Added triacylglycerols do not hasten hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation in washed minced cod muscle

Hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation in washed, minced cod muscle was related to the triacylglycerol to membrane lipid ratio. The same rapid development of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) and painty odor occurred with and without the presence of up to 15% menhaden oil. Without hemoglobin, development of TBARS and painty odor was slow, despite a high amount of hydroperoxides in samples with oil added (1135 micromol/kg muscle). This suggested that hemoglobin reacted by cleaving preformed hydroperoxides into secondary oxidation products. Nearly doubling the hemoglobin concentration approximately doubled the extent of lipid oxidation with and without added oil. This indicated that hemoglobin was limiting for the oxidation reaction. The noneffect of added oil suggests that membrane lipids and/or preformed membrane lipid hydroperoxides provided sufficient substrate in hemoglobin-catalyzed oxidation of washed minced cod muscle. Fe(2+-)ADP did not induce any oxidation of washed minced cod with/without added oil. Results suggest that lipid oxidation in fatty fish may be more related to the quantity and type of the aqueous pro-oxidant and the membrane lipids than to variations in total fat contents.     

Evaluation of occasional nonresponse of a washed cod mince model to hemoglobin (Hb)-mediated oxidation

An emerging model to test antioxidants for application in seafoods is washed cod mince fortified with hemoglobin (Hb) as a catalyst. This system has been used to test the antioxidative activity of certain muscle extracts and some pure compounds such as BHA, BHT, TBHQ, and propyl gallate during ice storage. However, the washed cod mince model has occasionally been resistant to Hb-mediated oxidation. This has been in cases when the moisture of the model has been minimized by washes at the protein isoelectric point (pH approximately 5.5) to allow for large additions of potentially antioxidative solutions. In this paper, noncontrollable and controllable factors for this intriguing occasional oxidation resistance were studied. Compositional analyses (lipid content, alpha-tocopherol, and lipid hydroperoxides) and structural analysis of a "normal" oxidizing model and a stable model were done to identify any differences among them. Some controllable factors related to the model preparation that were studied included different washing pH values (5.5-6.6), Hb concentrations (7.2 and 13.5 microM), final model moisture contents (75, 81, and 90%), and light exposure during ice storage (0 h, 3-4 h, or 24 h of light/day). Results revealed a 2-fold higher alpha-tocopherol content in the stable model than in the oxidizing model. Electron microscopy images showed a more and less disrupted myofibrillar structure in the stable and the oxidizing cod model, respectively. This indicated that "cold setting" (i.e., pre-gelation) of the stable model may have occurred and prevented Hb from diffusing freely in the model. Controllable factors that reduced lipid oxidation in the models were less Hb and lower moisture.     

Hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation and compositional characteristics of washed fish mince model systems made from cod (Gadus morhua), herring (Clupea harengus), and salmon (Salmo salar) muscle

The use of washed cod light muscle minces in mechanistic studies of hemoglobin (Hb)-mediated fish lipid oxidation has largely increased in the past 5 years. Although cod light muscle has a low level of intrinsic lipid oxidation catalysts, a prerequisite for a good oxidation model system, we believe it cannot fully mimic the oxidation kinetics taking place in other fish species being more susceptible to lipid oxidation. The aim of this study was to systematically investigate whether washed mince model systems useful in Hb-mediated oxidation studies could be prepared also from herring (Clupea harengus) and salmon (Salmo salar) light muscles. The kinetics of oxidation in the washed models was measured during ice storage (+/-Hb), and the results were related to compositional differences. Minces from cod, herring, and salmon light muscles were washed 3 times with 3 volumes of water and buffer. A 20 microM portion of Hb and 200 ppm streptomycin was then added, followed by adjustment of pH and moisture to 6.3 and 86%, respectively. Samples with or without Hb were then stored on ice, and oxidation was followed as peroxide value (PV), rancid odor, redness (a*) loss and yellowness (b*). Prior to storage, all minces and models were also analyzed for total lipids, fatty acids, alpha-tocopherol, proteins, Hb, Fe, Cu, and Zn. Hb-mediated lipid oxidation appeared within 2 days on ice in all models. Small differences in the oxidation rates ranked the models as herring > cod > salmon. These differences were ascribed to more preformed peroxides and trace elements in the herring model, and more antioxidants in the salmon model. Controls, without Hb, stayed stable in all cases except herring, where a very slight oxidation appeared, especially if the herring raw material had been prefrozen. In conclusion, fattier fish like dark muscle species and salmonoids are useful for making washed mince model systems and would be a better choice than cod if there is an interest in the oxidation kinetics of such species.     

