Pathogenic variability amongst isolates of Crinipellis perniciosa from cocoa (Theobroma cacao)

Dry witches' brooms from cocoa were imported from various areas within Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Trinidad and Venezuela. Basidiocarps of Crinipellis perniciosa were induced to form on these brooms and seedlings of different types of cocoa were inoculated with basidiospores either on the hypocotyl or cotyledon bud. Host reactions were assessed mainly by recording stem base swelling and broom development at the cotyledon node (hypocotyl inoculations) or the extent of swelling and branching of shoots (cotyledon bud inoculations).
Results from 30 experiments indicated considerable diversity amongst isolates in inducing disease symptoms, but suggested that two groups or populations of C. perniciosa exist on cultivated cocoa. One group (A), comprising isolates from Bolivia and Pichilingue (Ecuador) and most isolates tested from Colombia, induced severe symptoms on cocoa with Scavina 6 as one parent; the other group (B), comprising isolates from Brazil, Trinidad and Venezuela, did not. Within these groupings variants could be further distinguished by particular host reactions. Isolates from Ecuador, especially from the Oriente, a centre of diversity for Theobroma cacao, showed a range of pathogenicity comparable to that found amongst isolates from cultivated cocoa over a much wider area.     

Growth rates of, and mycelial interactions between, isolates of Crinipellis perniciosa from cocoa

Growth of 87 single-basidiospore isolates of Crinipellis perniciosa , derived from witches' brooms on cocoa in 10 localities throughout South America and the Caribbean, was examined at 25°C on five agar media (Czapek-Dox, prune extract, potato-dextrose, V8 and carboxymethylcellulose). Interactions (designated intermingling or mutually antagonistic) between paired mycelia of 64 isolates were determined on V8 plates.
Six somatic-compatibility groups were identified comprising isolates from; (1) Pichilingue and Rio Palenque in Ecuador, Chigorodo and Manizales in Colombia; (2) Sucua (Ecuador); (3) Manaus (Brazil); (4) Ouro Preto (Brazil); (5) Castanhal (Brazil); (6) Trinidad and Tobago. This geographical separation of isolates was supported by results of the growth tests; growth of isolates within each compatibility group differed from other groups on at least one of the five media.
Separation of isolates by these methods did not conflict with previous results from tests of pathogenicity and could be useful in selecting isolates for screening cocoa lines for resistance to C. perniciosa.     

Effects of the fungus Crinipellis perniciosa, causal agent of witches' broom disease, on cell and tissue cultures of cocoa (Theobroma cacao L.)

The symptoms of witches' broom disease in cocoa, caused by the Basidiomycete fungus Crinipellis perniciosa , are pronounced swelling of the terminal and axillary buds followed in the long term by necrosis of this tissue. The direct effect of C. perniciosa on cocoa cells was examined under controlled conditions by growing primary and secondary phase cultures of the fungus separately and also with callus cultures and with cell suspensions. Both primary and secondary phase mycelium reduced growth of callus cultures by about 47% after one week compared with the controls. However, cell suspensions containing primary phase mycelium showed initial growth double that of the uninfected controls after 5 days, but then growth was reduced below that of the control and particularly when the primary phase became secondary phase mycelium. This change in fungal development coincided with the time that the cell culture reached the stationary growth stage. Cell cultures inoculated with stationary phase mycelium showed the same growth as the control after 5 days but then growth was reduced to 50% of the control after 19 days incubation and remained at this low level subsequently. The inhibitory effect of secondary phase mycelium was examined by incubating callus and cell suspensions with culture filtrate from liquid cultures of the secondary phase. Inclusion of 50% by volume of culture filtrate from the secondary phase in the growth medium for callus and cell suspensions, respectively, resulted in a reduction in growth of the plant tissue cultures. Addition of fungal culture filtrates also led to loss in potassium and loss of viability of cell suspensions and of isolated cells as represented by protoplasts. The necrotrophic mode of the secondary phase may be achieved through the production of phytotoxins acting on the host cell membrane.     

