Euphresco inter‐laboratory comparison (2009–2012) on detection of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus and Ralstonia solanacearum in potato tubers: proposal to include TaqMan® real‐time PCR as a primary (core) screening test in EU/EPPO standard methods

In the European Union (EU) potato production is surveyed for Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus (potato ring rot) and Ralstonia solanacearum (potato brown rot) under Commission Directives 93/85/EEC with its amendment 2006/56/EC and 98/57/EEC with its amendment 2006/63/EC. A regular update of the Directives is required in view of developments in understanding of the biology of these organisms and the diagnostics recommended for their detection and identification. Three inter‐laboratory tests (ILT1, ILT2 and ILT3) were performed from 2009 to 2012 as part of a Euphresco Phytosanitary ERA‐NET project to assess performance of current official methods for C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus and R. solanacearum. A major aim of the ILTs was to generate data on the performance of real‐time PCR protocols to support their introduction as primary (core) screening tests for both pathogens. In ILT1, 29 laboratories from 23 countries participated, in ILT2, 23 laboratories from 18 countries and in ILT3 42 laboratories from 24 countries. Relative accuracies for real‐time PCR tests averaged 92% for R. solanacearum and 96% for C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus) and compared with existing primary (core) screening tests (immunofluorescence, conventional PCR, semi‐selective plating and bioassay) in terms of analytical sensitivity, analytical specificity and robustness. It was concluded that all methods tested, including real‐time PCR, can be considered as equivalent. Therefore TaqMan ^® real‐time PCR is recommended for inclusion in EU Directives and EPPO Standards as a reliable primary (core) screening method.     

Validation of four real‐time TaqMan PCRs for the detection of Ralstonia solanacearum and/or Ralstonia pseudosolanacearum and/or Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in potato tubers using a statistical regression approach

A new DNA extraction method and a new multiplex real‐time TaqMan PCR test for detection of Ralstonia solanacearum, Ralstonia pseudosolanacearum and Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in asymptomatic potato tubers are presented. This new multiplex PCR and three published TaqMan PCRs for detection of R. solanacearum and/or R. pseudosolanacearum and/or R. syzygii spp. and/or C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus were validated using linear regression analysis for estimating the Ct values and its variation at 5 × 10³ bacteria mL^?1. The three published PCRs that have been validated are Massart et al. (2014, detecting R. solanacearum and C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus), Weller et al. (1999, detecting R. solanacearum, R. pseudosolanacearum and R. syzygii spp.) and Gudmestad et al. (2009, detecting C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus). All tested PCRs were fit for purpose for their target organisms. The PCR tests have different target genes, allowing one of the sets to be used as first screening test and another as second screening test for the detection of R. solanacearum and/or R. pseudosolanacearum and/or C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in asymptomatic potato tubers.     

Detection of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in Potato Tubers by Multiplex PCR with Coamplification of Host DNA

A new multiplex PCR assay was developed for the detection of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in potato tubers. The assay combines two different tests in one reaction mixture. First, a highly specific and sensitive detection of the pathogen and second, an indicator test for successful amplification (internal PCR control), which monitors potentially false-negative PCR results, caused by inhibition of the PCR. For the simultaneous amplification of two different targets in one reaction mixture, a mix of two different primer sets was used. For the detection of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus, a pathogen-specific primer set PSA-1/PSA-R was used, based on the intergenic spacer region of the 16S–23S rRNA genes of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus. For the simultaneous amplification of the internal PCR control, the plant-specific primer set NS-7-F/NS-8-R was employed, permitting amplification of target sequence from plant DNA present in DNA extractions from potato core fluid. The applicability of the multiplex PCR was verified in 3500 composite samples of 200 seed potato tubers from 143 different cultivars in a survey for C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus by parallel testing using immunofluorescence, a bioassay in eggplant seedlings and multiplex PCR.     