Mechanisms of heme protein-mediated lipid oxidation using hemoglobin and myoglobin variants in raw and heated washed muscle

The hemoglobin variant rHb 0.1, which possesses a decreased ability to form subunits, stimulated lipid oxidation in washed fish muscle less effectively as compared to wild-type hemoglobin (rHb 0.0). This could be due to the lower hemin affinity and more rapid autoxidation rate of subunits as compared to tetramers. To differentiate between hemin affinity and autoxidation effects, ferrous V68T Mb was compared to ferrous wild-type myoglobin (WT Mb). WT Mb has a more rapid hemin loss rate (25-fold) than does V68T, while V68T autoxidized more rapidly than did WT Mb (60-fold). Ferrous WT Mb promoted TBARS and lipid peroxide formation more rapidly than did ferrous V68T (p < 0.01). This indicated hemin loss rate was more critical in determining onset of lipid oxidation as compared to autoxidation rate. Hemin alone was capable of stimulating lipid oxidation. Albumin enhanced the ability of hemin to promote lipid oxidation. MetMb promoted lipid oxidation more effectively than did ferrous Mb, which could be due to the lower hemin affinity of metMb as compared to that of ferrous Mb. EDTA, an iron chelator, had no effect on the rate or extent of lipid oxidation mediated by Mb in the cooked system. Variants with a 975-fold range of hemin affinities promoted lipid oxidation with equivalent efficacy in cooked washed cod contrary to results in uncooked washed cod. The cooking temperatures apparently denature the globin and release hemin reactant to such an extent that the impact of hemin affinity on lipid oxidation observed in the raw state is negated in the cooked state. These studies collectively suggest released hemin is of primary importance in promoting lipid oxidation in raw and cooked washed fish muscle.     

Effects of released iron, lipid peroxides, and ascorbate in trout hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation of washed cod muscle

Approximately 7% of the iron associated with hemoglobin was released from the heme protein during 2 degrees C storage in washed cod muscle. EDTA (2.2 mM) neither accelerated nor inhibited hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation based on the formation of lipid peroxides and TBARS. This suggested that low molecular weight iron was a minor contributor to hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation in washed cod muscle. Ascorbate (2.2 mM) was a modest to highly effective inhibitor of hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation depending on which washed cod preparation was assessed. Experimental evidence suggested that the ability of residual ascorbate to breakdown accumulating lipid hydroperoxides to reactive lipid radicals can explain the shift of ascorbate from an antioxidant to a pro-oxidant. Increasing the lipid peroxide content in washed cod muscle accelerated hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation and decreased the ability of ascorbate to inhibit lipid oxidation. Preformed lipid peroxide content in cod muscle was highly variable from fish to fish.     

Antioxidative properties of press juice from herring (Clupea harengus) against hemoglobin (Hb) mediated oxidation of washed cod mince