Production and Germination of Conidia of Trichoderma stromaticum, a Mycoparasite of Crinipellis perniciosa on Cacao

ABSTRACT Growth characteristics of the fungus Trichoderma stromaticum, a mycoparasite on the mycelium and fruiting bodies of Crinipellis perniciosa, the causal agent of witches'-broom disease of cacao, were evaluated under controlled environmental conditions. The ability of T. stromaticum to produce conidia and germinate on dry brooms was evaluated at three constant temperatures (20, 25, and 30 degrees C) and two constant relative humidities (75 and 100%). T. stromaticum produced abundant conidia on brooms at 100% relative humidity and incubation temperatures of 20 and 25 degrees C, but none at 30 degrees C. Sporulation of T. stromaticum was not observed at 75% relative humidity at any temperature. At 100% relative humidity and either at 20 or 25 degrees C, treatment of brooms with T. stromaticum suppressed C. perniciosa within 7 days. In contrast, at 30 degrees C, treatment with T. stromaticum had no effect on the pathogen in brooms maintained at either 75 or 100% relative humidity. Mycelium of C. perniciosa grew from brooms at all temperatures at 100% relative humidity. Conidial germination on broom tissue approximated 80% at temperatures from 20 to 30 degrees C. Results suggest that applying T. stromaticum under high-moisture conditions when the air temperature is below 30 degrees C may enhance the establishment of this mycoparasite in cacao plantations.     

A qualitative host-pathogen interaction in the Theobroma cacao-Moniliophthora perniciosa pathosystem

The aim of this study was to test whether resistance of clones of Theobroma cacao (cocoa) varied between isolates of Moniliophthora (formerly Crinipellis ) perniciosa , the cause of witches' broom disease. Developing buds of vegetatively propagated T. cacao grown in greenhouses in the UK were inoculated with 16 000 spores of M. perniciosa per meristem in water, under conditions where water condensed on the inoculated shoot for at least 12 h after inoculation. The proportion of successful inoculations varied between clones and was inversely correlated with time to symptom production or broom formation. A specific interaction was demonstrated among three single-spore isolates of M. perniciosa and the clone Scavina 6 (SCA 6) and a variety of susceptible clones. Isolates Castenhal-I and APC3 were equally likely to infect SCA 6 and the other clones, but isolate Gran Couva A9 never infected SCA 6, although it was as virulent on the other clones. The interaction was maintained when the wetness period was extended to 70 h. Offspring of SCA 6 × Amelonado matings were all susceptible to both Castenhal-I and GC-A5, with no evidence of greater variability in susceptibility to GC-A5 than Castanhal-I. This suggests recessive inheritance of a single homozygous factor conferring resistance to GC-A5, from SCA 6. The progenies were slightly more susceptible to Castanhal-I than GC-A5. The implications for managing the disease are discussed.     

Relationships Between Black Pod and Witches'-Broom Diseases in Theobroma cacao

ABSTRACT Field observations were conducted from 1998 to 2001 at the International Cocoa Genebank, Trinidad, to evaluate 57 cacao clones for resistance to black pod (BP) and witches'-broom (WB) diseases (caused by Phytophthora sp. and Crinipellis perniciosa, respectively). Each month ripe pods were harvested and the number of healthy and diseased was recorded. The number of brooms on vegetative shoots was recorded three times a year on selected branches. Twenty-three clones showed less than 10% of infection for both BP and WB on pods. Among those, eight clones showed an absence of brooms on the observed branches: IMC 6, MAN 15/60 [BRA], PA 67 [PER], PA 195 [PER], PA 218 [PER], PA 296 [PER], PA 303 [PER], and POUND 32/A [POU]. Broad-sense heritability was estimated at 0.38 and 0.57 for WB disease on pods and shoots, respectively, and at 0.51 for BP disease. Genetic correlation between WB disease on pods and on shoots was low and estimated at 0.39, whereas the correlation between WB and BP diseases on pods was 0.48. To choose putative parents for breeding schemes, it is suggested that clones are first assessed for their level of resistance to WB on shoots, and the most promising individuals are screened for BP with a detached pods test. Further studies are needed to confirm whether the level of resistance to WB on pods can be predicted using an early test on seedlings.     