Test performance study for detection of Ralstonia solanacearum and Clavibacter sepedonicus in potato tubers with TaqMan PCR

A test performance study (TPS) was organized in 2018 with ten official testing laboratories to evaluate the performance of different real-time PCR tests for the detection of Clavibacter sepedonicus and/or Ralstonia solanacearum in potato tubers. Participants were sent spiked potato extracts with low (0.8–1.2 × 10⁴ cfu mL^-1), medium (1.6–2.4 × 10⁵ cfu mL^-1) and high (1.6–2.4 × 10⁷ cfu mL^-1) bacterial loads, DNA extracts thereof and heel-end cores from symptomatic potato tubers. The four real-time PCR tests in this TPS for detection of C. sepedonicus were considered fit for purpose as principal screening methods. Two real-time PCRs in this TPS were considered fit for purpose as principal screening methods for detection of R. solanacearum. A third real-time PCR missed 23% of the DNA samples from low-level R. solanacearum spikes and is considered not fit for purpose as a principal screening method. Correct identification of spiked samples was lower when DNA extraction from the spiked samples was performed by the participating laboratories, highlighting the importance of appropriate DNA extraction protocols.     

False positive Ralstonia solanacearum real‐time PCR results in routine potato tuber samples caused by Advenella species: adaptations to avoid these cross‐reactions

Several real‐time PCR tests for the detection of Ralstonia solanacearum have been developed in recent years. Only the RS primer‐probe system, developed by Weller et al., detects all phylotypes of R. solanacearum in one test. The Saxon State Company for Environment and Agriculture (BfUL) has been using this real‐time PCR test since 2012 for routine testing of potato samples for R. solanacearum. Since the introduction of this test in the laboratory, samples were analysed which were suspected to be false positives [as they gave negative results in other standard tests of the European Union (EU) Commission Directive 2006/63/EC]. Advenella kashmirensis was identified as the cause of selected false positive samples. Inclusion of the three other known Advenella species revealed that this genus could be responsible for false positive results. Because of the rising number of these cases over the last years, two different modifications of the original test from Weller et al. were evaluated independently. It was possible to reduce false positive events, caused by Advenella species by 95% in retested potato tuber samples by using a shortened RS‐primer set in the first adaption of the RS primer‐probe system of Weller et al. The combination of the original RS primer‐set, published by Weller et al., with the RSP‐55T MGB‐probe, published recently in Vreeburg et al., in a second adaption, eliminated false positive events completely.     

Evaluation of the API 50CH and API ZYM systems for rapid characterization of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus, causal agent of potato ring rot

API 50CH and API ZYM systems were used to characterize fifty-three strains of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus from different geographic locations and several reference strains of the same and different species, including other potato pathogens. Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus strains displayed a high level of homogeneity, both in carbohydrate utilization and in enzymatic activity. Using API 50CH and API ZYM it was possible to differentiate C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus strains from the remaining taxa analysed in this study, which included representative strains of the other subspecies of C. michiganensis as well as other bacterial pathogens affecting potatoes. Therefore, these systems could be used as an effective method to characterize C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus. Such a procedure would constitute an alternative system to the conventional nutritional and physiological identification tests currently included in the official methods employed in the European Union to detect and identify this bacterium. The results obtained with the API systems agreed with the current taxonomic classification of C. michiganensis, clearly separating sepedonicus from the other subspecies belonging to this species.     

Evaluation of a diagnostic microarray for the detection of major bacterial pathogens of potato from tuber samples

Potato can be infected with many bacterial pathogens, the detection of which is necessary in seed certification. In this study, a diagnostic microarray previously tested for specificity of probes for detecting the potato bacteria causing blackleg and soft rot (Pectobacterium atrosepticum, Pectobacterium carotovorum, and Dickeya spp.), ring rot (Clavibacter. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus), scab (Streptomyces scabies and Streptomyces turgidiscabies) and brown rot (Ralstonia solanacearum) from pure culture was evaluated for analytical sensitivity when testing directly from tuber samples. The microarray readily detected all the bacterial species when 100 ng of the target bacterial DNA from pure culture was mixed with DNA from soil microbes and potato. However, detection was inconsistent when total DNA isolated directly from infected tubers or enriched bacterial culture was used. While the high specificity of the probes could be confirmed from the results of the DNA cocktail experiment used as a control, the study demonstrated that the level of analytical sensitivity of the microarray under the tested condition was not sufficient to detect bacteria directly from tubers. Therefore, in addition to the cost and organizational complexities, the low analytical sensitivity and limited reproducibility of the microarray are constraints for establishing the platform for routine detection of potato bacterial pathogens from tuber samples.     