The antioxidative effect of herring (Clupea harengus) light muscle press juice (PJ) against hemoglobin-(Hb-) mediated oxidation of washed cod mince during ice storage was tested. The PJ was fractionated into low-molecular-weight (LMW; <1 [corrected] kDa) and high-molecular-weight (HMW; >1, >3.5, and > 50 kDa) fractions; it was preheated (10 min, 100 degrees C) and tested with or without removing heat coagulated proteins. Its antioxidative effect was compared with that given by endogenous levels of two tentative antioxidant candidates: ascorbic acid and uric acid. Oxidation was followed by determining rancid odor, peroxide value, and redness. Whole herring PJ and the LMW-PJ fraction significantly (p < 0.001) extended the oxidation lag phase of controls, from 2 up to 8 and 7 days, respectively. The HWM-PJ fractions were significantly (p < 0.05) less efficient than the whole and LMW-PJ samples, giving only 3.5-4.5 days of lag phase. Heat-treated PJ, with and without the heat-coagulated proteins, gave 7 and 5 days of oxidation lag phase, respectively. Heating different batches of the LMW-PJ fraction grouped the results into two categories: one where heating almost fully destroyed the antioxidative activity (fractions prepared from spring-caught herring) and another where heating had no or a minor effect (fractions prepared from fall-caught herring). The spring LMW-PJ had low ascorbic acid levels (18-42.6 microM), and 50-100% were destroyed by the heating. In fall LMW-PJ, the levels were 76.2-137.6 microM, and only 43-51% were destroyed. Ascorbic acid fortification of heated spring LMW-PJ to reach the levels found in the corresponding unheated spring LMW-PJ sample and the heated fall LMW-PJ gave back most of the antioxidative activity, which proved an important role of ascorbic acid for the antioxidative activity of LMW-herring PJ. This conclusion is drawn despite the fact that pure solutions with endogenous levels of ascorbic acid (giving 8.4-19.6 microM in final model) only very slightly delayed Hb-mediated oxidation of the washed cod mince.     

Effect of pH on hemoglobin-catalyzed lipid oxidation in cod muscle membranes in vitro and in situ

The effect of pH and hemoglobin on oxidation of the microsomal lipids of cod was determined in isolated microsomes and in washed cod muscle. An increase of hemoglobin concentration from 0.5 to 15 microM accelerated lipid oxidation in both systems. In cod microsomes the rate of lipid oxidation increased in the order pH 6.8 > pH 7.6 > pH 8.4 > pH 6.0 > pH 3.5. However, in washed cod muscle a decrease of pH from 7.8 to 6.8 greatly increased the lag phase and decreased the rate of lipid oxidation. A further decrease in pH to 3.5 decreased the lag phase and increased the rate of lipid oxidation further. A decrease of pH from 7.6 to 6.4 greatly reduced the affinity of hemoglobin for oxygen. Formation of methemoglobin due to autoxidation occurred more rapidly at pH 6.0 than at pH 7.5. Structural changes of the isolated microsomal membranes could be the reason for the unexpected slow lipid oxidation in microsomes at pH 6.0 and below.     

Inhibition of hemoglobin-mediated oxidation of regular and lipid-fortified washed cod mince by a white grape dietary fiber

The effectiveness of a white grape dietary fiber concentrate (WGDF) against hemoglobin-mediated oxidation of washed cod mince, with and without 10% added herring oil, was evaluated during ice storage. WGDF was added at two different levels: 2 and 4% based on final weight. An ethanol extract with the ethanol extractable polyphenols (EPP) and the ethanol-extracted grape dietary fiber residue were also tested as antioxidants in the washed cod mince. The addition of WGDF to the model system completely and significantly (p 相似文献   

Loss of redness (a*) as a tool to follow hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation in washed cod mince

Instrumental measurement of redness loss (decrease in a* value) was evaluated as a tool to follow hemoglobin (Hb)-mediated lipid oxidation in fish muscle. Two washed cod mince model systems were used (prepared at pH 6.5 and 5.5), both fortified with 15 micromol/kg of trout Hb and adjusted to pH 6.5 and 81% moisture. The rate of oxidation was varied through pH alterations (pH 6.1 and 6.9) and addition of an antioxidative cod muscle press juice. During ice storage, TBARS, painty odor, and a* values were followed. In all "oxidizing" samples, a* values correlated well with TBARS and painty odor development; r = -0.95 and -0.77, respectively. In press juice containing samples, the correlation was lower (0.55 for a vs TBARS) because there was a slight a* value decrease even in the absence of measurable lipid oxidation. a* values distinguished between "oxidizing" and stable samples within 1 day, before any lipid oxidation products could be chemically detected. It was confirmed in an aqueous phosphate buffer model system that the redness loss corresponded to a buildup of brownish met-Hb at the expense of oxy- and deoxy-Hb. The a* value data were best used as a lipid oxidation index by calculating the rate of decrease (k value) in the "initial phase" of the redness loss (before accumulation of lipid oxidation products) or in the "differentiation phase" (during the exponential raise in TBARS/painty odor). Calibration to lipid oxidation products must, however, be made for each specific sample type. Washing method, pH, Hb-type, etc., all affected both k values and absolute a* readings. Small yellowness (b*) increases also occurred along with a value losses, possibly the result of polymerized Schiff bases.     