Factors influencing the production of basidiocarps and the deposition and germination of basidiospores of Crinipellis perniciosa, the causal fungus of witches' broom on cocoa (Theobroma cacao)

The production of basidiocarps by Crinipellis perniciosa on detached, dead witches'brooms from cocoa was assessed in relation to temperature, light, cocoa clone, age of broom and type of tissue, in cabinets with a daily cycle of 8 h wet and 16 h dry. More basidiocarps formed and matured at 20–25°C than at 25–30°C. In the latter regime the pilei were smaller and white, instead of the usual crimson colour, and the stipes were longer. No basidiocarps formed at 30–35°C. At 20–25°C. more basidiocarps formed and matured with light at 100 μE m^-2 s^-1 during the wet period than at 10 μE m^-2 s ^-1. Only one basidiocarp and five primordia developed on 20 brooms kept in the dark. Brooms from 10 cocoa clones at Pichilingue. Ecuador, differed in basidiocarp productivity. most basidiocarps forming on brooms from Seavina and least on ICS clones. The numbers of basidiocarps produced on brooms aged 1.2.3 or 4 months when detached from cocoa trees were similar but time to initiation of the first primordium differed considerably. More basidiocarps formed at nodes than internodes.
The discharge of basidiospores was optimal at 20–25°C and 80% RH: germination was optimal in water agar films. Neither process was dependent on light.     

Witches' broom disease on cocoa in Rondonia, Brazil: basidiocarp production on detached brooms in the field

Fruiting of Crinipellis perniciosa was assessed in relation to various climatic factors using dead witches' brooms detached from cocoa, either suspended in the canopy or laid on leaf litter under cocoa. Induction of basidiocarp production occurred over approximately 60 days with rain. Basidiocarps were finally observed on about 85% of brooms in all samples examined and induction of fruiting required at least 17 rainy days, although brooms with a minimum age of 2 years produced basidiocarps about 25 days before brooms with a minimum age of 1 year. Groups of brooms showed distinct cycles of basidiocarp production, and up to 50% of fruiting occurred on dead, attached leaves, Fruiting was reduced on brooms on leaf litter and basidiocarps survived for less time than when brooms were suspended in canopy. Brooms were most productive with moderate amounts of wetness per day, and less than 4 h or more than 20h was inhibitory. No fruiting occurred at mean air temperatures higher than 30°C or lower than 20°C. The microclimate of the litter layer is discussed in relation to reduction of fruiting caused by pruning of brooms.     

Witches' broom disease of cocoa in Rondonia, Brazil: infection of vegetative flushes and flower cushions in relation to host phenology

Formation of vegetative brooms and cushion infections were assessed in relation to host phenology and fructification of Crinipellis perniciosa over 2 years. Vegetative growth occurred in distinct periods or'flushes'based on an endogenous cycle of 8 weeks. Correlation analysis showed that growth patterns of the sample trees were very similar. There were four main flushes in 1984, three in 1985, and the first two in each year coincided with periods of fruiting of the fungus. Total yearly infection increased from 13% in 1984 to 32% in 1985 when there were more periods considered suitable for infection and production of basidiocarps. Many infections on young vegetative tissue produced more than one hypertrophied shoot (broom) and 11 new infections were produced from every fruiting broom in 1984 compared with 3.2 in 1985. The total number of vegetative brooms increased from about 160 per tree in September 1983 to about 650 in September 1985, despite natural broom loss of 68% every 12 months. Infection of flower buds (cushions) was related to flowering intensity and periodicity, and a small proportion of infected cushions produced brooms. The implications of these results are discussed in relation to methods of control.     

Genetic and Biological Diversity of Trichoderma stromaticum, a Mycoparasite of the Cacao Witches'-Broom Pathogen

ABSTRACT The witches'-broom disease, caused by the basidiomycete Crinipellis perniciosa, is the most limiting factor for cacao cultivation in Brazil. Trichoderma stromaticum is a mycoparasite of the witches'-broom pathogen of cacao that is currently being applied in the field to manage the disease in Bahia State, Brazil. In this work, molecular and traditional methods were used to study the genetic and biological diversity of this mycoparasite. Ninety-one isolates, mostly collected from farms not sprayed with the fungus, were analyzed by amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP), which showed that two genetic groups (I and II) of T. stromaticum occur in Bahia State. This classification of T. stromaticum into two distinct AFLP groups was also in agreement with several other characteristics, including growth on agar media at different temperatures and sporulation on infected stem segments (broom pieces) and rice grains. Group II favors higher temperatures compared with group I. The genetic and biological differences of the isolates, however, were not evident in field experiments, where sporulation was evaluated on the surface of brooms under natural conditions. Our results show that there is considerable genetic and biological diversity within T. stromaticum in Bahia and other cacao-growing regions of South America that are affected by the witches'-broom disease. This diversity could be explored in the development of efficient biological control agents against the disease. Factors that may affect the application and performance of this biocontrol agent in the field, such as sporulation on rice substrate and on the brooms and growth at various temperatures, are discussed.     

