Genetics of resistance to 3 isolates of Ascochyta fabae on Faba bean (Vicia faba L.) in controlled conditions

Summary Genetics of resistance to Ascochyta fabae Speg. in Vicia faba L. was studied with a final objective to develop resistant faba bean varieties to Ascochyta blight. The study was conducted separately on 3 single spore isolates (AF10-2 and AF13-2 from Tunisia and AF4-3 from France) and belonging to different groups of virulence (GV1 and GV2). Important general combining ability (GCA) effects were found especially with isolates AF10-2 and AF4-3. Specific combining ability (SCA), although significant for the 3 isolates, was important only with AF13 -2, but less important than GCA. Additive gene effects were predominant to non-additive effects. Lines 29H and A8817 transmitted to their progenies resistance to the 3 isolates, whereas 14–12 and 19TB conferred resistance to their progenies only with isolates AF13-2 and AF4-3, respectively. In the material studied, resistance was generally controlled by dominant genes but also could be attributed to recessive genes although less frequent. Analysis of segregation in the F2 of 2 crosses between the resistant lines (A8817 and 29H) and the susceptible line (14–12) with isolate AF4-3 revealed dominant monogenic control at the level of leaves in the 2 resistant lines and, in addition, a recessive gene controlling resistance of stems. Non-allelic interactions were occasionally manifested and their origin appeared to be due to line 19TB. A recurrent selection scheme was proposed with the objective to develop improved open-pollination populations and synthetic varieties responding to the objective of the national Tunisian research programme on faba bean.     

Identification of resistance to Ascochyta fabae in Vicia faba germplasm

A total of 752 faba bean accessions were screened under field conditions for resistance to Ascochyta fabae. Several methods of assessing disease development were compared for evaluating the resistance of these accessions. Thirty‐four accessions displayed low disease severity ratings. In 15 of them, lesions were restricted in size and number, whereas in the remaining 19, lesions were well developed but scarce. These lines could have been discarded if screening had depended only on scales based on lesion type, which shows the need to complement such scores with disease severity or to use a simplified scale that integrates both lesion type and the amount of damage.     

Evaluation of a collection of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) genotypes originating from the Maghreb for resistance to chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae) by assessment in the field and laboratory

Screening of 136 faba bean lines forresistance to chocolate spot caused by thefungus Botrytis fabae was conductedin field conditions with artificialinoculation. Detached leaves of thesegenotypes were also assessed for diseaseseverity after inoculation under controlledconditions with a B. fabaesuspension. The BPL710 and Aguadulcegenotypes were inserted as resistant andsusceptible checks, respectively. Diseasesymptoms were scored visually in bothexperiments. Diameter of lesions andproduction of spores were measured in thedetached leaf assay. The disease scoreindex and diameter of lesions were used tocalculate the area under the diseaseprogress curve (AUDPC) to measure thedisease progress. Significant differenceswere detected among genotypes for reactionto the disease in the field. However, nocomplete resistance was observed. Forhighly susceptible and highly resistantgenotypes, the laboratory assay generallyled to the same result as the field test,nevertheless, for more intermediate levelsthe agreement was weak. On detached leaves,diameter of lesions was significantlycorrelated to the AUDPC of disease scores(r = 0.89) and moderately correlated tosporulation (r = 0.52). The correlationbetween field AUDPC and detached leaf AUDPCof disease scores was low (r = 0.26). A lowcorrelation was also observed between fieldAUDPC and lesion size (r = 0.30) andbetween field AUDPC and sporulation (r =0.32). Among the 136 genotypes evaluated inthis study, nine were convincingly andhighly resistant in both tests. FRYM167 andFRYA58 genotypes were the most resistantwith low AUDPC of disease scores, low AUDPCof lesion diameter and low sporeproduction. These genotypes obviously havepartial resistance.     

Identification of segregation-distortion-neutral alleles to improve pollen fertility of indica-japonica hybrids in rice (Oryza sativa L.)