Aqueous extracts from some muscles inhibit hemoglobin-mediated oxidation of cod muscle membrane lipids

It was evaluated whether trout hemoglobin (Hb)-mediated oxidation of minced washed cod muscle lipids could be prevented by an aqueous isolate from cod and some other muscle sources. Lipid hydroperoxides and painty odor developed approximately 4 days faster in washed than unwashed cod mince. When adding back an aqueous fraction (press juice) isolated from unwashed mince to washed mince at 2-6-fold dilutions, development of hydroperoxides and painty odor was either delayed or completely prevented. The inhibitory substances were heat stable, and their effect was slightly reduced at reduced pH. The <1 kDa fractions of whole and heated press juices were as inhibitory as the unfractionated press juices. Inhibition by the unheated, heated, and ultrafiltered (30 kDa) press juices was lost after dialysis. These findings implied the presence of one or more highly effective aqueous low molecular weight antioxidants in cod muscle press juice. The same antioxidative properties were found in heated haddock, dab, and winter flounder muscle press juices but not in heated herring and chicken muscle press juices. Unheated chicken press juice was however highly inhibitory.     

Effect of low and high pH treatment on the functional properties of cod muscle proteins

The functional properties of cod myosin and washed cod mince (myofibrillar protein fraction) treated at high (11) and low (2.5) pH were investigated after pH readjustment to 7.5. The solubility of refolded myosin was essentially the same as the native myosin. The pH-treated myofibrillar proteins had increased solubility over the whole ionic strength range studied. Acid and alkali treatment gave myosin and myofibrillar proteins improved emulsification properties, which were correlated with an increase in surface hydrophobicity and surface/interfacial activity. Enhanced gel strength was observed with acid- and alkali-treated myosin compared to native myosin, while the same treatment did not significantly improve the gel strength of acid- and alkali-treated myofibrillar proteins. The acid- and alkali-treated protein samples unfolded and gelled at a lower temperature than did the native proteins, suggesting a less conformationally stable structure of the refolded proteins. Functional studies show that acid and alkali treatment, which leads to partial unfolding of myosin may improve functional properties of cod myosin and myofibrillar proteins, with the greatest improvement being from the alkali treatment. The results also show that improvements in functionality were directly linked to the extent of partial unfolding of myosin on acid and alkali unfolding and refolding.     

pH-induced shift in hemoglobin spectra: a spectrophotometeric comparison of atlantic cod ( Gadus morhua ) and mammalian hemoglobin

Due to a pH-sensitive effect in many fish hemoglobins (Hb), analytical errors may occur when mammalian Hb is used as a standard in quantitative spectrophotometric multicomponent analysis of fish blood. The aim of this work was to examine differences in the optical spectra of mammalian (human) and fish (farmed Atlantic cod) Hb subjected to pH 7.4 and 6.5. The absorption spectra of the common derivatives, deoxy- (HHb), oxy- (OHb), carboxy- (COHb), and methemoglobin (metHb), were determined in the spectral range of 450-700 nm. The metHb spectra of fish differed considerably from the corresponding human Hb spectra, whereas only minor differences in OHb, HHb, and COHb were found. Cod Hb was significantly (P < 0.05) influenced by a drop in pH compared to mammalian Hb. This resulted in deoxygenation of the Hb and increased autoxidation. For human Hb, a pH-independent isosbestic point in the spectra of OHb, HHb, and metHb at 523 nm was found. This isosbestic point was not found in the absorption spectra of cod Hb. In conclusion, spectra of cod metHb and human metHb behave differently. This must thus be taken into account in spectrophotometric multicomponent analysis. Ideally, Hb in muscle or blood should be determined by comparison to a standard made from the same species.     