Dual culture ofCrinipellis perniciosa and potato callus

Inoculation of potato callus cultures with basidiospores of the cocoa pathogenCrinipellis perniciosa resulted in the development of a mycelium which was morphologically identical to that found in green cocoa brooms. These dual cultures could be maintained for periods of several months. The nuclear condition of this mycelium was found to be variable, in contrast to previous reports. Basidiospores of the L-biotype ofC. perniciosa were also able to form dual cultures, although a biotrophic phase in its life cycle has yet to be demonstratedin vivo. Attempts to form stable heterokaryons between genetically distinct biotrophic mycelia were unsuccessful.     

Comparison of Crinipellis perniciosa isolates from Brazil by ERIC repetitive element sequence-based PCR genomic fingerprinting

Fifty isolates of Crinipellis perniciosa originating from Theobroma cacao , Heteropterys acutifolia and Solanum lycocarpum , from six states within Brazil, were characterized through ERIC-PCR, representing the first application of this method for molecular characterization within C. perniciosa . Phenetic analysis of banding patterns revealed a separation of isolates on the basis of host of origin, with T. cacao -derived isolates showing only a 0·2 similarity level to a cluster comprising the isolates from H. acutifolia and S. lycocarpum . Considerable intraspecific variability was observed within C. perniciosa isolates from T. cacao , with distinct groups observed correlating with geographical origin. Given that a number of isolates from T. cacao from the Amazon region grouped with isolates from Bahia state, this work discusses the possibility that current C. perniciosa populations pathogenic on T. cacao in Bahia originated from the Amazon region, rather than from alternative host plants.     

Variations in isolates of Mycogone perniciosa and in disease symptoms in Agaricus bisporus

Eight isolates of Mycogone perniciosa , five from Agaricus bisporus and three from Agaricus arvensis , were studied. One isolate of Mycogone rosae was also included. Aleuriospore and phialospore morphology varied among the isolates as did other characteristics, but M. rosae was the only isolate to produce a red colouration of the medium. Growth was also variable, with three isolates of M. pemiciosa growing at about half the rate of the fastest. The slow-growing isolates contained virus-like particles, 36 nm diameter, and produced sclerodermoid mushrooms. The fast-growing isolates did not contain virus-like particles and caused cap spotting, a symptom not previously described for M. perniciosa. M. rosae produced characteristic cap spots and no scierodermoid mushrooms. A comparison of two isolates of St. perniciosa. one from A. bisporus and one from A arvensis , showed a much greater yield reduction as a result of symptoms caused by the isolate from A. bisporus. The isolate of M. rosae had no significant effect on yield.
Restriction fragment banding patterns of ribosomal DNA showed no differences among the seven isolates of M. perniciosa from England, but the isolate from China was slightly different. The single isolate of M. rosae was distinct from M. perniciosa.     

Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis of Crinipellis perniciosa isolates from different hosts

DNA sequence polymorphisms among isolates of Crinipellis perniciosa , causing witches' broom disease in several genera and species in the Sterculiaceae, Solanaceae and Bixaceae, were revealed by random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) banding patterns. Comparisons were made among isolates from Theobroma cacao (cultivars SCA6 and SVB), T. grandiflorum, T. obovatum, T. subincanum, Herrania sp. (all collected near Belém, Brazil, at three plots within two kilometres of each other), and Bixa orellana and Solanum rugosum (150 and 1440 km from Belém, respectively). Genetic similarities, as determined by Sorensen's coefficient ( Sc_ij ; fraction of shared bands), ranged from 1·00 ( T. cacao SCA6 and T. grandiflorum ) to 0·56 ( S. rugosum and T. subincanum). Results indicate that proximity is more important than host species for determining the genetic relationships among isolates, that there were two independent sources of inoculum at the site near Belém, and that the isolate from B. orellana is most closely related to the isolate from T. cacao SVB. Comparisons were also made among multispore cultures from different basidiocarps on the same T. cacao SVB broom, as well as monospore cultures from the same S. rugosum basidiocarp. Banding patterns were similar among basidiocarps on the same broom, but differences were detected among monospore cultures from the same basidiocarp.     