The genetics of resistance to Ascochyta blight (Ascochyta fabae f. sp. fabae) was studied in two populations of faba bean (Vicia faba). Plants of a resistant population, ILB 752, and a susceptible one, NEB 463, were screened for their reaction to the pathogen and the results were quantified on a scale of 0–5. Crosses were made between plants both within and between accessions and the F₁ and F₂ generations assessed in a field trial 21 and 45 days after inoculation. Disease scores were greater at 45 days than at 21 days and they were not significantly affected by the presence of susceptible spreader rows in part of the trial. ILB 752 carried a major dominant gene conferring resistance while NEB 463 carried the recessive allele for susceptibility. Furthermore, a minority of plants of NEB 463 appeared to carry at least one pair of complementary recessive genes, also conferring resistance. Most of the plants of ILB 752 were homozygous for the dominant resistance gene and a few were heterozygous. Reciprocal crosses behaved identically, indicating the absence of maternal effects in the expression of Ascochyta blight resistance in faba beans. The results show that it is important to confirm the level of heterozygosity for the resistance genes in this partially outbreeding species before crossing is commenced. The major dominant gene for resistance, identified in ILB 752, has clear potential for use in breeding for Ascochyta blight resistance. The minor genes identified in NEB 463 also show the potential for accumulating resistance through mass selection. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Evaluating faba beans for rust resistance using detached leaves

A method was developed for testing detached leavesof faba beans for their response to rust disease.Leaves 5 to 8, counting from the shoot tip, wereexcised and maintained on a water-retaining medium,with 5 ppm gibberellic acid, in an enclosed box in atemperature-controlled glasshouse. Leaves treated inthis way remained in good health for up to 30 days.Rust spores were dispersed in a slurry of talc andwater and applied to the abaxial leaf surface. Diseasedevelopment of seven rust populations, collected fromseveral locations in eastern Australia, was monitoredfor 15 days on eight faba bean accessions. Fouraccessions were BPL lines which ICARDA claimed to havesome resistance, two were ILB lines from ICARDA whichhad been found to have stronger field resistance innorthern New South Wales, Australia, and the remainingtwo were known susceptibles. The detached-leaf testshowed that the two cultivars were susceptible, thefour BPL lines were intermediate and ILB 3107 and ILB3025 were slow-rusting. One rust population, which hadbeen stored under liquid nitrogen for several years,was less effective at inducing disease symptoms thanthe other six, which were all freshly collected. Theinteractions between host accessions and rustpopulations were statistically significant but minor,as the cultivars remained in their categories ofresistance or susceptibility. The detached-leaftechnique is thus suitable for use in screeningindividual plants for reaction to several differentpathogen species or genotypes without danger ofcross-contamination or induced resistance.     

Extent, variation and breeding impact of natural cross-fertilization in German winter faba beans using hilum colour as marker

Faba bean is a partially allogamous grain legume, mostly sown as spring crop in Central Europe, and in few mild coastal areas of UK and France as a winter crop. A population with a genetically wide base, conceived and selected for superior winter hardiness showing promise as winter crop in Germany was evaluated. The reproductive behaviour of this population was evaluated for its degree of cross-fertilization at five German environments (1999–2001), and inbred lines bred from it, plus one F1 bulk and further checks, were assessed for variation in cross-fertilization at three German environments (2001). Seed hilum colour, a dominant-recessive, biallelic locus, was used as a morphological marker. Cross-fertilization (population mean value of 60%) was shown to be higher than in spring faba beans and was environmentally influenced. Genetic variation was demonstrated, heritability was high (h²= 0.75), and heterosis was negative. Inbred lines with a cross-fertilization of 70% can be easily bred. Breeding synthetic cultivars is recommended, their optimum number of components is expected to be higher than the optimum recommended for spring faba beans. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The identification of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) trisomics by translocation tester set

Summary Five subtelocentric primary trisomics of Vicia faba L. were isolated from crosses between asynaptic mutants and normal plants or translocation tester stocks. The extra chromosome of each trisomic was identified cytologically by critical multivalent association at metaphase I of meiosis.     