Development of the simultaneous detection of Ralstonia solanacearum race 3 and Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in potato tubers by a multiplex real-time PCR assay

Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus and Ralstonia solanacearum (Smith) Yabuuchi et al. race 3 are the causal agents of ring-rot and brown-rot of potato respectively. These diseases represent a serious threat to potato production in temperate climates. Both bacteria are listed as A2 pests in the EPPO region and as zero-tolerance quarantine organisms in the European Union. All the detection tests developed so far were only focused on the detection of a single pathogen while the absence of both bacteria has to be certified in the seed tubers. We have therefore developed a new multiplex real-time PCR assay to simultaneously detect both bacteria in a single assay. Additionally, the reliability of this molecular diagnostic test has been improved by the simultaneous amplification of an internal control, corresponding to a potato gene co-extracted from the sample. The polyvalence and the specificity of each set of bacterial primers and probes were evaluated on more than 90 bacterial strains. The limit of detection of this triplex real-time protocol was similar to those observed with other molecular protocols previously developed for the individual detection of one of these bacteria. A concordance of 100 % was obtained in a blind test mimicking the routine application of the technology. In conclusion, this new protocol represents a straightforward and convenient method potentially adapted to primary screening of potato tubers.     

Accreditation process in the National Phytosanitary laboratory in Latvia1

The National Phytosanitary laboratory is the only laboratory in Latvia that provides testing of samples for regulated pests in the phytosanitary field. In 2001 a decision was made to implement Quality Assurance systems in the laboratory and obtain accreditation. From 2001 to 2003 preparation for accreditation took place in the laboratory. During this time a client of the laboratory, Sanitary Border Inspection of Latvia (SBI), arranged three audits to assess the activities of the laboratory in accordance with the requirements of ISO 17025. After a time and labour‐consuming preparation process on 2003‐12‐29 all the necessary documents including a Quality manual, two methods and procedures were submitted to the Latvian National Accreditation Bureau (LATAK). The first audit by LATAK was carried out in March 2005. After elimination of all non‐conformities, accreditation for two methods was received in 2005 (Method for detection and identification of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus in potato tubers and Method for detection and identification of Ralstonia solanacearum in potato tubers). The Quality Assurance System was implemented and applies to the whole laboratory. Every year LATAK experts carry out monitoring visits and each time imperfections are found they must be eliminated or improved.     

Sequence Analysis and Detection of Ralstonia solanacearum by Multiplex PCR Amplification of 16S–23S Ribosomal Intergenic Spacer Region with Internal Positive Control

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methods for detection and differentiation of Ralstonia solanacearum strains were compared. The 16S–23S rRNA gene ITS sequence data revealed the two main sequence clusters (divisions I and II) of R. solanacearum and further subclusters of division II. Based on this sequence data, primers were designed which differentiated divisions I and II. Furthermore, to improve reliability of the PCR assay for routine detection of R. solanacearum in host plants, a novel multiplex PCR assay was developed in which the pathogen-specific sequences are coamplified with host plant DNA as an internal PCR control (IPC). The assay was validated during routine testing of potato samples submitted in official surveys. Of 4300 samples from 143 cultivars, 13 tested positive in both multiplex PCR and immunofluorescence (IF) assays and could be confirmed by bioassay in tomato seedlings and reisolation of the pathogen. The IPC was successfully amplified from all samples tested. A further 12 samples gave positive IF results which were not confirmed by either the multiplex PCR or tomato bioassay, indicating a greater specificity of the latter two assays.     