Induction of resistance in cocoa against Crinipellis perniciosa and Verticillium dahliae by acibenzolar- S-methyl (ASM)

The benzothiadiazole compound acibenzolar- S -methyl (ASM) was assessed as an inducer of resistance against Crinipellis perniciosa , agent of witches' broom, and Verticillium dahliae , agent of vascular wilt, both on cocoa. ASM induced a reduction in incidence of witches' broom of up to 84·5% when sprayed 30 days before inoculation on cocoa seedlings of cv. Catongo. ASM also induced a reduction in severity of Verticillium wilt to 55·4% on cv. Theobahia. For both pathosystems, effects of dose on disease were not clearly observed. The efficacy of the inducer increased with the interval between sprayings and the respective inoculations with the pathogens. In another experiment, the effect of ASM on the control of witches' broom on cocoa seedlings was compared with that of cuprous oxide and tebuconazole, all sprayed 15 days before inoculation. ASM reduced disease incidence by 60·1% compared with the inoculated control. ASM was superior to tebuconazole, and there was also a tendency for ASM to be better than cuprous oxide. To understand the mechanism of action of ASM as an inducer of resistance, alterations in the levels of total phenolics, polyphenol oxidases and peroxidases were evaluated 3, 15 and 30 days after spraying of seedlings of cv. Catongo. Enzyme activities from seedlings of cv. Theobahia were evaluated 30 days after spraying. On cv. Catongo, no significant differences in total phenolic content and polyphenol oxidase activity were detected after spraying. However, an increase in peroxidase activity was detected at all times of evaluation. On cv. Theobahia, significant increases in activities of peroxidase and polyphenol oxidase were detected, indicating that defence responses due to ASM were dependent on host genotype.     

Canopy-microclimate effects on the antagonism between Trichoderma stromaticum and Moniliophthora perniciosa in shaded cacao

The collective impact of several environmental factors on the biocontrol activity of Trichoderma stromaticum ( Ts ) against Moniliophthora perniciosa ( Mp ), the cause of cacao witches' broom disease, was assessed under field conditions of shaded cacao ( Theobroma cacao ) in south-eastern Bahia, Brazil. Biocontrol experiments were performed adjacent to an automated weather station, with sensors and Ts -treated brooms placed at different canopy heights. Sporulation occurred at the same dates for all Ts isolates, but in different quantities. Broom moisture >30%, air temperature of approximately 23 ± 3°C, relative humidity >90%, solar radiation intensities <0·12 KW m⁻² and wind speed near zero were the key environmental parameters that preceded Ts sporulation events. A multiple logistic regression indicated that these weather variables combined were capable of distinguishing sporulation from non-sporulation events, with a significant effect of wind speed. Analyses of environmental factors at ground level indicated similar pre-sporulation conditions, with a soil moisture content above a threshold of 0·34 m³ m⁻³ preceding all sporulation events. The sporulation of five selected Ts isolates was compared at four different canopy heights. Isolates responded differently to weather variation in terms of sporulation and antagonism to Mp at different canopy levels, indicating that different microclimates are established along the vertical profile of a shaded cacao plantation. The potential of these findings for development of predictive mathematical models and disease-management approaches is discussed.     

Discovery of the Eucalyptus canker pathogen Chrysoporthe cubensis on native Miconia (Melastomataceae) in Colombia

Chrysoporthe cubensis is one of the most serious canker pathogens on commercially grown Eucalyptus species in the tropics and subtropics. During recent surveys for native hosts of C. cubensis in Colombia, fungi with fruiting structures similar to those of C. cubensis were found on native Miconia theaezans and Miconia rubiginosa , both members of the Melastomataceae. These fungi were identified based on morphology and DNA sequences of the ITS1/ITS2 region of the rDNA operon and the β-tubulin genes. The majority of isolates from M. theaezans and M. rubiginosa grouped together with South American C. cubensis isolates from Eucalyptus species and Syzygium aromaticum (clove). However, some of the isolates from M. theaezans grouped with isolates of Chrysoporthella hodgesiana , another anamorph species linked to Chrysoporthe , from Tibouchina spp. in Colombia. Pathogenicity of these fungi was assessed on various Melastomataceae. Miconia rubiginosa was more susceptible to infection by C. cubensis than two Eucalyptus clones . Isolates of C. cubensis and Chrysop. hodgesiana were mildly pathogenic on the various hosts included in the pathogenicity trials, and most pathogenic on Tibouchina urvilleana and Tibouchina lepidota .     