Comparison of some selection procedures and objectives in faba beans (Vicia faba L.). II. Selection for crude protein content

Summary Starting with two heterogeneous F₂ populations, each based on 20 cross combinations, different types of selection were applied for four consecutive selection cycles. Three of the selection procedures involved crude protein content (CP) and are presented in this paper. They were selection for high CP (HP), selection for low CP (LP) and independent culling levels selection for high CP and an index for seed yield per plant (ICL). For ICL-selection the attention is focussed on CP in this paper.For all three selection procedures, predicted and realized responses were calculated and expressed as percentage of a corresponding random population. The selection intensities (i) differed over selection procedures and generations. Differences in i between HP and LP within generations were mostly of minor interest. The response to HP-selection was slightly higher than to ICL-selection, but this may be due to the higher selection intensity exerted with the former method.HP-and LP-selection showed some remarkable differences, which were interpreted as a tendency towards partial dominance of high over low protein content. The total response to HP-selection gradually increased, whereas LP-selection yielded the total response largely after only one cycle of selection. The predicted response showed a tendency towards overestimation in the case of HP-selection and to underestimation in the case of LP-selection.Selection for high protein yield through CP seems to be feasible, although improvement of yield stability may eventually be more necessary. As no consistent correlation, either positive or negative, between SYP and CP could be detected, selection for either of these characters may be considerd independently of selection for the other one.     

Controls over pollination and ovule fertilization in Vicia faba

Summary Variation in the frequencies of pollination and ovule fertilization was generated among faba bean (Vicia faba L.) genotypes in experiments which compared self-and open-pollination, natural and extended photoperiods, presence and absence of honey bees and a range of plant populations.There was a near-1:1 relationship between the frequencies of pollination of stigmas and the fertilization of at least one ovule within the pistil. Pollination was the major barrier to fertilization of the pistil, and ovules, since no mechanism was evident in the style to prevent pistil fertilization. The frequency with which single ovules were fertilized in pollinated pistils fell as their distance from the stigma increased, and averaged 83.5% overall.The frequency of pollination was most influenced by the level of autofertility possessed by the genotype, and the activity of pollinators. Provision of honey bees to plants in caged plots showed that high levels of pollination could be achieved under open-pollinated conditions, but this was also influenced by autofertility. Increasing plant population in the field had only a small effect on pollination, but extending photoperiod caused the levels and timing of self-pollination in three genotypes to vary.Large differences were found among genotypes in their early stigma receptivity, that is, the frequency of stigmas found to be pollinated at the erect standard stage, prior to the flower opening and being visited by bees. The implications of early stigma receptivity for producing new cultivars were discussed.     

Comparison of some selection procedures and objectives in faba beans (Vicia faba L.). I. direct and index selection for seed yield

Summary Starting with two heterogeneous F₂ populations, each based on 20 cross combinations, different selection procedures were applied for four consecutive selection cycles. Three of the selection procedures involved seed yield per plant (SYP): (i) direct selection for SYP (DSY); (ii) indexselection for SYP (ISY) with plant length, the ratio of the vegetative top to plant length, end of grain filling and duration of the generative stage as auxiliary characters and finally; (iii) independent culling levels selection (ICL) for the index described above and crude protein content. For ICL-selection the attention is focussed on SYP in this paper.For all three selection procedures, predicted and realized responses were calculated and expressed as percentage of a corresponding non-selected population. The intensities of selection differed over selection methods and generations, mostly due to practical constraints.As far as predicted responses are concerned, ISY-selection seemed to be slightly superior to DSY-selection and DSY-selection to ICL-selection. This order may partly be due to differences in selection intensity. However, none of the predictions was very accurate, but the predictions of ICL-selection seemed to be the most accurate. This has been ascribed also to the relative mild selection intensity applied in ICL-selection. It is concluded that a decision in favour of a complicated selection procedure like index selection based on predicted responses only cannot be defended. As far as realized responses are concerned, DSY-selection seems to be slightly superior to the other two selection procedures, as it is the only procedure that resulted in a more or less stable positive response to selection.The auxiliary characters, especially plant length, showed a marked correlated response to all three selection procedures. In case of direct selection for SYP this seemed paradoxical with the inefficiency of index selection, but, it may reflect the differences in the genuine genotypic correlations and the estimated genotypic correlations.     