Effect of low pH on the susceptibility of isolated cod (Gadus morhua) microsomes to lipid oxidation

During the extraction of muscle to produce protein isolates by acid or alkali solubilization, membranes are exposed to abnormally low or high pH. Low but not high pH treatment induces rapid oxidation of membrane phospholipids in the presence of hemoglobin. The goal of this research work was to study the oxidative stability of microsomes under the conditions met during acid solubilization. Isolated microsomes from cod muscle were used as a model system. At pH 5.3 or lower, 99% of isolated cod membranes sedimented at low centrifugation speeds. Isolated membranes that were exposed to pH 3.0 were less susceptible to hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation. Cod hemoglobin exposed to pH 3 was rendered less pro-oxidative than the untreated cod hemoglobin. However, when microsomes and hemoglobin were together exposed to low pH, oxidation was promoted. Citric acid and calcium chloride, as well as press juice isolated from cod muscle, were able to inhibit lipid oxidation of microsomal suspensions.     

Studies with myoglobin variants indicate that released hemin is the primary promoter of lipid oxidation in washed fish muscle

Variants of sperm whale myoglobin (Mb) were used to assess the mechanism of heme protein-mediated lipid oxidation in washed cod muscle. A myoglobin variant with high hemin affinity (V68T) was an exceptionally poor promoter of lipid oxidation, while a Mb variant with low hemin affinity (H97A) was a potent promoter of lipid oxidation. V68T releases hemin slowly due to the ability of threonine to hydrogen bond with coordinated water and the distal histidine within the heme crevice. H97A rapidly releases hemin because the relatively small alanine residue creates a channel for water to easily enter the heme crevice which weakens the covalent linkage of hemin to the proximal histidine. A variant sensitive to heme degradation (L29F/H64Q) was a weaker promoter of lipid oxidation compared to wild-type Mb. This suggests that degrading the heme ring and releasing iron decreased the ability of Mb to promote lipid oxidation. Free radicals resulting from hemin-mediated decomposition of lipid hydroperoxides have the capacity to propagate lipid oxidation and degrade hemin catalyst. This may explain why heme proteins behave as reactants rather than "catalysts" of lipid oxidation in washed cod. Collectively these studies strongly suggest that released hemin is the critical entity that drives heme protein-mediated lipid oxidation in washed fish muscle.     

Fluorescence of muscle and connective tissue from cod and salmon

Autofluorescence of salmon and cod muscle was measured and compared with autofluorescence of collagen type I and type V. Similarities between fluorescence of fish muscle and collagen were found in that the same peaks were obtained around 390, 430, and 480 nm. These similarities are supported by principal component analyses. Texture and gaping score were predicted from the fluorescence spectra by partial least-squares regression. However, the predictions did not perform well. Relating fluorescence to the gaping score gave a prediction error of 0.91 and a correlation of 0.43 when measuring gaping on a scale from 0 to 5. There was no relation between texture and fluorescence spectra. Fluorescence of fish muscle could be related to the storage time. However, this relation seemed not to be induced by changes in collagen.     

Kinetics of oxidation of the lipids and proteins of cod sarcoplasmic reticulum

Lipid and protein oxidation in an NADH-Fe enzymic and an ascorbate-Fe nonenzymic system were determined simultaneously. The nonenzymic iron-reducing system gave rapid oxidation of lipid that leveled off at values much lower than those achieved in the enzymic system, which showed a continuous increase over the 1 or 2 h incubation times used. Protein sulfhydryl oxidation was more rapid in the nonenzymic system for total and accessible sulfhydryl groups, but the enzymic system oxidized the inaccessible sulfhydryl groups more rapidly. Both lipid and protein oxidations appeared to begin simultaneously. In the enzymic system, more lipid oxidation was achieved on a molar basis than oxidation of protein sulfhydryl groups, while in the nonenzymic system this was reversed. These data probably reflect the site specificity of the production of oxidizing elements in the two systems. The greater lipid oxidation in the enzymic system suggests that this may be the more important ferric iron-reducing system during storage of fish muscle.     