Bacterial diseases of potatoes in the major potato-growing areas in Turkey1

In 1988 and 1989 bacterial diseases of potatoes in Central Anatolia were investigated by utilizing the EC method for the detection of ring-rot bacterium (Clavibacter michiganensis ssp. sepedonicus) and using selective medium. 91 samples containing 200 tubers from commercial and farmers’ stores in Central Anatolia were tested for the presence of C.m.sepedonicus and about 50 tubers of each sample were also tested for the presence of soft-rot erwinias. Five different bacteria that cross-reacted with C.m.spedonicus antisera were isolated from heel-end extracts. All cross-reacted bacteria differed from C.m.sepedonicus morphologically and none of them was pathogenic on eggplant. C.m. sepedonicus was not detected, but Erwinia carotouora ssp. carotouora and Erwinia carotovora ssp. atroseptica were present in 7 and 17% of the samples respectively.     

Repetitive Sequence-derived PCR Profiling Using the BOX-A1R Primer for Rapid Identification of the Plant Pathogen Clavibacter Michiganensis Subspecies Sepedonicus

Repetitive sequence-derived PCR using the BOX-A1R primer was used to generate genomic fingerprints of Clavibacter michiganensis subspecies sepedonicus, the causal agent of bacterial ring rot disease of potato. A total of 35 C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus strains were selected for study in order to represent the widest possible historical, morphological and geographical diversity of the organism. Comparison was made with genomic fingerprints of C. michiganensis subsp. michiganensis, C. michiganensis subsp. insidiosus, C. michiganensis subsp. tessellarius, C. michiganensis subsp. nebraskensis as well as other related Gram positive plant pathogens. The resultant genomic fingerprints and subsequent cluster analysis show C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus to form a remarkably homogeneous group with approximately 84% similarity between all of the strains tested. There was no evidence to suggest that fingerprints varied with historic, morphological or geographic diversity. In addition, C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus isolated from asymptomatic sugar beet had the same fingerprint as those which were isolated as potato pathogens. This group was easily distinguished from the clusters formed by the other subspecies of C. michiganensis and Gram positive plant pathogens. The potential for this technique to be used as a relatively rapid method to replace the time consuming and sometimes inconclusive eggplant bioassay test is discussed.     

The MeloTuber Test: a real‐time TaqMan® PCR‐based assay to detect the root‐knot nematodes Meloidogyne chitwoodi and M. fallax directly in potato tubers

Potato is one of the many important hosts for the root‐knot nematodes Meloidogyne chitwoodi and M. fallax that can infest roots as well as tubers. In the latter they may cause surface galls and necrotic spots below the skin. In the EU these pathogens are categorized as quarantine organisms and are therefore regulated. Phytosanitary measures (PMs) are implemented and one aspect involves diagnostic procedures to detect these pathogens. To date, visual screening of external and internal symptoms is combined with the specific identification of these pests, either through microscopy, biochemical or molecular tests. A disadvantage of all these tests is the requirement of the prior extraction of nematodes from the tubers, which is not suitable for high‐throughput screening. This paper describes the MeloTuber Test developed to simultaneously detect M. chitwoodi and M. fallax by triplex real‐time TaqMan^® PCR directly in secondary potato tuber peelings. DNA extraction is carried out in a 96‐well plate of pooled secondary peelings from one hundred tubers. The analytical sensitivity is such that a single female can be readily detected in such a sample size. The validation data, described here, prove the suitability of this molecular test for the detection of M. chitwoodi and M. fallax in large scale screening tests.     

Rapid Identification of Clavibacter michiganensis Subspecies Sepedonicus based on the Stable Low Molecular Weight RNA (LMW RNA) Profiles

Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus causes potato ring rot disease. The identification process for this bacterium is complex and long. This work demonstrates that the stable low-molecular-weight (LMW) RNA profiles allow their rapid identification. Staircase electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels was used to analyze the LMW RNA profiles of 54 strains of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus from different geographic origins. The profiles of several strains of other subspecies of C. michiganensis and other pathogens of potatoes were also analyzed. All the strains of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus had the same LMW RNA profile. They had a band in class 2 of tRNA that was absent in the other subspecies of the species C. michiganensis. Also, the LMW RNA of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus was different with respect to the LMW RNA profiles of other pathogens of potato. The results indicate the possible utilization of LMW RNA profiles in identification of the bacteria causing potato ring rot disease.     