Molecular Fingerprinting Suggests Two Primary Outbreaks of Witches' Broom Disease (Crinipellis perniciosa) of Theobroma cacao in Bahia, Brazil

Crinipellis perniciosa (Stahel) Singer is the causal agent of witches' broom disease in the Sterculiaceae, Solanaceae, and Bixaceae families. The disease is endemic to the Brazilian Amazon, and was first reported infecting Theobroma cacao (cocoa) in the State of Bahia, Brazil, in 1989. Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analyses were performed on 46 isolates of C. perniciosa from cocoa that were collected from 15 counties in Bahia and the Brazilian Amazon. A total of 258 RAPD loci from 20 primers and three mixed primers were analyzed. Of these loci, 108 (42%) were polymorphic, with an average of 4.7 polymorphic loci per primer produced. Genetic similarities were estimated using Nei and Li's index and UPGMA clustering. Bootstrap analysis divided the phenogram into four significantly different clusters: two groups contained isolates from Ariquemes and from Ouro Preto, Rondônia, and the other two separated the isolates from Bahia into two major groups of C. perniciosa, classified as Group 1 (G1) and Group 2 (G2). The two groups of isolates from Bahia differed for their genetic similarity with the isolates from the Brazilian Amazon. The geographic distribution of the groups in Bahia suggests two independent focal points of introduction. Ongoing programs to screen for resistant cocoa genotypes should consider both groups of isolates.     

Sensitivity of Crinipellis perniciosa to two triazole fungicides in vitro and their effect on development of the fungus in cocoa

Two triazole fungicides, hexaconazole and triadimenol, were evaluated for their effects on the growth of Crinipellis perniciosa in vitro, and for their ability to prevent broom formation on cocoa seedlings. Amounts of both fungicides required to reduce fungal growth, germ tube extension and basidiospore germination by 50% were found respectively to be less than 1, 10-150 and more than 200 mg/l. Reductions in germ tube length were associated with slower rates of cell growth, whereas growth of dikaryotic mycelium was reduced due to shorter cell lengths. Isolates of C. perniciosa showed different sensitivities to the fungicides, variation between collections from different localities being greater than between collections from the same locality. Hexaconazole gave good control of the disease applied as a spray to cocoa seedlings both before and after inoculation. Triadimenol showed good activity when used as a preinoculation soil drench and in some treatments where plants became infected no necrosis of host tissue was observed. Activity was greatly reduced by drench treatments applied 10 days after inoculation, and most infected plants formed necrotic cankers.     

Changes in morphology and measurement of cytokinin levels during the development of witches' brooms on cocoa

The anatomy of diseased stems from brooms induced on cocoa ( Theobroma cacao ) by the fungus Crinipellis perniciosa was examined using the scanning electron microscope, and the amounts of selected cytokinins were measured by immunoassay.
Although the diseased stems were wider in diameter with a lower dry weight:fresh weight ratio than stems of healthy plants, the overall internal organization of tissues remained unchanged, and all the cell types were present. However, the vascular tissue was less differentiated in diseased stems since xylem vessels were absent and the ratio of phloem fibres and sieve tubes to phloem parenchyma was reduced. Cell sizes in diseased stems were larger for all tissues but cell numbers were unchanged except for xylem where fewer cells were seen.
Cytokinins (zeatin, zeatin riboside, isopentenyl adenine and isopentenyl adenosine) were measured in healthy plants and diseased stems at specific stages of disease development. Of these cytokinins only zeatin riboside was present in significantly greater amounts in diseased tissue. The likely role of plant growth regulator balance in stem enlargement and proliferation in witches' broom disease of cocoa is discussed.