A short review of research on male sterility and prospects for F1 hybrid varieties in field beans (Vicia faba L.)

Summary It has not yet been possible to utilise cytoplasmically inherited male sterility (CMS) in Vicia faba, in the commerical production of F₁ hybrids. The main problem has been a rapid increase in the proportion of fertile revertants during multiplication. Investigations, mainly in France, have clarified environmental causes of phenotypic instability, CMS and maintainer lines with improved stability have been selected, and two new cytoplasms have been produced by mutation of the first two. CMS is known to be associated with cytoplasmic spherical particles, and recognisable types of double stranded RNA, and there may also be an association with mitochondrial DNA, and polypeptides of mitochondrial origin.The better understanding of CMS may eventually lead to more easily managed forms, either through genetic manipulation or biochemical assays that breeders can use for screening for stability.     

Rate and inheritance of cross-fertilization in faba bean (Vicia faba L.)

Summary To assess the feasibility for synthetic varieties of Vicia faba L., 108 faba bean genotypes were screened for cross-fertilization rate in five field experiments carried out in 1989 and 1990 at Wageningen.Significant genotypic differences were observed for outcrossing rate, which ranged from 1 to 55%. These percentages, however, are thought to be not high enough for a commercially feasible production of synthetic varieties.The inheritance of cross-fertilization rate, determined by testing the F₄ generation of a cross between two inbreds, both with high outcrossing rates, appeared to be of a polygenic nature, as was indicated by the wide variation in, and the continous distribution of, the cross-fertilization rates. Among the F₄ lines tested some had a significantly higher cross-fertilization rate than the parents. However, this difference was not found when these lines were retested, indicating that possibilities for successful selection for higher outcrossing rates might be limited.     

Mutagenesis of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) and the identification of five different genes controlling no nodulation,ineffective nodulation or supernodulation

Summary Mutagenesis ofVicia faba L. using ethyl methanesulfonate has yielded three mutants (f13, f73, f245) with ineffective nodulation (Nod⁺Fix^–), one mutant (f48) unable to nodulate (Nod^–) and one supernodulating mutant (f32) having 3 to 5 times more nodules than the control in the absence of combined nitrogen, and expressing nitrate tolerant nodulation (Nod⁺⁺, Nts). All of the mutant phenotypes were controlled by single and distinct recessive genes designatedsyml tosym5, respectively. Grafting experiments showed that the (Nod⁺Fix^–) and (Nod^–) phenotypes were both under root genotype control and that the (Nod⁺⁺, Nts) phenotype was under shoot genotype control.     

Present status and future strategy in breeding faba beans (Vicia Faba L.) for resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses

Progress is being made, mainly by ICARDA but also elsewhere, in breeding for resistance to Botrytis, AScochyta, Uromyces, and Orobanche; and some lines have resistance to more than one pathogen. The strategy is to extend multiple resistance but also to seek new and durable forms of resistance. Internationally coordinated programs are needed to maintain the momentum of this work.Tolerance of abiotic stresses leads to types suited to dry or cold environments rather than broad adaptability, but in this cross-pollinated species, the more hybrid vigor expressed by a cultivar, the more it is likely to tolerate various stresses.     

Methods for screening resistance in chickpea to Ascochyta blight

Summary In Morocco, Ascochyta blight is a major limiting factor in chickpea production. The best long term solution to the problem seems to be the production of chickpea lines with durable resistance to the disease. Because of the nature of durable resistance, screening methods assessing resistance quantitatively had to be developed. Four methods are described: a seedling test, a germination test, a score of the percentage infected pods and a hair density score. With these screening methods a quantitative assessment of resistance in chickpea to blight appeared possible.Mr Pieters is with the FAO Plant Protection and Production division. Mr Tahiri is with the Service de Contrôle des Semences et Plants in Morocco.     

Pollination,fertilization and seed development in winter stocks of faba beans (Vicia faba L.)