Evaluation of antagonistic bacteria for suppression of bacterial ring rot of potato

Bacterial strains with potential for biological control of bacterial ring rot of potato caused byClavibacter michiganensis subsp.sepedonicus were isolated from the surface of potato tubers. Eighty-eight potential biocontrol candidates, selected on the basis ofin vitro antibiosis toC. m. sepedonicus, produced inhibition zones with radii ranging from 0.5 to 16 mm on test plates. All antagonistic isolates were screened in the greenhouse for biocontrol activity on micropropagated potato plantlets root-inoculated withC. m. sepedonicus. Eight strains consistently prevented infection of plantlets but there was no significant correlation between the width of the inhibition zone in thein vitro assay and ring rot suppression in the plant bioassay. Three strains that showed a high level of biological control potential were identified as a saprophytic enteric bacterium (strain 7G), anArthrobacter sp. (strain 16C), and a soil coryneform bacterium (strain 18A). These were tested in a field plot by co-inoculating cut seed potato tubers withC. m. sepedonicus and antagonists. Strains 7G and 18A significantly increased plant stand whereas 16C decreased disease incidence. The relative number of ostensibly ring rot-free progeny tubers was generally greater when antagonists were present.     

Rapid Identification of Clavibacter michiganensis Subspecies sepedonicus Using Two Primers Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (TP-RAPD) Fingerprints

Twenty strains of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus from different geographic origins and other reference strains of the same and different species, including other potato pathogens, were analysed with a new procedure named TP-RAPD that originates fingerprints of bacterial species. This procedure uses two primers to amplify the 16S rDNA gene. At 45 °C of annealing, the PCR product electrophoresed in agarose gels produced a band pattern that was different in all bacterial species studied as well as in the subspecies of C. michiganensis. All strains of C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus displayed the same TP-RAPD number of pattern. Unlike Gram negative bacteria, Gram positives of high G + C content, such as Clavibacter, produced low bands in TP-RAPD. By using a different set of two primers also based in the 16S rDNA sequence from Escherichia coli a more adequate amplification of Gram positives of high G + C including a greater number of bands was obtained. TP-RAPD patterns using the new set of primers described in this work is a reliable and fast method to identify C. michiganensis subsp. sepedonicus.     

Development of an EU protocol for the detection and diagnosis of Potato spindle tuber pospiviroid*

The work described here formed part of the EU SMT DIAGPRO project, to develop diagnostic protocols for 18 regulated pests. The Potato spindle tuber pospiviroid (PSTVd) protocol was developed primarily for testing in vitro‐ and glasshouse‐grown potato plants for the purposes of post‐entry quarantine and the production of pathogen‐tested nuclear stock. After a performance audit of methods used by 12 laboratories in Europe and America by ring testing, four methods were chosen for multilaboratory validation. For most laboratories, the detection limits were 10–20 mg of PSTVd‐infective tissue for R‐PAGE; 0.25–0.5 mg for DIG‐probe; 0.062 mg for RT‐PCR; and 0.0155 mg for TaqMan (this was the lowest weight of infective tissue tested). Some laboratories were able to extend the detection limit to 0.0155 mg for DIG‐probe and RT‐PCR. The DIG‐probe and R‐PAGE are recommended as primary detection methods, with confirmation of viroid presence by any of the four validated detection methods. Specific diagnosis requires the viroid to be sequenced. Other methods may be used for primary detection, providing that they preferably detect all PSTVd isolates and other Pospiviroids that have the potential to infect potato, and detect viroid in at least 1/10 of the tissue weight normally tested per plant.     