水洗结合pH值调整对鸡肉糜低盐热凝胶特性的影响

为解决肉糜类产品含盐量偏高而降低食盐添加量又影响其凝胶特性的技术难题,研究水洗结合pH值调整处理对0.88%食盐含量鸡胸肉糜热凝胶的质构特性、水分吸附和保水性的影响,并与0.15%和2.5%食盐添加量组进行对比。结果表明:水洗结合pH值调整不利于2.5%食盐组样品的质构特性,但对0.15%和0.88%食盐组的改善效果显著;pH值调整可显著增强0.15%和0.88%食盐组水洗肉糜的溶胀和凝胶保水性。2×2析因分析发现水洗和pH值调整具有显著的主效应和交互效应(P<0.05):两两比较后得出水洗组和pH值调整组的假设检验统计量(t值)为4.69,而水洗结合pH值调整组与未处理组的t值为30.25,P值均小于0.001。这些结果说明水洗结合pH值调整处理的新工艺可以使肌肉蛋白形成具有良好质构特性和保水性的低盐热凝胶,从而为低盐肉糜类产品的研发提供参考。     

Effects of oxidized dietary oil and vitamin E supplementation on lipid profile and oxidation of muscle and liver of juvenile atlantic cod (Gadus morhua)

The effects of oxidized dietary lipid and the role of vitamin E on lipid profile, retained tocopherol levels, and lipid oxidation of juvenile Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) were evaluated following a 9-week feeding trial. Four isonitrogenous experimental diets containing fresh or oxidized (peroxide value of 94 mequiv/kg) fish oil with or without added vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol or mixed tocopherols) were fed to juvenile cod in duplicate tanks. There was no significant (P > 0.05) influence on major lipid classes of cod liver and muscle by diet with the exception of sterols. Sterols content was increased in liver but decreased in muscle by oxidized dietary oil in the absence of vitamin E. Dietary vitamin E supplementation decreased the sterols level in cod liver but with no significant (P > 0.05) effect on their level in the muscle. Fatty acid composition varied between lipid fractions in muscle tissue and was affected by the diet. Oxidized oil significantly (P < 0.05) decreased the deposition of alpha-tocopherol in liver but not in muscle. gamma- and delta-Tocopherols from dietary tocopherol mixtures were retained at very low levels in liver, but higher retention was observed in muscle tissue. The oxidative state of both liver and muscle, as measured by the 2-thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) and headspace propanal, negatively correlated with tissue vitamin E levels. It is suggested that oxidized oil affected juvenile Atlantic cod by causing vitamin E deficiency in certain tissues and that these effects could be alleviated by supplementation of a sufficient amount of dietary vitamin E. The results also indicate that mixed tocopherols were good antioxidants for Atlantic cod, although less effective than alpha-tocopherol alone in many tissues with the exception of muscle, where gamma- and delta-tocopherols were deposited at relatively high levels.     

Effects of high pressure on the myofibrillar proteins of cod and turkey muscle

When turkey breast muscle and isolated myofibrillar protein and myosin of cod or turkey (pH approximately 7) were subjected to pressures up to 800 MPa for 20 min, DSC and electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) indicated that high pressure-induced denaturation of myosin led to the formation of structures that contained hydrogen bonds and were additionally stabilized by disulfide bonds. Disulfide bonds were also important in heat-induced myosin gels. Hardness of whole cod muscle, estimated by texture profile analysis, showed pressure-treated samples (400 MPa) to be harder than cooked (50 degrees C) or cooked and then pressure-treated or pressure-treated and then cooked samples, supporting the suggestion that pressure induces the formation of heat labile hydrogen-bonded structures while heat treatment gives rise to structures that are primarily stabilized by disulfide bonds and hydrophobic interactions. As expected, turkey myosin is more stable than that of cod; however, it seems their pressure-induced gelation mechanisms are similar.     

Effect of various cryostabilizers on the production and reactivity of formaldehyde in frozen-stored minced blue whiting muscle

The production of formaldehyde in frozen-stored minced blue whiting muscle was described by a rectangular hyperbolic model, and the effectiveness of each cryostabilizer is discussed in terms of its parameters. The maltodextrins assayed noticeably inhibited formaldehyde production, this effect being greater at -20 degrees C than at -10 degrees C. Sucrose was only effective at -20 degrees C. It seems that these compounds act by restricting molecular diffusion. The effect of each cryostabilizer on formaldehyde binding was closely regulated by its effect on production. This is discussed in terms of the binding equation parameters. The binding of formaldehyde during frozen storage was dependent on protein rearrangements leading to reactive groups becoming available. The constraints of cryostabilizers on molecular diffusion reduced the exposure of these groups. Consequently, the interpretation of formaldehyde reactivity was biased, leading to conclusions different from those that would be obtained from a study done under standard conditions.