer significant after the eighth week.     

Serotypic and biochemical characterization of Bacteroides nodosus isolates from Oregon.

Ninety-seven Bacteroides nodosus isolates were characterized by the tube agglutination test. Fourteen serotypes were identified including isolates that were serologically similar to Australian serotypes A, B and C. One additional isolate remains untyped and possibly represents another serotype. The isolates were cultured from 20 different flocks. Multiple isolates were obtained from 15 of the flocks and 13 of these had two to seven different B. nodosus serotypes. Eleven B. nodosus isolates representing one Australian and ten Oregon serotypes were nonfermentative in various carbohydrates and did not produce indole. These isolates all exhibited proteolytic activity. The prototype strains of 12 of the 14 serotypes demonstrated virulence as assessed by an elastase production assay.     

Antigenic stability of fimbriae of Bacteroides nodosus

Successful vaccination of sheep against footrot and attempts to eradicate the disease depend on there being a limit to the antigenic diversity of the causative bacterium, Bacteroides nodosus. Fimbrial antigenic variation was therefore investigated in vivo, both under conditions of chronic infection and under the pressure of a vaccine-induced immune response, to ascertain whether this represented an obstacle to such goals. Material was available from 5 experiments and although B. nodosus appeared to have undergone changes in its fimbrial antigens in one of these, the possibility that superinfection was responsible for the variation detected could not be ruled out because all sheep in this case were maintained at pasture. Overall, the results provided no evidence of fimbrial antigenic shift in B. nodosus in vivo and in conclusion, the survival of the organism in the sheep's foot, both in long-term natural infection and following vaccination, must therefore be related to factors other than the ability to undergo antigenic variation in order to evade the host's immune response.     

The effect of dissociation of Bacteroides nodosus pili on their efficacy as a protective antigen against ovine footrot.

Previous studies have shown that pili from homologous Bacteroides nodosus provide protective immunity in sheep against footrot, whereas denatured pilin subunits are ineffective. The aim of the present study was to examine whether pili that were dissociated into pilin subunits under less vigorous, non-denaturing treatment conditions, would provide an effective level of protective immunity. Using the techniques of gel permeation chromatography, light scattering and susceptibility to proteolysis as measures of disruption, it was shown that pili were dissociated either by the neutral detergents n-octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside (NOG) and Tween 80 or by lowering the pH with 1 M phosphoric acid to pH 2.2. Circular dichroic spectra indicated, however that the samples were not denatured by these treatments. Electron microscopic monitoring of detergent dissociated material following exhaustive dialysis showed the presence of protein-detergent micelles and "in-line" aggregates which gave the appearance of short fibres. Within these monitored preparations, there was no evidence of native undissociated pili. Pili dissociated by NOG or acid were tested in protection trials and shown to provide protective immunity, although agglutination titres of serum taken from the vaccinated sheep were significantly lower than those of animals inoculated with intact pili.     

The thermostability of proteases from virulent and benign strains of Bacteroides nodosus

Protease enzymes, produced by Bacteroides nodosus strains isolated from animals with virulent and benign forms of ovine footrot, were partially purified by ultra-filtration, ion exchange chromatography and gel permeation chromatography. Each enzyme had a similar pH optimum, was inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF), ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and ethyleneglycot-bis-aminoethylether-N,N-tetraacetic acid (EGTA), but was not inhibited by 1,10-phenanthroline. The results suggest that these enzymes are serine proteases that require divalent cations for activity. The enzymes could be distinguished by their differential temperature stability and differing susceptibility to irreversible inactivation by EDTA. Both enzymes were stabilised by incubation in the presence of Ca2+, but the enzyme purified from the virulent isolate required less Ca2+ for maximum stability. These results suggest that the differential thermostability of the protease activity detected in virulence tests is an intrinsic property of the protease enzymes.     

Classification of Bacteroides nodosus by agglutination tests

One thousand two hundred and sixty seven isolates of Bacteroides nodosus from 292 sheep in 58 flocks were examined. Of these, 1260 could be classified by slide agglutination into 8 serogroups designated A to H. Up to 6 serogroups were detected in individual flocks, with up to 4 serogroups being detected in a single foot. Of the 292 sheep examined, 38 (13%) carried mixed serogroup infections. Determination of the range of serological types infecting a flock frequently required the examination of a number of isolates from each of a number of sheep. Cross-tube agglutination tests carried out on 44 isolates and their antiserums indicated that members of some serogroups could be divisible into subgroups or serotypes. These results suggested that 16 or more serotypes of B. nodosus might exist. The nature of the antigens responsible for both slide and tube agglutination reactions needs to be determined.     

Studies on the ultrastructural morphology of Bacteroides nodosus.

The morphology of Bacteroides nodosus was examined with the electron microscope. B nodosus stained with solium phosphotungstate and uranyl acetate possessed fimbriae and in addition organisms negatively stained with sodium phosphotungstate often possessed rings on their surface. Phage-like particles were also observed in negatively stained preparations. In thin sections, B nodosus had a multilayered cell envelope and the type of cell division characteristic of Gram-negative bacteria. The cytoplasmic region contained a diffuse nucleoid area, ribosomes and, sometimes, concentrically arranged membranous lamellae. Fimbriae and capsular material were also seen in sections of B nodosus fixed with glutaraldehyde-osmium. Their visualisation appeared to be enhanced when ruthenium red was incorporated n the glutaraldehyde-osmium fixative but only when sections were stained with heavy metal salts, indicating that the fimbriae and capsule were not predominantly polysaccharide in nature.