Direct tuber testing for Potato Y potyvirus by real‐time RT‐PCR and ELISA: reliable options for post‐harvest testing?*

The method currently used for testing potato tubers for viruses following harvest involves a growing‐on test. This takes up to 6 weeks to complete, and there is therefore a demand for more rapid test results. The sensitivity and reliability of direct tuber testing by DAS‐ELISA and real‐time RT‐PCR (TaqMan) were compared with the growing‐on test. In addition, the reliability of all three methods for the detection of Potato Y potyvirus (PVY) in tubers was compared over post‐harvest intervals of 6, 10, 14 and 18 weeks. The test material came from plots of tubers (cv. ‘Maris Piper’) containing a primary infection of strains PVY^N and PVY^O, following aphid transmission from marked infector plants grown during the 2003 season. Sample material was homogenized and divided, to provide comparative test material for detection of PVY by ELISA and real‐time RT‐PCR. Tuber eye‐plugs were then taken and subjected to the growing‐on test. The remainder of the tuber was also grown on and tested, to ensure infection was not missed as a consequence of an uneven distribution of virus throughout the tuber material. The results obtained using the two methods for direct testing of the tubers, and those results obtained from the traditional growing‐on test, are compared. The advantages and disadvantages of each method are discussed.     

Development of a quantitative real‐time PCR assay for Phytophthora infestans and its applicability to leaf,tuber and soil samples

A sensitive real‐time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay was developed for the quantification of Phytophthora infestans, the cause of foliar and tuber late blight in potato. A primer pair (PinfTQF/PinfTQR) and a fluorogenic probe (PinfTQPR) were designed to perform a quantitative assay for the detection of P. infestans in leaves, tubers and soils. The assay was shown to be specific to P. infestans and the very closely taxonomically related non‐potato pathogen species P. mirabilis, P. phaseoli and P. ipomoea, but did not detect the potato pathogens P. erythroseptica and P. nicotianae. The assay was able to reliably detect P. infestans DNA at 100 fg per reaction and was effective in quantifying P. infestans in infected leaf tissue from 24 h after inoculation and also in infected symptomless tubers and diseased tubers. Attempts to detect oospores of P. infestans in naturally and artificially infested soil samples are described and compared with baiting tests and previous literature. It was not possible to detect oospores in soil samples due to problems with DNA extraction from the oospores themselves. However, the assay was shown to detect even very low levels of asexual inoculum (sporangia and mycelium) in soil. This work assembles all the necessary features of a quantitative P. infestans assay, which have previously been somewhat disparate: the sensitivity, specificity and quantitation are fully validated, the assay is shown to work in common applications in leaf and tuber tissue and the problems with P. infestans oospore detection are explored and tested experimentally.     

Evidence for presence of the founder Ia mtDNA haplotype of Phytophthora infestans in 19th century potato tubers from the Rothamsted archives

Late blight remained a significant disease for potato growers in Europe long after the famine of the 1840s. Of the four mitochondrial haplotypes of Phytophthora infestans, only the Ia mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotype has been identified previously in infected potato leaves from famine‐era herbarium specimens collected in England, Ireland and Europe in the 19th century. Long‐term soil fertility experiments were conducted on potato between 1876 and 1901 in Rothamsted to investigate effects of combinations of organic manures and mineral fertilizers on disease and yield. This report identifies for the first time the same Ia mtDNA haplotype of P. infestans in three diseased tubers from 1877 from the long‐term Rothamsted trials, thus providing the earliest evidence of the presence of the founder Ia mtDNA haplotype of P. infestans in potato tubers in England. Soil amendments had a significant impact on disease and yield. A real‐time PCR assay was used to detect and quantify P. infestans in tubers. The level of pathogen DNA was greatest in tubers from highest yielding plots that received combinations of inorganic nitrogenous and mineral fertilizers and least in tubers from plots with organic farmyard manures or non‐nitrogenous mineral fertilizers. The Ia mtDNA haplotype was also confirmed from diseased potato leaves during the same time period. Thus, the founder Ia mtDNA haplotype survived in potato tubers after 1846 and was present over 30 years later in the UK.