Summary Incidences of pollination and fertilization were determined in five stocks of winter bean (two populations, two inbred lines, one cultivar) in two years. In the second year, irrigation was included as an experimental treatment and the development of seeds was monitored. Large differences between years were found in the measures of pollination and fertilization, and irrigation was associated with a small but significant increase in the proportion of ovules which were fertilized within fertilized flowers, particularly in the ovules furthest from the stigma. This increase was clearly reflected in the corresponding indices of seed maturation in the irrigated plants. Irrigation was not associated with any change in the proportion of ovules which aborted. Small but statistically significant differences in all of the measures of pollination and fertilization were found among the stocks. It is suggested that the variation in the incidences of pollination and fertilization was largely associated with variation in the synchrony of anthesis within racemes. The proportion of ovules within pods which matured as seeds and the proportion which aborted both varied significantly among the five stocks. Abortion appeared to act independently of fertilization in affecting the index of seed maturation, so both mechanisms should be considered when breeding for improved filling of pods.     

Inheritance of seed coat colour in broad bean (Vicia faba L.)

Summary The inheritance of the seed coat colours violet, spotted, brown, green, red, black and beige was investigated in a 10×10 diallel cross between broad bean (Vicia faba L. major) lines. Spotted seed colour was dominant over any uniform seed coat colouring. Brown was dominant over black, green and normal (beige colour). Black and red seed parents behaved as recessive in all F₁ progenies. A 3 (coloured): 1 (normal) segregation ratio was observed in the F₂ of crosses of violet, brown, black, red and spotted seed coat parents to nornal seed coloured parents. Green x beige gave a segregation ratio of 9:7 in F₂. When two parents with different seed coat colour were involved in a cross, the F₂ showed a typical digenic segregation ratio thus demonstrating two unlinked and sometimes epistatic loci.Segregation of a multiallelic series at two loci explains all segregation ratios observed for seed coat colour in broad bean.     

Variation in the crude protein content of field beans (Vicia faba L.) in relation to the possible improvement of the protein content of the crop

Summary A survey of the protein content of various field bean varieties indicates a range of variation extending over sixteen units of crude protein from 22–38%. Analysis of single plants from within three WPBS varieties Dylan. Danas and Dacre indicates that a similar range exists within commercial varieties. Examination of the progenies of high and low protein single plant selections together with a preliminary estimation of heritability suggest that protein content is highly heritable. No significant correlations were found between protein content and seed yield.     

Screening techniques and sources of resistance to foliar diseases caused by fungi and bacteria in cool season food legumes

Screening techniques are an important component of the overall strategy of breeding for resistance to diseases in cool season food legumes. Suitable screening methods have been developed for several major foliar diseases of chickpea, pea, faba bean, and lentil, and sources of resistance have been identified. International cooperation plays an important role in promoting research and keeping collections of cultivated species and their wild relatives. New biotechnological approaches are promising for enhancing the practical use of genes for resistance.     

Breeding for wide adaptation in faba bean

Summary Broadening agronomic adaptation will improve yield stability in the grain legume Vicia faba L. We gathered information on the adaptation of European and Mediterranean material to European and Mediterranean environments. The material comprised 20 inbred lines (12 European and 8 Mediterranean lines) and 99 intra- and interpool-crosses in generation F₁. These were evaluated in 9 environments: two spring-sown Southern German environments (SGermE), and seven autumn-sown Mediterranean environments (MedE) in Sicily, Puglia, Andalucia and South Africa. Standard ANOVA, stability analyses and AMMI analysis were performed. Mean yield in F₁ was 257 g/row, the overall parental mean was 144 g/row. The range of environmental means was from 94 g/row to 411 g/row. The average regression coefficient in F₁ was b _i =1.07, being significantly greater than for the parents (b _i =0.68). The opposite was true for the relative magnitude of the deviations from the regressions, which were highly correlated to the AMMI-PC1-results. The AMMI analysis clearly separated the SGermE from the MedE, as well as the germplasm pools. Though the superiority of the F₁-hybrids over their parents was striking, their pattern of interactions with the environments strictly reflected that of their parents. A number of promising crosses was identified as a nucleus of a widely adapted faba bean genepool.